You can always trust me to over complicate a simple question.
The two have some pros and cons, as far as I'm concerned.
Costume
As far as just their costumes. I'd say Black Cat is sexier. It's tempting, sexual, and rather appealing. Not saying it's the smartest thing to be wearing when it's 20 degrees outside. I think Catwoman's current costume is probably one of the best she's ever had, and it is far sexier then the past incarnations.
Out of Costume
Out of the costumes I think Catwoman is sexier. I like the whole light haired thing, but Selina has that sort of sensuality to her when she's in casual clothes. There is just something great about brunettes. More so with short haired brunettes.
Personality
As far as personality goes. It's Catwoman by a country mile. I like Black Cat and all, but when it comes to relations. She's a very shallow person. She was far more interested in Spider-man and really felt disappointed when she saw who was behind the mask. Yes, she did get over that after a while.
As a guy, how do you imagine that would feel? This attractive woman is looking at you as if she wants to rip all your clothes off one minute. You have been saving her live and risking your own in the process on numerous occasions. She finally sees your face and her expression goes from lustful to something along the lines as if she had just kissed her brother.
To explain it to a woman. It is almost the equivalent of having some guy say he'd like to have sex with you. If only you'd be kind enough to put this bag over your head so he doesn't have to look at you. Not only that, but has the balls enough to tell you this while you are within arms reach of not only him. Also surrounding are boiling water and several sharp objects. Some of which are rusty.
Selina may have some personality issues when it comes to "moral boundaries". She just comes across to me as more playful and far less shallow.
Log in to comment