Let's try to make a list of the most overrated stories,series,runs etc of all time!
Write the stories,series etc that you think are overrated and in the end i will count to make the list( the list will be updated when new comments come).
For me it would be The Dark knight returns and Watchmen.
P.S. Overrated doesn't necessarily mean bad
EDIT Link to actual list : http://www.comicvine.com/myvine/squalleon/top-overrated-stories-of-all-time/75-40871/