Whether Thor is a god or not depends on the application of the term. Many real life people could qualify for godhood for example, in a fictional setting it can be even more ambiguous. Words relay the meanings of concepts and ideas, and there are a lot of different concepts and ideas playing around and interacting with each other with gods, godhood, deity's and the like. One of the most important original factors in defining a god was worship or pray. To worship or pray to an entity was to worship and pray to a god. Also hence why many past kings and queens have bragged about divine origins and divine bloodlines to further justify why and how people should worship them. Then you also can factor in enhanced abilities. Longer lifespans, immortality, stronger and bigger. Many of the things that a child might project and revere on to their parents, parents who also gave them life, cared for them and protected them and interacted with them in odd and mysterious ways, at least in the eyes of a young child. However not all parents are equal and neither are all god concepts. So power does factor in, but its relative of course. Then another common factor with can overlap with the former is the explanation of what could have been considered supernatural events, actions and activities. Humans can't use their basic senses to know reality on a microscopic level or larger than the macroscopic, so explanations for things tend to be very human centric, which usually meant people believed that if something happened, its because something decided that it should and made it so. There is (was) no good reason for lightning hence a god did it.
Characters like Batman, Superman, Hulk, Sentry, Thor, Odin, Spider-man, Aunt May, Tony Stark in the traditional real word sense of the words, would all have varying success as far as accomplishing above, and the biggest advantage would be existing in the past, the long distant past where science as it is today was non existent and all written things were written by hand, and so just speaking really loudly in a town square was probably the fastest way to spread information. In those conditions it would be pretty easy for Batman and Tony Stark (no armor, just his personality, charisma and intellect) to become very influential and powerful humans, and possibly even transcend that and become demi gods. Give them their modern day knowledge and history and transplant them to their bodies in the past and its not that unfeasible they could have become mythological gods. Knowledge of chemistry and physical reactions. Knowledge of solar cycles and when to predict eclipses. For characters like Superman and Sentry such a thing would be very easy. The reason it would be harder in modern times would be because of modern day skepticism, superior knowledge and scientific ability to explain, define and reject things. You won't find as many religions popping up about Spider-man (may have happened in a story line though, I know it has for a few other characters) but otherwise many of those characters struggle in being worshipped or prayed to. So that they fail to adequately meet an idea isn't really a big slap in the face, its just a right time, right place thing. Also most modern heroes have competition in themselves, something because of how news was carried and people interacted in historic times, wasn't an issue, so it would be hard for Sentry to carve out a religion now days with Hyperion, Blue Marvel, Wonder Man flying around, and guys like Gladiator and Silver Surfer visiting now and then.
Thats without adding in all the funny stiff with Marvel and Gaea and Demiurge and Atum and Elder gods to Demons and expelled energy which would become godstuff that made what Marvel considers gods, which is to say like the term mutant, Marvel has effectively created a species/race that are gods by definition rather than filling out a criteria to be defined as gods. So Hercules, Thor, Leir are gods by genetic heritage. Like the term mutant in Marvel, the word god still means something, even though some non gods can defeat some gods, because the term has nothing to do with who beats who, and many non mutants can beat mutants, but not all gods are like Thor and not all mutants are like Storm Mad Jim Jaspers or Legion. So in Marvel and DC I think since they use to have the godwave no? Anyway in Marvel and DC, there seems to be "godstuff" - as in a substance that is real, quantifiable and actual that some beings have that others don't. Thor is a candidate for having some of this stuff by virtue of his genes - Gaea and Odin. Except godstuff is a bit more sci fi for some than others. It also creates problems for those whose application of terms like god carry certain inherent values, that are more metaphysical than some substance that can be passed on like a genetic trait.
Log in to comment