Favorite Comic Runs VOTING: Dan Slott's THE AMAZING SPIDER-MAN vs. SUPERIOR SPIDER-MAN

@laflux:

Look i could get in this ignorant stupid fight with an idiot. But what i will add on is Slott has a point in most of the time Peter is shown too be pretty shallow. Even in Spectacular Spider-Man shuddering anytime Aunt May talked about MJs wonderful personality before he met her. Things like that Peter has done in the comics too. So there's been alot supporting Peter of just being shallow. With some girls it even felt like he dealt with their insane amount of baggage because they're hot.

@the_lobster_

You get it man you pretty summed up the truth right there.

Superior rocks

@jashro44: I'd love to see Yost take the reigns on Spidey. He's done such a good job with Kaine, and I haven't really seen him write a bad story.

It seems we are just in sync today, first the battle of the week and now this.

I went with Superior. I actually enjoyed Ock as Spider-Man. It was a pretty fun run to me

Hail SpOck!

Both are pretty good. I went with amazing spider-man

Superior Spider-Man, was just that SUPERIOR. Otto proved what I have believed for a looooong time. Peter is an underachiever who does not live up to his potential. His power set, combined with his intellect, Spider-Man should be one of the most effective crime fighters on the planet. From Spider-Bots, to leaving MJ, Otto made better decisions than Peter. Outside of his heart, Peter was the Inferior Spider-Man.

I would dearly love to never have to read another idiotic "Such and such was SUPERIOR" joke ever again.

They're both pretty mediocre, but ASM had the excellent Stefano Casseli to balance out Slott's complete inability to provide a satisfying climax.

@brockrumlow: But basically ruined all of Peter's relationships. Peter isn't JUST a superhero. Awesome Crossbones pic btw.

I was just here to read the comments but this post made me vote for Superior.

It's been a while since I read it, but honestly Brand New Day has been my favourite Spidey-era in the time I've been reading (also Back in Black, but I'm biased cause that was my first entry story arc). It had a pretty horrible starting point, obviously, but out of that we got a bunch of really great Spider-man stories from a variety of writers. And I really loved the reimagining of Spidey's villains, Hammerhead in particular was pretty great.

Big Time was when I started reading comics. I go with AMZ for sentimental value.

I actually enjoyed Superior more than Amazing. That said it was refreshing that it ended with the true Superior Spider-Man The one and only Peter Parker.

True, but it wasn't the Perfect Peter Parker, It was the Superior Spider-Man. And thank you.

@granitesoldier: Yea I want to see Yost write a spider-man story as well now that Peter is back. I'm curious to see what it would be like...

I will always choose superior Spidey better than any amazing spiderman i have read in....ever

Amazing Spider-Man for me. Amazing Spider-Man gets my vote just because of two storylines: Big Time and New Ways to Die. In those storylines at least Peter felt like Peter and there was some good characterization behind each character that made an appearance. Slott's ASM had at least some big changes to the characters that sticked for a lot of time and he was generous to each villain he ever used(unlike in Superior).

Can't vote. I'd have to vote for which one I hated less.

@vandinejd_1991:

Superior was a really cool change up...