Take a point, add a point : kill or not-kill the Bat-family

This is not a battle thread. And you don't have to take a point from one of the members of the Bat-family, if you don't want to. The rules are standard rules of the Take Point Give Point threads.

The Rules

1. For each post, you may add 1 point to a character and subtract 1 point from a different character.
2. Add labels to all points that you change. For example, if you subtract a point from a character, then add (-1) after their name. Add (+1) to the character you are giving a point to.
3. You may also bold the names and points of the two characters you make a change to. This makes it easier for other users to see
4. what you changed. Since you may only subtract a single point and add a single point for each post, there should only be two bold names in your post. (This rule is optional if you follow rule 3)
5. Characters with zero points are eliminated. They are removed from the list and cannot be brought back.
6. You may only vote once every 24 hours, although you can vote for several days in a row. Your votes do not have to be identical each time.
7. After half have been eliminated (in this case: 10) the amount will double and when that is halved it doubles again... ...rinse and repeat this formula.

I'll start:

Joker -11 (+1)

Clayface -10

Batman -9 (-1)

Bane -10

Mr. Freeze -10

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -10

Two Face -10

The Penguin -10

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc -10

The Scarecrow -10

Riddler -10

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -10

Nightwing -10

Damian Wayne -10

Jason Todd -10

Joker -11

Clayface -10

Batman -10 (+1)

Bane -10

Mr. Freeze -10

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -10

Two Face -10

The Penguin -10

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc -9 (-1)

The Scarecrow -10

Riddler -10

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -10

Nightwing -10

Damian Wayne -10

Jason Todd -10

@theconman1876:

Joker -11

Clayface -10

Batman -10

Bane -10

Mr. Freeze -11 (+1)

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -10

Two Face -10

The Penguin -10

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc -9

The Scarecrow -10

Riddler -10

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -10

Nightwing -9 (-1)

Damian Wayne -10

Jason Todd -10

@JokerTheShining:

Joker -11

Clayface -10

Batman -10

Bane -10

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -10

Two Face -10

The Penguin -10

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc -9

The Scarecrow -10

Riddler -10

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11 (+1)

Nightwing -9

Damian Wayne - 9 (-1)

Jason Todd -10

Joker -11

Clayface -10

Batman - 11 (+1)

Bane -10

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -10

Two Face -10

The Penguin -10

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 8 (-1)

The Scarecrow -10

Riddler -10

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11

Nightwing -9

Damian Wayne - 9

Jason Todd -10

Joker -12 (+1)

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -10

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -10

Two Face -10

The Penguin -10

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 8

The Scarecrow -10

Riddler -10

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11

Nightwing -8 (-1)

Damian Wayne - 9

Jason Todd -10

Joker -12

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -10

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -10 (+1)

Two Face -10

The Penguin -10

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 8 (-1)

The Scarecrow -10

Riddler -10

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11

Nightwing -8

Damian Wayne - 9

Jason Todd -10

@Liara: Hi, you didn't list-in your add and take scores which you'd thumbnailed: (+1)(-1) This is a correction post, you don't have to correct your original post. Thank you for joining, see you in another 22 hours!!

Joker -12

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -10

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -11 (+1)

Two Face -10

The Penguin -10

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 7 (-1)

The Scarecrow -10

Riddler -10

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11

Nightwing -8

Damian Wayne - 9

Jason Todd -10

This is not my vote, it's a correction to the former voter. Please read my earlier post as my own time frame (currently at 9 hours.)

Joker -12

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -10

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -11

Two Face -10

The Penguin -11 (+1)

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 7 (-1)

The Scarecrow -10

Riddler -9 (-1)

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11

Nightwing -8

Damian Wayne - 9

Jason Todd -10

@Deadite: Kill or not kill? So are we giving points to the character we want killed off? Just double checking because of others voting patterns. Killer Croc over Bats and Harly seems odd to me.

@knighthood:

Nope. It's standard take-point-give-point function, you take the points from the character you want to eliminate. I can see how the title can mislead this, the title's purpose was to spice up the thread and makes the list seemed more threatening to the Bat titled heroes.

Originally I wanted to introduce other street-level villains from other hero's franchises to the list, but I didn't want to over-do it and made it less fun (:

Joker -13 (+1)

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -10

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -11

Two Face -10

The Penguin -11

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 7

The Scarecrow -10

Riddler -9

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11

Nightwing -7 (-1)

Damian Wayne - 9

Jason Todd -10

@ Deadite: Sorry I forgot that, thanks for correcting it.

Joker -13

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9 (-1)

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -11

Two Face -10

The Penguin -11

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 7

The Scarecrow -10

Riddler -10 (+1)

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11

Nightwing -7

Damian Wayne - 9

Jason Todd -10

Joker -14(+1)

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -11

Two Face -10

The Penguin -11

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 7

The Scarecrow -10

Riddler -10

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11

Nightwing -6 (-1)

Damian Wayne - 9

Jason Todd -10

@Liara No problem (: It's nice to have new additions on the thread.

Joker -14

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12(+1)

Two Face -10

The Penguin -11

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 7

The Scarecrow -10

Riddler -10

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11

Nightwing -6

Damian Wayne - 8 (-1)

Jason Todd -10

Joker -14

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -11

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 7

The Scarecrow - 9 ( -1)

Riddler -10

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11 ( +1)

Nightwing -6

Damian Wayne - 8

Jason Todd -10

Joker -14

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -11

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 7

The Scarecrow - 9

Riddler -11 (+1)

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11

Nightwing -6

Damian Wayne - 7 (-1)

Jason Todd -10

Joker -16 (+1)

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -11

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 7

The Scarecrow - 9

Riddler -11

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11

Nightwing -5 (-1)

Damian Wayne - 7

Jason Todd -10

Joker -17 (+1)

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -11

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 7

The Scarecrow - 9

Riddler -11

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11

Nightwing -4 (-1)

Damian Wayne - 7

Jason Todd -10

Joker -17

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -11

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 6 (-1)

The Scarecrow - 9

Riddler -12 (+1)

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11

Nightwing -4

Damian Wayne - 7

Jason Todd -10

Joker -18 (+1)

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -11

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 6

The Scarecrow - 9

Riddler -12

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11

Nightwing -3 (-1) I'm surprised no one has jumped in yet to defend him. This is one of the good ones that can be a real threat, in the late game.

Damian Wayne - 7

Jason Todd -10

Joker -19 (+1)

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -11

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 6

The Scarecrow - 9

Riddler -12

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11

Nightwing -2 (-1)

Damian Wayne - 7

Jason Todd -10

@Deadite said:

I'm surprised no one has jumped in yet to defend him. This is one of the good ones that can be a real threat, in the late game.

lol well i'll try my best but it looks like everyone is gunning for him. You dont sound like you hate him so why take it from him?

@DEGRAAF said:

@Deadite said:

I'm surprised no one has jumped in yet to defend him. This is one of the good ones that can be a real threat, in the late game.

lol well i'll try my best but it looks like everyone is gunning for him. You dont sound like you hate him so why take it from him?

No, there's no way I hate him. When it comes to characters in the Batman's universe villains are exceptionally iconic, and has a real base of fans that's possible for this circumstances to work. Where they can maybe be equals. (Part of it is because of the movies, I guess) And where making a thread topic like this, which could only work on very few other superheroes' dimensions.

I'm really just trying to efficiently kill off the major ones. (I tried this on Batman, someone jumped in and defended him, so...) Batman has really flavorful, quality villains, that's the only reason why this would work.

I'm mapping out for some other heroes's that I can make this kind of threads with. If you have ideas, give me a shout (:

Joker -18

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -11

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 5 (-1)

The Scarecrow - 9

Riddler -12

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11

Nightwing -4 (+1)

Damian Wayne - 7

Jason Todd -10

Joker -18

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -9 (-1)

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 5

The Scarecrow - 9

Riddler -12

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11

Nightwing -6 (+1)

Damian Wayne - 7

Jason Todd -10

Hi, @DEGRAAF: You may only vote once every 24 hours, this is a correction post, you don't have to correct your original post. Thank you for joining, see you in another hour after this post!!

Joker -18

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -9 (-1)

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 5

The Scarecrow - 9

Riddler -12

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11

Nightwing -5 (+1)

Damian Wayne - 7

Jason Todd -10

This is not my vote, it's a correction to a miss-added vote. Please read my earlier post as my time frame (currently at 22 hours 49min.)

Joker -18

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -9

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 4 (-1)

The Scarecrow - 9

Riddler -12

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -11

Nightwing -6 (+1)

Damian Wayne - 7

Jason Todd -10

Joker -19 (+1)

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -9

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 4

The Scarecrow - 9

Riddler -12

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -10 (-1)

Nightwing -6

Damian Wayne - 7

Jason Todd -10

Joker -20 (+1)

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -9

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 4

The Scarecrow - 9

Riddler -12

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -10

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -9 (-1)

Nightwing -6

Damian Wayne - 7

Jason Todd -10

Joker -20

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -9

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 4

The Scarecrow - 9

Riddler -12

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -9 (-1)

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -9

Nightwing -7 (+1)

Damian Wayne - 7

Jason Todd -10

Joker -21 (+1)

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -9

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 4

The Scarecrow - 9

Riddler -12

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -9

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -8 (-1)

Nightwing -7

Damian Wayne - 7

Jason Todd -10

Joker -22 (+1)

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -9

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 4

The Scarecrow - 9

Riddler -12

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -9

Catwoman -10

Tim Drake -7 (-1)

Nightwing -7

Damian Wayne - 7

Jason Todd -10

Joker -22

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -9

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 4

The Scarecrow - 9

Riddler -12

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -9

Catwoman -11 (+1)

Tim Drake -7

Nightwing -7

Damian Wayne - 7

Jason Todd -9 (-1)

Never cared for Jason Todd and always had a personal soft spot for Selina.

Joker -22

Joker -21 (-1)

Joker -21

Hi, @XMen1963 You may only add 1 point to one character each turn, and when you do, chose another character and take a point from him/her.

This is a correction post, you don't have to correct your original post. Thank you for joining, see you after another 23 hours. You may vote once every 24 hours.

Joker -21

This is not my vote, it's a correction to a miss-added vote. Please read my earlier post as my time frame (currently at 11 hours 58min.)

@XMen1963: I think you added 1 to two people and subtracted 1 from no one by mistake.

@Deadite said:

Hi, @XMen1963 You may only add 1 point to one character each turn, and when you do, chose another character and take a point from him/her.

This is a correction post, you don't have to correct your original post. Thank you for joining, see you after another 23 hours. You may vote once every 24 hours.

Joker -21

Clayface -10

Batman - 12

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -9

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 4

The Scarecrow - 9 (-1)

Riddler -12

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -9

Catwoman -11

Tim Drake -7

Nightwing- 10 (+1)

Damian Wayne - 6

Jason Todd -9

This is not my vote, it's a correction to a miss-added vote. Please read my earlier post as my time frame (currently at 11 hours 58min.)

You did you math wrong, nightwing now just got +2, and scarecrow got -0.

@batshrine: Thanks for correcting this.

Joker -21

Joker -21

Joker -21

Joker -21

Clayface -10

Batman - 12

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -8

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 3

The Scarecrow - 8

Riddler -13 (+1)

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -8 (-1)

Catwoman -11

Tim Drake -8

Nightwing- 10

Damian Wayne - 6

Jason Todd -9

Joker -22

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -8

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 2 (-1)

The Scarecrow - 8

Riddler -13

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -8

Catwoman -11

Tim Drake -9 (+1)

Nightwing- 10

Damian Wayne - 6

Jason Todd -9

Joker -23 (+1)

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -8

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 2

The Scarecrow - 8

Riddler -13

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -8

Catwoman -11

Tim Drake -8 (-1)

Nightwing- 10

Damian Wayne - 6

Jason Todd -9

Joker -23

Clayface -10

Batman - 11

Bane -9

Mr. Freeze -11

Poison Ivy -10

Harley Quinn -12

Two Face -10

The Penguin -8

Barbara Gordon -10

Killer Croc - 2

The Scarecrow - 8

Riddler -13

Cassandra Cain -10

Ra's al Ghul -8

Catwoman -11

Tim Drake -8

Nightwing- 11 (+1)

Damian Wayne - 5 (-1)

Jason Todd -9