Top 20 Superhero Movies of all time 2014

Check out the Top animated Superhero films voting forum here! ---> http://www.comicvine.com/forums/gen-discussion-1/top-10-animated-superhero-films-1594168/#14

So I was just searching the internet for a good 'best superhero movies of all time' list, and I cannot find a single good one. Most lists are created by people who really don't know what their talking about, and leave me cringing by the end. So why don't we viners come together and create a definitive list.

Voting

Comment on this video with the names of 20 superhero films you think are the best of all time, and put a point value next to each film (20 being the most, and 1 being the least.)

The List

I'll stop tallying votes after one week (August 19th). The films with the top 20 most votes will then be compiled into a list and put out so that you all can check out the results and complain about them in the comments. Please put your top film with 20, then 19, etc.

The Rules

Please do not criticize the choices of a fellow poster. The choices of each reader are their respected opinions, and should be treated as such.

Each user can only submit one list.

Live-action films only.

Let's do this!

The Dark Knight, Winter Soldier, Avengers, Ironman, should be around the top. I'll make a list later.

I'll Start it off

20- The Dark Knight

19- Batman

18- The Amazing Spider-man

17- Superman

16- Batman Begins

15- Guardians of the Galaxy

14- Spider-man

13- Batman Returns

12- The Avengers

11- Watchmen

10- Ironman

9- Kick-ass

8- X-men First Class

7- Hellboy

6- Spiderman 2

5- Dark Knight Rises

4- Man of Steel

3- Superman 2

2- X2

1- Thor

20.The Amazing Spiderman 2

19. The Dark Knight

18. Guardians of The Galaxy

17. Superman 2

16. .Spider-Man

15.Superman

14. X-Men First class

13. The Wolverine

12.X-Men Days of Future past

11 .Ironman

10.Captain America TWS

9. The Punisher (2004)

8. Dredd

7. Ghost Rider

6. The Amazing Spiderman

5. Man of Steel

4. Spiderman 2

3. Batman and Robin

2. Daredevil

1.Captain America TFA

Honorable mention: Avengers Phew! That was hard!

Beata

@spidey_jackson: You have Spidey 2 and ASM1 on their twice for 22 total. I'll delete the duplicates and push the rest up

@spidey_jackson: Batman and Robin made your top 20? And even topped Thor?

@eyedcyou:

@eyedcyou: Thanks! See what you're doing to my sanity!

Beata

All of this year's (except ASM2) should be in there.

@xwraith: so make a list c:

You broke your own rules already LOL!

@transformers1024: Yep. Say what you want, but it was pure fun for me. But i edited it. Check it out now!

Beata

@pokeysteve: ah shit...

Let's do this!

20 avengers

19 guardians of the galaxy

18 TASM2

17 captain America winter solider

16 captain America first avenger

15 Xmen DOFP

14 dark night

13 spiderman

12 spiderman 2

11 TASM

10 X2

9 batman begins

8 blade trinity

7 x men

6 dark knight rises

5 ironman 3

4 the incredibles

3 watchmen

2 spawn

1 MoS

@proto3296: It was just pointed out to me that I broke my own rule, so I had to fix it lol...But live-action only, so swap incredbiles.

@proto3296: Woah. Spawn is so high O.o interesting.

Beata

@spidey_jackson: Just to make sure you understand, he has spawn receiving 2 points, so it's at the bottom. Probably could've stated it better, but I want the numbers next to the movies to be points not ranking.

@eyedcyou: I gotta do my list all over!

Damn you. :P

Beata

1 Avengers

2 Cap 2

3 batman begins

4 Gotg

5 Spider-Man 2

6 Constantine

7 Thor

8 Iron man

9 Batman

10 Superman

11 XMen 2

12 Xmen dofp

13 Blade

14 Dark knight

15 mos

16 watchmen

17 x-men first class

18 kick ass

19 Hellboy

20 Thor 2

@spidey_jackson: I apologize if I had come off as rude in that comment. Definitely not my intentions. Just a bit surprised is all. It's your opinion, and although I disagree with it, I still respect it.

@$#$ I forgot 300 and Sin city

@lurchadamo: I changed the op to make it clearer, but if avengers is your top rated movie, please put the 20 next to it. the 20 means 20 points. thx

@transformers1024: No harm done. I know my opinion isn't the popular one.

Beata

@eyedcyou: Does V for Vendetta count?

1. Batman Returns - 20pts
2. Iron Man - 19pts
3. Watchmen - 18pts
4. Sin City - 17pts
5. Avengers - 16pts
6. Winter Soldier - 15pts
7. Batman (1989) - 14pts
8. Superman II Director's Cut - 13pts
9. Amazing Spider-Man 2 - 12pts
10. Guardians of the Galaxy - 11pts
11. Dredd - 10pts
12. Men in Black - 9pts
13. Weird Science - 8pts
14. Spider-Man 2 - 7pts
15. Batman Begins - 6pts
16. Amazing Spider-Man -5pts
17. Kick-Ass - 4pts
18. The Crow - 3pts
19. Incredible Hulk - 2pts
20. Kick-Ass 2 - 1pts

20? My BAMF Villain is only 5.... well let's see

20-Watchmen

19-Man of Steel

18-Captain America TWS

17-X-Men DOFP

16-The Dark Knight

15-Spiderman 2

14-Iron Man

13-Constantine

12-Hellboy

11-X-Men First Class

10-Batman Begins

9-Spiderman 1

8-V for Vendetta

7-Captain America

6-Kick Ass

5-Blade 2

4-Ghost Rider

3-Blade

2-The Incredible Hulk

1-Gaurdians of the Galaxy

@transformers1024: sure. I'll say if it's from a comic book it's ok.

@spidey_jackson: @eyedcyou: lol yeah spawn wasn't that good. The nostalgia behind it is the only reason it made my list. And you can swap it out for transformers.

This was really hard and took a good 30 minutes. I knew what my top 2 were so I put those in place and thought up all the ones I love and then carved it down to 20. I gauged them by how much I want to rewatch them. Some stood out as better so I moved them accordingly. Then I went down the list starting with Avengers and asking myself if I wanted to watch that more than The Wolverine and I do so it stays. Went down the list like that and here we are.

• Man of Steel 20
• Winter Soldier 19
• Avengers 18
• The Wolverine 17
• Incredible Hulk 16
• DoFP 15
• First Class 14
• TMNT 2 13
• TMNT 12
• Spider-Man 2 11
• Dark Knight 10
• Iron Man 3 9
• TASM 8
• Batman 7
• Fantastic 4 6
• Spider-Man 5
• Ghost Rider 4
• The Punisher 3
• Superman 2 2
• Thor 1

20 - X-Men: Days of Future Past

19 - The Dark Knight Rises

18 - Captain America: The Winter Soldier

17 - The Avengers

16 - Thor

15 - Dredd

14 - Iron Man

13 - Captain America: The First Avenger

12 - Kick-Ass

11 - Batman Begins

10 - Batman Returns

9 - Batman (1989)

8 - Spider-Man

7 - The Incredible Hulk

6 - The Wolverine

5 - The Dark Knight

4 - Kick-Ass 2

3 - Spider-Man 3

2 - X-Men Origins: Wolverine

1 - Spider-Man 2

This list isn't exact, and will probably change as soon as I get a chance to watch Guardians of the Galaxy, but this is how it stands for now.

20. Avengers

19. Captain America: The Winter Soldier

18. Man of Steel

17. X-Men: Days of Future Past

16. Iron Man 2

15. Iron Man

14. X-Men: First Class

13. Batman Begins

12. Amazing Spider-Man

11. Spider-Man 2

10. Superman 2: The Richard Donner Cut

9. Captain America: The First Avenger

8. The Incredible Hulk

7. X2

6. Thor: The Dark World

5. Thor

4. Spider-Man

3. Daredevil (The Director’s Cut)

2. Batman (1989)

1. X-Men

20. Avengers

19. Amazing Spider-Man 2

18. Winter Soldier

17. Iron Man

16. X-Men: Days of Future Past

15. Iron Man 3

14. Guardians of the Galaxy

13. Incredible Hulk

12. X-Men 2

11. Thor: The Dark World

10. Man of Steel

9. Amazing Spider-Man

8. Kick-Ass

7. Spider-Man 2

6. The Wolverine

5. Kick-Ass 2

4. First Class

3. Thor

2. Hellboy

1. Captain America: The First Avenger

Keep em coming!

20- Captain America: The Winter Soldier
19- Hellboy 2: The Golden Army
18- The Dark Knight
17- Guardians of the Galaxy
16- X-Men: Days of Future Past
15- Marvel's The Avengers
14- Iron Man
13- Hellboy
12- X-Men 2
11- X-Men: First Class
10- Spider-Man 2
9- Kick-Ass
8- Super
7- Captain America: The First Avenger
6- Blade 2
5- X-Men
4- Spider-Man
3- The Amazing Spider-Man
2- The Amazing Spider-Man 2
1- Kick-Ass 2

20: Dark Knight

19: Cap 2

18: MOS

17: Batman Begins

16: Dark Knight Rises

15: GotG

14: Watchmen

13: Iron Man

14: Spiderman 2

13: Spiderman

12: Avengers

13: Batman

12: X-men First Class

11: X-men 2

10: X-me DoFP

9: X-men

8: Superman 2

7: Superman

6: X-men

5: Kick-ass

4: Thor 2

3: Superman Returns

2: ASM 2

1: Batman Returns

20 Man of Steel

19 Captain America Winter Soldier

18 Captain America First Avenger

17 Hancock

16 Thor Dark World

15 Incredible Hulk

14 Iron Man

13 Batman 1989

12 The Dark Knight

11 Punisher Dirty Laundry (ITS GREAT, youtube it.)

10 Dredd

9 Dark Knight Rises

8 X-men First Class

7 X-men Days of Futures past

6 Constantine

5 Watchmen

4 (1977 version) The Amazing Spiderman

3 Batman Returns

2 Thor

1 X-men Origins Wolverin

@eyedcyou: 20 best or our 20 favourites?

CHANGED LIST

20.The Dark Knight

19. Man of Steel

18. Kickass

17. CA:TWS

16. .Spider-Man

15.Spiderman 2

14. TDKR

13. Batman Begins

12.GOTG

11 .Superman I

10.Superman II

9. X-men 2

8. X-men

7. Captain America:TFA

6. Dredd

5. Spiderman

4. X-men: DOFP

3. Avengers

2. Batman(1989)

1.Thor

Good luck with tallying up those votes. Honestly you should have gone for top 10

@larryashlynn: You got MoS twice on yours

• 20 - Batman Begins
• 19 - Spider-Man
• 18 - The Dark Knight
• 17 - The Incredible Hulk
• 16 - Man of Steel
• 15 - Batman
• 14 - Blade
• 13 - Spider-Man 2
• 12 - Superman
• 11 - The Amazing Spider-Man
• 10 - The Dark Knight Rises
• 9 - Transformers
• 8 - Captain America: TWS
• 7 - Superman 2
• 6 - The Avengers
• 5 - G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra
• 4 - X-Men 2
• 3 - Iron Man 2
• 2 - Batman Returns
• 1 - Blade 2

@saint_wildcard: Yeah, tallying all these are gonna be a pain in the arse.

Beata

@saint_wildcard: fixed

20 points Cap 2

19 points MOS

18 Punisher Dirty Laundry

17 Incredible Hulk

16 Batman 1989

15 The Dark Knight

14 Thor Dark World

13 Batman Returns

12 Watchmen

11 Iron Man

10 X-men Days of Futures past

9 Cap first

8 Dredd

7 Dark Knight Rises

6 Flash Gordon

5 Xmen first Class

4 Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (1990)

3 Hancock

2 Iron Man 2

1 Spiderman 2

Let's get more!

20. The Dark Knight

19. The Dark Knight Rises

18. Batman The Dark Knight Returns, Part 2

17. Batman Begins

16. Kick-Ass

15. The Batman Superman Movie: World's Finest

14. Batman: Under the Red Hood

13. Avengers Assemble

12. Watchmen

11. X-Men First Class

10. Hellboy 2: The Golden Army

9. Batman: Mystery of Batwoman

8. Batman: Mask of the Phantasm

7. Blade

6. Hulk Vs.

5. Iron Man 3

4. The Incredible Hulk

3. Kick-Ass 2

2. Man of Steel

1. X-Men Origins: Wolverine (I know they messed alot of things up, but still enjoyable.)

@eyedcyou: You can have 100 in a ranked list, so why don't you set it out like that? I know it would be hard to get 100 films in a list.

Maybe you could set it out similar to my heroes/villains.
http://www.comicvine.com/profile/guru_crack/lists/comic-vine-top-100-villains-2014/52996/

Sorry if you rpefer your way of doing things thought i'd throw the idea out there.

@guru_crack: Considered doing a bigger list, but I don't think the variety would allow the list to get that big. Also, I asked for live-action films only :P could I ask you to redo your list?

Genuinely Surprised by the lack of Spider-Man 2 love.

20 Spider-Man 2

19 The Dark Knight

18 Avengers

17 Winter Soldier

16 Thor

15 Batman Begins

14 TMNT (1990)

13 Guardians of the Galaxy

12 Days of Future Past

11 Batman

10 Iron Man

9 Superman: The Movie

8 Blade II

7 Captain America: The First Avenger

6 Hellboy

5 The Dark Knight Rises

4 X-Men First Class

3 Iron Man 3

2 Man of Steel

1 Blade

Just tallied up all the current points. To my surprise, The Dark Knight is not in first.