Favorite DC Animated Movies VOTING: 'Wonder Woman' vs. 'Superman vs. The Elite'

Superman here for sure.

Superman vs elite for me. While it's design of superman was a bit silly the film stayed true to essence of the original story and even included the famous dreams speech. Unfortunately I haven't seen Wonder Woman. I should probably get around to seeing it.

Sigh, no love for old school Superman.

Wonder Woman the Animated Movie is far superior. This is the type of movie fans want to see a live action version of. The story is humorous, characters are lovable and the music is epic. I went into this movie being skeptical that a WW movie could work, but by the end I had been convinced a WW story can deliver the goods. The dvd sales for this movie were originally low, but within the past year and a half it has shot up the DC animated movie sales list. If you haven't seen this movie, you may be missing out on one of the gems of the dc animated universe.

Though not the best DC DTV, Wonder Woman was light years better than Superman vs The Elite. SvTH may be the worst DC DTV since the first GL DTV movie!

This is INSANELY hard, but I'm gonna say Wonder Woman by a hair.

I absolutely loved Superman vs The Elite.

Wonder Woman without question.While Superman was better than most thought it would be given the shitty title and the fact that's it's a single issue story.

WW just tops it in every way.Not only that but just like Bret Hart Wonder Woman(2009) is the best there is, the best there was and the best there ever will be.It gives you all you want out of an WW film and just blows you away by giving you what you didn't even know you wanted.

Like downright gory, disturbing violence and action scenes, mostly involving women(naturally), a score worthy of mention among the greats, funnier than most comedy's today and a climax so epic in stakes and scope that it has yet to be matched by any of the other films be they animated or not(bigger than The Avengers and Dark Knight Rises).Also no Deus Ex Machina for once, although to be fair i would say she is over-powered but reasoning is reasonable.

For once, I'm going with the "I can't choose" option. Typically I feel like that's a copout option. But in this case I really do like both of these pretty equally. Both were fun, well animated pieces that I enjoyed multiple times. There's really no way to choose without digging out my Dark Knight collectible Two-Face coin and flipping it.

(and no, that's not a joke. I keep this coin in my pocket at all times.)

I really liked them both but I found Superman to be a little holier than thou in that one. Voted Wonder Woman but they are both great movies.

Wonder Woman all I have to say is the lasso scene and it has Nathan Fillian from Firefly and the Amazonian warrior women who look like super models beat the crap out of sexist men :)

Both. I think they both show interesting ways how the superhero format can be played. Wonder Woman brought the best about the heroine and gives the superhero origin a nice change and plays with gender types especially with Diana/Steve Trevor dynamic. Superman vs The Elite explores the different superheroes we are looking and ones we support, do we want a majestic god like Superman or do we the renegades like Manchester Black who plays with our assumptions of heroes? Cool but brutal?

People liked the Wonder Woman movie better? I hope DC sees this because they no excuse to not a live-action film for this long.

Anyway, I prefer Superman vs. The Elite and I like how it chose to be a bit different from the original story rather than be a carbon copy like The Dark Knight Returns was.

Wonder Woman solely based on animation style.

Totally agree!

The Wonder Woman animated movie didn't even make my top ten list of superhero animated movies.

And by the way guys, when you say you liked the "animation" more in the Wonder Woman movie, it isn't the animation you're critiquing. Both movies are animated about the same way. What you're actually critiquing is the production value and the designs.

Superman vs the Elite had some pretty ugly and inconsistant designs, and the first 1/4 of the movie has some really bad compositions and shots. But it's SUCH a good Superman story.

Do you have to ask?

WW . hated the animation in supes vs the elite (also they poked fun at The Authority, BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)

I chose Wonder Woman since I really liked what they did with her character in that film.

@dimitridkatsis: there's love for old school supes, just not for this inferior movie, especially compared to the ww movie. and no, the original comic story did not do a thing for me. it was bland, predictable and done way better in a million animes.

Saying it again and again doesn't make it true :P

Wonder Woman has vote. As much as I love the scene where Superman goes Sephiroth (for those who understand this reference) against the Elite, Wonder Woman had great casting choice. And near the end where its Amazons vs the Army of Ares is just perfect.

I like how a majority of people are posting that both movies were good regardless of which one they are voting for. I personally think we just love these two movies so much because they show the hero exactly as we think of them as. When you see the movies, you can help but think "Yes! That is Wonder Woman" or "Yes! That is Superman!". You feel like you are actually seeing the real character as they are, instead of just some version of them that directors think they could work out as.

I pick Both. On a side note, I think Justice League: Crisis on Two Earths had the smoothest animation of all the animated DC movies.