Id go my own way everytime, but if I absolutely had to pick one.. Id go with Alice, not only is she a hot chick but shes less naive and I like her personality better, she also has freaking superpowers.
Couldn't have said it better ^_^
Neither! Everyone dies around both of them when they could have made the decision to just get the f**k outta dodge and let shit take care of itself. With Rick, people entrusted him to make the right decision to get them through hell. Yet he became aimless almost as soon as he found his family again and now how many of the original survivors remain in TV and Comic? he makes the right decisions too slowly and others suffer or die as a result of waiting... waiting... waiting...
With Alice, if you follow her you will die and she will do very little to ensure your survival because she's always on a freakin suicide mission and only has time for you providing she hasn't done a somersault/backflip/dropkick to zombie-face in the last half hour. I mean really,
everyone but Alice is as good as red-shirt recruitment in any zombie situation. If she'd have died in the first film, more people might have actually survived....
No, if my life counted on someone else in a zombie situation it would have to be McGuyver!