A debate about the movie Titanic.

Avatar image for gambit1024
Gambit1024

10217

Forum Posts

47

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 9

#1  Edited By Gambit1024

Hello people, I had a small argument with my friend about the movie Titanic  and I'd just like to see what other people feel about the debate.  
 
Ok, so at the end of Titanic, Jack and Rose make it out of the ship, and they get to a floating piece of wall in the freezing water. Rose gets on top of the wall, and she's hanging onto Jack. The wall can only support one person. Now Rose can either let go of Jack and get to safety, or stay with him and die together. In the movie, she ends up letting go.  
 
Now my question is: Was Rose a bad person for doing this? 
 
My friend is convinced that Rose should've died with Jack and by "letting him die" she pretty much murdered him. I say that she did the right thing because a) he was screwed anyway and b) killing herself would've been extremely foolish and would not have made a good ending.  
 
Your thoughts?

Avatar image for caligula
Caligula

12660

Forum Posts

44899

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 12

#2  Edited By Caligula

it all depends. 
 
if you truly love someone then you should be willing to go down with them. (My Opinion)

Avatar image for iloverobots
iloverobots

466

Forum Posts

112

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

#3  Edited By iloverobots

Spoiler alert!

Avatar image for gambit1024
Gambit1024

10217

Forum Posts

47

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 9

#4  Edited By Gambit1024
@iloverobots: Psh, it's like 10 years old lol
Avatar image for matezoide2
Matezoide2

16064

Forum Posts

8551

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 1

#5  Edited By Matezoide2

she did the right thing
thats what Jack wanted,he knew he was screwed anyway,so he wanted that ,at least, Rose could live
Rose choicing to die would be the selfish choice,not only she would negate Jack's last wish,she would be using death as a way to not mourn over Jack's death

Avatar image for magian
Magian

159119

Forum Posts

925

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 4

User Lists: 11

#6  Edited By Magian
@Matezoide said:
" she did the right thing thats what Jack wanted,he knew he was screwed anyway,so he wanted that ,at least, Rose could live "
This.
Avatar image for hdorman1
hdorman1

4668

Forum Posts

410

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 2

#7  Edited By hdorman1

that door could have well have supported him aswell 
she was being greedy 
also 

No Caption Provided

what should have happened 
Avatar image for supergamera
SuperGamera

628

Forum Posts

18676

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 8

User Lists: 2

#8  Edited By SuperGamera

if everyone died the movie would suck

Avatar image for progenitorigin
progenitorigin

7575

Forum Posts

663

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

#9  Edited By progenitorigin

I've debated before about the possibility that that piece of floating debris could have still possibly held them both above water, but Jack himself requested that she live on, because at that point Jack had to have already known he was going through hypothermia and extreme frostbite.  Seeing as how long it took for the rescue boat to even try to go and search for survivors (in actual history, people have condemned some of the officers on the boats for refusing to go look for survivors), Jack would most likely have already succumbed to the hypothermia and probably would still have died. 
 
I think Rose did the right thing, as painful as it was to watch.
Avatar image for king_saturn
King_Saturn

250493

Forum Posts

509

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#10  Edited By King_Saturn
so I forgot this movie...
Avatar image for supertide
SuperTide

15900

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 4

User Lists: 0

#11  Edited By SuperTide

She just did what Jack wanted her to.

Avatar image for renee
Renee

10398

Forum Posts

10246

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 5

#12  Edited By Renee
@Gambit1024 said:
My friend is convinced that Rose should've died with Jack and by "letting him die" she pretty much murdered him.

Rose did not murder him. I'm pretty sure he was already dead for a long time in the water, like practically everyone else. So of course she's going to try and save herself. It's what Jack would have wanted. It would dishonor him had she not tried to live.
 
<3 Titanic!
Avatar image for sylver
Sylver

1606

Forum Posts

1312

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 2

#13  Edited By Sylver

I don't think she was bad.  She was respecting Jack's "last wishes".  I'm sure he wasn't planning on dying (even though he probably knew it was likely), but he wanted her to be safe even if he did.  And the only reason she let go of him was because he was dead.  Holding onto a dead body wasn't exactly going to "prove her love".  He asked for her to find a way to live and she did....because she loved him!
Goodness...people just have to make these good movies so complicated in meaning...

Avatar image for jotham
Jotham

4576

Forum Posts

2321

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 4

User Lists: 0

#14  Edited By Jotham

I don't really remember, but wasn't he dead when she let go?

Avatar image for prince_cortsether
Prince CortSether

2375

Forum Posts

2

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Kate Winslet is ugly.
 
On topic, couldn't they have both switched in and out and taken shifts on top of the floating debris?