Michael Fassbender Magneto vs Heath Ledger Joker

Both equally. I truely mean that. They both bought their respective characters to life.

You say that but I am the only one that has actually voted for both so far.

MF takes it by default seeing as Ledger's Joker wasn't anything special.

Fassbender portrayal was mesmerizing. Seriously, I absolutely adored every scene involving him in both movie. Don't get me wrong, Ledgers Joker was amazing as well, but Micheal's Mags was just show stealing, and honestly got me interested in the character.

Heath Ledger

Joker.

Fassbender was great, but Heath Ledger totally transformed the joker. Its really close but I remember being captivated through every moment of Ledger's Joker.

This is really close, but i'd say ledger was just a little bit better

Heath Ledger revolutionized that role. I didn't even think Fassbender was that impressive.

Both

The Joker should stomp.

@erik: Not anymore. Also I was at work. I should not have even been online

Even though I say Ledger is kind of overrated solely due to his death, he was still excellent. Fassbender is cool too but he didn't bring the memorable performance that Ledger did.

I've been in those shoes before. Some jobs I have had even blocked this site as NSFW for some reason.

Both

Both were fantastic.

They were both good, but this isn't close IMHO. Ledger's performance will be remembered forever..AND NOT BECAUSE HE DIED. (I guess some folks that have no idea about acting like to say that.) The little nuances; the ticks, the head movements, the lip-smacking, the slight stutters.

Heath directed the Joker's Terrorist Videos...and more!

I mean..c'mon folks!

Ledger

Fassbender's great, but Joker curbs this, Fassbender needs a bit more meat to show off his acting chops, he's fully capable of equalling Ledger.