Honestly Held Unpopular Opinions

This topic is locked from further discussion.

#1 Edited by RideASpaceCowboy (266 posts) - 4 months, 2 days ago - Show Bio

Below is a list of opinions which I freely admit and honestly hold to, yet at the same time recognize would not be held by most others. I'm of course interested to find out if there are any actually in agreement with me on some of them, but I'm also interested in hearing what opinions you have with respect to the comics industry that you guess would be equally unpopular. Here's your chance to take a stand for what you believe. In alphabetical order, I believe...

  1. All-Star Batman and Robin, the Boy Wonder was a better Batman story than The Dark Knight Returns
  2. Anime and Manga are aesthetically homogenous and less interesting as a result than the diverse breadth of Western art styles
  3. Black and white comics are incomplete until they become fully colored
  4. Continuity should never get in the way of good story-telling and the concept of a single shared universe ought to be abandoned in favor of numerous Elseworlds-style imprints equally “real” with respect to one another
  5. Digital comics are the real version and the physical copy in merely a spare printout
  6. Ed McGuinness and John Romita Jr. are among the worst artists in the industry today
  7. Females should be depicted visually in an idealized and unrealistic manner, possessing petite frames, gorgeous faces, and ample breasts
  8. Greg Land is one of the best artists in the industry today, particularly in his depiction of females
  9. Heroes and other characters put forth as a moral example should not be depicted as homosexuals (except as a clearly acknowledged character flaw) and should never be depicted as transsexual
  10. Heroines should not be depicted in a manner which deliberately subverts ontologically predefined gender roles (as opposed to socially arbitrary ones) or diminishes their femininity, and should never be written in such a way as to advance a Feminist agenda or philosophy
  11. Infinite comics which take advantage of the unique opportunities of the digital canvas should represent the vast majority, if not totality, of the comics medium
  12. Marvel heroes are generally less interesting particularly because of the pathos infused into their character as opposed to the DC heroes which are more archetypal and iconic, serving not as relatable characters but rather the gods of a modern mythology to whom one can look up at
  13. Star Wars: Republic comics chronicling the adventures of Quinlan Vos and the entire series of Star Wars: Legacy (both by John Ostrander) are superior to the actual films themselves
#2 Posted by Ravager4 (1465 posts) - 4 months, 2 days ago - Show Bio

#3 Posted by MatKrenz (1083 posts) - 4 months, 2 days ago - Show Bio

In response to #9.

#4 Posted by Jonny_Anonymous (15671 posts) - 4 months, 2 days ago - Show Bio
#5 Posted by MatKrenz (1083 posts) - 4 months, 2 days ago - Show Bio

Actually found a better picture.

#6 Posted by Durfee (13 posts) - 4 months, 2 days ago - Show Bio

OP be trolling.

#7 Posted by Jokergeist (314 posts) - 4 months, 2 days ago - Show Bio

@RideASpaceCowboy said:

Below is a list of opinions which I freely admit and honestly hold to, yet at the same time recognize would not be held by most others. I'm of course interested to find out if there are any actually in agreement with me on some of them, but I'm also interested in hearing what opinions you have with respect to the comics industry that you guess would be equally unpopular. Here's your chance to take a stand for what you believe.

"I believe that whatever doesn't kill you simply makes you...stranger."

--The Joker

Sincerely,

#8 Posted by JakeN7 (777 posts) - 4 months, 2 days ago - Show Bio

@RideASpaceCowboy:

Oh my god, I can not disagree more.

Numbers 1, 2, 5, 7, 10, 11, and 12 are just mind numbingly stupid.

However, #9 not only personally offends me, but also disgusts me. I'm physically repulsed by the fact that it's 2013 and people can still be as ignorant, biased and bigoted as that statement was. Right after having a MLK JR assembly at school today no less. Throw your pre-conceived notions away and learn to love and accept people for who they are. Having been raised by lesbian grandmothers, having lesbian aunts, having a gay uncle and gay friends, I am totally aware that I have more knowledge and experience than most people when it comes to gay people and how their sexual orientation has nothing to do with whether they can serve as role-models and idols to young children (SPOILER: They can.) I know that most people are not as fortunate as I am to have actual real-life experiences with wonderful, beautiful, loving, gay folks such as my family and friends. However, that does not excuse you from your misguided sense of morality, of which I have no use for. If you truly believe that there is something inferior about being homosexual and that homosexuals should not allowed to be superheroes, then I feel nothing but the deepest pity for you.

P.S. So I'm guessing you don't care for Batwoman, Northstar, and Alan Scott (New 52) right?

P.P.S. I'm totally up for a spirited, civil debate with you if you so wish.

#9 Posted by The_Tree (4185 posts) - 4 months, 2 days ago - Show Bio

This thread won't end well.

#10 Posted by akbogert (2139 posts) - 4 months, 2 days ago - Show Bio

@The_Tree: It didn't exactly start well, did it?

Wait, does this constitute as trolling or troll-baiting or troll-feeding? I'm still new to this thing...

#11 Posted by Matchstick (561 posts) - 4 months, 2 days ago - Show Bio
#12 Posted by The Stegman (12932 posts) - 4 months, 2 days ago - Show Bio

Why not just put these in the Unpopular Opinion thread? Unless you're trying to troll, in which case, shame on you.

#13 Posted by god_spawn (30421 posts) - 4 months, 2 days ago - Show Bio

We have a thread for these things anyway.

Moderator
Please Log In

Use your keyboard!

  • ESC