Winter Soldier: 8.5/10

YES!

Gotta love internet tough guys.

@norrinboltagonprime21: thats great

9.5/10 gotta leave room for a better movie in the future :)

8.5-9/10 for moi

Okay, I'll go with a 9 for now. Gotta leave room for improvement and never settle :D

Arturo, I still haven't seen it. :-(

In the context of summer blockbuster action movie? Maybe, I would say this gives Transformers a run for it's money.

In the context of the likes of The Godfather? An actual 10/10 movie? No, Chris Evan's three emotions; Happy, sad and angry, and Johansson's stunning performance as boobs on legs just insult by comparison.

The beginning of this film perfectly sums it up. Captain America beating people up, obviously fake French accents, and a gratuitous shot of Scarlett Johansson's ass. You have to admire my willpower to have not walked out of the cinema right then and there.

@sheenlantern:

In the context of summer blockbuster action movie? Maybe, I would say this gives Transformers a run for it's money.

In the context of the likes of The Godfather? An actual 10/10 movie? No, Chris Evan's three emotions; Happy, sad and angry, and Johansson's stunning performance as boobs on legs just insult by comparison.

What other emotions was he supposed to potray in a movie where he's Captain America besides happy, sad, and angry? And all three were believeable and seemingly natural. I don't see whats so bad about it. He has three emotions and he killed all of them so I don't see the point of complaining.

Johansson also did a good job at acting. Just becuase nice boobs and an ass doesn't degrade her as an actor. That puts her in the position of the character Black Widow.

The beginning of this film perfectly sums it up. Captain America beating people up, obviously fake French accents, and a gratuitous shot of Scarlett Johansson's ass. You have to admire my willpower to have not walked out of the cinema right then and there.

Captain America beating people up? How does that deal with acting and how does that destory the character of Captain America? Is he supposed to be having friendly conversations with them or something?

Fake french accents? Interesting. I know a lot of French people and have stayed in France and their accents seemed like it fit. Are you saying "fake accents" as if they are people who are not french but speaking as if they are? Doesn't that bring the essense of what acting is? Potraying someone you're not but still making it believeable to the audiance.

Whats wrong with her ass? Its a movie watched by predominately males. You're not going to watch a movie like magic mike, a movie directed towards woman, and expect to see more female bodies than male. And even there is a problem with that, how does that effect her ability to act in any way?

Pretty solid 9

It was great but it was missing something I can't put my finger on.

10/10 for me, by far the best Marvel movie in my opinion. I don't even really care about Cap all that much, but this movie was everything I wanted from a Marvel movie and more. LOVED it. It's about time we saw Captain America bash in some heads instead of carry on with the boy-scout nonsense we saw in Cap 1 and The Avengers.

8.5 is a fair ranking. I'd rate it somewhere between there and 9, though I'd need a revisit to form a concrete opinion.

You might get your point across better if you toned the abrasiveness down a notch.

10/10. Greatest superhero movie I have ever seen.

This

This, or between this and 9.5.

My opinion in the movie too...

@war_killer: I know you didn't ask me but I personally tHink tHere wasn't any real cHaracter development. I didn't see Cap growing from tHis experience. He stayed tHe same in my eyes.

I still enjoyed tHe movie Heavily. I enjoyed it more tHan IM3, Dark World, Wolverine, MoS, and Kick-Ass 3.

It is a fantastic movie. I'm only nitpicking tHe character development because I feel like if it had more of that it would have been something special.

-ABstract4$$#073-

@m3th: I think there was good character development with Black Widow. We got see more of her human side and get a better idea of how she works. We've only gotten glimpses of her past and her character in both IM2 and Avengers, but we got to see a lot more of how she thinks and operates in this movie.

The scene where she's asking Cap about how if their places had been reversed and it was up to her to save him, would he trust her to do so...and then Cap was like "I would now." Just seeing the reaction on her face, to me it showed that she was beginning to realize that she doesn't have to hide behind a mask but could be open and honest without the fear of being judge. I felt it was a great development for her character.

As for Cap, while personality-wise there really wasn't much development, we did get to see that Cap had begun adjusting to living in the present. In Avengers we didn't get to really see how he was adjusting, but here we see that he's trying to catch up on important events that missed, TV shows, people, etc. What I liked about this movie was that while Steve was now in 2014, his personality was still in the 1940s. That scene where Fury is trying to convince Cap to see the world like he does, only for Cap to say "don't hold your breath." That really showed what kind of man Steve is, showing that no matter how dark the world gets he'll still always have hope that things can get better.

I would like to point out that I did like how Steve picked up some pointers from Black Widow. Like the scenes when Steve and Natasha are hiding out in that mall. We see how different the two are, with one being a soldier and the other a spy. Seeing Steve getting ready to fight, but having Widow find a more subtle way to avoid capture was something interesting and something Steve could use in the future as well.

@war_killer: I respect tHat response. I overlooked Black Widows cHaracter development. Plus, you are rigHt Cap sHowed Caps potential to grow and adapt in tHis new world more.

I still feel like if it Had more cHatacter development tHe movie would Have been sometHing special. But, I respect your response.

-ABstract4$$#073-

I just watched it. My favorite Marvel movie as of now. Way better than the Avengers and the comedy in this wasn't as blatant as in Avengers (although a few jokes felt of place fore me). Action was good for a street level hero movie, about as good as Arrow. Although there was no traditional bad guy the enemies were taken seriously and were very interesting to watch as the plot unfolded. I'd give it a 9.

haha, and thus is the futility of such an arbitrary rating system. I think people rating 9 or 10 are just trolling, if not you're 100% right here. I actually had high expectations with this one, trusting the opinions of others who felt similarly to me about the recent Marvel launches. I mean, I give it that it's an improvement. But I won't be watching it a second time, that should reflect an opinion more appropriate than what's being thrown around here :D

Winter Soldier 10/10 perfect movie!!

9/10

9/10

7/10 for me.

8

8/10 is fair for me, much praise for what it did well and so forth but there were certain aspects kept me from embracing it fully: inconsistencies in Cap's ability, my overall lack of interest in SHIELD-related plots and I personally found Falcon's character underwhelming. Also I hated that Cap jumped out of the plane without a parachute when there was no reason to do so.

But yeah 8/10.

11/10, It makes Godfather, Fight Club, The Matrix, Titanic and My Little Pony look like sh!t. It's honestly the best thing to ever be filmed. I cried while watching it. It's just so beautiful. Man if every movie had this level of balanced action, romance, and comedy the world would be a better place. And don't even get me started on the actors, Chris Evans is the Ben Affleck of this generation.

7.75/10

It was good, but not great. You could tell the filmmakers didn't want it to be great, by the way the movie pulled all its punches.

It was okay but it reminded me too much of the current political landscape and I personally go to the movies or read books precisely to forget about whatever is going on in the real world. Although I felt the same way about Cap's comics too. I'd probably rate it 7/10, it was average, wasn't horribly written but it just wasn't my cup of tea. That and I wanted more Winter Soldier than what I got...I do look forward to future plans for the character however, at least I think I do, I have no clue what their plans are.

@racob7: Got to be honest was very disappointed with the movie as a whole. Liked Captain America: The First Avenger. Gave that a 7/10. Then I saw all the reviews on this new film and everyone was giving it 9 or 10/10 and was really looking forward to watching it and omg I was so disappointed 6/10.

Nothing special happens, some good effects and some decent action sequences but no story what so ever. My god I could of wrote it.