#1 Edited by TheCannon (18742 posts) - - Show Bio

Contest over. Dr Doom is the winner

This has been done before for male and female heroes, so now I'm doing it for villains. I want to find out the top super villain of comics. I have listed 20. 10 Marvel, 10 DC.

How it works:

Here are the rules of Take a Point, Add a Point game (I'm sure a lot of you are already familiar with the game; the set of rules was copied from Rabbitearsblog's rules). First you must copy the list above you, take one point off of the person you hate the most on the list and add a point to the to the person you like the most on the list. When a person hits 0 they are out of the list. There can be only be one winner!

Rules:

For each post, you may add one point to a character and subtract one point from a different character. Add labels to all points that you change. For example, if you subtract a point from a character, then add (-1) after their name. Add (+1) to the character you are giving a point to.

You may also bold the names and points of the two characters you make a change to. This makes it easier for other users to see what you changed. Since you may only subtract a single point and add a single point for each post, there should only be two bold names in your post. (This rule is optional if you follow rule 3.)

Characters with zero points are eliminated. They are removed from the list and cannot be brought back.

You may only vote once every 24 hours, although you can vote for several days in a row. Your votes do not have to be identical each time.

The points of the remaining heroes must always add up to 200. Any more or less constitutes an INCORRECT post (Incorrect posts will just be left out by the next user)

After at least half of the characters have been eliminated (in this case: 10), you have the option to add two points to a character and subtract two points from a character. If a character has only one point left, you may only subtract one point from that character and add one point to another character. You may not subtract from more than more character in a single post. All other rules remain the same. Further point increases can be made later in the game at the discretion of the game leader. Please remember with multi-post posting that the number of points you take from one character must always equal the number of points you give to another character in that same post.

The list:

Dr Doom - 10

Magneto - 10

Loki - 10

Galactus - 10

Green Goblin - 10

Mandarin - 10

Thanos - 10

Dr Octopus - 10

Red Skull - 10

The Leader - 10

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker - 10

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 10

Sinestro - 10

Black Manta - 10

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 10

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

Online
#2 Posted by TheCannon (18742 posts) - - Show Bio

Dr Doom - 10

Magneto - 10

Loki - 11 (+1)

Galactus - 10

Green Goblin - 10

Mandarin - 10

Thanos - 10

Dr Octopus - 10

Red Skull - 10

The Leader - 10

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 10

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 9 (-1)

Sinestro - 10

Black Manta - 10

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 10

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

Online
#3 Posted by Rabbitearsblog (5894 posts) - - Show Bio

Dr Doom - 10

Magneto - 11 (+1)

Loki - 11

Galactus - 10

Green Goblin - 10

Mandarin - 10

Thanos - 10

Dr Octopus - 10

Red Skull - 10

The Leader - 10

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 10

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 8 (-1)

Sinestro - 10

Black Manta - 10

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 10

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

#4 Posted by nickthedevil (12498 posts) - - Show Bio

No Zoom? :(

#5 Posted by TheBane2890 (1958 posts) - - Show Bio

No Bane?

#6 Posted by mervotron (257 posts) - - Show Bio

Dr Doom - 10

Magneto - 12 (+1)

Loki - 11

Galactus - 10

Green Goblin - 10

Mandarin - 10

Thanos - 10

Dr Octopus - 10

Red Skull - 10

The Leader - 10

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 10

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 8

Sinestro - 10

Black Manta - 10

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 9 (-1)

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

#7 Posted by TDK_1997 (14896 posts) - - Show Bio

Dr Doom - 10

Magneto - 12

Loki - 11

Galactus - 10

Green Goblin - 10

Mandarin - 10

Thanos - 10

Dr Octopus - 10

Red Skull - 10

The Leader - 9 (-1)

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 11 (+1)

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 8

Sinestro - 10

Black Manta - 10

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 9

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

#8 Posted by TheCannon (18742 posts) - - Show Bio

@nickthedevil said:

No Zoom? :(

@TheBane2890 said:

No Bane?

You can never make everyone happy in these. I wanted to include the Penguin and Riddler, but I didn't. I included the Flash rogue Mirror Master, what more do you want?

Online
#9 Posted by nickthedevil (12498 posts) - - Show Bio

I want a quarter pounder, hold the pickles, no tomato either, give me two sides of fries and can i get a Coke with that?

#10 Posted by Kairan1979 (16746 posts) - - Show Bio

@TDK_1997 said:

Dr Doom - 10

Magneto - 12

Loki - 11

Galactus - 10

Green Goblin - 10

Mandarin - 10

Thanos - 10

Dr Octopus - 10

Red Skull - 10

The Leader - 9

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 11

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 8

Sinestro - 11 (+1)

Black Manta - 10

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 8 (-1)

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

#11 Posted by TheCannon (18742 posts) - - Show Bio

@nickthedevil said:

I want a quarter pounder, hold the pickles, no tomato either, give me two sides of fries and can i get a Coke with that?

Oh I'm afraid we're all out of that. I'm afraid all we have left is a punch in the face.

Online
#12 Posted by nickthedevil (12498 posts) - - Show Bio

Lol

#13 Posted by rogue_mar1e (19833 posts) - - Show Bio

Dr Doom - 11 (+1)

Magneto - 11 (-1)

Loki - 11

Galactus - 10

Green Goblin - 10

Mandarin - 10

Thanos - 10

Dr Octopus - 10

Red Skull - 10

The Leader - 9

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 11

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 8

Sinestro - 11

Black Manta - 10

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 8

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

#14 Posted by TheBane2890 (1958 posts) - - Show Bio

@TheCannon: I want the characters that are actually good, and the ones, that would actually get votes, not ones that will be eliminated right of the bat!

#15 Posted by TheCannon (18742 posts) - - Show Bio

I tried to be fair and include both Marvel and DC characters. When I got to DC, I tried to include a little of everyone. That's why mirror master is on there. If I put more Batman villains on there, they would of been Riddler, Penguin, Scarecrow, Poison Ivy, Harley Quinn, then Bane would of come in.

Online
#16 Posted by TheBane2890 (1958 posts) - - Show Bio

@TheCannon: Bane is better then all those characters, and half the characters on your list I wouldn't of used! There are hundreds of better villains in both universes!

#17 Posted by TheCannon (18742 posts) - - Show Bio

No there aren't. You could make the argument that Bane is better than Harley, which I would agree. But she's more popular. The only reason Mirror Master is on there is because I wanted a Flash rogue. And there are not hundreds of better villains from either universe. Just go along with the points unless you want to continue arguing.

Online
#18 Posted by TheBane2890 (1958 posts) - - Show Bio

Of the people on your list these would be the people I would've used:

Dr Doom, Magneto, Loki, Green Goblin, Thanos, Red Skull, Lex Luthor, The Joker, Sinestro, & Darkseid

These are the ones I wouldn't of used:

Galactus, Mandarin, Dr Octopus, Brainiac, General Zod, Two-Face, Bizarro, & Mirror Master

And this is where I'd put the characters I would be on the border about using, and I'd still probably wouldn't use them:

The Leader & Black Manta

Like I said earlier half your list isn't even worth using. And yes there are hundreds of better characters to use from both universes. And when you look at were the better villains are from most are from either Batman or the X-Men, and everyone knows that! Other series have great villains as well, but they aren't nearly as good of a character as the ones found in those series.

#19 Posted by TheCannon (18742 posts) - - Show Bio

How do you even consider not putting Galactus and Brainiac on here? Everyone else I could understand not using, but not Galactus and Brainiac.

Online
#20 Posted by TheBane2890 (1958 posts) - - Show Bio

Because neither one of them is overly popular, and because neither of them are the best villain!

#21 Posted by TheCannon (18742 posts) - - Show Bio

Brainiac is the best Superman villain and the second best villain in the DC Universe. Galactus ranks #4 in Marvel.

Online
#22 Posted by TheBane2890 (1958 posts) - - Show Bio

Please! The best villain in Superman is Lex, and Galactus isn't even in the top 20 Marvel villains! I would put Shocker above Galactus, and I would use Doomsday way before I use Brainiac, in fact I would even use Conduit before I use Brainiac!

#23 Posted by TheCannon (18742 posts) - - Show Bio

Who the f*** puts the Shocker above Galactus. Galactus has put the entire planet at risk. The only thing Shocker ever put at risk was his dignity. I've never even heard of Conduit.

Online
#24 Posted by TheBane2890 (1958 posts) - - Show Bio

Galactus is a giant P****! He may've put a planet at risk, but he still ran away like the P**** he is! And Conduit may be unknown to you and most fans, but he is a much better character then Brainiac!

#25 Posted by TheCannon (18742 posts) - - Show Bio

Have you ever read anything with Galactus?

Online
#26 Posted by TheBane2890 (1958 posts) - - Show Bio

Yes I have! And he is an extremely boring character. The only time I thought his appearance was even kinda cool, was in Earth-9997 and even then it wasn't that great, and he was still boring!

#27 Posted by TheCannon (18742 posts) - - Show Bio

You're a f***ing idiot. Galactus is one of the most interesting villains in comics. He's no where near as interesting as Dr Doom, Magneto, or Loki, but he ranks up there with them.

Online
#28 Posted by TheBane2890 (1958 posts) - - Show Bio

No he doesn't! Characters like Lady Deathstrike, Blackheart, Rhino, Hammerhead, Constrictor, Klaw, and much much more are way more interesting, and way better characters then Galactus! FF is one of the worst comic series ever!

#29 Posted by TheCannon (18742 posts) - - Show Bio

Klaw and Hammerhead suck. I've never even heard of the Constrictor. The other ones, except Rhino I guess you could argue about, but Galactus is still interesting. The FF is one of the best comics ever. Better than anything DC ever put out.

Online
#30 Posted by TheBane2890 (1958 posts) - - Show Bio

@TheCannon: The point of putting sh*ty characters in my last post, was to show how much Galactus sucks! And the FF does suck, but I will admit it is far better then half the sh*t DC comes out with, but Batman stomps almost all Marvel comics!

#31 Posted by TheCannon (18742 posts) - - Show Bio

Batman doesn't compare at all to Thor, Spider-man, the X-men, the Fantastic Four, Iron Man, Captain America, Hulk, or the Avengers.

Online
#32 Posted by Kairan1979 (16746 posts) - - Show Bio

@rogue_mar1e said:

Dr Doom - 11

Magneto - 12 (+1)

Loki - 11

Galactus - 10

Green Goblin - 10

Mandarin - 10

Thanos - 10

Dr Octopus - 10

Red Skull - 10

The Leader - 9

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 11

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 8

Sinestro - 11

Black Manta - 10

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 7 (-1)

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

#33 Posted by nickthedevil (12498 posts) - - Show Bio

Dr Doom - 11

Magneto - 11 (-1)

Loki - 11

Galactus - 10

Green Goblin - 10

Mandarin - 10

Thanos - 10

Dr Octopus - 10

Red Skull - 11 (+1)

The Leader - 9

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 11

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 8

Sinestro - 11

Black Manta - 10

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 7

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

#34 Posted by TheBane2890 (1958 posts) - - Show Bio

@TheCannon: Are you kidding me! Minus FF those are pretty good titles, and some of the best, but Batman is 1000x better then all of them put together! Yes, some of his comics do get a bit boring, and some of his villains aren't that great, but they are still better then most of Marvels characters, and there are far less boring comics in Batman then there are in any of the other titles you mentioned!

#35 Posted by TheCannon (18742 posts) - - Show Bio

Batman is just the same. Every few years you ask yourself "Okay, who's gonna be the new Robin?" The stories get old, and they can't keep their history right,

Online
#36 Posted by Mighty Thorion (797 posts) - - Show Bio

@nickthedevil said:

Dr Doom - 11

Magneto - 11

Loki - 11

Galactus - 10

Green Goblin - 10

Mandarin - 10

Thanos - 10

Dr Octopus - 10

Red Skull - 11

The Leader - 9

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 12 (+1)

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 8

Sinestro - 11

Black Manta - 10

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 6 (-1)

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

#37 Posted by webofthornns (670 posts) - - Show Bio

@Mighty Thorion said:

@nickthedevil said:

Dr Doom - 11

Magneto - 11

Loki - 11

Galactus - 9 (-1)

Green Goblin - 10

Mandarin - 11 (+1)

Thanos - 10

Dr Octopus - 10

Red Skull - 11

The Leader - 9

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 12

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 8

Sinestro - 11

Black Manta - 10

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 6

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

#38 Posted by TheCannon (18742 posts) - - Show Bio

@webofthornns said:

Dr Doom - 11

Magneto - 11

Loki - 12 (+1)

Galactus - 9

Green Goblin - 10

Mandarin - 11

Thanos - 9 (-1)

Dr Octopus - 10

Red Skull - 11

The Leader - 9

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 12

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 8

Sinestro - 11

Black Manta - 10

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 6

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

Online
#39 Posted by davelecave (1113 posts) - - Show Bio

Dr Doom - 11

Magneto - 11

Loki - 12

Galactus - 9

Green Goblin - 10

Mandarin - 11

Thanos - 9

Dr Octopus - 10

Red Skull - 11

The Leader - 9

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 13 (+1)

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 8

Sinestro - 11

Black Manta - 9 (-1)

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 6

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

#40 Posted by Kairan1979 (16746 posts) - - Show Bio

Dr Doom - 11

Magneto - 12 (+1)

Loki - 12

Galactus - 9

Green Goblin - 10

Mandarin - 11

Thanos - 9

Dr Octopus - 10

Red Skull - 11

The Leader - 9

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 13

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 8

Sinestro - 11

Black Manta - 9

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 5 (-1)

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

#41 Posted by mervotron (257 posts) - - Show Bio

Dr Doom - 11

Magneto - 13 (+1)

Loki - 12

Galactus - 9

Green Goblin - 10

Mandarin - 11

Thanos - 9

Dr Octopus - 10

Red Skull - 11

The Leader - 9

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 13

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 8

Sinestro - 11

Black Manta - 9

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 4 (-1)

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

#42 Posted by Zomboid (740 posts) - - Show Bio

Dr Doom - 11

Magneto - 13

Loki - 12

Galactus - 8 (-1)

Green Goblin - 10

Mandarin - 11

Thanos - 9

Dr Octopus - 10

Red Skull - 11

The Leader - 9

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 14 (+1)

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 8

Sinestro - 11

Black Manta - 9

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 4

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

#43 Posted by TheCannon (18742 posts) - - Show Bio

@Zomboid said:

Dr Doom - 11

Magneto - 13

Loki - 13 (+1)

Galactus - 8

Green Goblin - 10

Mandarin - 11

Thanos - 9

Dr Octopus - 10

Red Skull - 11

The Leader - 9

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 14

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 7 (-1)

Sinestro - 11

Black Manta - 9

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 4

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

Online
#44 Posted by Nia Wolf (215 posts) - - Show Bio

Dr Doom - 11

Magneto - 13

Loki - 14 (+1)

Galactus - 8

Green Goblin - 10

Mandarin - 11

Thanos - 9

Dr Octopus - 10

Red Skull - 11

The Leader - 9

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 14

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 7

Sinestro - 10 (-1)

Black Manta - 9

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 4

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

#45 Posted by rogue_mar1e (19833 posts) - - Show Bio

Dr Doom - 12 (+1)

Magneto - 13

Loki - 14

Galactus - 8

Green Goblin - 10

Mandarin - 11

Thanos - 9

Dr Octopus - 9 (-1)

Red Skull - 11

The Leader - 9

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 14

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 7

Sinestro - 10

Black Manta - 9

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 4

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

#46 Posted by Deadcool (6811 posts) - - Show Bio

Dr Doom - 12

Magneto - 13

Loki - 14

Galactus - 8

Green Goblin - 11 (+1)

Mandarin - 11

Thanos - 9

Dr Octopus - 9

Red Skull - 11

The Leader - 9

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 14

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 7

Sinestro - 10

Black Manta - 9

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 3 (-1)

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

#47 Posted by Kairan1979 (16746 posts) - - Show Bio

Dr Doom - 12

Magneto - 14 (+1)

Loki - 14

Galactus - 8

Green Goblin - 11

Mandarin - 11

Thanos - 9

Dr Octopus - 9

Red Skull - 11

The Leader - 9

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 14

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 7

Sinestro - 10

Black Manta - 9

Two-Face - 10

Bizarro - 2 (-1)

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

#48 Posted by Tunsieon (316 posts) - - Show Bio

Dr Doom - 12

Magneto - 13 (-1)

Loki - 14

Galactus - 8

Green Goblin - 11

Mandarin - 11

Thanos - 9

Dr Octopus - 9

Red Skull - 11

The Leader - 9

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 14

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 7

Sinestro - 10

Black Manta - 9

Two-Face - 11 (+1)

Bizarro - 2

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

Mirror Master but no Captain Cold?

#49 Posted by Nia Wolf (215 posts) - - Show Bio

Dr Doom - 12

Magneto - 13

Loki - 15 (+1)

Galactus - 7 (-1)

Green Goblin - 11

Mandarin - 11

Thanos - 9

Dr Octopus - 9

Red Skull - 11

The Leader - 9

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 14

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 7

Sinestro - 10

Black Manta - 9

Two-Face - 11

Bizarro - 2

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

#50 Posted by TheCannon (18742 posts) - - Show Bio

@Nia Wolf said:

Dr Doom - 12

Magneto - 13

Loki - 16 (+1)

Galactus - 7

Green Goblin - 11

Mandarin - 11

Thanos - 9

Dr Octopus - 9

Red Skull - 11

The Leader - 9

Lex Luthor - 10

The Joker- 14

Brainiac - 10

General Zod - 7

Sinestro - 10

Black Manta - 9

Two-Face - 11

Bizarro - 1 (-1)

Darkseid - 10

Mirror Master - 10

I wanted to take a point off of General Zod, but I figured it was time to put Bizarro out of his misery.

Online