• 175 results
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
#1 Posted by yahweh (326 posts) - - Show Bio


#2 Edited by yahweh (326 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor

1.You get all the powers Thor has displayed over the years

2. You have access to the full power of the Odin Force at all times

3. You also get Rune Magic

4. Your powers increase with age

or

Superman

1. You powers are completely dependent upon a yellow sun

2. Weaknesses are included for Superman

3. This pre 52 superman, not all star, not silver age, not golden superman

4. Your powers increase with age

#3 Posted by TheCannon (18918 posts) - - Show Bio

How do you not pick Thor? The only thing Superman has that Thor doesn't is speed.

#4 Posted by Jorgevy (5114 posts) - - Show Bio

Do Superman's powers increase with age? or with solar exposion? like, if he stays 1000 years under a blue sun, he will get much more powerful but it's because of the sun and not because of the age? or Im mixing this up?

#5 Posted by bgibs13390 (891 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor all the way. The only thing that Superman has him on is speed and heat vision. Thor has the badass hammer and I'm not going to lie I would love to be the god of storms. Overall he is also more powerful with a wider array of powers.

#6 Posted by tim2081 (519 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor easily, especially with the full power of Odin Force.

#7 Posted by AKA_TERMINATOR (332 posts) - - Show Bio

@TheCannon said:

How do you not pick Thor? The only thing Superman has that Thor doesn't is speed.

uh their thor and superman don't have the same super powers for example thor doesn't have heat vision, x- ray vision, arctic breath and so on... kinda like superman doesnt relie on a hammer, he was born with his powers ( i think. ) so we all know the differences in both characters.

Me personally i'd prefer supermans because of heat fision and arctic breath. x-ray vision too...lol

#8 Posted by Sovereign91001 (4538 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman. No if ands or buts.

#9 Posted by yahweh (326 posts) - - Show Bio

@Jorgevy said:

Do Superman's powers increase with age? or with solar exposion? like, if he stays 1000 years under a blue sun, he will get much more powerful but it's because of the sun and not because of the age? or Im mixing this up?

Under continous yellow sun exposure, Superman becomes increasingly more powerful: intelligence, strength, speed,etc. All increase.

It's the same as if the longer you stay under a sun without sun tan lotion, the worse your tan becomes, but instead of getting a tan, you get more powerful.

And ONLY a yellow sun can give you your powers.

@AKA_TERMINATOR said:

@TheCannon said:

How do you not pick Thor? The only thing Superman has that Thor doesn't is speed.

uh their thor and superman don't have the same super powers for example thor doesn't have heat vision, x- ray vision, arctic breath and so on... kinda like superman doesnt relie on a hammer, he was born with his powers ( i think. ) so we all know the differences in both characters.

Me personally i'd prefer supermans because of heat fision and arctic breath. x-ray vision too...lol

1. Thor has heat vision

2. Thor has artic breath

3. Superman's powers depend on the sun. Without it, he's human. Thor without his hammer>>>>Superman without the sun.

4. Thor is born with his powers as well.

#10 Posted by yahweh (326 posts) - - Show Bio

@TheCannon said:

How do you not pick Thor? The only thing Superman has that Thor doesn't is speed.

Thor has speed as well.

#11 Posted by TheGoldenOne (38849 posts) - - Show Bio

-________________-

#12 Posted by ComicMan24 (147093 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman's, definitely.

#13 Posted by Mega_spidey01 (3078 posts) - - Show Bio
SUPERMAN FOR ME.
#14 Posted by Aronmorales (9434 posts) - - Show Bio

Hmm...Thor.

Wait, do I also get Mjolnir?

#15 Posted by JayMar89 (91 posts) - - Show Bio

man of steel all the way

#16 Posted by yahweh (326 posts) - - Show Bio

@Aronmorales said:

Hmm...Thor.

Wait, do I also get Mjolnir?

Obviously.....

@TheGoldenOne said:

-________________-

I'm not understanding your point.

#17 Posted by yahweh (326 posts) - - Show Bio

@JayMar89 said:

man of steel all the way

Did you vote?

#18 Posted by karrob (4280 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor

#19 Posted by JayMar89 (91 posts) - - Show Bio

yeah

#20 Posted by FadeToBlackBolt (23334 posts) - - Show Bio

So the OP makes a thread asking if he should make this thread, most people say no, he then makes the thread anyway, and fanwanks Thor to invalidate any purpose it could have had.  
 
Yep, this is a worthwhile thread. 

#21 Posted by Remi (613 posts) - - Show Bio

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

So the OP makes a thread asking if he should make this thread, most people say no, he then makes the thread anyway, and fanwanks Thor to invalidate any purpose it could have had. Yep, this is a worthwhile thread.

You also forgot that he and others have made this thread before and that he's done the general "whose powers would you rather have" thread. ^_^

#22 Posted by Jorgevy (5114 posts) - - Show Bio

@yahweh: once again Im confusin, I tought Blue Suns could also increase Kryptonians powers pre 52 and I though that Thor without his hammer still retained several powers

#23 Posted by Duke_Nasty (1017 posts) - - Show Bio

I hate both but easily Superman because I could just walk around in street clothes as Superman.

#24 Posted by AKA_TERMINATOR (332 posts) - - Show Bio

@yahweh said:

@Jorgevy said:

Do Superman's powers increase with age? or with solar exposion? like, if he stays 1000 years under a blue sun, he will get much more powerful but it's because of the sun and not because of the age? or Im mixing this up?

Under continous yellow sun exposure, Superman becomes increasingly more powerful: intelligence, strength, speed,etc. All increase.

It's the same as if the longer you stay under a sun without sun tan lotion, the worse your tan becomes, but instead of getting a tan, you get more powerful.

And ONLY a yellow sun can give you your powers.

@AKA_TERMINATOR said:

@TheCannon said:

How do you not pick Thor? The only thing Superman has that Thor doesn't is speed.

uh their thor and superman don't have the same super powers for example thor doesn't have heat vision, x- ray vision, arctic breath and so on... kinda like superman doesnt relie on a hammer, he was born with his powers ( i think. ) so we all know the differences in both characters.

Me personally i'd prefer supermans because of heat fision and arctic breath. x-ray vision too...lol

1. Thor has heat vision

2. Thor has artic breath

3. Superman's powers depend on the sun. Without it, he's human. Thor without his hammer>>>>Superman without the sun.

4. Thor is born with his powers as well.

Very true, as far as thor goes he was a warrior though that had to earn his hammer.

#25 Posted by yahweh (326 posts) - - Show Bio

@Jorgevy said:

@yahweh: once again Im confusin, I tought Blue Suns could also increase Kryptonians powers pre 52 and I though that Thor without his hammer still retained several powers

Yes on both accounts.

@Duke_Nasty said:

I hate both but easily Superman because I could just walk around in street clothes as Superman.

So can Thor.

#26 Edited by yahweh (326 posts) - - Show Bio

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

So the OP makes a thread asking if he should make this thread, most people say no, he then makes the thread anyway, and fanwanks Thor to invalidate any purpose it could have had. Yep, this is a worthwhile thread.

They say they don't care, so I make the thread.

And current thor possesses the same powers as classic thor, so be quiet about fanwanking and go read a comic for once in your life.

#27 Edited by FadeToBlackBolt (23334 posts) - - Show Bio
@yahweh said:

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

So the OP makes a thread asking if he should make this thread, most people say no, he then makes the thread anyway, and fanwanks Thor to invalidate any purpose it could have had. Yep, this is a worthwhile thread.

They say they don't care, so I make the thread.

And current thor possesses the same powers as classic thor, so shut the fuck up about fanwanking and go read a comic for once in your life.

I have read a comic, no doubt more than you, which is why I know that the deck is clearly stacked here for everyone to say Thor.  
 
Whatever validation you're looking for in these threads isn't going to be found. 
 
Oh, and your name is horribly offensive and tactless.  
 
And flagged, have a nice day =] 
#28 Posted by yahweh (326 posts) - - Show Bio

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

I have read a comic, no doubt more than you, which is why I know that the deck is clearly stacked here for everyone to say Thor. Whatever validation you're looking for in these threads isn't going to be found. Oh, and your name is horribly offensive and tactless. And flagged, have a nice day =]

1. You don't know how many comics I've read, so shut up.

2. Not really stacked for Thor, because IF you've read comics, you would classic thor and current thor are one in the same, so I didn't fanwank, I stated the obvious, and yet you had to be informed of something that's common knowledge.

3. My name is merely a name, and it only offends you? Get over it.

4. See ya, troll.

#29 Posted by majestic99 (8637 posts) - - Show Bio

@FadeToBlackBolt: And I guess you have trouble reading seeing as how more people choose Superman.

#30 Posted by FadeToBlackBolt (23334 posts) - - Show Bio
@yahweh said:

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

I have read a comic, no doubt more than you, which is why I know that the deck is clearly stacked here for everyone to say Thor. Whatever validation you're looking for in these threads isn't going to be found. Oh, and your name is horribly offensive and tactless. And flagged, have a nice day =]

1. You don't know how many comics I've read, so shut up.

2. Not really stacked for Thor, because IF you've read comics, you would classic thor and current thor are one in the same, so I didn't fanwank, I stated the obvious, and yet you had to be informed of something that's common knowledge.

3. My name is merely a name, and it only offends you? Get over it.

4. See ya, troll.

1. Ever the charmer.  
 
2. Really? That's fine, I don't remember classic Thor getting taken out by Rhino. Of course, that would be acknowledging that Thor has a weakness, and we don't want to put that down, do we? 
 
3. Eh, that's a fair call.  
 
4. Yes, I'm the troll. I'm the one who makes dozens of the same thread, doesn't listen to reason, swears when someone points out our faults and is so starved for attention that I'd make a thread asking people if I should make a thread.  
20000 posts against your 300. Entire wiki-pages written by me against your 162 wikipoints. Of the two of us, I'm clearly the troll. 
#31 Posted by majestic99 (8637 posts) - - Show Bio

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

1. Ever the charmer. 2. Really? That's fine, I don't remember classic Thor getting taken out by Rhino. Of course, that would be acknowledging that Thor has a weakness, and we don't want to put that down, do we? 3. Eh, that's a fair call. 4. Yes, I'm the troll. I'm the one who makes dozens of the same thread, doesn't listen to reason, swears when someone points out our faults and is so starved for attention that I'd make a thread asking people if I should make a thread. 20000 posts against your 300. Entire wiki-pages written by me against your 162 wikipoints. Of the two of us, I'm clearly the troll.

1. Whatever

2. I said Current Thor possesses the same powers as Classic Thor, I didn't say he was written the same.

3. So I post more, and make threads?(which aren't the same) Yes. Because I post more I'm a troll.

Your logic is impeccable.

#32 Posted by FadeToBlackBolt (23334 posts) - - Show Bio
@majestic99 said:

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

1. Ever the charmer. 2. Really? That's fine, I don't remember classic Thor getting taken out by Rhino. Of course, that would be acknowledging that Thor has a weakness, and we don't want to put that down, do we? 3. Eh, that's a fair call. 4. Yes, I'm the troll. I'm the one who makes dozens of the same thread, doesn't listen to reason, swears when someone points out our faults and is so starved for attention that I'd make a thread asking people if I should make a thread. 20000 posts against your 300. Entire wiki-pages written by me against your 162 wikipoints. Of the two of us, I'm clearly the troll.

1. Whatever

2. I said Current Thor possesses the same powers as Classic Thor, I didn't say he was written the same.

3. So I post more, and make threads?(which aren't the same) Yes. Because I post more I'm a troll.

Your logic is impeccable.

Ooooh, so we have to take this based solely on the fact that current Thor should be written as having the Odin Force, Rune powers and alike, but the writers not using any of that is just a little hiccough? Yet you were specific to choose Superman's weakest iteration since the Golden Age. See how obvious it is that you're biased? 
 
Yeah, not sure where you learned to count, 20000 is more than 300. I post more =] 20000 is even more than 10000, shocking isn't it?  
 
And your threads are the same.  
 
"Thor or XXXXX; whose powers would you rather have?" 
"Thor or XXXXX; whose powers would you rather have?"      
"Will Thor love me if I make enough of these threads?"
"Thor or XXXXX; whose powers would you rather have?"  
#33 Posted by yahweh (326 posts) - - Show Bio

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

Ooooh, so we have to take this based solely on the fact that current Thor should be written as having the Odin Force, Rune powers and alike, but the writers not using any of that is just a little hiccough? Yet you were specific to choose Superman's weakest iteration since the Golden Age. See how obvious it is that you're biased? Yeah, not sure where you learned to count, 20000 is more than 300. I post more =] 20000 is even more than 10000, shocking isn't it? And your threads are the same. "Thor or XXXXX; whose powers would you rather have?" "Thor or XXXXX; whose powers would you rather have?" "Will Thor love me if I make enough of these threads?" "Thor or XXXXX; whose powers would you rather have?"

1. Never said that, I merely gave him the Odin Force, you're puttign words in my mouth.

2. You said me making posts makes me a troll, which it doesn't.

3. Still haven't made duplicate threads.

#34 Posted by yahweh (326 posts) - - Show Bio

@Remi said:


You also forgot that he and others have made this thread before and that he's done the general "whose powers would you rather have" thread. ^_^

1. I am aware of that

2. No I haven't

#35 Edited by FadeToBlackBolt (23334 posts) - - Show Bio
@yahweh said:

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

Ooooh, so we have to take this based solely on the fact that current Thor should be written as having the Odin Force, Rune powers and alike, but the writers not using any of that is just a little hiccough? Yet you were specific to choose Superman's weakest iteration since the Golden Age. See how obvious it is that you're biased? Yeah, not sure where you learned to count, 20000 is more than 300. I post more =] 20000 is even more than 10000, shocking isn't it? And your threads are the same. "Thor or XXXXX; whose powers would you rather have?" "Thor or XXXXX; whose powers would you rather have?" "Will Thor love me if I make enough of these threads?" "Thor or XXXXX; whose powers would you rather have?"

1. Never said that, I merely gave him the Odin Force, you're puttign words in my mouth.

2. You said me making posts makes me a troll, which it doesn't.

3. Still haven't made duplicate threads.

1. Oh, so you gave Thor the Odin Force as well as his classic powers. I see. Wait... Doesn't that support my "you buffed Thor up to extremes" theory?  
  
2. Ugh, no I didn't. I said making the same threads over and over makes you a troll. This is like trying to explain quantum physics to a second grader or a Cannon.  
 
3. Yes, you have. There's an umbrella thread for these pointless fantasy threads, that you ironically created, which means every one of these threads is a redundancy. 
#36 Posted by majestic99 (8637 posts) - - Show Bio

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

1. Oh, so you gave Thor the Odin Force as well as his classic powers. I see. Wait... Doesn't that support my "you buffed Thor up to extremes" theory? 2. Ugh, no I didn't. I said making the same threads over and over makes you a troll. This is like trying to explain quantum physics to a second grader or a Cannon. 3. Yes, you have. There's an umbrella thread for these pointless fantasy threads, that you ironically created, which means everyone of these threads is a redundancy.

1. If you read, I've already said Current Thor possesses the same powers as Classic Thor.

2.I haven't made duplicate threads.

3. So me making threads makes it a fantasy? Your logic is flawless.

#37 Posted by FadeToBlackBolt (23334 posts) - - Show Bio
@majestic99 said:

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

1. Oh, so you gave Thor the Odin Force as well as his classic powers. I see. Wait... Doesn't that support my "you buffed Thor up to extremes" theory? 2. Ugh, no I didn't. I said making the same threads over and over makes you a troll. This is like trying to explain quantum physics to a second grader or a Cannon. 3. Yes, you have. There's an umbrella thread for these pointless fantasy threads, that you ironically created, which means everyone of these threads is a redundancy.

1. If you read, I've already said Current Thor possesses the same powers as Classic Thor.

2.I haven't made duplicate threads.

3. So me making threads makes it a fantasy? Your logic is flawless.

1. Yes. I know. We've moved past that. I'm addressing the fact that you gave him additional powers that were outside of the ordinary in order to weight the thread. I'm not saying anything against Thor, I'm saying that you have no integrity and are slow.  
 
2. YES. YOU HAVE. What part of redundancies do you not get? 
 
3. "Which power would you rather have" is a fantasy question. Seriously, you can't be serious with this. This has to be an act. I mean, no one is this dumb. 
#38 Posted by jwalser3 (5074 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman

But if I have Thor's power could I lose the Hammer would I lose the power?

#39 Posted by majestic99 (8637 posts) - - Show Bio

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

1. Yes. I know. We've moved past that. I'm addressing the fact that you gave him additional powers that were outside of the ordinary in order to weight the thread. I'm not saying anything against Thor, I'm saying that you have no integrity and are slow. 2. YES. YOU HAVE. What part of redundancies do you not get? 3. "Which power would you rather have" is a fantasy question. Seriously, you can't be serious with this. This has to be an act. I mean, no one is this dumb.

1. So he has the Odin Force. Big whup. Get over it. It seems since giving Thor the Odin Force is the end of the world I'd say you're the slow one.

2. No I haven't

3. No, it's just a question. Like "where is this from?" or "who is this?" Only difference is you like to criticize me.

#40 Posted by 0n1zuka (3715 posts) - - Show Bio

@majestic99: FadeToBlackBolt does have a point about your alt's name. It is offensive to some people.

#41 Posted by majestic99 (8637 posts) - - Show Bio

@0n1zuka said:

@majestic99: FadeToBlackBolt does have a point about your alt's name. It is offensive to some people.

They can get over it. Worse things have been said on the internet.

#42 Posted by majestic99 (8637 posts) - - Show Bio

@jwalser3 said:

Superman

But if I have Thor's power could I lose the Hammer would I lose the power?

No, you'll always have the hammer.

#43 Edited by FadeToBlackBolt (23334 posts) - - Show Bio
@majestic99 said:

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

1. Yes. I know. We've moved past that. I'm addressing the fact that you gave him additional powers that were outside of the ordinary in order to weight the thread. I'm not saying anything against Thor, I'm saying that you have no integrity and are slow. 2. YES. YOU HAVE. What part of redundancies do you not get? 3. "Which power would you rather have" is a fantasy question. Seriously, you can't be serious with this. This has to be an act. I mean, no one is this dumb.

1. So he has the Odin Force. Big whup. Get over it. It seems since giving Thor the Odin Force is the end of the world I'd say you're the slow one.

2. No I haven't

3. No, it's just a question. Like "where is this from?" or "who is this?" Only difference is you like to criticize me.

1. The Odin Force which is basically a plot power, yeah, I'd say it's a big deal. The bigger issue is that you gave Superman weaknesses and a weakened, virtually featless, iteration against a Thor that you've just compiled from every version's most powerful aspects. You have no integrity, you make these threads to fanwank Thor, these are facts that are not in dispute.  
 
2. Not going to keep arguing that, it's getting sad.  
 
3. I don't like to criticize you, I point out stupidity in all threads, it's what I do. Also, where is this from and who is this both have a dedicated thread and are locked when someone makes a specific thread for them. Kind of like how there's a dedicated thread for these.... 
 
Nicely done, proving the opposition's point is always a good defence =] 
#44 Posted by jwalser3 (5074 posts) - - Show Bio

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

1. The Odin Force which is basically a plot power, yeah, I'd say it's a big deal. The bigger issue is that you gave Superman weaknesses and a weakened, virtually featless, iteration against a Thor that you've just compiled from every versions most powerful aspects. You have no integrity, you make these threads to fanwank Thor, these are facts that are not in dispute.

He has a point.

#45 Posted by Onemoreposter (4065 posts) - - Show Bio

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

So the OP makes a thread asking if he should make this thread, most people say no, he then makes the thread anyway, and fanwanks Thor to invalidate any purpose it could have had. Yep, this is a worthwhile thread.

This. This so very much.

@majestic99 said:

@FadeToBlackBolt: And I guess you have trouble reading seeing as how more people choose Superman.

Yes, more people have chosen Superman. OP still blatantly stacked the cards in favor of Thor when making this thread.

#46 Edited by The_Tree (7525 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman. He has X-ray vision.

/thread

Online
#47 Posted by 0n1zuka (3715 posts) - - Show Bio

At any rate, my vote goes to Superman. I've kinda become not so fond of Thor these days, I wonder why that is.

#48 Posted by TheThe (1739 posts) - - Show Bio

I want Thor powers in a Supe costume.

#49 Posted by majestic99 (8637 posts) - - Show Bio

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

1. The Odin Force which is basically a plot power, yeah, I'd say it's a big deal. The bigger issue is that you gave Superman weaknesses and a weakened, virtually featless, iteration against a Thor that you've just compiled from every version's most powerful aspects. You have no integrity, you make these threads to fanwank Thor, these are facts that are not in dispute. 2. Not going to keep arguing that, it's getting sad. 3. I don't like to criticize you, I point out stupidity in all threads, it's what I do. Also, where is this from and who is this both have a dedicated thread and are locked when someone makes a specific thread for them. Kind of like how there's a dedicated thread for these.... Nicely done, proving the opposition's point is always a good defence =]

1. Pre 52 Superman has feats

2. Whatever

3. The only stupidity in this thread is you

@jwalser3 said:

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

1. The Odin Force which is basically a plot power, yeah, I'd say it's a big deal. The bigger issue is that you gave Superman weaknesses and a weakened, virtually featless, iteration against a Thor that you've just compiled from every versions most powerful aspects. You have no integrity, you make these threads to fanwank Thor, these are facts that are not in dispute.

He has a point.

Not really. I have said MULTIPLE times that Classic Thor and current Thor are the same AND said it was PRE 52 Superman. I mean, pre 52 Superman has feats, right?

#50 Posted by SoA (4844 posts) - - Show Bio

superman, my powers are natural and i don't have to compensate...err... i mean rely, on a over-sized mallet