Should DC hire Tom Taylor to write a Gotham City Sirens book?

Yes.

Yes.

Yes

Yes!

I think he'd do a good job ---- problem is, the old GCS book's greatest strength was the relationship between the three leads; a dynamic that had built up over years and doesn't exist any more.

Huh, thought this was about The Unwritten character when I saw the title <_<

BB

*inhales* *holds breath for thirty seconds* YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS.

@joygirl said:

For some reason I kinda wanna see him write Superman, but this wouldn't be a bad idea at all.

He would do a decent job but currently the three characters don't have that chemistry between them.

He'd do a good job.

Remake the chemistry, take it down to basics. It wouldn't take long to rebuild, especially with fan memory and theory filling in the blanks for him. And if anyone has the talent it's Tom Taylor.

Basically this. I think the biggest hurdle would be determining a good premise for bringing them together (and I guess part of that would be finding a way to either juggle this with, or remove Harley from, connection to Suicide Squad). They don't have to be best buds, but the groundwork for them to be is certainly there (not to mention pre-Flashpoint knowledge and Ame-Comi Girls presentation), and I think a relationship would be developed rather organically and believably just by virtue of them working together.

I think he could do a pretty good job with a Sirens book, but first I need to see how he does with Ivy. Overall, GCS was one of my favorite books pre-52. As a matter of fact it was the second trade I picked up when I first started collecting comics as a hobby. I would love to see the book revived.

They indeed shouldn't be the best pals in the world or BFF's but they should have some simple connection between them.They can't be a team just because we or DC want them to be a team.I think it would be cool if we forget and remove all the crap about Harley being part of the Suicide Squad and have her grounded only in Gotham and have some little spark between Ivy and Selina.

Yes and no. He would do a great job but we have got alot of Gotham books out there already.

@lilben42: Let's presume they would cancel Catwoman to make room for this...so that'd maintain the status quo.