Was Infinity A Good Event?

I think I'd put it somewhere between good and great

@theacidskull: it wasn't though. Not the New Avengers part. Good character dynamics and ish

@danhimself: what one did you vote for?

I found it to be great IMO

It gets an 8-8.5 from me. I hope Marvel events take note from this and keep improving.

It was great. It is the best marvel event since Civil War.

Great event but I don't expect folks that haven't been reading Hickman's Avengers books to enjoy it like us that do.

By far the best comic event since Annihilation.

It was pretty solid.

Great

Good....I just can't say that it was great....I feel like it was advertised as a Thanos centric event and it felt more like Thanos was added in as an afterthought

It was ok.

Better than BotA...not that that is saying much.

I didn't like how THanos centric it got, but other than that it was ok.

Great to see a threat that kicked the Marvel U's ass.

I haven't read it but if I told you that originally Hickman never wanted to write the Avengers but instead wanted to write an Imperial Guard book, would that make more sense?

It was kind of like multiple events in one thanos attacking earth and avengers battling in space which could have been to seperate events as I felt that certain things needed more development and the end was a bit anticlimactic so I go ok

kind of...but I do think he's doing great things with the Avengers...but it might not be for everyone...I love long form story telling though

Yes, really enjoyed it...best marvel arc IMO since Dark Angel Saga and Second Coming

They should get rid of Avengers so Hickman can write twice as much New Avengers.

I wanted more illuminati in the main book too

@theacidskull: agreed it was bad, good art but very full of $h*t story

It was good it seemed like it turned the Inhumans into the next x-men just for the movies but it's a wait and see if that pans out, most of the tie ins were enjoyable the art was good, I'd of rather seen the Ragnarok Now storyline in Uncanny Avengers turned into an event instead of the Avengers New Avengers Infinity but to each there own, I have no real complaints with it. I enjoyed it more then AvX and Age of Ultron that's for sure.

What was it specifically that you didn't like about it?

Half of it was good. I liked the Thanos part, but Avengers in space fighting builders was boring and a waste of time.

And saying it's the best Marvel event in years ain't sayin' much.

It felt like the story was jumbled everywhere..Half the time it was in space and the other half was going on about Thanos. It just felt very unorganized

To me the whole series was like 'wohoo avengers yeah vuhouu' so i think it kinda sucked.I would have said Thanos parts were good but the ending was horrible so i couldn't even said that rather than that weird plot demanding ending i would rather to have Starbrand and Captain Universe joining the fight and he start getting overpowered slowly with an epic fight

@jonny_anonymous: where to start, the Avengers win basically because they get lucky, the threat in space felt irrelevant, Thanos' son... who cares? I mean what is his backstory? Why did Thanos felt threatened by him? And if I as a reader am left with those questions then the story sucked. It was a mess and if you enjoy the Avengers scrambling, clueless, and getting slapped around then yea you probably loved this event. Oh, and someone finally kill BlackBolt, he is useless and a punk.

It was great. The story opened up a lot of new stories to be told for a years. I enjoyed every issue including all the ti-ins and the writing and the art both were great all around so it was a great event especially coming right after the disaster that was Age Of Ultron.

I agree with @moonchilde! Best marvel storyline since Annihilation!!! i love Hickmans stories!

IMO it was the best event story in the past 5 years. Hickman did a great job giving us action but a great story to go along with it. It was not just page after page of fights like many events have become lately.