Superman : Birthright or Batman : Year One

Year One.

Year One, but Birthright is awesome too.

bump

One

I thought Birthright was pretty boring. Haven't read Year One.

Haven't read Birthright, so Batman Year One

I haven't read year one yet. But birthright was, to me, the perfect superman origin.

Word for word exactly what I was going to say.

Both are sublime origin stories, but I preferred Year one.

i take it you dont like the legion of superheroes?

I'm a huge Superman fan but Batman: Year One is better.

@allstarsuperman: Huh? What do you mean?

@sog7dc: Legion_of_Super-Heroes they were inspired by superboy so in the birthright continuty they can't exist. I like them but, i hate the idea of superboy. hey check out my origin for superman: http://www.comicvine.com/forums/gen-discussion-1/your-favorite-characters-your-way-1499111/#0

This, except the exact opposite. :P