Marvel Ladies vs DC Women

Marvel Ladies vs DC Women

I wish to make a Marvel Ladies - DC Women counterpart list, and I need your help. Please feel free to add or make the necessary changes that would make the best heroines match-up. I know this has been done numerous times, but still I want to share my list and want your opinion regarding who would be the victor in the match-up and which team would eventually win in the battle royale .

So, here’s my list.

Marvel Ladies vs DC Women

1. Black Cat vs Catwoman

2. Black Widow vs Huntress

3. Tigra vs Vixen

4. Colleen Wing vs Judomaster

5. Elektra vs Katana

6. Misty Knight vs Batwoman

7. Tarantula vs Batgirl

8. Hellcat vs Flamebird

9. X 23 vs Black Bat

10. Mockingbird vs Black Canary

11. Firestar vs Starfire

12. She Hulk vs Powergirl

13. Spiderwoman vs Donna Troy

14. Thundra vs Big Barda

15. Valkyrie vs Hawkgirl

16. Ms Marvel vs Wonder Woman

17. Invisible Woman vs Jade

18. Shadowcat vs Gypsy

19. Storm vs Cyclone

20. Rogue vs Raven

21. Scarlet Witch vs Zatanna

22. Aurora vs Libery Belle

23. Photon vs Dr Light

24. Moonstone vs Fire

25. Wasp vs Bumblebee

26. Psylocke vs Mary Marvel

27. Jubilee vs Dove

28. Namora vs Mera

29. Emma Fros vst Miss Martian

30. Spider Girl vs Stargirl

31. Dagger vs Spoiler

32. Crystal vs Phantom Lady

33. Jessica Jones vs Supergirl

34. Firebird vs Firehawk

35. Dazzler vs Halo

36. Songbird vs Ice

37. Ronin (Maya Lopez) vs Manhunter

38. Mary Jane Watson vs Lois Lane

Marvel's women are just accesories.

DC

DC

I swear people don't even read the posts on this site he's asking for more comparisons between the characters of each company not just which ones you like better.

I'll play along

1. Black Cat vs Catwoman

2. Black Widow vs Huntress

3. Tigra vs Vixen

4. Colleen Wing vs Judomaster

5. Elektra vs Katana

6. Misty Knight vs Batwoman

7. Tarantula vs Batgirl

8. Hellcat vs Flamebird

9. X 23 vs Black Bat

10. Mockingbird vs Black Canary

11. Firestar vs Starfire

12. She Hulk vs Powergirl

13. Spiderwoman vs Donna Troy

14. Thundra vs Big Barda

15. Valkyrie vs Hawkgirl

16. Ms Marvel vs Wonder Woman

17. Invisible Woman vs Jade

18. Shadowcat vs Gypsy

19. Storm vs Cyclone

20. Rogue vs Raven

21. Scarlet Witch vs Zatanna

22. Aurora vs Libery Belle

23. Photon vs Dr Light

24. Moonstone vs Fire

25. Wasp vs Bumblebee

26. Psylocke vs Mary Marvel

27. Jubilee vs Dove

28. Namora vs Mera

29. Emma Frost vs Miss Martian

30. Spider Girl vs Stargirl

31. Dagger vs Spoiler

32. Crystal vs Phantom Lady

33. Jessica Jones vs Supergirl

34. Firebird vs Firehawk

35. Dazzler vs Halo

36. Songbird vs Ice

37. Ronin (Maya Lopez) vs Manhunter

38. Mary Jane Watson vs Lois Lane

My opinion's on who is better compared to the other

Winners: catwoman, Black Widow, Vixen, Judomaster, Elektra, Batwoman, Batgirl, Flamebird, X-23, Black Canary, Starfire, Power girl, Donna Troy, tie, Valkyrie, Wonder woman, Jade, Shadowcat, STorm, Raven, Scarlet Witch, Aurora, Photon, Moonstone, Bumblebee, Mary Marvel, Dove, Mera, Miss martian, Spidergirl, Spoiler, Crystal, Supergirl, Firebird, tie, Ice, Manhunter, MJ

1. Black Cat vs Catwoman

2. Black Widow vs Huntress

3. Tigra vs Vixen

4. Colleen Wing vs Judomaster (not sure who these are)

5. Elektra vs Katana

6. Misty Knight vs Batwoman

7. Tarantula vs Batgirl

8. Hellcat vs Flamebird

9. X 23 vs Black Bat

10. Mockingbird vs Black Canary

11. Firestar vs Starfire

12. She Hulk vs Powergirl

13. Spiderwoman vs Donna Troy

14. Thundra vs Big Barda

15. Valkyrie vs Hawkgirl

16. Ms Marvel vs Wonder Woman

17. Invisible Woman vs Jade

18. Shadowcat vs Gypsy

19. Storm vs Cyclone

20. Rogue vs Raven

21. Scarlet Witch vs Zatanna

22. Aurora vs Libery Belle

23. Photon vs Dr Light

24. Moonstone vs Fire

25. Wasp vs Bumblebee

26. Psylocke vs Mary Marvel

27. Jubilee vs Dove

28. Namora vs Mera

29. Emma Frost vs Miss Martian

30. Spider Girl vs Stargirl

31. Dagger vs Spoiler

32. Crystal vs Phantom Lady

33. Jessica Jones vs Supergirl

34. Firebird vs Firehawk

35. Dazzler vs Halo

36. Songbird vs Ice

37. Ronin (Maya Lopez) vs Manhunter

38. Mary Jane Watson vs Lois Lane

Although this could have been cut down to less fights

Lol. People really don't read the OP do they? Although @sizzling_bulalo: didn't do themselves any favors by using "vs." in the post when it wasn't a battle thread.

MJ vs Lois Lane could go either way, but Id point towards Lois, because she is an army brat. MJ has Cap training but you know...

the other ones IMO

1. Black Cat vs Catwoman

2. Black Widow vs Huntress

5. Elektra vs Katana

9. X 23 vs Black Bat

10. Mockingbird vs Black Canary

11. Firestar vs Starfire

12. She Hulk vs Powergirl

13. Spiderwoman vs Donna Troy

15. Valkyrie vs Hawkgirl

16. Ms Marvel vs Wonder Woman

17. Invisible Woman vs Jade

20. Rogue vs Raven

21. Scarlet Witch vs Zatanna

24. Moonstone vs Fire

25. Wasp vs Bumblebee

26. Psylocke vs Mary Marvel

28. Namora vs Mera

29. Emma Frost vs Miss Martian

30. Spider Girl vs Stargirl

31. Dagger vs Spoiler

33. Jessica Jones vs Supergirl

@Manwhohaseverything said:

@fodigg: Well, he did ask "who would be the victor in the match-up, and who would win the Battle Royal." So, it does sound kinda "battle-ish"

Ha! And so he did! He snuck it into the end of his post:

and want your opinion regarding who would be the victor in the match-up and which team would eventually win in the battle royale .

And so I am guilty of exactly what I scoffed at others for doing, not entirely reading the post. Luckily this is the internet and hardly unusual...

@fodigg: I wasn't really sure where he was going with it so I just chose my favorites compared to the others.....

1. Black Cat vs Catwoman

2. Black Widow vs Huntress (barely)

3. Tigra vs Vixen

4. Colleen Wing vs Judomaster

5. Elektra vs Katana

6. Misty Knight vs Batwoman

7. Tarantula vs Batgirl

8. Hellcat vs Flamebird

9. X 23 vs Black Bat

10. Mockingbird vs Black Canary

11. Firestar vs Starfire

12. She Hulk vs Powergirl

13. Spiderwoman vs Donna Troy

14. Thundra vs Big Barda

15. Valkyrie vs Hawkgirl

16. Ms Marvel vs Wonder Woman

17. Invisible Woman vs Jade

18. Shadowcat vs Gypsy

19. Storm vs Cyclone

20. Rogue vs Raven

21. Scarlet Witch vs Zatanna

22. Aurora vs Libery Belle

23. Photon vs Dr Light

24. Moonstone vs Fire

25. Wasp vs Bumblebee

26. Psylocke vs Mary Marvel

27. Jubilee vs Dove

28. Namora vs Mera

29. Emma Fros vst Miss Martian

30. Spider Girl vs Stargirl

31. Dagger vs Spoiler

32. Crystal vs Phantom Lady

33. Jessica Jones vs Supergirl

34. Firebird vs Firehawk

35. Dazzler vs Halo

36. Songbird vs Ice

37. Ronin (Maya Lopez) vs Manhunter

38. Mary Jane Watson vs Lois Lane

DC: 22 Marvel: 16

Winner: DC

1. Black Cat vs Catwoman.....black cat has probability fields power

2. Black Widow vs Huntress

3. Tigra vs Vixen

4. Colleen Wing vs Judomaster

5. Elektra vs Katana

6. Misty Knight vs Batwoman

7. Tarantula vs Batgirl

8. Hellcat vs Flamebird.....hellcat has telekinesis

9. X 23 vs Black Bat

10. Mockingbird vs Black Canary

11. Firestar vs Starfire...starfire can shoot energy blasts but firestar controls fire and generate fire,microwaves

12. She Hulk vs Powergirl

13. Spiderwoman vs Donna Troy

14. Thundra vs Big Barda

15. Valkyrie vs Hawkgirl

16. Ms Marvel vs Wonder Woman...the actual wonder woman sucks....ms.marvel has energy blasts

17. Invisible Woman vs Jade...put a bubble inside jade head and it's done

18. Shadowcat vs Gypsy i love shadowcat but she can just phase and gypsy has precognition and illusions

19. Storm vs Cyclone

20. Rogue vs Raven

21. Scarlet Witch vs Zatanna

22. Aurora vs Libery Belle

23. Photon vs Dr Light

24. Moonstone vs Fire

25. Wasp vs Bumblebee....wasp has more experience she is an avengers and she can grow unlike bumblebee

26. Psylocke vs Mary Marvel..telepathy and telekinesis

27. Jubilee vs Dove...jubilee can control dove powers and she has more experience

28. Namora vs Mera

29. Emma Fros vst Miss Martian

30. Spider Girl vs Stargirl...shooting stars,and spider girl can't fly

31. Dagger vs Spoiler....spoiler doesn't has powers she has just agility and dagger has agility plus light daggers

32. Crystal vs Phantom Lady

33. Jessica Jones vs Supergirl

34. Firebird vs Firehawk..firehawk can control and generate thermal nuclear energy and firebird is immune against radiation

35. Dazzler vs Halo...she doesn't need sound to convert

36. Songbird vs Ice...I had problems to choose one because ice can do powerful blizzards

37. Ronin (Maya Lopez) vs Manhunter...ronin can copy others moves

38. Mary Jane Watson vs Lois Lane...Lois is an amazing fighter

Batman

I would have to think that Scarlet Witch would be the ultimate winner here. Why? Three words...

"No. More. Womens."

@feebadger said:

I would have to think that Scarlet Witch would be the ultimate winner here. Why? Three words...

"No. More. Women."

there, now it's correct. But, wouldn't that also destroy her? she is a woman after all

@Jorgevy said:

@feebadger said:

I would have to think that Scarlet Witch would be the ultimate winner here. Why? Three words...

"No. More. Women."

there, now it's correct. But, wouldn't that also destroy her? she is a woman after all

"NO. MORE. WOMENS!" I know what i meant, dammit!!! ;P And no, it wouldn't. She's saying the plural. She would be the singular.

@feebadger: Maybe she is a man in drag...

@Jorgevy: Bingo! That's her mutant power... looking good in tights with the legs of a rugby player.

@feebadger: damn, now that image will forever burn inside my encephalon

The Black Cat FTW.

dc

1. Black Cat vs Catwoman (Super Powers, Luck manipulation)

2. Black Widow vs Huntress (Better fighter)

3. Tigra vs Vixen

4. Colleen Wing vs Judomaster (Unfamiliar with Judomaster)

5. Elektra vs Katana (Elektra 8/10, way better fighter)

6. Misty Knight vs Batwoman (MK has bionic arms and can used like guns)

7.Tarantula vs Batgirl (I assume this Batgirl is Barbara Gordon? well current Tarantula might prove too much)

8. Hellcat vs Flamebird.....(hellcat has telekinesis)

9. X 23 vs Black Bat (Close but X takes it)

10. Mocingbird vs Black Canary (Canary Scream is the key)

11. Firestar vs Starfire... (Firestar 7/10)

12. She Hulk vs Powergirl

13. Spiderwoman vs Donna Troy (Can't stand Donna)

14. Thundra vs Big Barda (Tie)

15. Valkyrie vs Hawkgirl (Valkyrie stomps)

6. Ms Marvel vs Wonder Woman (Current WW sucks, Ms. Marvel can absorb energy and discharge it)

17. Invisible Woman vs Jade ( Invisible Woman could win this in her sleep)

18. Shadowcat vs Gypsy (Dont know gypsy)

19. Storm vs Cyclone (Overkill)

20.Rogue vs Raven Overkill

21. Scarlet Witch vs Zatanna (Too much raw power)

22. Aurora vs Libery Belle (Much better arsenal)

23. Photon vs Dr Light,

24. Moonstone vs Fire

25. Wasp vs Bumblebee....wasp has more experience she is an avengers and she can grow unlike bumblebee

26. Psylocke vs Mary Marvel..telepathy and telekinesis

27. Jubilee vs Dove

28. Namora vs Mera

29. Emma Frost vs Miss Martian

30. Spider Girl vs Stargirl. Stargirl hasnt impressed me ever.

31. Dagger vs Spoiler....Overkill

32. Crystal vs Phantom Lady

33. Jessica Jones vs Supergirl

34. Firebird vs Firehawk..

35. Dazzler vs Halo. Halo could win, both have disadvantages

36. Songbird vs Ice...

37. Ronin (Maya Lopez) vs Manhunter.

38. Mary Jane Watson vs Lois Lane. Who cares?

Dc womens are just plain better

1. Black Cat vs Catwoman

2. Black Widow vs Huntress

3. Tigra vs Vixen

4. Colleen Wing vs Judomaster (not sure who these are)

5. Elektra vs Katana

6. Misty Knight vs Batwoman

7. Tarantula vs Batgirl

8. Hellcat vs Flamebird

9. X 23 vs Black Bat

10. Mockingbird vs Black Canary

11. Firestar vs Starfire

12. She Hulk vs Powergirl

13. Spiderwoman vs Donna Troy

14. Thundra vs Big Barda - dunno who they are

15. Valkyrie vs Hawkgirl

16. Ms Marvel vs Wonder Woman

17. Invisible Woman vs Jade

18. Shadowcat vs Gypsy

19. Storm vs Cyclone

20. Rogue vs Raven

21. Scarlet Witch vs Zatanna

22. Aurora vs Libery Belle - Dunno Libery Belle

23. Photon vs Dr Light

24. Moonstone vs Fire

25. Wasp vs Bumblebee

26. Psylocke vs Mary Marvel

27. Jubilee vs Dove

28. Namora vs Mera

29. Emma Frost vs Miss Martian

30. Spider Girl vs Stargirl

31. Dagger vs Spoiler - dunno who spoiler

32. Crystal vs Phantom Lady

33. Jessica Jones vs Supergirl

34. Firebird vs Firehawk

35. Dazzler vs Halo

36. Songbird vs Ice

37. Ronin (Maya Lopez) vs Manhunter

38. Mary Jane Watson vs Lois Lane

Marvel 19

DC - 14

Psylocke defeats Mary Marvel?

Seriously?

Following matches are stupid/mis-matches

Jessica Jones vs

Supergirl, (JJ

would'nt be able to hurt her)

Rouge vs

Raven,

(Obvious isn't it, I dont see rouge touching her even with ms. Marvels powers)

Hellcat

vs Flamebird (Patsy has telekinesis)

Firebird

vs Firehawk (Bonita is immune to anything that Firehawk can do)

Dagger

vs Spoiler (Spoiler counter hurt her)

Jubilee

vs Dove (Plasma discharge, could burn, scar or detonate poor Dawn. Current Jubes wins also)

Aurora

vs Liberty Belle ( LB's is just too inconsistent, I think)

Spider-Woman vs

Donna Troy (Venom blasts wont do squat)

Storm vs Cyclone (Duh)

Valkyrie vs Hawkgirl (knock the weapon out of hawkgirls hands and she is powerless)

Gotta love the comments about Marvel having terrible female super heroes.

I'll go with Marvel chicks. Although DC tries to promote their women I just gotta say that Marvel does better at promoting their gals. I mean yeah, they may have less solo's in the women department but their women are much more well known compare to their counter parts in DC.

1. Black Cat vs Catwoman

2. Black Widow vs Huntress

3. Tigra vs Vixen

4. Colleen Wing vs Judomaster

5. Elektra vs Katana

6. Misty Knight vs BStarfireatwoman

7. Tarantula vs Batgirl

8. Hellcat vs Flamebird

9. X 23 vs Black Bat

10. Mockingbird vs Black Canary

11. Firestar vs Starfire

12. She Hulk vs Powergirl

13. Spiderwoman vs Donna Troy

14. Thundra vs Big Barda

15. Valkyrie vs Hawkgirl

16. Ms Marvel vs Wonder Woman

17. Invisible Woman vs Jade

18. Shadowcat vs Gypsy

19. Storm vs Cyclone

20. Rogue vs Raven

21. Scarlet Witch vs Zatanna

22. Aurora vs Libery Belle

23. Photon vs Dr Light

24. Moonstone vs Fire

25. Wasp vs Bumblebee

26. Psylocke vs Mary Marvel

27. Jubilee vs Dove

28. Namora vs Mera

29. Emma Fros vst Miss Martian

30. Spider Girl vs Stargirl

31. Dagger vs Spoiler

32. Crystal vs Phantom Lady

33. Jessica Jones vs Supergirl

34. Firebird vs Firehawk

35. Dazzler vs Halo

36. Songbird vs Ice

37. Ronin (Maya Lopez) vs Manhunter

38. Mary Jane Watson vs Lois Lane

Marvel - 20

Dc- 18

dc wina but not easy

@eunicegalaxy:current wonder woman is still much stronger,faster more durable and a much better fighter than ms marvel.

@johnkmccubbin91: current wonder woman is still much stronger,faster more durable and a much better fighter than ms marvel.

@gokuwarrior: Probabably

@johnkmccubbin91:it's a fact.

@gokuwarrior: Didn't say it wasn't

DC 23

Marvel 9

several obstaining

doesn't help that Marvel doesn't write woman well, mostly they are there to be won by the superhero or to fly around and look pretty but not empowered. not exactly modern portrayl of women.

1. Black Cat vs Catwoman

2. Black Widow vs Huntress

3. Tigra vs Vixen

4. Colleen Wing vs Judomaster

5. Elektra vs Katana

6. Misty Knight vs Batwoman

7. Tarantula vs Batgirl

8. Hellcat vs Flamebird

9. X 23 vs Black Bat

10. Mockingbird vs Black Canary

11. Firestar vs Starfire

12. She Hulk vs Powergirl

13. Spiderwoman vs Donna Troy

14. Thundra vs Big Barda

15. Valkyrie vs Hawkgirl

16. Ms Marvel vs Wonder Woman

17. Invisible Woman vs Jade

18. Shadowcat vs Gypsy

19. Storm vs Cyclone

20. Rogue vs Raven

21. Scarlet Witch vs Zatanna

22. Aurora vs Libery Belle

23. Photon vs Dr Light

24. Moonstone vs Fire

25. Wasp vs Bumblebee

26. Psylocke vs Mary Marvel

27. Jubilee vs Dove

28. Namora vs Mera

29. Emma Fros vst Miss Martian

30. Spider Girl vs Stargirl

31. Dagger vs Spoiler

32. Crystal vs Phantom Lady

33. Jessica Jones vs Supergirl

34. Firebird vs Firehawk

35. Dazzler vs Halo

36. Songbird vs Ice

37. Ronin (Maya Lopez) vs Manhunter

38. Mary Jane Watson vs Lois Lane

I think Magik would be a better matchup for Raven then Rogue, since you know both Magik and Raven are magic users and Rogue isn't.

@bierschneeman:ms marvel has no chance against wonder woman.

@cobalion:current wonder woman is still much stronger,faster,more durable and a much better fighter than ms marvel,ms marvel has no chance against her.

Those saying DC writes women better either don't read X-Men or just plain don't like Marvel.

Also, there's no way in hell that Scarlet Witch losses to Zatanna.

we'll see, they are facing off soon on another topic.... besides Ms Marvel has a set character, Wonderwoman completely changes every 10 years. sooo.... yeah Id rather go with what tried and true, rather than an icon that no one can agree on.

I love marvel, but their women are all decorative superhero trophies, (just look at all the various X-men love triangles and quadrangles) and when they aren't switching from superhero to superhero, they kind of blend into the background. theres no empowerment, its like marvel is stuck in the 60s mindset where a woman isn't a woman without needing a man. marvel writes women for men who think women are property.

ohh and scarlet witch doesn't fit that scenario, but she still sucks. I don't see how she lasted this long she's just.... meh.. while as Zatanna at least has some uniqueness to her character.

excuse me?,wonder woman has had the same background for more than 50 years,her origin changed in some points just in the last 2 years,ms marvel is the one that is ambiguous,she is the ripped off a male character but not as powerful as her male version not even close,and now instead of respecting her as her own character they changed her name to captain marvel,and make her take the role of a male character leaving her in his shadow and taking away her signature costume and style.

and it's a fact that wonder woman is still above ms marvel in terms of power,it has always been that way,and it hasn't changed.

and in which topic are they facing off?.