Thanks, everyone.
@lightsout said:
I think the comic-differences is something that's been widely "accepted" (with exceptions as you said, since Kingdom Come from DC is close enough to Civil War's themes of super-heroic accountability), but I actually never thought of the cartoon/movie comparison until you said it. Very good observation.
Although, I might argue that their animations/movies may be more serious, but still based on the classic-superheroics** -- the Batman ones already lend towards "realism", character introspection, etc (since those themes are already present in Batman, we'll have to wait until MoS comes out to see how much it follows that path).
**That is, they haven't done things like tackle discrimination (the way X-men does), and still pretty much have the stronger black-&-white distinction of what's good/just & what's not that DC is known for (where Marvel, or at least the personalities of their characters, have more shades of gray).
Yeah, definitely, I guess it's pretty widely-accepted in comics. I mean, just look at Hickman's Avengers and Johns' Justice League. The former's an epic, serious and stoic superhero team book while the latter's a more traditional superhero blockbuster.
I suppose some margin of superheroics have to be allowed with anything by DC and Marvel. But when I say serious, I don't so much mean 'realism' as I do 'serious in tone'. As in there's a less 'fun adventure' vibe and a more 'this is a serious job' sort of thing. Of course, there are noted exceptions, but that's how it comes off to me.
But yeah, good point about Marvel's characters being less morally black-and-white. Which makes the comparison even more layered now O_o
Log in to comment