hal jordan and norrin radd swap roles

hal jordan and norrin radd are flying through the universe and both get sucked into alternate realities where norrin is in the dc universe at the time of abin surs death and when hals in marvel when galactus goes to norrins home world. hal becomes the surfer and norrin becomes the green lantern. are they successful in eachothers roles? which is more successful? is hal better at wielding the power cosmic than norrin? is norrin a better lantern than hal? embrace debate (i picked these two characters because ive always considered them to be equals. marvel and dc's sides of the same coin so to speak)

Hal would defy Galactus from day one. Norrin could become a very powerful Green Lantern but would definately leave to become the most powerful Blue lantern of all time.

@evilvegeta74: thats not entirely true because norrin was against destroying planets with life and would only destroy lifeless planets. overtime galactus feared surfer might not find a planet in time so he changed surfers morality so he would be willing to destroy planets with life. thats galactus tampering and i know green lantern couldnt defy it immediately. he would have to have someone help him like surfer than rebel.