Take a Point Add a Point Best Marvel Live Action Film

X-Men 2: 26

Amazing Spider-Man: 78 (+4)

Iron Man: 40

Iron Man 2: 0 (-4)

Captain America: 40

The Avengers: 100

@Dark_Magician said:

X-Men 2: 18 (-4) This making it this far is ridiculous

Amazing Spider-Man: 78

Iron Man: 40

Captain America: 40

The Avengers: 108 (+8)

X-Men 2: 10 (-8)

Amazing Spider-Man: 78

Iron Man: 40

Captain America: 40

The Avengers: 116 (+8)

X-Men 2: 2 (-8)

Amazing Spider-Man: 86

Iron Man: 40

Captain America: 40 (+8)

The Avengers: 116

I would have voted for Avengers instead of Captain America: First Avenger, but let's be honest, Avengers aor going to win anyways, so I thought I'd give the vote to Cap's movie to make him tied with Iron Man.

X-Men 2: 0 (-8) Eliminated

Amazing Spider-Man: 94 (+8)

Iron Man: 40

Captain America: 40

The Avengers: 116

Amazing Spider-Man: 86 (-8)

Iron Man: 48 (+8)

Captain America: 40

The Avengers: 116

Amazing Spider-Man: 94 (+8)

Iron Man: 48

Captain America: 32 (-8)

The Avengers: 116

Points up to 16 each way

Amazing Spider-Man: 88 (should have 88. Someone added 8, instead of 2 when they eliminated X-Men 2)

Iron Man: 40 (-8)

Captain America: 32

The Avengers: 124 (+8)

Points up to 16 each way in case anyone missed it

Amazing Spider-Man: 88

Iron Man: 56 (+16)

Captain America: 32

The Avengers: 108 (-16)

Amazing Spider-Man: 88

Iron Man: 56

Captain America: 16 (-16) Brilliant film and deserves to be top 4 but rest are better

The Avengers: 124 (+16)

Amazing Spider-Man: 88

Iron Man: 72 (+16)

Captain America: 0 (-16) ELIMINATED

The Avengers: 124

Amazing Spider-Man: 88

Iron Man: 56 (-16)

The Avengers: 140 (+16)

Amazing Spider-Man: 72

Iron Man: 56 (-16)

The Avengers: 156 (+16)

Amazing Spider-Man: 56 (-16)

Iron Man: 72 (+16)

The Avengers: 156

Amazing Spider-Man: 56

Iron Man: 56 (-16)

The Avengers: 172 (+16)

@BlueLantern1995 said:

@ThatThorFan said:

Saying Iron Man is better than Amazing Spider-Man is a joke, even though Iron Man is goood

People have there opinions I can understand why people prefer Iron Man if it wasn't good we wouldn't have Avengers. Although I prefer ASM I can see some people not liking it as much as Iron Man. I hope ASM comes second (with Avengers 1st) as it does deserve it.

Amazing Spider-Man: 72

Iron Man: 24 (-16)

The Avengers: 188 (+16)

Best Top 3. Iron Man is great but I prefer the other two.

Amazing Spider-Man: 72

Iron Man: 8 (-16)

The Avengers: 204 (+16)

What the heck happened to everything? Oh well.

@DCFan1992 said:

Amazing Spider-Man: 72

Iron Man: 0 (-8) ELIMINATED!!!

The Avengers: 112 (+8)

I would vote against the Amazing Spider-man, but I still haven't seen it.

Points now 32 each way

Amazing Spider-Man: 40 (-32)

The Avengers: 144 (+32)

If anyone feels this is too much let me know as the rules are double each half do that makes it 32 but personally I feel a bit much. But sticking to it so no one gets confused thinking it should go up.

@johnkmccubbin91:

Amazing Spider-Man: 8 (-32)

The Avengers: 176 (+32)

@Kairan1979 said:

@johnkmccubbin91:

Amazing Spider-Man: 0 (-32) ELIMINATED

The Avengers: 208 (+32)

WINNER AVENGERS

I was just wanting peoples thoughts I am also doing Take a point Add a point for Best DC films

http://www.comicvine.com/forums/gen-discussion/1/take-a-point-add-a-point-best-dc-live-action-film/693344/?

and Best Non DC/Marvel films

http://www.comicvine.com/forums/gen-discussion/1/take-a-point-add-a-point-best-non-dc-or-marvel-live-action-film/695285/

I was considering after these were finished doing a kinda shoot out Take a point add a point to find out what the best overall is. So is this a good idea or not? How many from each should be I was considering doing the top 3 in each one. Should they also be handicapped on how they start like for instance the winner from each one starts with 10 and the others (how ever many there are) are one less for wherever they finished. I would like to hear your opinions and thanks for taking part.

Bump for above comment

YEAH! Avengers win!

Anyone with suggestions on my comment above?

@TheCannon: @Cap10nate: @DCFan1992: @Kairan1979: @BlueLantern1995: @TheMinister: @ThatThorFan: @kuonphobos: @haydenclaireheroes: @ChaosMarvel: @tg1982:

I was just wanting peoples thoughts I am also doing Take a point Add a point for Best DC films

http://www.comicvine.com/forums/gen-discussion/1/take-a-point-add-a-point-best-dc-live-action-film/693344/?

and Best Non DC/Marvel films

http://www.comicvine.com/forums/gen-discussion/1/take-a-point-add-a-point-best-non-dc-or-marvel-live-action-film/695285/

I was considering after these were finished doing a kinda shoot out Take a point add a point to find out what the best overall is. So is this a good idea or not? How many from each should be I was considering doing the top 3 in each one. Should they also be handicapped on how they start like for instance the winner from each one starts with 10 and the others (how ever many there are) are one less for wherever they finished. I would like to hear your opinions and thanks for taking part.

Sorry if you didn't want to be tagged in this was trying to tag people in to get opinions in case they didn't see the message earlier

@johnkmccubbin91: I don't think you really need to handicap anything. The votes will take care of that shortly. Three or four from each group would probably be fine.

@Cap10nate: Thanks for the advise I personally wouldn't handicap them either just an idea and was wondering what people thought as it give who came first a deserving advantage