Who should Stargirl date?

Vote for who do you think Stargirl should date?

1. Green Arrow [yay]

2. Hawkman [yay]

3. Baz the new green lantern [don't like him :( I want Hal Jordan ]

4. Vibe [yay]

5. Steve Trevor [could be interesting]

Oh what she can't date MM because he is green.....racist.

Unless things have changed considerably, she's still, you know, 17.

@sethysquare: Where's MM? And Stargirl looks a little young to date these guys. Most of them seem older than her.

I'm going for Catwoman solely for entertainment value.

@DarkKnightDetective: Ewwwwwwwwwwwww. Have you seen MM? Would you date something as ugly as that? LOL

@AtPhantom: Maybe she is 18 now

@Lvenger: late teens or early 20s is too young?

Isn't Ollie like early twenties? The only one seemed much older is MM. He is like hundred over years old I think.

Besides...

I think Vibe, assuming he's no longer a douchebag, would be the least creepy if she had to date someone.

Hmm, none of the choice's strike my fancy. If she's dating inside the superhero community maybe Tim Drake?

A teen hero like Red Robin or Blue Beetle!

Love that David Finch is illustrating a team book. Johns writing another one on the other hand... not so much. Give someone else a shot and stop hogging all the titles for yourself.

Catwoman! :P

@sethysquare: I wouldn't put her with Hawkman or Trevor. They look very late 20s, maybe even early 30s. But in that case, Arrow or Vibe would be the best love interests. And I've seen that video before. Ew is all I have to say.

@Lvenger: I believe Hawkman is around mid twenties as well, he is just drawn very buff. Steve Trevor sounds like late twenties or early thirties though. But I don't think it matters. My cousin is 9 years younger than her husband.

Also yes, 15 year old victoria... lol, the world is going to end.

My choice would be Green Arrow.

@sethysquare: Johns will get his way, and have her dating Vibe soon enough.

I'm just glad to see Stargirl.

@Twentyfive: What makes you think he likes vibe?

Me too I'm so glad to see Stargirl.

@sethysquare: Well there was some concern in JSA when Captain Marvel was dating Stargirl. As Billy Batson it was fine but the issue of Captain Marvel being with Stargirl was highlighted in JSA. I know Johns has had a few stints on that so it could have been him that did it but I can't remember.

@sethysquare: Why else would such a relatively unknown character be on a big-named team?

It's the same with Cyborg. If Johns didn't like these characters, they wouldn't have huge roles in the new U.

And like Hal Jordan. If Johns didn't like him, then we'd be seeing a lot more John Stewart. Johns, with all his like of these characters has made them take center stage of the DCU, though I don't know how big a role Vibe will play.

@Deranged Midget said:

Love that David Finch is illustrating a team book. Johns writing another one on the other hand... not so much. Give someone else a shot and stop hogging all the titles for yourself.

Couldn't agree more. I'll definitely still pick this up, and I'm really hoping it'll be good, but they really couldn't pick any other writer? I like most of John's work (emphasis on most. He's plenty of things that I don't like as well) but it just seems like he's everywhere... and I REALLY don't want him leaving Aquaman to write another team book, considering his current team book is the weakest thing he's writing at the moment, and Aquaman is arguably the strongest

@Imagine_Man15 said:

@Deranged Midget said:

Love that David Finch is illustrating a team book. Johns writing another one on the other hand... not so much. Give someone else a shot and stop hogging all the titles for yourself.

Couldn't agree more. I'll definitely still pick this up, and I'm really hoping it'll be good, but they really couldn't pick any other writer? I like most of John's work (emphasis on most. He's plenty of things that I don't like as well) but it just seems like he's everywhere... and I REALLY don't want him leaving Aquaman to write another team book, considering his current team book is the weakest thing he's writing at the moment, and Aquaman is arguably the strongest

Exactly. Why give the title to the man who's worst work yet in the New 52 is on a team book? If he's leaving Aquaman to write another garbage team title, I'm going to flip. He's a far better solo writer as evident with Aquaman and Green Lantern. I'm positive there are other capable writers who are willing to give a team book a go in the New 52.

@sethysquare: Why does Stargirl need to date anyone? How old is she going to be even?

Edit: It just seems odd to single her out. Why not "who should hawkman date" or something?

@Lvenger said:

@sethysquare: Well there was some concern in JSA when Captain Marvel was dating Stargirl. As Billy Batson it was fine but the issue of Captain Marvel being with Stargirl was highlighted in JSA. I know Johns has had a few stints on that so it could have been him that did it but I can't remember.

I don't know. I find it al right though.

@Twentyfive said:

@sethysquare: Why else would such a relatively unknown character be on a big-named team?

It's the same with Cyborg. If Johns didn't like these characters, they wouldn't have huge roles in the new U.

And like Hal Jordan. If Johns didn't like him, then we'd be seeing a lot more John Stewart. Johns, with all his like of these characters has made them take center stage of the DCU, though I don't know how big a role Vibe will play.

Do you think that it could've been because Cyborg is perhaps the most prominent minority and with a very unique skill set?

Also, I highly doubt that he gets to make every single decision. Even Geoff Johns can get editorial mandate.

100% disagree with you on Hal. You do know that Kyle Rayner has been the most prominent Green Lantern before Hal came back right?

The Green Lantern main book was about Kyle Rayner not Hal Jordan. I believe the fact that Hal Jordan is back is because Kyle Rayner and John Steward are not as popular and iconic as Hal. I don't think Geoff particularly likes Vibe, Vibe just seems like a good minority candidate to revamp.

@fodigg: Well, cos Stargirl is one of my favourite character and I'm thrilled that she is back and not in comicbook limbo (surprisingly no one made a big fuss that Courtney is missing but everyone cried for that lame stephanie brown).

And I think giving her a high profile relationship on the team would make elevate both her and the other guy's status.

I mean Green Arrow and Black Canary had a really high profile relationship and wedding, I hope the same could be done for Stargirl (and green arrow)

@sethysquare: I'm glad they decided to diversify their All-Star lineup, and even gladder that he is one of their "Big 7" I would definitely not have chosen anyone else.

Yep you are right about editorial mandates, and no I never knew Rayner was the GL before Hal magically came back.

I don't feel like DC is doing enough with John. I believe they use him as just to appease those like myself looking for minority characters. They need to do something with him. Give him a power boost, an origin story, a girlfriend. Something. He's kind of like a background character.

And what minority quota would they be filling with Vibe?

@sethysquare said:

@fodigg: Well, cos Stargirl is one of my favourite character and I'm thrilled that she is back and not in comicbook limbo (surprisingly no one made a big fuss that Courtney is missing but everyone cried for that lame stephanie brown).

And I think giving her a high profile relationship on the team would make elevate both her and the other guy's status.

I mean Green Arrow and Black Canary had a really high profile relationship and wedding, I hope the same could be done for Stargirl (and green arrow)

I didn't complain about any of the JSA cuts because I assumed they'd be in Earth 2.

@Twentyfive said:

@sethysquare: I'm glad they decided to diversify their All-Star lineup, and even gladder that he is one of their "Big 7" I would definitely not have chosen anyone else.

Yep you are right about editorial mandates, and no I never knew Rayner was the GL before Hal magically came back.

I don't feel like DC is doing enough with John. I believe they use him as just to appease those like myself looking for minority characters. They need to do something with him. Give him a power boost, an origin story, a girlfriend. Something. He's kind of like a background character.

And what minority quota would they be filling with Vibe?

I do applaud DC's attempt to be more racially diverse. So I'm excited about Cyborg, Katana and several minorities getting featured.

But I don't care for John, mostly because I'm a huge GL fan and he has not had much stories and character development. He is a very stern and boring person. Very serious and sadly, there weren't much good stories or character development about him. I don't like him as a character, unlike Cyborg whom I'm a big fan of.

Uhm.... I don't think there is a minority quota. Even so, Vibe is hispanic, they're considered minorities also, so not sure what you are trying to say with that comment on Vibe though.

@fodigg said:

@sethysquare said:

@fodigg: Well, cos Stargirl is one of my favourite character and I'm thrilled that she is back and not in comicbook limbo (surprisingly no one made a big fuss that Courtney is missing but everyone cried for that lame stephanie brown).

And I think giving her a high profile relationship on the team would make elevate both her and the other guy's status.

I mean Green Arrow and Black Canary had a really high profile relationship and wedding, I hope the same could be done for Stargirl (and green arrow)

I didn't complain about any of the JSA cuts because I assumed they'd be in Earth 2.

Legacy characters like Jade, Enchantress, Stargirl, Wildcat #2 are all considered to be in the Limbo since there is no way a 20+ year old man can have a child that is of the same age.

@sethysquare: I mistyped. I hate using the word "quota". It is the same thing as "Tokenism". Shame I can't take that back lol. He's Hispanic? That's cool. He and Jaime Reyes now!

@sethysquare said:

@fodigg said:

@sethysquare said:

@fodigg: Well, cos Stargirl is one of my favourite character and I'm thrilled that she is back and not in comicbook limbo (surprisingly no one made a big fuss that Courtney is missing but everyone cried for that lame stephanie brown).

And I think giving her a high profile relationship on the team would make elevate both her and the other guy's status.

I mean Green Arrow and Black Canary had a really high profile relationship and wedding, I hope the same could be done for Stargirl (and green arrow)

I didn't complain about any of the JSA cuts because I assumed they'd be in Earth 2.

Legacy characters like Jade, Enchantress, Stargirl, Wildcat #2 are all considered to be in the Limbo since there is no way a 20+ year old man can have a child that is of the same age.

True, but they could be introduced as standalone characters.

Shazam

@sethysquare said:

@DarkKnightDetective: Ewwwwwwwwwwwww. Have you seen MM? Would you date something as ugly as that? LOL

Considering J'onn can look like anyone you want, I doubt that would really be an issue.

The only one seemed much older is MM. He is like hundred over years old I think.

Pre-Flashpoint, he was over 225 million years old.

Vibe or GA.

I think that Ollie is a good pick for her.

Why does she have to date anyone....?

@Twentyfive said:

@sethysquare: Why else would such a relatively unknown character be on a big-named team?

It's the same with Cyborg. If Johns didn't like these characters, they wouldn't have huge roles in the new U.

And like Hal Jordan. If Johns didn't like him, then we'd be seeing a lot more John Stewart. Johns, with all his like of these characters has made them take center stage of the DCU, though I don't know how big a role Vibe will play.

Definitely got that right with Johns playing favorites.

@The_Tree: Yeah. I read somewhere that Johns said he likes that character. But I am not complaining at all. He is adding color to a monochromatic universe.

Cyborg was imo a perfect addition to the main JLU, and I couldn't add a more fitting character.

@Twentyfive: I'm not complaining at all either. I'm not going to go jumping to conclusions on the quality of JLA, or the inclusion of Vibe or Baz. (Although I will detest having Catwoman on the team.) JLA has the potential to be interesting. While I'm still unable to accept Cyborg as a founder, I do like him on the League.

On topic; Stargirl should either date Vibe, or date no one. And I hope they don't force some sort of team romance.

she should date jason todd.

Green Arrow as far as I heard he already rock the cradle

Martian Manhunter

Billy Batson.

Who has two thumbs and a stupid pair of razor sharp Falcon rip off wings?

Captain Marvel

If she's going to date anyone on this team, Vibe would be the best choice.

Stargirl should date Blue Beetle. That would be an interesting match

@Sovereign91001 said:

Hmm, none of the choice's strike my fancy. If she's dating inside the superhero community maybe Tim Drake?

Yes,Now is the chance.Didn't star girl have an unresolved crush on Tim?

Dude, she's freaking 19 at the oldest, she shouldn't be dating any of them. What is wrong with you?

@CrimsonCake said:

@Sovereign91001 said:

Hmm, none of the choice's strike my fancy. If she's dating inside the superhero community maybe Tim Drake?

Yes,Now is the chance.Didn't star girl have an unresolved crush on Tim?

yep

Courtney + Tim=Happy X-bolt

Catwoman. ^_^

@Joygirl said:

Catwoman. ^_^

If she can't have Tim and has to date someone on the team, this is the next best option lol.