• 121 results
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
#1 Edited by MannEffest (1305 posts) - - Show Bio
CHARGE! Towards… something.

Recently @veshark gave IGN a run for their money in CV's own list that arguably puts their's to shame (you can find that glorious list here; CV's Top 25 Battles in DC Comics History). Veshark has graciously allowed me to carry on the banner of battles, but this time, under the Marvel Comics logo!

Marvel has had an equally impressive array of fights and battles (From One-on-One's to "Oh s#% it's the end of the world... again" moments). So I wanted to have a time to put Marvel in the spotlight, and that's where you, the esteemed readers of CV, come in! This will be much like last time if you are joining us again (if not welcome! Take a seat and listen to the rules), but I will reiterate them again so we can familiarize ourselves with them. Once again, thanks to @veshark for the hard work he put in last time! I probably have no idea what I'm getting myself into.

*EDIT* Voting has ended!!! I will post the results later today or tomorrow! :D Thanks for everyone who participated!

How to Vote

  • Think of your top ten most memorable or best Marvel Comics Battles
  • *RULE CHANGE* Nominate UP TO ten choices (Not everyone can put ten because they are not as knowledgeable of Marvel Comics, so basically however little you want is okay)
  • Whenever a battle hits 3 votes, it goes into the 'Top 25' list.
  • Battles in the list are no longer up for nomination.
  • Once this is done, I'll compile a finalized list with our victors. With pictures and (hopefully as entertaining) commentary.

Restrictions

No Public Perception and Crap

As stated before in the DC version, IGN failed on the "battles" part of things. So, just to keep things short… Punches must be thrown in order for it to be considered a battle. Big cosmic battles count this time as well.

Marvel Comics Only

Pretty self explanatory, no DC, Image, Valiant, Dark Horse, Etc. Alternate universes count; Marvel Zombies, Ultimate Universe and all that jazz.

Once Voted

As the rules stated (and still state), 3 votes for a single battle puts it into the Top 25 automatically. The first 25 battles to get five votes are essentially confirmed for the list. Once a battle is in the 'Top 25 Confirmed' - you may no longer vote for that battle.

So, LET THE GAMES BEGIN!

Voting will end on Monday at 5:00pm EST

Hopefully I will have the full list combined by 5:00pm EST on Tuesday! Then Round 2 begins.

#2 Edited by MannEffest (1305 posts) - - Show Bio

25 Confirmed Battles (Voting ENDED)

Avengers vs. Masters of Evil (Avengers #277) - 3

Avengers vs. Thanos and the Cull Obsidian (Infinity) - 3

Black Bolt vs. Vulcan (War of Kings) - 3

Civil War Final Battle (Civil War) - 3

Captain America vs. Winter Soldier (The Winter Soldier) - 3

Daredevil and Elektra vs. Bullseye (Daredevil #181) - 3

Heroes vs. Villains (Secret Wars) - 3

Hulk vs. The Marvel Universe (World War Hulk) - 3

Hulk vs. Skaar (Incredible Hulk #611) - 3

Iron Man vs. The Mandarin (Iron Man: Haunted) - 3

Moon Knight vs. Bushman (Moon Knight: The Bottom) - 3

Nova vs. Annihilus (Annihilation) - 3

Odin vs. Thanos (Infinity Watch #35) - 3

Scarlet Spider (Kaine) and Venom (Flash Thompson) vs Carnage (Minimum Carnage) - 3

Spider-Man vs. Kraven the Hunter (Kraven's Last Hunt) - 3

Spider-Man vs. Morlun (The Spider Totem) - 3

Spider-Man vs. Green Goblin (Death of Gwen Stacy) - 3

Thanos vs. The Marvel Universe (Infinity Gauntlet) - 3

Thor vs. Iron Man (Thor #3 vol 3) - 3

Ultimate Spider-Man vs Green Goblin/Ultimate Six (Death of Spider-Man) - 3

Ultimates vs. Liberators (Ultimates 2) - 3

Ultimates vs. The Chitauri (Ultimates 1) - 3

Ultimates vs. Ultimate Hulk (Ultimates 1) - 3

X-Men vs. Bastion (Second Coming) - 3

Young Thor, Thor and King Thor vs Gorr (Godbomb) - 3

Battles Nominated (Voting ENDED)

Honorable Mentions (2 votes)

Avengers vs. Loki (Avengers #1) - 2

Beta Ray Bill vs Stardust - 2

Dr. Doom vs. The Beyonder (Secret Wars) - 2

Fantastic Four vs. Galactus (The Galactus Trilogy) - 2

Magneto vs Apocalypse (AoA) - 2

Spider-Man vs. Kingpin (Back in Black) - 2

Venom vs. Carnage (Maximum Carnage) - 2

Winter Soldier vs. Iron Man (The Death of Captain America) - 2

Wolverine vs. Sabertooth (Wolverine #212) - 2

Wolverine vs. Gorgon (Enemy of the State) - 2

Wolverine vs. Hulk (Incredible Hulk #340) - 2

Wolverine vs Shingen (Wolverine #4) - 2

X-Men vs. Hellfire Club (Dark Phoenix Saga) - 2

Other Votes

Avengers vs. Dark Avengers (Siege) - 1

Avengers vs. Korvac - 1

Avengers vs. Ultron (Ultron Unlimited) - 1

Beta Ray Bill vs. Asteroth (Stormbreaker Saga) -1

Black Dwarf vs. the Imperial Council (Infinity) - 1

Black Panther vs. Stealth Iron Man (Black Panther: Enemy of the State II) - 1

Captain America vs. Batroc the Leaper - 1

Captain America vs. Iron Spider (Civil War) - 1

Captain America vs. Kang (Kang Dynasty) - 1

Colossus vs Juggernaut (Uncanny X-Men #183) - 1

Daredevil vs. Bullseye (Daredevil #5 vol 5) - 1

Deadpool vs. Ajax (Original Deadpool Series IIRC) - 1

Dr. Doom vs. Cosmic Hulk and Skaar - 1

Elektra vs Bullseye (Elektra #2) - 1

Emma Frost vs. Kitty Pryde (Astonishing X-Men) - 1

Fear Itself Final Battle (Fear Itself) - 1

Ghost Rider vs. Lucifer - The Legend of Sleepy Hollow, Illinois - 1

Guardians of the Galaxy vs. Ultron & Phalanx army (Annihilation: Conquest) - 1

Hulk vs. Maestero - 1

Hulk vs. Super Skrull (Incredible Hulk #375) - 1

Hulk vs. Wolverine (Incredible Hulk #181) - 1

Iceman vs. Thor (Astonishing X-Men) - 1

Juggernaut vs. D'Spayre ('97 Juggernaut Series) - 1

Marvel Universe vs. Phoenix Cyclops (Avengers Vs. X-Men) - 1

Molecular Man vs. Beyonder (Secret Wars 2) - 1

Odin vs. Seth - 1

Punisher vs. Barracuda (Long Cold Dark) - 1

Punisher vs. The Gnuccis - 1

Punisher and Wolverine vs. Little People - 1

Red Hulk vs. Hulk (World War Hulks) - 1

Ronan the Accuser, Silver Surfer, Quasar, Nova and Beta Ray Bill vs. Lord Mar-Vell (The Thanos Imperative) - 1

Silver Surfer vs. Morg (The Herald Ordeal) - 1

Silver Surfer vs. Cable (Cable and Deadpool #10) - 1

Scarlet Spider vs. Kraven the Hunter (Scarlet Spider #23) - 1

Spider-Man vs. Doc Ock (If This Be My Destiny) - 1

Spider-Man vs. Doc Ock (Dying Wish) - 1

Spider-Man vs. Kaine (Spider-Island) - 1

Spider-Man vs. Juggernaut - 1

Thor vs. Gorr (The God Butcher) - 1

Thor vs. Agnir and Null (Fear Itself) - 1

Thor vs. Beta Ray Bill (The Mighty Thor #337) - 1

Thor vs. Juggernaut (The Mighty Thor #429) - 1

Thor vs. Silver Surfer (Fear Itself) - 1

Ultimates vs. Ultimate X-Men (Ultimate War) - 1

Ultimate Wolverine vs. Ultimate Hulk (Ultimate Wolverine vs. Hulk) - 1

Ultimates vs. Ultimate Thor (Ultimates 1) - 1

Wolverine vs Mystique (Get Mystique) - 1

Wolverine vs. Omega Red (Wolverine Origins) - 1

X-Men vs. Acolytes (Mutant Genesis) - 1

X-Men vs. Dark Phoenix (Dark Phoenix Saga) - 1

X-Men vs. Marauders - 1

X-Men vs. Magneto (Magneto Triumphant) - 1

X-Men vs. Proteus (Classic X-Men #33-34) - 1

#3 Edited by Fallschirmjager (18983 posts) - - Show Bio

no particular order

  • Ultimate Spider-Man vs Green Goblin/Sinister Six (Death of Spider-Man)
  • Spider-Man vs Kraven the Hunter (Kraven's Last Hunt)
  • Spider-Man vs Green Goblin (Death of Gwen Stacy)
  • Spider-Man vs Kingpin (Back in Black)
  • Captain America vs Iron Man (Civil War, both fights)
  • Captain America vs Winter Soldier (The Winter Soldier)
  • Young Thor, Thor and King Thor vs Gorr (Godbomb)
  • Daredevil and Elektra vs. Bullseye (Daredevil #181)
  • Sentry vs Hulk (WWH)
  • Thanos vs Marvel (Infinity Gauntlet)
Online
#4 Posted by MannEffest (1305 posts) - - Show Bio

Oh yes, order isn't required.

#5 Edited by Veshark (9058 posts) - - Show Bio

Yay! Mighty Marvel's turn! And @manneffest, you'll do fine...long as you've got patience and a calculator ;)

In alphabetical order:

  1. Black Panther vs. Stealth Iron Man (Black Panther: Enemy of the State II)
  2. Captain America vs. Winter Soldier (Winter Soldier)
  3. Fantastic Four vs. Galactus (The Galactus Trilogy)
  4. Fear Itself, Final Battle (Fear Itself)
  5. Iron Man Classic vs. The Mandarin (Iron Man: Haunted)
  6. Moon Knight vs. Bushman (Moon Knight: The Bottom)
  7. The Ultimates vs. Ultimate Hulk (Ultimates 1)
  8. The Ultimates vs. The Chitauri (Ultimates 1)
  9. The Ultimates vs. Ultimate X-Men (Ultimate War)
  10. Winter Soldier vs. Iron Man (The Death of Captain America)

I'll try to come up with a No 10 later, I've got too many choices....so this list is subject to random change upon notice!

#6 Posted by hart7668 (2294 posts) - - Show Bio

Ah, I'm not quite up to my Marvel battles, but here is my paltry list:

  • Beta Ray Bill vs. Thor (when he beat Thor and took Mjolnir - don't remember comic)
  • Thanos vs. Odin (again, don't remember story arc)
  • Spider-Man vs. Morlun
  • Beta Ray Bill vs. Stardust (Godhunter)

....aaaaand I'll brush up to try to add 6 more before the nominating period ends. Which is when exactly?

#8 Posted by cameron83 (7643 posts) - - Show Bio

@veshark: I say Iron Man vs Captain America in Civil War.

Are there any notable Spider-man fights?

Iron Fist must be mentioned,though...however,I don't know of any notable Iron Fist fights.

#9 Edited by dagmar_merrill (10327 posts) - - Show Bio

Only have one.

Namor vs Human torch from Marvels.

Edit: I have 3 more.

Iron Man vs Mandarin.

Daredevil vs Bullseye. (Don't know the issue number off the top of my head I know it's written by Frank Miller and Kingpin plays a big part in the issue)

Marvel 1602 - Dr. Doom vs everyone.

#10 Edited by Fallschirmjager (18983 posts) - - Show Bio

@cameron83 said:

Are there any notable Spider-man fights?

i could have made all 10 of my nominations Spider-Man fights -.-

Online
#11 Posted by cameron83 (7643 posts) - - Show Bio

@cameron83 said:

Are there any notable Spider-man fights?

i could have made all 10 of my nominations Spider-Man fights -.-

I know that,but any recommendations?

#12 Edited by Fallschirmjager (18983 posts) - - Show Bio

@cameron83: For Starters:

  • Ultimate Spider-Man vs Green Goblin/Sinister Six (Death of Spider-Man)
  • Spider-Man vs Kraven the Hunter (Kraven's Last Hunt)
  • Spider-Man vs Green Goblin (Death of Gwen Stacy)
  • Spider-Man vs Kingpin (Back in Black)

More?

  • Ultimate Spider-Man vs Sinister Six (Ultimate Six arc)
  • Ultimate Spider-Man vs Venom
  • Kaine vs Carnage
  • Spider-Man + allies vs Carnage + allies (Maximum Carnage)
  • Spider-Island battle

I could keep going xD

Online
#13 Edited by cameron83 (7643 posts) - - Show Bio

@cameron83: For Starters:

@fallschirmjager said:
  • Ultimate Spider-Man vs Green Goblin/Sinister Six (Death of Spider-Man)
  • Spider-Man vs Kraven the Hunter (Kraven's Last Hunt)
  • Spider-Man vs Green Goblin (Death of Gwen Stacy)
  • Spider-Man vs Kingpin (Back in Black)

More?

  • Ultimate Spider-Man vs Sinister Six (Ultimate Six arc)
  • Ultimate Spider-Man vs Venom
  • Kaine vs Carnage
  • Spider-Man + allies vs Carnage + allies (Maximum Carnage)
  • Spider-Island battle

I could keep going xD

Damn,it's actually sad that I haven't read many of those. It's even more sad that I forgot many of those fights (The Death of Ultimate Spider-man is one of the best fights in comics imo)

#14 Edited by PapiNacho (3232 posts) - - Show Bio

Not really qualified to nominate here.

#15 Posted by Floopay (8721 posts) - - Show Bio

@veshark: In no particular order:

  1. Quasar and Nova vs. Annihilus (Annilhilation)
  2. Odin vs. Seth (Thor 300ish I think)
  3. Molecular Man vs. Beyonder (Secret Wars 2)
  4. Deadpool vs. Ajax (Original Deadpool Series IIRC)
  5. Thor vs. Agnir and Null (Fear Itself)
  6. Wolverine vs. Sabertooth (Wolverine 212) OR Wolverine vs. Yashida (Can't remember the issue)
  7. Beta Ray Bill vs. Asteroth (Stormbreaker Saga)
  8. Juggernaut vs. D'Spayre ('97 Juggernaut Series)
  9. Ultimate Spider-Man vs. Sinister Six/Green Goblin
  10. Ultimates vs. Thor
  11. Iron Man vs. Mandarin (Iron Man: Haunted)
  12. Punisher vs. Daken (Dark Reign) or Punisher vs. Barricuda (Punisher MAX)

Thanks for reading,

Floopay

#16 Posted by Fallschirmjager (18983 posts) - - Show Bio

@cameron83: 90% of the marvel comics I read are Spider-based, :P

Online
#17 Edited by AllStarSuperman (23013 posts) - - Show Bio

I don't read enough marvel

#18 Posted by Veshark (9058 posts) - - Show Bio
#19 Edited by YourNeighborhoodComicGeek (20446 posts) - - Show Bio

I'm just going to pop in a few battles I thought were pretty good.

  • World War Hulk vs. Everybody (WORLD WAR HULK entire arc)
  • Thanos with Infinity Gauntlet vs. Everybody (INFINITY GAUNTLET #4)
  • Doctor Doom vs. Beyonder (SECRET WARS #10)
  • Heroes vs. Villains (SECRET WARS entire arc)
  • Anti-Registration vs. Pro-Registration (CIVIL WAR #7)
  • Scarlet Spider vs. Kraven (SCARLET SPIDER #23)
  • Avengers vs. each other/Loki (AVENGERS #1)
  • Daredevil vs. Bullseye (DAREDEVIL #181)
  • Hulk vs. Wolverine (INCREDIBLE HULK #181)
  • Mindless Hulk vs. Avengers (INCREDIBLE HULK #316)

Other battles

  • Spider-Man vs. Green Goblin (AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #122)
  • Captain America vs. Arnim Zola (CAPTAIN AMERICA #9)
  • Silver Surfer vs. Thor (THE SILVER SURFER #4)
  • Wolverine vs. Gorgon (WOLVERINE #31)
  • Deadpool vs. Punisher (DEADPOOL #55-56)
  • Punisher vs. Daken (DARK REIGN: THE LIST - PUNISHER #1)
  • Thor vs. Hercules (THE MIGHTY THOR #126)
  • Thor vs. Beta Ray Bill (THE MIGHTY THOR #338)
  • Ultimate Spider-Man vs. Sinister Six/Green Goblin (ULTIMATE SPIDER-MAN #159-160)
  • Hulk vs. Thing (FANTASTIC FOUR #25-26)
  • Nick Fury vs. Baron von Strucker (STRANGE TALES #156-157)
  • Nick Fury vs. Captain America (STRANGE TALES #159)
  • Wolverine vs. Gray Hulk (INCREDIBLE HULK #340)
  • Spider-Man vs. Kraven (AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #634-637)
  • Captain America vs. Baron Zemo (AVENGERS #277)
#20 Posted by cameron83 (7643 posts) - - Show Bio

@veshark said:

Hey guys, just want to clarify: I'm not running this tournament, @manneffest is. I was just calling y'all in to help ;)

@floopay @cameron83

ooohh

@cameron83: 90% of the marvel comics I read are Spider-based, :P

:) They are addicting!

OH,I remember one:

Sinister Six vs Intel (Spiderman: Ends of the Earth)

#21 Edited by Alak (928 posts) - - Show Bio

@manneffest:

Thanks for kick-starting this thread. I really hope the results turn out as well as the DC ones did!

@veshark:

My Marvel knowledge sucks compared to my DC knowledge, but I got your back! :D

  1. Guardians of the Galaxy vs. Ultron & Phalanx army (Annihilation: Conquest)
  2. Nova vs. Annihilus (Annihilation)
  3. X-men & Ultimates vs. Magneto (Ultimatum)
  4. Peter Parker vs. Wilson Fisk (The Amazing Spider-man)
  5. Anti-Registration vs. Pro-registration (Civil War)
  6. Spider-man vs. Morlun (Spider-man: The Other)
  7. Daredevil vs. Bullseye (Shadowland)
  8. Captain America vs. The Liberators (Ultimates)
  9. Hulk vs. X-Men (World War Hulk)
  10. Hulk vs. Silver Surfer (Planet Hulk)
#22 Edited by CheeseSticks (2589 posts) - - Show Bio

1- The X-Men vs the nimrods and Bastion, in Second Coming.

2- Thanos vs Galactus, Eternity, etc. In the fifth of six issue of The Infinity Gauntlet.

3- AoA: Magneto and X-Man vs Apocalypse and Holocaust.

4- Magneto vs the X-Men in the arc Magneto Triumphant (Uncanny X-Men 112-113).

5- X-Men vs the Marauders (Uncanny X-Men 211).

6- Magneto and his acolytes vs the X-Men in Mutant Genesis (X-Men vol 2, #1-3)

Yeah i know, i love the X-Men.

#23 Edited by Alak (928 posts) - - Show Bio

Wow, I just realized all of my nominations were published from the mid-2000s to present. I really feel like a Marvel newbie now...

#24 Posted by Pokeysteve (8690 posts) - - Show Bio

@manneffest:

How to Vote

  1. Think of your top ten most memorable or best DC Comics Battles

You should fix that when you get a chance.

Don't know as much about Marvel as I do DC but I'll give it a shot.

  • Punisher VS Barracuda - Long Cold Dark
  • Spider-Man VS Morlun
  • Wolverine VS Gorgon
  • Punisher and Wolverine VS Midgets/Little People - Punisher: Marvel Knights numbers 16 and 17
  • Elektra VS Bullseye - Elektra #2
  • Punisher VS The Gnuccis
  • Ghost Rider VS Lucifer - The Legend of Sleepy Hollow, Illinois
  • Hulk VS The X-Men - WWH

That's all I got without smothering the list in Punisher haha.

#25 Posted by batmannflash (6226 posts) - - Show Bio

@veshark: i havent read enough pre-marvel now stories :( But i'll try my best to think of good Marvel fights.

I'll do it when I wake up tomorrow

#26 Edited by HumanRocket (9394 posts) - - Show Bio

No particular order

• Civil War final battle

• Nova vs Annhilus

• Sentry vs Hulk

• Magneto vs Apocalypse (AoA)

• Ultimate Spider-Man vs Sinister Six

• Thor vs Iron Man

• Captain America vs Winter Soldier

• Thanos and the Black Order vs The Avengers

• Scarlet Spider (Kaine) vs Carnage

• Spider Man vs Kraven

¤

#27 Edited by Alak (928 posts) - - Show Bio

@manneffest:

Trying to help the OP out here. These battles for sure got at least 3 votes thus far.

  • Spider-man vs. Morlun (Spider-man: The Other)
  • Anti-registration vs. Pro-registration (Civil War) <<< also referred to as Final Battle of Civil War
  • Nova vs. Annihilus (Annihilation)
  • Hulk vs. Sentry (World War Hulk)

Spider-man vs. Kraven got a lot of mentions, but I don't think those are from the same issues. It'd be a lot easier if people referenced the issue number or event title of a fight. I may have skipped count on some other fights, but oh well, this is my contribution lol.

#28 Posted by TheAcidSkull (18835 posts) - - Show Bio

Hulk Vs Skaar Incredible Hulk 611 beats everything IMO

Online
#29 Posted by MannEffest (1305 posts) - - Show Bio

@manneffest:

How to Vote

  1. Think of your top ten most memorable or best DC Comics Battles

You should fix that when you get a chance.

Don't know as much about Marvel as I do DC but I'll give it a shot.

  • Punisher VS Barracuda - Long Cold Dark
  • Spider-Man VS Morlun
  • Wolverine VS Gorgon
  • Punisher and Wolverine VS Midgets/Little People - Punisher: Marvel Knights numbers 16 and 17
  • Elektra VS Bullseye - Elektra #2
  • Punisher VS The Gnuccis
  • Ghost Rider VS Lucifer - The Legend of Sleepy Hollow, Illinois
  • Hulk VS The X-Men - WWH

That's all I got without smothering the list in Punisher haha.


Oops, thanks for pointing that out! That would have been disastrous :O BTW an't nothing wrong with Punisher ;)

@yourneighborhoodcomicgeek: Hey could you shorten your list to ten? That would be great! I know its hard (Because I struggled), but just to make my life easier and give everyone a chance to vote! Thanks!

@veshark: Once more time, THANKS!! I can now get this thing of its feet! This is going to be awesome, I'll start compiling the votes that we have so far today!

Awesome lits everybody! (I might change the voting until it reaches 4 points just so everyone can vote, not sure, feedback?

#30 Edited by Perethorn (3805 posts) - - Show Bio

1. Thanos vs Marvel Universe

2. Thor vs Gorr

3. Hulk vs Sentry

4. Beta Ray Bill vs Stardust

5. Odin vs Thanos

6. Thor vs Silver Surfer (Fear Itself)

7. Iron Man vs Captain America (Civil War)

8. Beta Ray Bill vs Thor

9. Venom vs Carnage (Maximum Carnage)

10. Hulk vs Maestro

#31 Posted by solon (421 posts) - - Show Bio

no particular order

Thanos vs Odin - Thor Boold and Thunder

Civil war final battle

Thanos and black order vs Avengers ( Infinity)

Black Bolt vs Vulcan (War of kings)

Thor vs Bor ( Thor 600)

Nova vs Annihulus (Annihilation)

WWhulk vs everyone

Dr. Doom vs Cosmic Hulk and Skaar ( incredible hulk 606)

The X-men vs Hellfire Club

Spider-man vs Morlun

#32 Posted by HeraldofGanthet (3782 posts) - - Show Bio

@pokeysteve:

Punisher and Wolverine VS Midgets/Little People - Punisher: Marvel Knights numbers 16 and 17

Wait a minute.. Wolverine and the Punisher were fighting midgets? That's messed up man. Were they at least super-powered midgets like Puck from Alpha Flight?

#33 Edited by Battle_Forum_Junkie (8743 posts) - - Show Bio

@veshark Thor(s) vs. Gorr the god butcher - Thor: god of thunder #11

Civil War final battle. I think that's already been nominated, though.

Spider-Man: Civil War - Captain America vs. Iron Spider. If I could I'd nominate Cap's speech later in the book. Just because of how awesome it was. :P

Captain America vs. Batroc the leaper - Tales of Suspense #75. I read it when I first got into comics and it's still one of my favorite Captain America comic book fights.

#34 Posted by batmannflash (6226 posts) - - Show Bio

I'll try my best:

Wolverine vs Hulk (Incredible Hulk 340)

X-Men vs Hellfire Club (Dark Phoenix Saga)

Wolverine vs Gorgon (Enemy of the State)

Spider-Man vs Green Goblin (Death of Gwen Stacey)

Civil War Final Battle, Pro vs Anti-Registration

Avengers vs Thanos & Black Order (Infinity)

3 Thors vs Gorr (Godbomb)

Emma Frost vs Kitty Pryde (Astonishing X-Men)

Wolverine vs Mystique (Get Mystique)

Wolverine vs Shingen (Wolverine by Claremont)

#35 Posted by YourNeighborhoodComicGeek (20446 posts) - - Show Bio

@manneffest: I edited it. Just take the first ten as the votes.

#36 Posted by Pokeysteve (8690 posts) - - Show Bio

@pokeysteve:

Punisher and Wolverine VS Midgets/Little People - Punisher: Marvel Knights numbers 16 and 17

Wait a minute.. Wolverine and the Punisher were fighting midgets? That's messed up man. Were they at least super-powered midgets like Puck from Alpha Flight?

Nope. There were a group of them and they'd cut the legs off of mob guys at the knee hahahaha god I love Garth Ennis. It won't make the top list but I had to put it in.

#37 Posted by HeraldofGanthet (3782 posts) - - Show Bio

@pokeysteve:

That's sick, dude. Not you for enjoying it, but Ennis for drawing it. That guy's twisted.

#38 Edited by Pokeysteve (8690 posts) - - Show Bio

@pokeysteve:

That's sick, dude. Not you for enjoying it, but Ennis for drawing it. That guy's twisted.

Ennis wrote. I love the guy who drew it too. I'll get you a couple scans a bit later. It's exactly like you think it would be hahaha.

#39 Posted by HeraldofGanthet (3782 posts) - - Show Bio

@pokeysteve:

It's exactly like you think it would be hahaha.

Aw man. I can't watch...

#40 Posted by Pokeysteve (8690 posts) - - Show Bio

@heraldofganthet:

Note: Logan is missing his face because Punisher blew it off with a shotgun. They aren't getting along.

#41 Posted by RisingBean (4778 posts) - - Show Bio

No order.

Wolverine vs Shingin- Wolverine limited series 4

Hulk vs Super Skrull - Incredible Hulk 375

Daredevil vs Bullseye- Daredevil 181

Spider-Man vs Doctor Octopus- Amazing Spider-Man 32 (or maybe it was 33.)

X-Men vs Proteus -Classic X-Men 33-34

Colossus vs Juggernaut- Uncanny X-Men 183

Ultimates vs Chitauri- Ultimates Vol 1 12-13

Wolverine vs Gorgon- Wolverine vol 3 31

Thor Vs Juggernaut- The Mighty Thor 429

Ultimates vs Liberators Ultimates Vol 2 12-13

#42 Posted by HeraldofGanthet (3782 posts) - - Show Bio

@pokeysteve:

What in the hell?! Aw man.... That is SOOOOO twisted. That's like something out of Vertigo Comics or something. I need to lie down....

#44 Posted by Pokeysteve (8690 posts) - - Show Bio

@heraldofganthet: Lol that's Ennis for you!! Man that was a good story. And a great fight!

#45 Posted by Veshark (9058 posts) - - Show Bio

No order.

Wolverine vs Shingin- Wolverine limited series 4

Hulk vs Super Skrull - Incredible Hulk 375

Daredevil vs Bullseye- Daredevil 181

Spider-Man vs Doctor Octopus- Amazing Spider-Man 32 (or maybe it was 33.)

X-Men vs Proteus -Classic X-Men 33-34

Colossus vs Juggernaut- Uncanny X-Men 183

Ultimates vs Chitauri- Ultimates Vol 1 12-13

Wolverine vs Gorgon- Wolverine vol 3 31

Thor Vs Juggernaut- The Mighty Thor 429

Ultimates vs Liberators Ultimates Vol 2 12-13

Only two Ultimate battles? You wound me, RB.

But good choices, lots of classic battles from many eras in here.

#46 Posted by MannEffest (1305 posts) - - Show Bio

All these lists tell me I need to read more Ultimate titles :/ If it survives the hunger of Galactus!

#47 Posted by Veshark (9058 posts) - - Show Bio

All these lists tell me I need to read more Ultimate titles :/ If it survives the hunger of Galactus!

I highly-recommend you pick up the earlier Ultimate books in trade. They're fantastic!

#48 Edited by RisingBean (4778 posts) - - Show Bio

@veshark: I could have easily filled it with Ultimate fights. But I wanted to spread the wealth. I literally said "What fights as a kid made me say whoa?" I padded out a few modern era things so I didn't look like a relic of the 80's. (Which I am, but...)

I don't feel like looking the issue numbers up but another 10 badass Ultimate fights. Almost nothing Post Ultimatum because I simply haven't committed the battles to memory and don't feel like researching. If they stand out, fine.

Thing vs Ronan the Accuser.

Spider-Man, Shang Chi, Iron Fist, Elektra, Enforcers, Hammerhead, Moon Knight-Gang war.

Captain America vs Vampires

Spider-man+ Ultimates vs the Six (more accurately the Five)

Spider-Man vs Green Goblin (Death of Parker)

Ultimates vs Red Skull

Hulk vs Wolverine

X-men vs Apocalypse

Reed vs Thanos

Captain America vs the Ultimates backup roster (Graveyard fight in Ultimates V 2, not vs War Machine and co.)

Edit for clarification.

#49 Edited by MannEffest (1305 posts) - - Show Bio

Well, after a long first day of compiling what we have (grueling yet fun to say the least), we have the ending day tally! And boy is it looking pretty good.

@juiceboks @fallschirmjager @yourneighborhoodcomicgeek @rulerofthisuniverse @wolverine08 @monsterstomp @sog7dc@allstarsuperman @batmannflash @dagmar_merrill @hart7668 @bogey @silverpool @jake_fury @alak @pokeysteve @deaditegonzo@the_comebacks @mulder15 @billy_batson @yung_ancient_one @patrat18 @cameron83 @lyrafay @liberty @papinacho@ballpointhero @comicstooge @matchesmalone21 @squalleon@cheesesticks @battle_forum_junkie@risingbean @jokergeist @floopay @pyrogram @theacidskull @lvenger @comicstooge @heraldofganthet @citizenbane@billy_batson @god_spawn @cameron83 @laflux @tdk_1997 @entropy_aegis @awesam @dccomicsrule2011 @bumpyboo@rustyroy @kairan1979 @libert @veshark

Just note, voting does not end until Monday, so feel free to get some more friends in on it!

ALSO, once a battle got 3 votes, all votes after that were null and void (Looking at you Civil War Final Battle, which got 6), so math junkies don't freak out! There is a method behind this madness!

Without further ado...

Battles Confirmed

Avengers vs. Thanos and the Cull Obsidian (Infinity) - 3

Civil War Final Battle (Civil War) - 3

Daredevil and Elektra vs. Bullseye (Daredevil #181) - 3

Hulk vs. The Marvel Universe (World War Hulk) - 3

Nova vs. Annihilus (Annihilation) - 3

Odin vs. Thanos (Infinity Watch #35) - 3

Spider-Man vs. Kraven the Hunter (Kraven's Last Hunt) - 3

Spider-Man vs. Morlun (The Spider Totem) - 3

Thanos vs. The Marvel Universe (Infinity Gauntlet) - 3

Ultimate Spider-Man vs Green Goblin/Ultimate Six (Death of Spider-Man) - 3

Battles Nominated

Avengers vs. Loki (Avengers #1) - 1

Beta Ray Bill vs. Asteroth (Stormbreaker Saga) -1

Beta Ray Bill vs Stardust - 2

Black Bolt vs. Vulcan (War of Kings) - 1

Black Dwarf vs. the Imperial Council (Infinity) - 1

Black Panther vs. Stealth Iron Man (Black Panther: Enemy of the State II) - 1

Captain America vs. Batroc the Leaper - 1

Captain America vs. Iron Spider (Civil War) - 1

Captain America vs Winter Soldier (The Winter Soldier) - 2

Colossus vs Juggernaut (Uncanny X-Men #183) - 1

Deadpool vs. Ajax (Original Deadpool Series IIRC) - 1

Dr. Doom vs. Cosmic Hulk and Skaar - 1

Dr. Doom vs. The Beyonder (Secret Wars) - 1

Elektra vs Bullseye (Elektra #2) - 1

Emma Frost vs Kitty Pryde (Astonishing X-Men) - 1

Fantastic Four vs. Galactus (The Galactus Trilogy) - 1

Fear Itself Final Battle (Fear Itself) - 1

Ghost Rider vs. Lucifer - The Legend of Sleepy Hollow, Illinois - 1

Guardians of the Galaxy vs. Ultron & Phalanx army (Annihilation: Conquest) - 1

Heroes vs. Villains (Secret Wars) -

Hulk vs. Maestero - 1

Hulk vs. Super Skrull (Incredible Hulk #375) - 1

Hulk vs. Wolverine (Incredible Hulk #181) - 1

Iron Man vs. The Mandarin (Iron Man: Haunted) - 1

Juggernaut vs. D'Spayre ('97 Juggernaut Series) - 1

Magneto vs Apocalypse (AoA) - 2

Marvel Universe vs. Phoenix Cyclops (Avengers Vs. X-Men) - 1

Molecular Man vs. Beyonder (Secret Wars 2) - 1

Moon Knight vs. Bushman (Moon Knight: The Bottom) - 1

Odin vs. Seth - 1

Punisher vs. Barracuda (Long Cold Dark) - 1

Punisher vs. The Gnuccis - 1

Punisher and Wolverine vs. Little People - 1

Scarlet Spider (Kaine) vs Carnage - 1

Scarlet Spider vs. Kraven the Hunter (Scarlet Spider #23) - 1

Sider-Man vs. Doc Ock (If This Be My Destiny) - 1

Spider-Man vs. Doc Ock (Dying Wish) - 1

Spider-Man vs. Green Goblin (Death of Gwen Stacy) - 2

Spider-Man vs. Kingpin (Back in Black) - 2

Thor vs. Gorr (The God Butcher) - 1

Thor vs. Agnir and Null (Fear Itself) - 1

Thor vs. Beta Ray Bill (The Mighty Thor #337) - 1

Thor vs. Iron Man (Thor #3) - 2

Thor vs. Juggernaut (The Mighty Thor #429) - 1

Thor vs. Silver Surfer (Fear Itself) - 1

Ultimates vs Liberators (Ultimates 2) - 1

Ultimates vs. Ultimate Hulk (Ultimates 1) - 1

Ultimates vs. The Chitauri (Ultimates 1) - 1

Ultimates vs. Ultimate X-Men (Ultimate War) - 1

Ultimate Wolverine vs. Ultimate Hulk (Ultimate Wolverine vs. Hulk) - 1

Ultimates vs. Ultimate Thor (Ultimates 1) - 1

Venom vs. Carnage (Maximum Carnage) - 1

Winter Soldier vs. Iron Man (The Death of Captain America) - 1

Wolverine vs. Sabertooth (Wolverine #212) - 1

Wolverine vs. Gorgon (Enemy of the State) - 2

Wolverine vs. Hulk (Incredible Hulk #340) - 2

Wolverine vs Mystique (Get Mystique) - 1

Wolverine vs Shingen (Wolverine #4) - 2

Young Thor, Thor and King Thor vs Gorr (Godbomb) - 2

X-Men vs. Acolytes (Mutant Genesis) - 1

X-Men vs. Bastion (Second Coming) - 1

X-Men vs. Hellfire Club (Dark Phoenix Saga) - 2

X-Men vs. Marauders - 1

X-Men vs. Magneto (Magneto Triumphant) - 1

X-Men vs. Proteus (Classic X-Men #33-34) - 1

If you wish to change one of your votes, please tell me so I may do so accordingly!

#50 Posted by hart7668 (2294 posts) - - Show Bio

@manneffest: I don't see Beta Ray Bill vs Stardust on your list of nominations....I def voted for that one :p