Comic Vine's Top 100 Superman Universe Stories: Community Step

78 results
1
2

This topic is locked from further discussion.

Skewer

348

Forum Posts

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#51 Edited By Skewer

I'd co-sign and vote for these:

For the man who has everything
Kingdom come.
Red son.
Superman adventures 25, 41, 21,22,23,30,31,6,7,8,11,12.
Superman and the legion of superheroes.
Superman beyond.
Superman birthright.
Superman brainiac.
Superman for all seasons.
Superman last son.
Superman secret origin.
Superman/ batman/ wonder woman trinity.
Whatever happened to the man of tommorow?

11 years ago

Gambit1024

10217

Forum Posts

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 9

#52 Edited By Gambit1024

I'll be cosigning the following:

Action Comics (1938) #1 ("Superman! Champion of the Oppressed...")
Action Comics (1938) #775 ("What's so Funny about Truth, Justice and the American Way?")
All-Star Superman
Brainiac
Death of Superman
Final Crisis
Infinite Crisis
Kingdom Come
Superman Annual #11 (For the Man who has everything)
Superman: Birthright
Superman: Earth One (Volume 1)
Superman: Earth One (Volume 2)
Superman: Last Son (2009)
Superman: Red Son
Superman/Batman: Public Enemies ( Superman/Batman #1-6)
The Man of Steel (1986)

11 years ago

SandMan_

4581

Forum Posts

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#54 Edited By SandMan_

We need more people...

11 years ago

Squalleon

9994

Forum Posts

3193

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 7

#55 Edited By Squalleon

@SandMan_ said:

We need more people...

for what reason?

11 years ago

Lvenger

36475

Forum Posts

899

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 50

User Lists: 18

#56 Edited By Lvenger

@Squalleon said:

@SandMan_ said:
We need more people...
for what reason?

Larger sample=better representation of the results. Scientific method bro :P

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#57 Edited By The Poet Moderator

@Lvenger said:

@Squalleon said:
@SandMan_ said:
We need more people...
for what reason?
Larger sample=better representation of the results. Scientific method bro :P

Well, doesn't matter as much in this step because next step is the one where we need the most participation. All this cosigning will create an inital order in which voters will add their votes to their choices. That's the step we want more people as Lvenger points out, they will help better represent the community. Each voter has 5 votes but the thing which makes Final Order Voting different from cosigning is Cosigns = 1 pt each where as FOVs = 5pts each and with 5 votes each that's 25pts from one user alone. In that step I want in the area of 100 people (or on up there...) (@SandMan_ does that answer your question too?)

what I really hope is that the users who usually come to my lists months after everything is finalized and say, "Where is THIS character? This list is INVALID because you don't have THIS character!" [change character to story and you get the people I absolutely love...). So as long as we get a lot of stories people like it'll be fine...oh I like even numbers :P

11 years ago

SandMan_

4581

Forum Posts

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#58 Edited By SandMan_

Alright.

11 years ago

ngroove

327

Forum Posts

268

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#59 Edited By ngroove

Acrion Comics 285: The World's Greatest Heroine!

Action Comics 432 : Target of the Toymen!

Action Comics 500: The Life Story of Superman

Daring New Adventures of Supergirl 13: Echoes of Time Gone By / Star Light, Star Bright, Blackstarr Rises Tonight / Starfall

Superman 88: The Terrible Trio!

Superman 167: The Deadly Duo

Superman 249: The Challenge of Terra-Man

Superman 287 Who Was That Dog I've Seen You With Last Night?

Superman 292 : The Luthor Nobody Knows

Superman 310: The Killer With The Kryptonite Heart!

Superman (1987) 50 "The Human Factor"

Cosign: Superman the Wedding Album

Oh yeah....can somebody talk the arcs in individual issues, such as Brainiac is actually Action Comics 866-870???

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#60 Edited By The Poet Moderator

@sethysquare: added (I edited your post just to alphabetize it which made it easier to input it...thought I should say...)

@Skewer: same as above I alphabetized your list. I'm not sure what those numbers "22,23,30,31,6,7,8,11,12." are about...are you nominating additional issues of Superman Adventures? Is that what you are doing?

@Gambit1024: added

@kfhrfdu_89_76k: added

I'll get to the last one in a a little bit...

11 years ago

SandMan_

4581

Forum Posts

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#61 Edited By SandMan_

This is a pretty big list.

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#62 Edited By The Poet Moderator

@SandMan_: Indeed!

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#63 Edited By The Poet Moderator

@ngroove: added.

I need nomination reasons (3 sentences on why each is important) for:

Action Comics (1938) #285 ("The World's Greatest Heroine!")
Action Comics (1938) #432 ("Target of the Toymen!")
Action Comics (1938) #500 ("The Life Story of Superman")
Supergirl (1982) #13
Superman (1939) #88 ("The Terrible Trio!")
Superman (1939) #167 ("The Deadly Duo")
Superman (1939) #249 ("The Challenge of Terra-Man")
Superman (1939) #287 ("Who Was That Dog I've Seen You With Last Night?")
Superman (1939) #292 ("The Luthor Nobody Knows")
Superman (1939) #310 ("The Killer With The Kryptonite Heart!")
Superman (1987) #50 ("The Human Factor")

I'm not sure I understand you when you say:

Oh yeah....can somebody talk the arcs in individual issues, such as Brainiac is actually Action Comics 866-870???

are you asking if the Brainiac is brainiac the story arc?

11 years ago

DonFelipe

2373

Forum Posts

129833

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 8

#64 Edited By DonFelipe

@The Poet said:

@ngroove: added.
I'm not sure I understand you when you say:
Oh yeah....can somebody talk the arcs in individual issues, such as Brainiac is actually Action Comics 866-870???
are you asking if the Brainiac is brainiac the story arc?

Maybe@ngroove's asking to add all the issue numbers to all story arcs (where missing). Just in case, here's the information for my nominations:

Batman/Superman/Wonder Woman: Trinity (#1-3; 2003)
Lex Luthor: The Unauthorized Biography (1989)
Superman Inc. (Elseworlds; 1999)
Superman: A Nation Divided (Elseworlds; 1999)
Superman: Up Up and Away! (2006)
Superman's Metropolis (Elseworlds; 1996)
Superman/Batman#81-84 ("Sorcerer Kings") (2011)
Superman/Supergirl: Maelstrom (#1-5; 2008)
War of the Supermen (#0, #1-4; 2010)
Trial of Superman (Superman (1987) #106-108; Adventures of Superman #529-531; Action Comics #716-717; Superman: The Man of Steel #50-52; Superman: The Man of Tomorrow #3; 1995-96)
Time and Time Again (Adventures of Superman #476-477; Action Comics #663-664; Superman (1987) #54-55; 1991)

11 years ago

DonFelipe

2373

Forum Posts

129833

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 8

#65 Edited By DonFelipe

@ThePoet Here's the 3 nomination reasons you've been waiting for:

Superman/Batman #81-84 ("Sorcerer Kings") (2011)
Our 2 favorite heroes in a story of magic and time travel! Medieval Batman from the future recruits current day Superman to help him correct the time line while current day Batman searches for Superman with the help of Shadowpact (Detective Chimp, Phantom Stranger, Ragman, etc.) and the JLA of the future. Besides the actual story, the appearance of all the different mystical and dark characters (and versions of some of them) makes this an interesting read and with great artwork.
Superman/Supergirl: Maelstrom (#1-5; 2008)
This story may not be one of the biggest Superman stories but I do like it for many different reasons nonetheless: First of all, I'm a fan of Phil Noto and his style works well for Superman & Supergirl, too. Beyond that, this is a 5-part mini-series about relationships - a slave (Maelstroem) following in love with Doomsday, Doomsday not sharing the love but trying to use it for his purposes (he's also quite sarcastic and funny in this one!), and last not least the relationship between Superman & Supergirl, who try to solve some issues during a "camping trip" to a weird planet where they have to survive without their superpowers. It's an unusual Superman story.

War of the Supermen (#0, #1-4; 2010)
One can argue there's too much action and too many characters involved on less than 100 pages. It's definitely not easy to keep track with all the action. However, it's a story about the Superman family protecting their adopted home, as they choose to defend Earth and fight against their own people, the Kryptonians led by General Zod. This 4-part mini-series is the conclusion to the New Krypton arc and comes with brilliant artwork and a great message (Lois' memo) at the very end; excerpt: 'Someday I hope humankind will be more receptive to change, to living as a "melting pot" of people and cultures. To set aside suspicions and live together peacefully. [...] Sometimes that seems to be an impossible goal.'

11 years ago

Billy Batson

62296

Forum Posts

1287131

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 11

#66 Edited By Billy Batson

Cosigns:

Action Comics (1938) #775 ("What's so Funny about Truth, Justice and the American Way?")
All-Star Superman
Escape from Bizarro World
Hitman #34 ("Of Thee I sing")
Lex Luthor: Man of Steel
Lex Luthor: The Unauthorized Biography
Superman Vs. Muhammad Ali (1978)
Superman: Red Son
Superman: Tales of the Bizarro World (Adventure Comics #285-299)
Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow?
Superman Annual #11 (For the Man who has everything)

BB

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#67 Edited By The Poet Moderator

@Billy Batson: added

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#68 Edited By The Poet Moderator

Cosign Status:

SPOILER WARNING: Click here to reveal hidden content.

Action Comics (1938) #1 ("Superman! Champion of the Oppressed...") : 6 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus kfhrfdu_89_76k etragedy DonFelipe Lvenger Gambit1024

Action Comics (1938) #22-23 "Europe at War" : 2 Cosign(s): etragedy Lvenger

Action Comics (1938) #285 ("The World's Greatest Heroine!") : 1 Cosign(s): ngroove

Action Comics (1938) #432 ("Target of the Toymen!") : 1 Cosign(s): ngroove

Action Comics (1938) #484 ("Superman Takes a Wife") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Action Comics (1938) #500 ("The Life Story of Superman") : 1 Cosign(s): ngroove

Action Comics (1938) #554 ("'If Superman Didn't Exist...'") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Action Comics (1938) #761 ("For A Thousand Tears") : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Action Comics (1938) #775 ("What's so Funny about Truth, Justice and the American Way?") : 6 Cosign(s): Squalleon kfhrfdu_89_76k The_Tree Lvenger Gambit1024 Billy Batson

Action Comics (1938) #865 ("Terrible Toyman") : 2 Cosign(s): sethysquare kfhrfdu_89_76k

Action Comics (2011) #13 : 3 Cosign(s): Gambit1,024 kfhrfdu_89_76k The_Tree

Action Comics Annual #1 ("Skeeter") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Adventures of Superman Annual #7 ("Truth and Justice") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

All-Star Superman : 12 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries Squalleon Moonchilde ENGLENTINE chalkshark The_Tree Mucklefluga GunGunW Lvenger sethysquare Gambit1024 Billy Batson

Batman/Superman/Wonder Woman: Trinity (#1-3; 2003) : 3 Cosign(s): DonFelipe Lvenger Skewer

Brainiac : 8 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries guttridgeb kfhrfdu_89_76k The_Tree Lvenger sethysquare Gambit1024

Christmas With The Super-Heroes #2 ("Ex-Machina") : 1 Cosign(s): Chalkshark

DC Comics Presents #29 ('Where No Superman Has Gone Before'") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

DC Comics Presents #81 ("All This and Kobra Too!") : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_ 1

DC Comics Presents #85 ("The Jungle Line") : 1 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1

DC Comics Presents #87 ("Year of the Comet") : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_ 1

DC One Million : 2 Cosign(s): Squalleon The_Tree

Death of Superman : 6 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus ckuakini ENGLENTINE The_Tree Lvenger Gambit1024

Emperor Joker : 2 Cosign(s): Squalleon Lvenger

Escape from Bizarro World : 2 Cosign(s): Dracade102 Billy Batson

Final Crisis : 4 Cosign(s): The_ Tree ckuakini tomlikesfries Gambit1024

Final Crisis: Superman Beyond 3D : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Flashpoint: Project Superman : 1 Cosign(s): Delphic

Grounded : 1 Cosign(s): ckuakini

H'el on Earth : 3 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1 ckuakini The_Tree

Hitman #34 ("Of Thee I sing") : 4 Cosign(s): Squalleon kfhrfdu_89_76k Lvenger Billy Batson

Infinite Crisis : 4 Cosign(s): Delphic The_Tree Lvenger Gambit1024

JLA: Liberty and Justice : 2 Cosign(s): Gambit1,024 Lvenger

JLA: The Nail : 2 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe Lvenger

Justice League of America: The Lightning Saga : 3 Cosign(s): GunGunW Strafe Prower ckuakini

Justice Society of America: Thy Kingdom Come : 1 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1

K (Superman/Batman #44-9) : 1 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus

Kingdom Come : 11 Cosign(s): Squalleon etragedy ckuakini Moonchilde ENGLENTINE tomlikesfries chalkshark Lvenger sethysquare Skewer Gambit1024

Last Stand of New Krypton : 2 Cosign(s): Eternal19 The_Tree

Lex Luthor: Man of Steel : 5 Cosign(s): The_ Tree kfhrfdu_89_76k DonFelipe Lvenger Billy Batson

Lex Luthor: The Unauthorized Biography (1989) : 4 Cosign(s): DonFelipe kfhrfdu_89_76k ENGLENTINE Billy Batson

New Krypton : 3 Cosign(s): Eternal19 The_Tree Lvenger

Reign of Doomday : 4 Cosign(s): Z3RO180 Strafe Prower The_Tree Lvenger

Sinestro Corps War : 1 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1

Starman #75 ("Sons And Fathers") : 1 Cosign(s): Chalkshark

Superboy (1994) #59 ("Mission to Krypton") : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_

Superboy (1994) #60-65 Hyper-Tension! : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_ 1

Superboy: Incubation (2011 Superboy #1-8) : 1 Cosign(s): sethysquare

Superboy: The Boy of Steel (2010 ADVENTURE COMICS #0-3 and 5-6) : 1 Cosign(s): The_ Tree

Supergirl (1982) #13 : 1 Cosign(s): ngroove

Supergirl Last Daughter of Krypton (Supergirl 2011 #1-7) : 1 Cosign(s): sethysquare

Supergirl Many Happy Returns (Supergirl #75-80) : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_ 1

Supergirl Saga : 1 Cosign(s): Dracade102

Supergirl: Power (Supergirl 2005 #0-5) : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Superman (1939) #156 ("The Last Days of Superman") : 1 Cosign(s): GunGunW

Superman (1939) #165 ("The Sweetheart Superman Forgot") : 2 Cosign(s): etragedy kfhrfdu_89_76k

Superman (1939) #662 ("Secrets in the Night") : 1 Cosign(s): Delphic

Superman (1939) #676 ("Memorial Day") : 1 Cosign(s): Gambit1024

Superman (1939) #1 ("Detective Sergant Blake") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Superman (1939) #129 ("The Girl in Superman's Past") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Superman (1939) #141 ("Superman Returns Too Krypton!") : 2 Cosign(s): Sandman_ kfhrfdu_89_76k

Superman (1939) #166 ("The Sons of Superman!") : 1 Cosign(s): ckuakini

Superman (1939) #167 ("The Deadly Duo") : 1 Cosign(s): ngroove

SUPERMAN (1939) #174 ("Super-Mxyzptlk....Hero!") : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Superman (1939) #2 ("Superman Champions Universal Peace!") : 2 Cosign(s): etragedy kfhrfdu_89_76k

Superman (1939) #247 ("Must there be a Superman?") : 3 Cosign(s): etragedy Squalleon Lvenger

Superman (1939) #249 ("The Challenge of Terra-Man") : 1 Cosign(s): ngroove

Superman (1939) #270 ('I Can't Go Home Again') : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Superman (1939) #287 ("Who Was That Dog I've Seen You With Last Night?") : 1 Cosign(s): ngroove

Superman (1939) #292 ("The Luthor Nobody Knows") : 1 Cosign(s): ngroove

Superman (1939) #310 ("The Killer With The Kryptonite Heart!") : 1 Cosign(s): ngroove

Superman (1939) #38 ('The Battle of the Atoms') : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Superman (1939) #4 ("Challenge of Luthor") : 4 Cosign(s): jonEsherfey kfhrfdu_89_76k etragedy 2

Superman (1939) #408 ('The Day the Earth Died') : 3 Cosign(s): etragedy chalkshark Lvenger

Superman (1939) #505 ("Reign of the Superman") : 4 Cosign(s): GunGunW ckuakini ENGLENTINE Lvenger

Superman (1939) #53 ("The Origin of Superman") : 2 Cosign(s): etragedy Lvenger

Superman (1939) #64- "Metropolis Mailbag" : 1 Cosign(s): Chalkshark

Superman (1939) #712 ("Lost Boy, A Tale of Krypto the Superdog") : 2 Cosign(s): Gambit1,024 chalkshark

Superman (1939) #88 ("The Terrible Trio!") : 1 Cosign(s): ngroove

Superman (1987) #2 ("the Secret Revealed") : 1 Cosign(s): ckuakini

Superman (1987) #50 ("The Human Factor") : 1 Cosign(s): ngroove

Superman 80-Page Giant 2011 #1 'Quarter-life Crisis of Infinite Jimmy Olsens' : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Superman Adventures #25 : 2 Cosign(s): kfhrfdu_89_76k Skewer

Superman Adventures #41 : 2 Cosign(s): Squalleon Skewer

Superman and The legion Of Superheroes : 4 Cosign(s): Sandman_ The_Tree sethysquare Skewer

Superman and the Men of steel. ( 2011 Action Comics #1-8) : 5 Cosign(s): Sandman_ guttridgeb The_Tree Lvenger sethysquare

Superman Annual #11 (For the Man who has everything) : 11 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus Squalleon etragedy RazzaTazz kfhrfdu_89_76k DonFelipe The_Tree Lvenger Skewer Gambit1024 Billy Batson

Superman Annual #2 ('Loves Labors... "Private Lives"') : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Superman Annual #6 ("The Feral Man of Steel") : 1 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe

Superman Beyond #1-8 : 2 Cosign(s): Icon Skewer

Superman Confidential #'s1-5 & 11 ("Kryptonite") : 2 Cosign(s): Chalkshark GunGunW

Superman Family (2012) #1 : 2 Cosign(s): Icon The_Tree

Superman for All Seasons : 7 Cosign(s): Squalleon etragedy kfhrfdu_89_76k chalkshark The_Tree Lvenger Skewer

Superman Inc (Elseworlds; 1999) : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

Superman The Coming Of Atlas (SUPERMAN #677-680 and DC 1st Issue Special #1) : 2 Cosign(s): Sandman_ The_Tree

Superman vs. Aliens : 1 Cosign(s): Z3RO180

Superman Vs. Muhammad Ali (1978) : 5 Cosign(s): Z3RO180 The_Tree Mucklefluga Lvenger Billy Batson

Superman vs. the Amazing Spider-Man : 3 Cosign(s): sinestro_GL wmwadeii Lvenger

Superman: A Nation Divided (Elseworlds; 1999) : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

Superman: Birthright : 6 Cosign(s): Sandman_ DonFelipe The_Tree Lvenger Skewer Gambit1024

Superman: Camelot Falls (2007) : 3 Cosign(s): jonEsherfey xxxddd kfhrfdu_89_76k

Superman: Earth One (Volume 1) : 4 Cosign(s): Icon ckuakini The_Tree Gambit1024

Superman: Earth One (Volume 2) : 2 Cosign(s): sethysquare Gambit1024

Superman: Ending Battle : 2 Cosign(s): Dracade102 kfhrfdu_89_76k

Superman: Exile : 1 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus

Superman: For Tomorrow : 7 Cosign(s): Icon xxxddd RazzaTazz Moonchilde kfhrfdu_89_76k The_Tree Lvenger

Superman: Godfall : 2 Cosign(s): Sandman_ The_Tree

SUPERMAN: KRYPTONITE NEVERMORE : 2 Cosign(s): Squalleon etragedy

Superman: Last Son (2009) : 3 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries The_Tree Skewer

Superman: Last Son of Earth (2000) : 1 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe

Superman: Peace on Earth : 3 Cosign(s): Gambit1,024 chalkshark Lvenger

Superman: President Lex (2010) : 2 Cosign(s): sethysquare Lvenger

Superman: Red Son : 10 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries Squalleon Moonchilde DonFelipe The_Tree Lvenger sethysquare Skewer Gambit1024 Billy Batson

Superman: Secret Identity : 3 Cosign(s): The_ Tree kfhrfdu_89_76k Lvenger

Superman: Secret Origin (2009) : 5 Cosign(s): GunGunW The_Tree Lvenger sethysquare Skewer

Superman: Speeding Bullets (1993) : 3 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe ENGLENTINE Lvenger

Superman: Tales of the Bizarro World (Adventure Comics #285-299) : 2 Cosign(s): Dracade102 Billy Batson

Superman: The Black Ring ( Action Comics #890-900, Action Comics Annual #13 and Secret Six #29) : 4 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries kfhrfdu_89_76k DonFelipe The_Tree

Superman: The Dark Side (1998) : 1 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe

Superman: The Journey (Superman #117, 121-125, Action Comics #83) : 1 Cosign(s): xxxddd

Superman: The Last Family of Krypton (2010) : 1 Cosign(s): Delphic

Superman: The Wedding Album : 2 Cosign(s): Delphic The_Tree

Superman: Up Up and Away! (2006) : 2 Cosign(s): DonFelipe The_Tree

Superman: World Without a Superman : 1 Cosign(s): Icon

Superman's Girl Friend, Lois Lane #106 ('I Am Curious (Black)!') : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Superman's Metropolis (Elseworlds; 1996) : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

Superman's Pal Jimmy Olsen #24 "The Gorilla Reporter" : 1 Cosign(s): Z3RO180

Superman/Batman #81-84 ("Sorcerer Kings") : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

Superman/Batman: Absolute Power (Superman/Batman #14-18) : 3 Cosign(s): xxxddd The_Tree Lvenger

Superman/Batman: Finest Worlds (SUPERMAN/BATMAN #50-56) : 3 Cosign(s): GunGunW The_Tree Lvenger

Superman/Batman: Public Enemies ( Superman/Batman #1-6) : 4 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1 tomlikesfries Lvenger Gambit1024

Superman/Fantastic four (1999) : 2 Cosign(s): Z3RO180 kfhrfdu_89_76k

Superman/Shazam: First Thunder (2006) : 1 Cosign(s): The_ Tree

Superman/Supergirl: Maelstrom : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

The Dark Knight Returns : 2 Cosign(s): etragedy kfhrfdu_89_76k

The Greatest Hero of Them All : 1 Cosign(s): ckuakini

The Man of Steel (1986) : 5 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus etragedy ckuakini DonFelipe Gambit1024

The Supergirl from Krypton (Superman/Batman #8-13) : 2 Cosign(s): Squalleon sethysquare

The Trial of Superman : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

Time and Time Again : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

War of the Supermen : 2 Cosign(s): DonFelipe The_Tree

Wednesday Comics : 2 Cosign(s): Chalkshark kfhrfdu_89_76k

Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow? : 9 Cosign(s): Sandman_ Squalleon etragedy kfhrfdu_89_76k DonFelipe The_Tree Lvenger Billy Batson

World of New Krypton : 2 Cosign(s): Dracade102 The_Tree

World's Finest #68 ('The Menace from the Stars') : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

World's Finest #75 ('The New Team of Superman and Robin' ) : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Current top 12:

All-Star Superman : 12 Cosign(s):
Kingdom Come : 11 Cosign(s):
Superman Annual #11 (For the Man who has everything) : 11 Cosign(s):
Superman: Red Son : 10 Cosign(s):
Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow? : 9 Cosign(s):
Brainiac : 8 Cosign(s):
Superman for All Seasons : 7 Cosign(s):
Superman: For Tomorrow : 7 Cosign(s):
Action Comics (1938) #1 ("Superman! Champion of the Oppressed...") : 6 Cosign(s):
Action Comics (1938) #775 ("What's so Funny about Truth, Justice and the American Way?") : 6 Cosign(s):
Death of Superman : 6 Cosign(s):
Superman: Birthright : 6 Cosign(s):

Assignment Sheet:

@jonEsherfey I need 2 nomination reasons:

Superman (1939) #4 ("Challenge of Luthor")
Superman: Camelot Falls (2007)

@ngroove I need 11 nomination reasons:

Action Comics (1938) #285 ("The World's Greatest Heroine!")
Action Comics (1938) #432 ("Target of the Toymen!")
Action Comics (1938) #500 ("The Life Story of Superman")
Supergirl (1982) #13
Superman (1939) #167 ("The Deadly Duo")
Superman (1939) #249 ("The Challenge of Terra-Man")
Superman (1939) #287 ("Who Was That Dog I've Seen You With Last Night?")
Superman (1939) #292 ("The Luthor Nobody Knows")
Superman (1939) #310 ("The Killer With The Kryptonite Heart!")
Superman (1939) #88 ("The Terrible Trio!")
Superman (1987) #50 ("The Human Factor")

@SandMan_ I need 1 nomination reason:

DC Comics Presents #81 ("All This and Kobra Too!")

@xxxddd I need 1 nomination reason:

Superman: The Journey (Superman #117, 121-125, Action Comics #83)

11 years ago

ngroove

327

Forum Posts

268

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#69 Edited By ngroove

Action Comics (1938) #285 ("The World's Greatest Heroine!")

Supergirl, previously hidden-ly used as "Superman's Secret Weapon", is finally revealed out in public, in a grand celebration. Added with suspenseful, exciting super-challenges for her, such as battling the "Infinite Monster".

Action Comics (1938) #432 ("Target of the Toymen!")

Featuring two warring Toymen, Winslow Schott, and Jack Nimball (the one chosen to be in that "Challenge of the Superfriends" show).

Action Comics (1938) #500 ("The Life Story of Superman")

A giant-sized issue, recalling everything you need to know about Superman - Krypton, Superbaby, Superboy, Smallvile, Metropolis, Krypto, Supergirl, even his greatest loves, and a few of his dastardly enemies, one of them (not so surprisingly "guess who"?) behind the entire plot, involving a Superman Museum, throughout the issue.

Supergirl (1982) #13-15

An exciting "new costume" for Supergirl, the kinda "rejected" costume for the Helen Slater movie, but nevertheless, a spectacular new costume! Read as Supergirl takes on her worst foe yet, BlackStarr

Superman (1939) #167 ("The Deadly Duo")

Superman against two of his very worst enemies, Luthor and Brainiac, in their first of many feuds against him as a duo! Also featuring Lexor, Ardora, the sometimes-used woman who would be Mrs. Lex Luthor, and the revelation that Brainiac is from a "him" to an "it", a computer!

Superman (1939) #249 ("The Challenge of Terra-Man")

First appearance of Terra-Man, of course, classic recurring Super-foe of the 70s-mid 80s, Regarded a joke to many modern fans after that, but nevertheless, still fond to those who digs him fondly, for being that space cowboy.

Superman (1939) #287 ("Who Was That Dog I've Seen You With Last Night?")

A Krypto-centered tale, in which he falls in love! A tender yet with a twist, that the dog of his affections, rejects him, because he's too "Super" a dog, not "normal".

Superman (1939) #292 ("The Luthor Nobody Knows")

SERIOUSLY, I GENIUNELY CANNOT BELIEVE this has not been elected / cosigned yet! A classic by Elliot S. Maggin! in the Bronze Age, incorporating a previous Silver Age story, while making it its own! A penultimate story chronicling, along with a flashback from their very start, as friends, Lex Luthor's relationship with Clark Kent / Superboy / Superman, as a mischievous friend with test tubes, to young nuisance, to perpetual enemy!

Superman (1939) #310 ("The Killer With The Kryptonite Heart!")

The first appearance of the second, but first recurring, throughout the Bronze and Copper ages, Metallo, Roger Corben! Guest-threatening SKULL!

Superman (1939) #88 ("The Terrible Trio!")

Superman against Golden Age Arch-enemies Toyman, Prankster, and Luthor!

Superman (1987) #50 ("The Human Factor")

May be part 4 of "Krisis of the Krimson Kryptonite", which, for the most part, is just another Superman feud against Lex Luthor and Mister Mxyzptlk, but my opinion, most notable, most important, most crucial, perhaps even touching, part, and it may be just a side-part of the tale! It is the issue, six years before it would finally happen, perhaps even goaded by "Lois & Clark: the New Adventures of Superman", which all would be the climax of a 50+ years of courtship between the two, even if only for fifteen years; Clark Kent and Lois Lane becomes engaged, towards the path to marriage!

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#70 Edited By The Poet Moderator

@ngroove: added! thanks so much!

I'll add my cosign to Superman (1939) #292 ("The Luthor Nobody Knows") even though admittedly I have not read it because your reason seem very passionate and I love seeing that sort of passion in this list...

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#71 Edited By The Poet Moderator

like I said before: Final few hours to nominate anything additional

Then tomorrow will be the final day to cosign anything, so remember to cosign!

Cosigns can change the order! They make the initial order of the list and can make a story higher on the list if just by 1 pt! I'm not going to call out people in this step to cosign or anything so anyone who does does. Your choice to cosign. Been open a week so we'll have to move on Tuesday for the Final Order Voting (which I WILL annoy people about...)

11 years ago

ngroove

327

Forum Posts

268

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#72 Edited By ngroove

Thanks a lot!

Another Co-Sign: Lois Lane 106: this story set in the days when there was "white" neighborhoods and "black" neighborhoods, racial disharmonies as a result from ages of racism still ran rampant, based on color of skin. An inspiring tale, with Lois Lane, walking in the skin of an African American, to spend a day in a local black neighborhood, eventually choosing to transfusing her blood with a man most vigilant, previously against her when she was still white. Only after her skin re-reverted itself at the last minute, he saw, recognized her, finally having smiling, and realize, while holding her hand, that in the inside, all people are the same.

11 years ago

Strafe Prower

13013

Forum Posts

76113

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 16

#73 Edited By Strafe Prower

I'll co-sign Final Crisis and Sinestro Corps War.

11 years ago

NewKid

410

Forum Posts

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#74 Edited By NewKid

co-signs -

All-Star Superman

Superman For All Seasons

Lex Luthor: Man Of Steel

For The Man Who Has Everything

Red Son

Superman and the Men of Steel

Action Comics (1938) #775 ("What's so Funny about Truth, Justice and the American Way?")

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#75 Edited By The Poet Moderator

@ngroove: @Strafe Prower: added

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#76 Edited By The Poet Moderator

@NewKid: added!

Cosign stat:

SPOILER WARNING: Click here to reveal hidden content.

Action Comics (1938) #1 ("Superman! Champion of the Oppressed...") : 7 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus kfhrfdu_89_76k etragedy DonFelipe Lvenger Gambit1024 The Poet

Action Comics (1938) #22-23 "Europe at War" : 2 Cosign(s): etragedy Lvenger

Action Comics (1938) #285 ("The World's Greatest Heroine!") : 1 Cosign(s): ngroove

Action Comics (1938) #432 ("Target of the Toymen!") : 1 Cosign(s): ngroove

Action Comics (1938) #484 ("Superman Takes a Wife") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Action Comics (1938) #500 ("The Life Story of Superman") : 1 Cosign(s): ngroove

Action Comics (1938) #554 ("'If Superman Didn't Exist...'") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Action Comics (1938) #761 ("For A Thousand Tears") : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Action Comics (1938) #775 ("What's so Funny about Truth, Justice and the American Way?") : 7 Cosign(s): Squalleon kfhrfdu_89_76k The_Tree Lvenger Gambit1024 Billy Batson NewKid

Action Comics (1938) #865 ("Terrible Toyman") : 2 Cosign(s): sethysquare kfhrfdu_89_76k

Action Comics (2011) #13 : 3 Cosign(s): Gambit1,024 kfhrfdu_89_76k The_Tree

Action Comics Annual #1 ("Skeeter") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Adventures of Superman Annual #7 ("Truth and Justice") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

All-Star Superman : 13 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries Squalleon Moonchilde ENGLENTINE chalkshark The_Tree Mucklefluga GunGunW Lvenger sethysquare Gambit1024 Billy Batson NewKid

Batman/Superman/Wonder Woman: Trinity (#1-3; 2003) : 4 Cosign(s): DonFelipe Lvenger Skewer The Poet

Brainiac : 8 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries guttridgeb kfhrfdu_89_76k The_Tree Lvenger sethysquare Gambit1024

Christmas With The Super-Heroes #2 ("Ex-Machina") : 1 Cosign(s): Chalkshark

DC Comics Presents #29 ('Where No Superman Has Gone Before'") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

DC Comics Presents #81 ("All This and Kobra Too!") : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_ 1

DC Comics Presents #85 ("The Jungle Line") : 1 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1

DC Comics Presents #87 ("Year of the Comet") : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_ 1

DC One Million : 2 Cosign(s): Squalleon The_Tree

Death of Superman : 7 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus ckuakini ENGLENTINE The_Tree Lvenger Gambit1024 The Poet

Emperor Joker : 3 Cosign(s): Squalleon Lvenger The Poet

Escape from Bizarro World : 3 Cosign(s): Dracade102 Billy Batson The Poet

Final Crisis : 6 Cosign(s): The_ Tree ckuakini tomlikesfries Gambit1024 Strafe Prower The Poet

Final Crisis: Superman Beyond 3D : 2 Cosign(s): Squalleon The Poet

Flashpoint: Project Superman : 1 Cosign(s): Delphic

Grounded : 1 Cosign(s): ckuakini

H'el on Earth : 3 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1 ckuakini The_Tree

Hitman #34 ("Of Thee I sing") : 4 Cosign(s): Squalleon kfhrfdu_89_76k Lvenger Billy Batson

Infinite Crisis : 5 Cosign(s): Delphic The_Tree Lvenger Gambit1024 The Poet

JLA: Liberty and Justice : 2 Cosign(s): Gambit1,024 Lvenger

JLA: The Nail : 2 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe Lvenger

Justice League of America: The Lightning Saga : 3 Cosign(s): GunGunW Strafe Prower ckuakini

Justice Society of America: Thy Kingdom Come : 1 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1

K (Superman/Batman #44-9) : 1 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus

Kingdom Come : 11 Cosign(s): Squalleon etragedy ckuakini Moonchilde ENGLENTINE tomlikesfries chalkshark Lvenger sethysquare Skewer Gambit1024

Last Stand of New Krypton : 2 Cosign(s): Eternal19 The_Tree

Lex Luthor: Man of Steel : 6 Cosign(s): The_ Tree kfhrfdu_89_76k DonFelipe Lvenger Billy Batson NewKid

Lex Luthor: The Unauthorized Biography (1989) : 4 Cosign(s): DonFelipe kfhrfdu_89_76k ENGLENTINE Billy Batson

New Krypton : 3 Cosign(s): Eternal19 The_Tree Lvenger

Reign of Doomday : 4 Cosign(s): Z3RO180 Strafe Prower The_Tree Lvenger

Sinestro Corps War : 2 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1 Strafe Prower