Did Halle Berry fit better as Storm or as Catwoman?

Halle Berry took the role as Ororo Munroe aka Storm on the x-men movies. She also took the role as Catwoman. Did she fit better taking the role as Storm or Catwoman?

In my opinion, though both role that she played were not showing the comic characters' real character and what those comic characters can really do, but I think Halle fits better as Storm cos Halle looks like Storm more. Halle also looks better and still looked beautiful with the white hair. In Catwoman, she didn't really looked sexy but thin and her acting as Catwoman was kinda exagerrating. Halle acted well as Storm. It was the Storm script that made us feel disappointed

Lastly, Halle's Storm costume also looks better than the Catwoman costume.

How about you?

She was a terrible, terrible Catwoman. lol.

@rogue_mar1e said:

She was a terrible, terrible Catwoman. lol.

Halle was always swaying her hips when she becomes Catwoman, until the end of the movie. hehehe : )

she was better as storm

@rogue_mar1e said:

She was a terrible, terrible Catwoman. lol.

Which is why Anne Hathaway can relax. Anne may not be the best Catwoman in Movie history, but she surely won't be the worst. lol

@TheGreyOutcastX said:

@rogue_mar1e said:

She was a terrible, terrible Catwoman. lol.

Which is why Anne Hathaway can relax. Anne may not be the best Catwoman in Movie history, but she surely won't be the worst. lol

rofl! : )

I do not blame Halle's failure as Catwoman on her. That costume was bad. In fact nearly everything about that movie was bad. I feel Halle's performance would be considered good if she had a better costume designer, script, and director, but then again I haven't seen that movie in a long time.

@knighthood said:

I do not blame Halle's failure as Catwoman on her. That costume was bad. In fact nearly everything about that movie was bad. I feel Halle's performance would be considered good if she had a better costume designer, script, and director, but then again I haven't seen that movie in a long time.

Yes. I also think if her costume was better then Halle wouldn't definitely be the worst Catwoman.

BUt I was actually surprised that they chose Halle because Catwoman is white.

@jhazzroucher:

Eartha Kitt was a great African American Catwoman. So Halle playing that role isn't anything new.

@knighthood said:

@jhazzroucher:

Eartha Kitt was a great African American Catwoman. So Halle playing that role isn't anything new.

Oh i didn't know that. Thank you for the info.

I don't think Halle Berry's Catwoman was awful, because the character she was portraying sure as hell wasn't Catwoman.

Whatever character she was actually portraying? Yeah, that was awful.

Catwoman was just a fail in so many ways. I liked her as Storm.

yeah, she is a better storm. Catwoman failed

I haven't even seen Catwoman but know how much they failed with that movie, and the game. It was horrible beyond horrible.

She did a horrible job as both characters. Glad X-Men First Class undid that entire movie.

Storm, she was good, but she wasn't a big character in those movies really, can't blame her for Catwoman, she tried her best,that problem laid with the script.

She did a decent job as Storm. Her role as Catwoman, now that's a different story...

Neither

The issue really comes down to the writing. Storm was a minor character in a well written movie. Catwoman was a MAJOR character in a poorly written movie. Because her role is so much more prominant in Catwoman she sucks more as Catwoman than as Storm. But I don't think she would be able to carry a Storm solo movie any better than she did Catwoman.

She was better as Storm even if she had to deliver a line as storm that I consider up there as worst/corny/lame script writing when she asked "that" question to Toad.

not a fan of her in either, but If I had to pick I'd say storm, but both were letdowns in my mind

She was pretty awful at both of them.

Catwoman was horrendous, so her Storm wins. If winning means being less naff than something else.

Gutted.

Am I the only one who like Halle berry as catwoman. It wasn't her fought it was the director and writer(s) fought.

But I did really like her as storm

She was really bad at both IMO. Which is disappointing because I like her.

Halle Berry is terrible in everything she does in life.

ouch

@sesquipedalophobe said:

Halle Berry is terrible in everything she does in life.

I'll have you know that she can spell her name very well. >:(

she sucked as both

Angela Bassit (I am not positive if I spelled her last name right) would have made a better Storm and just about anybody could have been a better Catwoman

@rogue_mar1e said:

She was a terrible, terrible Catwoman. lol.

STORM!

definitely she fit Storms look pretty much perfectly, she had absolutely no reason to be in Catwoman which is generally considered the butt end of comic book movie jokes.

Storm: Uninteresting/Cheesy/Not African enough(they annoyingly Americanized every character in that Trilogy besides Nightcrawler). I will admit the writers gave her little to do besides kick ass on ocassion.

>

Catwoman: I had the sudden wisdom to avoid this trash.

keep her away from the comic book world.

@jhazzroucher: i liked her better in x-men as storm than catwoman, but i do not blame her for the bed performance, i blame the director, writer and costume design cause it did not make any sense. i believe they were trying to make as sexy as possible and it ended up messing up the movie completely.

in x-men, she was more of a background character in the first movie, in the secound she actually had more of a speaking role and in the third she finally had become the leader started to act more like storm

She was god awful in both.Halle simply can't play a "superhero type".They shouldn't have picked her for Storm but I would assume they were using her name to get people to see it, which is stupid considering they were already using one of Marvel's most popular properties.Catwoman was basically written FOR her but again, they were using one of DC's popular properties so they could have sold the film off that instead of trying to use an A-list actress.

She's was kinda good as Catwoman. But if she had more of Storm's features then maybe the part would have been better. I mean hello you missing something (the blue eyes) and lots more.

Storm

Storm

Neither. she sucked in both.

neither

She's a horrible Actress period, plain and simple.

Storm.