Ranking the New-52 (NEW52 READERS NEEDED)

If you are late to voting, that is ok. If you want to vote on previous issues, just indicate that in your post.

Ok this is no easy task, but I'm going to give it a shot with a method I think might work. Whenever I want to know how good a new-52 series is, the first thing I do is Google 'best new-52 series' but when I do this, all of the lists are from like 2 years ago. So I thought maybe we can come together and create an updated list... I don't plan on doing this in my normal format though, because then everyone would have to make lists of 50+ and that just seems ridiculous. So here's the plan...

Guidelines READ

- I will post the names of 5 New-52 titles every few days, and you readers will respond by giving point values (0-5) to each title. This will basically work like a popularity tournament.

- So, for example. I would post 'Batman', then you would respond below what score you would give to the series (0 being the lowest score, 5 being the highest score).

- After I've gone through and asked you guys what you think about every series, I will compile the votes into a master list, calculate out average scores, and rank every title in order from worst to best.

- If you would like to be tagged for all future posts, please let me know. This will become easier after you see my model below.

- I will only be using New-52 titles that have AT LEAST 5 issues, and are meant to be running titles (no mini-series.)

- If you have not read the series, please put a '/' for that issues score. Since not everyone has read every title, some titles will get less scores than others. To counter act this, I will be going off of average scores at the end of the questions. So everytime someone scores a series, I will be adding that score to the total, but I will also count how many voters each series had. Got it? Good.

So let's try to get this going... IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO BE TAGGED FOR ALL FUTURE POSTS, LET ME KNOW.

First 5

- Batman

- Superman

- Wonder Woman

- Flash

- Aquaman

(This is how you should answer)

- 5

- 3

- 5

- 4

- 4

OR

5, 3, 5, 4, 4

Are we ranking series at there current state or evaluating the entire run? If it is the latter then...

- Batman: 5

- Superman: 3.5

- Wonder Woman: 5

- Flash: 4

- Aquaman: 4.5

@jphu8414: Try to evaluate the whole series if you've read it. But I'll take what I can.

I haven't read all of these runs, I'll spend the night/tomorrow reading to I can rank WW SM and BM

-Batman: 5 (Read the whole series)

-Superman: 3 (Read the whole series) ~Pass on this one man :(~

-Wonder Woman: 4.5 (Read the whole series) ~Very interesting characters in this I will say and a lot of unexpected twists~

-Flash: 4 (Read the whole series) ~Pretty good i'd grade it about a "B"~

-Aquaman 5 (Just finish reading the whole series last week) ~I was actually surprised at how good this comic turned out to be it changed my opinion on Aquaman a lot. ~

up

• Batman: 3
• Superman: 3 (Johns has improved things a lot and even though he was a terrible writer, Lobdell was an improvement from the title's beginnings.)
• Wonder Woman: 5
• Flash: 4
• Aquaman: 4

5

4

4

5

5

ups

- Batman - 5

- Superman - 3

- Wonder Woman - 5

- Flash - 3

- Aquaman - 5

Batman - 4

Superman - 3

Wonder Woman - 4 (only read a few issues)

Flash - 4 (same as WW)

Aquaman - 3

- Batman 4

- Superman 3

- Wonder Woman 4

- Flash 4

- Aquaman (didn't/don't read)

Batman - 3.5

Hit and miss for me. Really enjoyed Owls arcs, Death of the Family sucked and was 50/50 on Zero Year.

Superman - 2

-Only been reading Geoff Johns' work, which I've liked, but previous writer's work has horrible word of mouth (from sources I trust)

Wonder Woman - 4

Pretty good overall but I'm not high on the art

Flash - 4

Loved Buccelleto/Manapul's run but Venditti's has been meh so far

Aquaman - 4.5

Terrific re-imagination and world building of Aquaman's mythos by Johns and Jeff Parker has continued wwith good stuff - especially character development for Arthur and Mera (latter especially)

I'll just copy and paste what I put for the other thread on DC forum.

Batman - 4

Superman - 3

Wonder Woman - 5

Flash - 3

Aquaman - 5

I'm taking into account the totality of each series, not just the momentum of current issues.

2 more responses and I'll move onto the next 5 books.

I haven't read the whole series(I did for flash), I'm rating these out of what I read

Batman 3.5

Superman 4

Wonder Woman 4.5

Flash 4

Aquaman 4.5

I don't know who you plan on doing next, but I'd like it if you waited til the beginning of next month for Green Arrow, so I can read the first issue of the new creative team

4 - Batman

/ - Superman

/ - Wonder Woman

4 - Flash

5 - Aquaman

Could've sworn I posted earlier.

@eyedcyou Tag me in the next match please. :)

5- Batman (this one gets extra credit)

3 - Superman (Geoff Johns is bringing it up his work is around 4 or 5)

5- Wonder Woman

3- Flash

5- Aquaman

3, 3, 5, 3, 4.

@jphu8414: @ariesxmasters: @lvenger: @consolemaster001: @bluebeetle1: @xenonyte: @theamazingimmortalman: @fallschirmjager: @youknowwhattodo: @mrnoital: @idude: @bierschneeman: @smashbrawler: @newkid@abdullahzubair@blackhawk000111@saint_wildcard@outside_85@timelord@the_stegman@mr_clockwork91@transformers1024

Good responses on the first 5. They've been added to the master list.

NEXT FIVE:

Green Lantern

Justice League

Batgirl

Supergirl

Catwoman

Green Lantern - 4

Justice League - 4

Batgirl - didn't/don't read

Supergirl - 3

Catwoman- didn't/don't read

4 (only because of Johns), 3, 2, /, 0.

GL-4

JL-5

BG- DOn't Read

Supergirl- 4

Catwoman- Don't Read

@eyedcyou:

Green Lantern2 - The Never ending cross overs really make it hard for me to love this book.

Justice League 4 - Geoff Johns gets Lex loving it.

Batgirl 4 - Really enjoyed it once it was free from crossing over with Batman

Supergirl 4 - Red Daughter of Krypton was fantastic its really to bad Kara can't stay a Red for a long time.

Catwoman 1 - DC put an end to this book please just be done with it.

Green Lantern - 4

Justice League - 4

Batgirl - 3

Supergirl - 3

Catwoman - 1

GL- 3 Getting tired of event after event and unfortunately it's about to interfere with Infinity Man and the Forever People.

JL- 5 Maybe a little bias but team books never disappoint me.

Batgirl- 4

Supergirl- Don't read

Catwoman- Don't Read

3 Green Lantern (it started out good, but yu HAVE to read GLC GLNG and RL in order to figure out whats going on with the CONSTANT crossovers.)

4 Justice League (started out okay....its gotten a whole lot better)

5 Batgirl (never once did I think I might drop this)

4 Supergirl (was never bad, and now its awesome)

1 Catwoman

3-Green Lantern

4 - Justice League

4 - Batgirl

/ - Supergirl

/ - Catwoman

I should really read more...

Green Lantern - 3. It's ok.

Justice League - 4. I was disapointed when i've read the first bigger arc ( Darkseid's invasion &mstuff ), In the Arc they absolutly Fuc...sorry, made Darkseid a lame ass thug. But then it got much better,

Batgirl - i haven't read it,

Supergirl - 2. It's ok. Not really great.

Catwoman - i haven't read.

Green Lantern- Didn't touch yet

Justice League- Same as green lantern

Batgirl- 4.5 (Read them all) ~Pretty good, does a really good job of explaining why she hates the Joker and how she got paralyze, along with why her mother and brother weren't in her life, as well as some side stuff like court of owls and some side crime here and there~

Supergirl- 3 (Read them all) I have a lot to say about this so get ready:

~The problem is Supergirl never evolves, she never develops as a characters, and that can annoy the reader. When you read, you like to see the character naturally develop and grow, and this is not the case for Supergirl. She is so stuck on the past and how her home planet krypton was destroyed, she won't accept help from anybody and will kick your butt the second you offer some help/advise, but if you talk about "reviving" krypton (which she knows deep in her heart you can and superman also told her it is not possible either) she is all ears and will do whatever you say. She is very new to her power this time around and finds herself not being able to control them properly and sometimes her powers randomly go off with her meaning them to. Verdict= pass on this one man :"(~

Catwoman- 4 (Read them all)~This one is good not bad. Pretty much the adventures of catwoman as I see it. I will say I wish they had went in depth a little more about her past and her parents and her being caught and thrown a orphanage when she was younger they glossed over it very vaguely which I thought was weird. Batman will be making some "interesting guess appearance". Some of the things Batman does or says during his guess appearance will leave you scratching your head and say "Would Batman really do this", but pretty good overall minus a few things~

Green Lantern - 4

Justice League - 3

Batgirl - 4

Supergirl - / Havn't read

Catwoman - / Refuse to read

Green Lantern - 4

Justice League - 4

Batgirl - 3

Supergirl - 2

Catwoman - 1

Tag me for the future.

Green Lantern - N/A

Justice League - 3

Batgirl - 4

Supergirl - 3

Catwoman - 4

Wasn't on for the original if these will still count.

- Batman: 4

- Superman: 2.5

- Wonder Woman: 3.5

- Flash: 3

- Aquaman: 4

@guru_crack: Thank you for the contribution, and I will count those votes, but if you look up a few posts, You will see that I posted the next 5 books.

@eyedcyou: Yea I did I voted all 10 on the one post, thanks.

@guru_crack: Ah, got it.

Green Lantern - Don't read

Justice League - 3

Very hit and miss.

Batgirl - Don't read

Supergirl - Don't read

Catwoman - Don't read

green lantern 3 (whole series) it's been great but they have to many crossovers

justice league 4 (whole series)

batgirl 4 (whole series)

Supergirl 3.5 (whole series) it's good most of the time but some of it is bad

Catwomen negative 5 by far one of the worst series of the new 52; and, its had multiple writers and it still sucks.

Green Lantern: 4.5

Justice League: 5.0

Batgirl: 4.0

Supergirl: 3.5

Catwoman: 3.0

Green Lantern: 4, not caught up

Justice League: 5

Batgirl: /, haven't yet read her stuff in the New 52

Supergirl: /

Catwoman: /

BUMP

up

Green Lantern- 5

Grayson- 3

Aquaman- 5

Grayson- 4

Earth 2- 4

Up

Green Lantern /

Justice League - 4

Batgirl - 5

Supergirl /

Catwoman - 0

GL 4

JL 3

BG 3

SG 3

CW 0

Green Lantern - 4

Justice League - 3

Batgirl - /

Supergirl - 3

Catwoman - /

@mrnoital: @lvenger: @theamazingimmortalman: @smashbrawler: @saint_wildcard: @timelord: @newkid: @mrtummytumms: @bierschneeman: @idude: @drfate: @ariesxmasters: @transformers1024: @youknowwhattodo: @guru_crack: @fallschirmjager: @benk111: @jphu8414: @deathstroke52: @larryashlynn: @mr_clockwork91: @blackhawk000111: @xenonyte: @crazyscarecrow@energie@bluebeetle1@consolemaster001@abdullahzubair

NEXT 5:

- Swamp Thing

- Action Comics

- Detective Comics

- Constantine

- Justice League Dark

Swamp Thing - /

Action Comics - 4

Detective Comics - 4

Constantine - /

Justice League Dark - 3

Swamp Thing - 5

Action Comics - 4

Detective Comics -3

Constantine - /

Justice League Dark - 3

- Swamp Thing - 5

- Action Comics - 3

- Detective Comics - 4

- Constantine - 5

- Justice League Dark - 5