What is the greatest comic book film ever........

.....Other than The Dark Knight? Just curious to know what you guys think.

The Winter Soldier

History of Violence

Road To Perdition

Why are you asking other than The Dark Knight? That's nowhere near the best.

For the question, probably The Avengers, The Dark Knight Rises, or Batman Begins.

Superman (1978)

Spiderman-2

@jphu8414 said:

Second that.

Mos.

Batman Begins

Watchmen is the most underrated

very true

Are you saying that is better than the dark knight? I hate Ledgers joker, but the film is ok, rises is a bucket load of problems and horribleness.

I would say Avengers, Iron man or X2. For its time Spawn is great. Blade was awesome back then too. Watchmen is certainly underrated.

For me it depends on how you rank it:

Best comicbook movie I didnt know was a comicbook: Blade (from before Twilight ruined vampires, and so risky Marvel wouldn't put their name on it).

Best Superhero movie: Batman Begins.

Most ambitious: Watchmen

Best straight up adaptation: 300

Other than the Dark Knight? In that case, MoS.

Iron Man & Spider-Man 2. No question.

V for Vendetta.

Toughy.. I guess the following are in my top list.

1. Spider-Man
2. Iron Man
3. Captain America Winter Soldier
4. The Dark Knight
5. Captain America First Avenger

1. The Dark Knight Rises
2. X-Men First Class
3. Batman Begins

Other than the Dark Knight.... hmmmm well mines is

1) MoS

2) The Avengers

and many more but don't want to list them until I see the Winter Soldier

Crumb, American Splendor and Ghost World.

BB

*Sigh*

No appreciation for the classics on Comicvine I see...

I'm going to split it into two categories, best team comic book film and best solo comic book film, mostly because I don't think it's fair to judge a team film the same way as a solo film.

Best Team Film: The Avengers

Best Solo Film: Spiderman-2 (I'd actually put it above the Dark Knight)

Never saw V for Vendetta, but I read the graphic novel and its amazing.

I'll have a definite answer on Friday.

Also V for Vendetta,Spider Man 2,and X-2.

Agreed.

THE op should rename the thread what is the greatest comic book film ever besides batman begins

I'd give the nod to Spider-Man 2, Iron Man, and ...not sure

Man of Steel is a personal favorite tho

• Kick-Ass
• Superman 2, Richard Donner cut
• Batman Begins
• Spider-Man
• Super (If it counts)

All of these are better then TDK.

Scott Pilgrim vs. the World or American Splendor.

Hmmm... The first Superman, Avengers, the first Spider-man, X-men first class.

Avengers being my personal favourite.

Also I feel 2004's Punisher is very underrated.

While I'd still put TDK at #1 (so far, maybe that'll change in a week to ten days..yes, I'm going to wait that long to see Winter Soldier, so I don't have to fight crowds, stand in line and deal with noisy kids) if we're excluding that, I'd be torn between MOS (For me, the polarization film tells me it's actually great.) and Iron Man. To this day, I am sad that IM 2 and 3, while box-office hits, had such a decline in quality. Superman and Superman II, (The Christopher Reeve films) are maybe the most fun, but I cringe when Zod and company use their "telekinesis" powers, and when they use their super-breath to attack Metropolis, and folks are still walking in and out of Kentucky-Fried Chicken places like nothings going on. The first Superman was a bit less campy, but the Ned Beatty character who was there for comic-relief, that I could have done without.

From Hell

A History of Violence

Captain America: TWS

Iron Man

TDK

In no real order.

Honourable mentions:

The Avengers

Spider-man 2

X2

Kick-ass

Blade II

Best part of the movies man!

1. (The entire Star Wars series, tho Ep1 was "meh")

2. Scott Pilgrim

3. Spiderman 2

4. X-2

5. X-men first class

6. Avengers

haven't seen Capt winter soldier yet so it may be up there.

Damn it. you beat me to Ghost World!

I've got high hopes for The Winter Soldier, however as it stands, these are my favourite 3.

• Batman Begins
• The Dark Knight
• Road to Perdition

Greatest CMB? What are we basing this on? Ratings or box office?

Let's see if you still that way when you're 50! :)

Other than the Dark Knight or Iron Man?

I really enjoyed Spiderman 2 (the Raimi one) I'm surprised I don't hear more about it. It's definitely a top 3 superhero movie for me.

• Daredevil
• Punisher
• Iron Man 1

Haven't seen Winter Soldier yet.

Daredevil

MOS for my money

Avengers after that Rises and after that The Dark World.

The Avengers and then Watchmen.

Winter Soldier

MOS

Cap A

THENN TDK