what bat family member would you kill off?

I wouldn't kill Barbara but I would rip her legs off in a way so vicious they could never be restored even with robotics, if she died in the process......well I'm willing to take that risk. If I have to kill someone off it would be Batwoman 1. because I've read very little with her in it and she's the only member of the Bat family I have absolutely no connection to, she seems cool but frankly I have a stronger connection to Titus. and 2 if I can't rip Barbara's legs off and make her be Oracle again she could at least step it up to Batwoman instead of Batgirl

@The Stegman said:

None. I like them all.

The Joker breaks into your house one night and wakes you up by throwing a gun on your stomach, when you sit up all the Bat Family members are strapped together by a giant bomb. The Joker says either you shoot one of them or he blows them up and takes out you entire neighborhood. He is not bluffing, it's not a joke, what do you do.

I wouldnt mind seeing Damian Wayne getting bumped off. We already have the trained killer and all around badass in the batman family.

Batwing or Batwoman, preferably both. They have never been integral to Batman's history, nor will they ever.

Batman, I have no problem with the character, I'd just love to see the reactions of the fan boys

@The Stegman said:

@BlackArmor:

@The Stegman said:

None. I like them all.

The Joker breaks into your house one night and wakes you up by throwing a gun on your stomach, when you sit up all the Bat Family members are strapped together by a giant bomb. The Joker says either you shoot one of them or he blows them up and takes out you entire neighborhood. He is not bluffing, it's not a joke, what do you do.

Shoot the Joker.

huh......................how did I overlook that possibility?.....fair enough

Can we kill both Damian and Jason? If I had to have one or the other go...well, Jason it is. Never cared for the character.

@BlackArmor: Damn, man....

When I glanced at the post title, I read "what family member would you kill off?" When I finally saw the word "bat," I was a lot less horrified.

@VampireSelektor said:

@BlackArmor: Damn, man....

lol, which comment is this in response too, my Oracle solution, my disinterest in Batwoman, or my Joker scenario

@Adnan said:

Bruce Wayne. He's set up Batman Inc, and Dick has proven himself as a worthy successor to the cowl in my eyes. Everyone else has some sorta established role in the Bat-mythos (Steph should still be in Britain and Cass in Hong Kong, right?) Plus, some sense of progression would be nice. He doesn't have to die for that to happen, but if one member of the Batfamily has to die, imo it's him. Probably won't happen, but that point seems irrelevant to this discussion.

Actually I am agree with you...

Jason. He's basically outlived his usefulness as a character.

@Adnan said:

Bruce Wayne. He's set up Batman Inc, and Dick has proven himself as a worthy successor to the cowl in my eyes. Everyone else has some sorta established role in the Bat-mythos (Steph should still be in Britain and Cass in Hong Kong, right?) Plus, some sense of progression would be nice. He doesn't have to die for that to happen, but if one member of the Batfamily has to die, imo it's him. Probably won't happen, but that point seems irrelevant to this discussion.

Actually I am agree with you...

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

All of that is non-canon now, and Dick wasn't really a worthy successor. Bruce had to come back and save the entire Universe from the Hunter-Killer. The whole point of Batman Inc was to have Batmen for smaller areas, while Bruce could protect the world.

But I still having the feeling that Bruce have to die, I don't feel that the Bat-family members could grow more as character until Batman dies, I don't like Batman as a man, but an immortal idea of justice and fear, like the Phantom.

Helena.

None, I love them all.

EDIT: Carrie Kelly

Todd and Damian, preferably beating each other to death with blunt instruments.

@Funrush said:

I think it would be interesting if Dick was killed off for a year or two. Maybe it could be done to him what has been done to Batman in Scott Snyder's series.

which is what?

Bruce

JUST ONE? Nope, can't decide. Just gonna have to kill all of them, EXCEPT Batman, Nightwing, Tim(Red) Robin, & Barbara. That gives us Batman, Nightwing, Robin(drop the Red), & a Batgirl. That's more then enough! Trim the fat!