Comic Vine's Top 100 Superman Universe Stories: Community Step

78 results
1
2

This topic is locked from further discussion.

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

Edited By The Poet Moderator

Welcome to the Community Step of our Superman Stories List!

What We've done thus far:

SPOILER WARNING: Click here to reveal hidden content.

Comic Vine's Top 100 Superman Universe Stories: Sign-up

FIRST: we collected the initial nominators who included: chalkshark, ckuakini, Delphic, DonFelipe, Dracade102, Eternal19, etragedy, Gambit1024, GunGunW, Icon, joeagentofhand1, jonEsherfey, Joshmightbe, RedheadedAtrocitus, SandMan_, sethysquare, Squalleon, The_ Tree, tomlikesfries, and Z3RO180.

each nominated 5 stories to make a list of 100 stories.

NOW:

We are doing COMMUNITY NOMINATIONS, which is where everyone has the importunity to:

Nominate Stories that are missing (this includes individual issues, arcs, mini series with a focus on Superman or Superman related characters).

Nomination Requirements: Each story must have a page on comic vine AND you have to write 3+ sentences on why they should be on the list

or...

Co-sign Existing Characters (add you name to your favorite characters to add points to them!)

Community Nominations will end Sunday, January 13th and Cosigning will end Monday, January 14th, so get those cosigns/nominations in!

The List Thus Far:

Action Comics (1938) #1 ("Superman! Champion of the Oppressed...")
Action Comics (1938) #22-23 "Europe at War"
Action Comics (1938) #285 ("The World's Greatest Heroine!")
Action Comics (1938) #432 ("Target of the Toymen!")
Action Comics (1938) #484 ("Superman Takes a Wife")
Action Comics (1938) #500 ("The Life Story of Superman")
Action Comics (1938) #554 ("'If Superman Didn't Exist...'")
Action Comics (1938) #761 ("For A Thousand Tears")
Action Comics (1938) #775 ("What's so Funny about Truth, Justice and the American Way?")
Action Comics (1938) #865 ("Terrible Toyman")
Action Comics (2011) #13
Action Comics Annual #1 ("Skeeter")
Adventures of Superman Annual #7 ("Truth and Justice")
All-Star Superman
Batman/Superman/Wonder Woman: Trinity
Brainiac
Christmas With The Super-Heroes #2 ("Ex-Machina")
DC Comics Presents #29 ('Where No Superman Has Gone Before'")
DC Comics Presents #81 ("All This and Kobra Too!")
DC Comics Presents #85 ("The Jungle Line")
DC Comics Presents #87 ("Year of the Comet")
DC One Million
Death of Superman
Emperor Joker
Escape from Bizarro World
Final Crisis
Final Crisis: Superman Beyond 3D
Flashpoint: Project Superman
Grounded
H'el on Earth
Hitman #34 ("Of Thee I sing")
Infinite Crisis
JLA: Liberty and Justice
JLA: The Nail
Justice League of America: The Lightning Saga
Justice Society of America: Thy Kingdom Come
K (Superman/Batman #44-9)
Kingdom Come
Last Stand of New Krypton
Lex Luthor: Man of Steel
Lex Luthor: The Unauthorized Biography
New Krypton
Reign of Doomday
Sinestro Corps War
Starman #75 ("Sons And Fathers")
Superboy (1994) #59 ("Mission to Krypton")
Superboy (1994) #60-65 Hyper-Tension!
Superboy: Incubation (2011 Superboy #1-8)
Superboy: The Boy of Steel (2010 ADVENTURE COMICS #0-3 and 5-6)
Supergirl (1982) #13
Supergirl Last Daughter of Krypton (Supergirl 2011 #1-7)
Supergirl Many Happy Returns (Supergirl #75-80)
Supergirl Saga
Supergirl: Power (Supergirl 2005 #0-5)
Superman (1939) #156 ("The Last Days of Superman")
Superman (1939) #165 ("The Sweetheart Superman Forgot")
Superman (1939) #662 ("Secrets in the Night")
Superman (1939) #676 ("Memorial Day")
Superman (1939) #1 ("Detective Sergant Blake")
Superman (1939) #129 ("The Girl in Superman's Past")
Superman (1939) #141 ("Superman Returns Too Krypton!")
Superman (1939) #166 ("The Sons of Superman!")
Superman (1939) #167 ("The Deadly Duo")
SUPERMAN (1939) #174 ("Super-Mxyzptlk....Hero!")
Superman (1939) #2 ("Superman Champions Universal Peace!")
Superman (1939) #247 ("Must there be a Superman?")
Superman (1939) #249 ("The Challenge of Terra-Man")
Superman (1939) #270 ('I Can't Go Home Again')
Superman (1939) #287 ("Who Was That Dog I've Seen You With Last Night?")
Superman (1939) #292 ("The Luthor Nobody Knows")
Superman (1939) #310 ("The Killer With The Kryptonite Heart!")
Superman (1939) #38 ('The Battle of the Atoms')
Superman (1939) #4 ("Challenge of Luthor")
Superman (1939) #408 ('The Day the Earth Died')
Superman (1939) #505 ("Reign of the Superman")
Superman (1939) #53 ("The Origin of Superman")
Superman (1939) #64- "Metropolis Mailbag"
Superman (1939) #712 ("Lost Boy, A Tale of Krypto the Superdog")
Superman (1939) #88 ("The Terrible Trio!")
Superman (1987) #2 ("the Secret Revealed")
Superman (1987) #50 ("The Human Factor")
Superman 80-Page Giant 2011 #1 'Quarter-life Crisis of Infinite Jimmy Olsens'
Superman Adventures #25
Superman Adventures #41
Superman and The legion Of Superheroes
Superman and the Men of steel. ( 2011 Action Comics #1-8)
Superman Annual #11 (For the Man who has everything)
Superman Annual #2 ('Loves Labors... "Private Lives"')
Superman Annual #6 ("The Feral Man of Steel")
Superman Beyond #1-8
Superman Confidential #'s1-5 & 11 ("Kryptonite")
Superman Family (2012) #1
Superman for All Seasons
Superman Inc.
Superman The Coming Of Atlas (SUPERMAN #677-680 and DC 1st Issue Special #1)
Superman vs. Aliens
Superman Vs. Muhammad Ali (1978)
Superman vs. the Amazing Spider-Man
Superman: A Nation Divided
Superman: Birthright
Superman: Camelot Falls (2007)
Superman: Earth One (Volume 1)
Superman: Earth One (Volume 2)
Superman: Ending Battle
Superman: Exile
Superman: For Tomorrow
Superman: Godfall
SUPERMAN: KRYPTONITE NEVERMORE
Superman: Last Son (2009)
Superman: Last Son of Earth (2000)
Superman: Peace on Earth
Superman: President Lex (2010)
Superman: Red Son
Superman: Secret Identity
Superman: Secret Origin (2009)
Superman: Speeding Bullets (1993)
Superman: Tales of the Bizarro World (Adventure Comics #285-299)
Superman: The Black Ring ( Action Comics #890-900, Action Comics Annual #13 and Secret Six #29)
Superman: The Dark Side (1998)
Superman: The Journey (Superman #117, 121-125, Action Comics #83)
Superman: The Last Family of Krypton (2010)
Superman: The Wedding Album
Superman: Up Up and Away! (2006)
Superman: World Without a Superman
Superman's Girl Friend, Lois Lane #106 ('I Am Curious (Black)!')
Superman's Metropolis (1996)
Superman's Pal Jimmy Olsen #24 "The Gorilla Reporter"
Superman/Batman #81-84 ("Sorcerer Kings")
Superman/Batman: Absolute Power (Superman/Batman #14-18)
Superman/Batman: Finest Worlds (SUPERMAN/BATMAN #50-56)
Superman/Batman: Public Enemies ( Superman/Batman #1-6)
Superman/Fantastic four (1999)
Superman/Shazam: First Thunder (2006)
Superman/Supergirl: Maelstrom
The Dark Knight Returns
The Greatest Hero of Them All
The Man of Steel (1986)
The Supergirl from Krypton (Superman/Batman #8-13)
The Trial of Superman
Time and Time Again
War of the Supermen
Wednesday Comics
Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow?
World of New Krypton
World's Finest #68 ('The Menace from the Stars')
World's Finest #75 ('The New Team of Superman and Robin' )

11 years ago

Squalleon

9994

Forum Posts

3193

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 7

#1 Edited By Squalleon

How did we forget that one!

EMPEROR JOKER!

Its an entire Superman story arc with Joker as the most powerfull being of the universe!! Joker tricks Mxyzptlk into taking his powers!The world is going mad and Joker changed the fabric of reality completely!A great story that shows how brains beat brawns sometimes even when the brains can change the universe to their will!

@The Poet How do i cosign exactly?

CO-SIGNS

Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow? +1
All-Star Superman +1
Superman (1939) #247 ("Must there be a Superman?") +1
Superman: Red Son +1
Superman Annual #11 (For the Man who has everything) +1

Did i do it right?

11 years ago

DonFelipe

2373

Forum Posts

129833

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 8

#2 Edited By DonFelipe

3 more that should be in the mix:

Lex Luthor: The Unauthorized Biography #1

In the Unauthorized Biography, a journalist investigates the past of Lex Luthor, how he became this cruel and manipulative businessman, and tries to find a publisher for his revealing story. Soon he's under the radar of Luthor himself and ask the only person he can still trust, Clark Kent, for help. Though this story is not considered to be canon (anymore), it is still a great crime noir story.

Superman: A Nation Divided #1

Superman signs up to fight for the Union Army in the Civil War, unsure if he will ever make it out alive. This all changes from the moment on a cannonball hits him and bounces right back. Amusing Elseworlds story about Superman becoming America's greatest soldier of the Civil War.

Superman: Time and Time Again

An explosion accidentally throws Superman through time without control of where he's going, only further explosions will send him into another era. Superman finds himself send to different times in the past and future fighting T-Rex, the Nazis, joining a circus, and teaming up with several incarnations of the Legion of Superheroes. This is a great and funny story (arc) for fans of time travel.

11 years ago

GC8

2900

Forum Posts

78610

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 1422

User Lists: 8

#3 Edited By GC8

Five More

'The New Team of Superman and Robin' (World's Finest #75) - When Batman is injured, Superman steps in to take his place. A story that highlights the friendship between Kal El and Bruce Wayne.

'Loves Labors... "Private Lives"' (Superman Annual #2 '88) - This one isn't about Superman, but two of the supporting characters. When Barrage puts Dan Turpin in the hospital, he begins to reevaluate things, including his relationship with Captain Sawyer.

'I Am Curious (Black)!' (Superman's Girl Friend, Lois Lane #106) - Another one where the focus is not on Superman. In order to do a story on Metropolis' black community, Lois Lane has Superman use Dahr-Nel's Plastimold Machine in the Fortress of Solitude to transform her into a black woman. One of the things that makes this issue so great is the final page which contains no dialog whatsoever, but delivers the great sense of hope in the brotherhood of mankind that lies at the heart of the Superman series'.

'Where No Superman Has Gone Before' (DC Comics Presents #29) - In trying to stop Mongul's Warworld, Supergirl is catapulted beyond the natural barriers of the universe. Superman tries to rescue her, but The Spectre bars his way! This shows that even at his most powerful, Superman had his limits. No matter how powerful you are, there is always someone else more powerful than you.

'The Day the Earth Died' (Superman #408) - Sooner or later Superman was going to have to deal with the threat of nuclear war. Does he have the power to stop it? Should he?

11 years ago

GC8

2900

Forum Posts

78610

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 1422

User Lists: 8

#4 Edited By GC8

Oh... and also:

Batman: The Dark Knight Returns - I know what you're thinking. That's a Batman story! Well, true enough, but Superman also appears; and no other story better crystallizes the differences between Batman and Superman's approach to fighting crime.

Cosigns:

Superman for All Seasons +1
The Man of Steel +1
Kingdom Come +1
Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow? +1
Superman Annual #11 (For the Man who has everything) +1

11 years ago

SandMan_

4581

Forum Posts

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#5 Edited By SandMan_

Superman 141 Superman Returns Too Krypton!- In this classic story Superman finds a way to travel back in time lands on his own planet Krypton. Meeting his own parents and falling in love with the actress Lyla Lerrol. Superman was comfortable with his life there and was willing to die there when the planet would reach its end. Unfortunatly, fate has other plans.

11 years ago

Strafe Prower

13013

Forum Posts

76113

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 16

#6 Edited By Strafe Prower

I'll co-sightn The Lightning Saga and Reign of Doomsday

11 years ago

deactivated-5d921c81bd12c

4881

Forum Posts

322406

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 7

User Lists: 3

#7 Edited By deactivated-5d921c81bd12c

I'd like to cosign Brainiac and Superman and the Men of Steel.

11 years ago

xxxddd

3861

Forum Posts

29703

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 14

#8 Edited By xxxddd

@The Poet: Sorry if I missed this,

but Superman/Batman Absolute Power(the non canon story), Superman: For Tomorrow, Superman: Camelot Falls, and Superman: The Journey are all good reads.

11 years ago

Raw_Material

3553

Forum Posts

9505

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 25

User Lists: 9

#9 Edited By Raw_Material

Co-Signing +points

Superman: Earth One +1
Death of Superman +1
Kingdom Come +1
The Man of Steel +1
Final Crisis +1
The Greatest Hero of Them All +1
He'l on Earth +1
Reign of the Superman +1
Justice League of America: The Lightning Saga +1

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#10 Edited By The Poet Moderator

@Squalleon: added. Yep. that's great. All you have to do is take the list of stories (shown above) and name your favorates. Don't even have to type "+1" if you don't want to. Of course you'll be automatically cosigning your own story (you can see the spreadsheet in seeing in how I am collecting cosigns...

@etragedy: @SandMan_: @Strafe Prower: added

@guttridgeb: added

@xxxddd: oh you are right on time!

added you as a cosigner for: Superman: For Tomorrow, Superman: Camelot Falls

Since Superman/Batman Absolute Power and Superman: The Journey haven't been nominated yet, can you write 3 or more sentences for each of them on why they should be nominated? (sort of like above ones)

11 years ago

Squalleon

9994

Forum Posts

3193

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 7

#11 Edited By Squalleon

@The Poet: We Broke the 100 story barrier :'-)

yeah we will get a top 100 after all!

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#12 Edited By The Poet Moderator

@ckuakini: added.

remember you can't cosign the stories you nominated (you are automatically cosigning a story). there was only one story you tried to cosign that you had nominated, but I thought I should mention this fact for other people to...

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#13 Edited By The Poet Moderator

@Squalleon said:

@The Poet: We Broke the 100 story barrier :'-)
yeah we will get a top 100 after all!

I figured we would be able too as soon as Primm mentioned he had 20 or so stories he wanted to nominate...

We are at 112 now and I haven't added Primm's stories he sent via pm (15 stories and we'll beat Batman's total story amount..)

11 years ago

Squalleon

9994

Forum Posts

3193

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 7

#14 Edited By Squalleon

@The Poet:

Also Add Final Crisis : Superman Beyond

"To save the woman he loves, the greatest hero of all time becomes the pawn of ultra-dimensional forces when a wounded emissary from a world of doomed super gods comes to Earth on the eve of the Final Crisis! Superman Beyond features Supermans from parallel earths and 3D comic format which makes it quite unique and enjoyable "

11 years ago

RazzaTazz

11948

Forum Posts

234582

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 1887

User Lists: 79

#15 Edited By RazzaTazz

I will co sign these.
Superman Annual #11 (For the Man who has everything)
Superman: For Tomorrow

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#16 Edited By The Poet Moderator

@Squalleon: @RazzaTazz: added! We have 118! :D

11 years ago

SandMan_

4581

Forum Posts

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#17 Edited By SandMan_

More!

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#18 Edited By The Poet Moderator

Now to post the cosign totals:

SPOILER WARNING: Click here to reveal hidden content.

Action Comics (1938) #1 : 1 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus
Action Comics (1938) #554 ("'If Superman Didn't Exist...'") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy
Action Comics (1938) #775 ("What's so Funny about Truth, Justice and the American Way?") : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon
Action Comics (1938) #865 ("Terrible Toyman") : 1 Cosign(s): sethysquare
Action Comics (2011) #13 : 1 Cosign(s): Gambit1,024
Adventures of Superman Annual #7 ("Truth and Justice") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy
All-Star Superman : 2 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries Squalleon
Batman/Superman/Wonder Woman: Trinity : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe
Brainiac : 2 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries guttridgeb
Christmas With The Super-Heroes #2 ("Ex-Machina") : 1 Cosign(s): Chalkshark
DC Comics Presents #29 ('Where No Superman Has Gone Before'") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy
DC Comics Presents #81 ("All This and Kobra Too!") : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_
DC Comics Presents #85 ("The Jungle Line") : 1 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1
DC Comics Presents #87 ("Year of the Comet") : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_
Death of Superman : 2 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus ckuakini
Emperor Joker : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon
Escape from Bizarro World : 1 Cosign(s): Dracade102
Final Crisis : 2 Cosign(s): The_ Tree ckuakini
Final Crisis: Superman Beyond 3D : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon
Flashpoint: Project Superman : 1 Cosign(s): Delphic
Grounded : 1 Cosign(s): ckuakini
H'el on Earth : 2 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1 ckuakini
Hitman #34 ("Of Thee I sing") : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon
Infinite Crisis : 1 Cosign(s): Delphic
JLA: Liberty and Justice : 1 Cosign(s): Gambit1,024
JLA: The Nail : 1 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe
Justice League of America: The Lightning Saga : 3 Cosign(s): GunGunW Strafe Prower ckuakini
Justice Society of America: Thy Kindom Come : 1 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1
K (Superman/Batman #44-9) : 1 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus
Kingdom Come : 3 Cosign(s): Squalleon etragedy ckuakini
Last Stand of New Krypton : 1 Cosign(s): Eternal19
Lex Luthor: Man of Steel : 1 Cosign(s): The_ Tree
Lex Luthor: The Unauthorized Biography : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe
New Krypton : 1 Cosign(s): Eternal19
Reign of Doomday : 2 Cosign(s): Z3RO180 Strafe Prower
Sinestro Corps War : 1 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1
Starman #75 ("Sons And Fathers") : 1 Cosign(s): Chalkshark
Superboy (1994) #59 ("Mission to Krypton") : 1 Cosign(s):
Superboy (1994) #60-65 Hyper-Tension! : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_
Superboy: Incubation (2011 Superboy #1-8) : 1 Cosign(s): sethysquare
Superboy: The Boy of Steel (2010 ADVENTURE COMICS #0-3 and 5-6) : 1 Cosign(s): The_ Tree
Supergirl Last Daughter of Krypton (Supergirl 2011 #1-7) : 1 Cosign(s): sethysquare
Supergirl Many Happy Returns (Supergirl #75-80) : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_
Supergirl Saga : 1 Cosign(s): Dracade102
Supergirl: Power (Supergirl 2005 #0-5) : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon
Superman (1939) #156 ("The Last Days of Superman") : 1 Cosign(s): GunGunW
Superman (1939) #165 ("The Sweetheart Superman Forgot") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy
Superman (1939) #662 ("Secrets in the Night") : 1 Cosign(s): Delphic
Superman (1939) #676 ("Memorial Day") : 1 Cosign(s): Gambit1024
Superman (1939) #141 ("Superman Returns Too Krypton!") : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_
Superman (1939) #166 ("The Sons of Superman!") : 1 Cosign(s): ckuakini
SUPERMAN (1939) #174 ("Super-Mxyzptlk....Hero!") : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon
Superman (1939) #2 ("Superman Champions Universal Peace!") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy
Superman (1939) #247 ("Must there be a Superman?") : 2 Cosign(s): etragedy Squalleon
Superman (1939) #4 ("Challenge of Luthor") : 1 Cosign(s): jonEsherfey
Superman (1939) #505 ("Reign of the Superman") : 2 Cosign(s): GunGunW ckuakini
Superman (1987) #2 ("the Secret Revealed") : 1 Cosign(s): ckuakini
Superman #408 ('The Day the Earth Died') : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy
Superman #64- "Metropolis Mailbag" : 1 Cosign(s): Chalkshark
Superman #712 ("Lost Boy, A Tale of Krypto the Superdog") : 1 Cosign(s): Gambit1,024
Superman 80-Page Giant 2011 #1 'Quarter-life Crisis of Infinite Jimmy Olsens' : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon
Superman Adventures #41 : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon
Superman and The legion Of Superheroes : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_
Superman and the Men of steel. ( 2011 Action Comics #1-8) : 2 Cosign(s): Sandman_ guttridgeb
Superman Annual #11 (For the Man who has everything) : 4 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus Squalleon etragedy RazzaTazz
Superman Annual #2 ('Loves Labors... "Private Lives"') : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy
Superman Annual #6 ("The Feral Man of Steel") : 1 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe
Superman Beyond : 1 Cosign(s): Icon
Superman Confidential #'s1-5 & 11 ("Kryptonite") : 1 Cosign(s): Chalkshark
Superman Family (2012) : 1 Cosign(s): Icon
Superman for All Seasons : 2 Cosign(s): Squalleon etragedy
Superman Inc. : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe
Superman The Coming Of Atlas (SUPERMAN #677-680 and DC 1st Issue Special #1) : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_
Superman vs. Aliens : 1 Cosign(s): Z3RO180
Superman Vs. Muhammad Ali (1978) : 1 Cosign(s): Z3RO180
Superman: A Nation Divided : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe
Superman: Birthright : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_
Superman: Camelot Falls (2007) : 2 Cosign(s): jonEsherfey xxxddd
Superman: Earth One : 2 Cosign(s): Icon ckuakini
Superman: Earth One : 1 Cosign(s): sethysquare
Superman: Ending Battle : 1 Cosign(s): Dracade102
Superman: Exile : 1 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus
Superman: For Tomorrow : 3 Cosign(s): Icon xxxddd RazzaTazz
Superman: Godfall : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_
SUPERMAN: KRYPTONITE NEVERMORE : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon
Superman: Last Son (2009) : 1 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries
Superman: Last Son of Earth (2000) : 1 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe
Superman: Peace on Earth : 1 Cosign(s): Gambit1,024
Superman: President Lex (2010) : 1 Cosign(s): sethysquare
Superman: Red Son : 2 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries Squalleon
Superman: Secret Identity : 1 Cosign(s): The_ Tree
Superman: Secret Origin (2009) : 1 Cosign(s): GunGunW
Superman: Speeding Bullets (1993) : 1 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe
Superman: Tales of the Bizarro World (Adventure Comics #285-299) : 1 Cosign(s): Dracade102
Superman: The Black Ring ( Action Comics #890-900, Action Comics Annual #13 and Secret Six #29) : 1 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries
Superman: The Dark Side (1998) : 1 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe
Superman: The Journey (Superman #117, 121-125, Action Comics #83) : 1 Cosign(s): xxxddd
Superman: The Last Family of Krypton (2010) : 1 Cosign(s): Delphic
Superman: The Wedding Album : 1 Cosign(s): Delphic
Superman: Up Up and Away! (2006) : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe
Superman: World Without a Superman : 1 Cosign(s): Icon
Superman's Girl Friend, Lois Lane #106 ('I Am Curious (Black)!') : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy
Superman's Metropolis (1996) : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe
Superman's Pal Jimmy Olsen #24 "The Gorilla Reporter" : 1 Cosign(s): Z3RO180
Superman/Batman: Absolute Power (Superman/Batman #14-18) : 1 Cosign(s): xxxddd
Superman/Batman: Finest Worlds (SUPERMAN/BATMAN #50-56) : 1 Cosign(s): GunGunW
Superman/Batman: Public Enemies ( Superman/Batman #1-6) : 1 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1
Superman/Fantastic four (1999) : 1 Cosign(s): Z3RO180
Superman/Shazam: First Thunder (2006) : 1 Cosign(s): The_ Tree
The Dark Knight Returns : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy
The Greatest Hero of Them All : 1 Cosign(s): ckuakini
The Man of Steel (1986) : 3 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus etragedy ckuakini
The Supergirl from Krypton (Superman/Batman #8-13) : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon
The Trial of Superman : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe
Time and Time Again : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe
Wednesday Comics : 1 Cosign(s): Chalkshark
Wednesday Comics : 1 Cosign(s): Dracade102
Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow? : 3 Cosign(s): Sandman_ Squalleon etragedy
World's Finest #75 ('The New Team of Superman and Robin' ) : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

11 years ago

TrueMoonchilde

2447

Forum Posts

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#19 Edited By TrueMoonchilde

I'd like to co-sign the following.

Kingdom Come
For Tomorrow
Red Son
All-Star Superman

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#20 Edited By The Poet Moderator

@Moonchilde: added

Here is the cosign chart updated:

SPOILER WARNING: Click here to reveal hidden content.

Action Comics (1938) #1 : 1 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus

Action Comics (1938) #554 ("'If Superman Didn't Exist...'") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Action Comics (1938) #775 ("What's so Funny about Truth, Justice and the American Way?") : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Action Comics (1938) #865 ("Terrible Toyman") : 1 Cosign(s): sethysquare

Action Comics (2011) #13 : 1 Cosign(s): Gambit1,024

Adventures of Superman Annual #7 ("Truth and Justice") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

All-Star Superman : 3 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries Squalleon Moonchilde

Batman/Superman/Wonder Woman: Trinity : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

Brainiac : 2 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries guttridgeb

Christmas With The Super-Heroes #2 ("Ex-Machina") : 1 Cosign(s): Chalkshark

DC Comics Presents #29 ('Where No Superman Has Gone Before'") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

DC Comics Presents #81 ("All This and Kobra Too!") : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_

DC Comics Presents #85 ("The Jungle Line") : 1 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1

DC Comics Presents #87 ("Year of the Comet") : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_

Death of Superman : 2 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus ckuakini

Emperor Joker : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Escape from Bizarro World : 1 Cosign(s): Dracade102

Final Crisis : 2 Cosign(s): The_ Tree ckuakini

Final Crisis: Superman Beyond 3D : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Flashpoint: Project Superman : 1 Cosign(s): Delphic

Grounded : 1 Cosign(s): ckuakini

H'el on Earth : 2 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1 ckuakini

Hitman #34 ("Of Thee I sing") : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Infinite Crisis : 1 Cosign(s): Delphic

JLA: Liberty and Justice : 1 Cosign(s): Gambit1,024

JLA: The Nail : 1 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe

Justice League of America: The Lightning Saga : 3 Cosign(s): GunGunW Strafe Prower ckuakini

Justice Society of America: Thy Kingdom Come : 1 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1

K (Superman/Batman #44-9) : 1 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus

Kingdom Come : 4 Cosign(s): Squalleon etragedy ckuakini Moonchilde

Last Stand of New Krypton : 1 Cosign(s): Eternal19

Lex Luthor: Man of Steel : 1 Cosign(s): The_ Tree

Lex Luthor: The Unauthorized Biography : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

New Krypton : 1 Cosign(s): Eternal19

Reign of Doomday : 2 Cosign(s): Z3RO180 Strafe Prower

Sinestro Corps War : 1 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1

Starman #75 ("Sons And Fathers") : 1 Cosign(s): Chalkshark

Superboy (1994) #59 ("Mission to Krypton") : 1 Cosign(s):

Superboy (1994) #60-65 Hyper-Tension! : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_

Superboy: Incubation (2011 Superboy #1-8) : 1 Cosign(s): sethysquare

Superboy: The Boy of Steel (2010 ADVENTURE COMICS #0-3 and 5-6) : 1 Cosign(s): The_ Tree

Supergirl Last Daughter of Krypton (Supergirl 2011 #1-7) : 1 Cosign(s): sethysquare

Supergirl Many Happy Returns (Supergirl #75-80) : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_

Supergirl Saga : 1 Cosign(s): Dracade102

Supergirl: Power (Supergirl 2005 #0-5) : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Superman (1939) #156 ("The Last Days of Superman") : 1 Cosign(s): GunGunW

Superman (1939) #165 ("The Sweetheart Superman Forgot") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Superman (1939) #662 ("Secrets in the Night") : 1 Cosign(s): Delphic

Superman (1939) #676 ("Memorial Day") : 1 Cosign(s): Gambit1024

Superman (1939) #141 ("Superman Returns Too Krypton!") : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_

Superman (1939) #166 ("The Sons of Superman!") : 1 Cosign(s): ckuakini

SUPERMAN (1939) #174 ("Super-Mxyzptlk....Hero!") : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Superman (1939) #2 ("Superman Champions Universal Peace!") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Superman (1939) #247 ("Must there be a Superman?") : 2 Cosign(s): etragedy Squalleon

Superman (1939) #4 ("Challenge of Luthor") : 1 Cosign(s): jonEsherfey

Superman (1939) #505 ("Reign of the Superman") : 2 Cosign(s): GunGunW ckuakini

Superman (1987) #2 ("the Secret Revealed") : 1 Cosign(s): ckuakini

Superman #408 ('The Day the Earth Died') : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Superman #64- "Metropolis Mailbag" : 1 Cosign(s): Chalkshark

Superman #712 ("Lost Boy, A Tale of Krypto the Superdog") : 1 Cosign(s): Gambit1,024

Superman 80-Page Giant 2011 #1 'Quarter-life Crisis of Infinite Jimmy Olsens' : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Superman Adventures #41 : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Superman and The legion Of Superheroes : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_

Superman and the Men of steel. ( 2011 Action Comics #1-8) : 2 Cosign(s): Sandman_ guttridgeb

Superman Annual #11 (For the Man who has everything) : 4 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus Squalleon etragedy RazzaTazz

Superman Annual #2 ('Loves Labors... "Private Lives"') : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Superman Annual #6 ("The Feral Man of Steel") : 1 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe

Superman Beyond : 1 Cosign(s): Icon

Superman Confidential #'s1-5 & 11 ("Kryptonite") : 1 Cosign(s): Chalkshark

Superman Family (2012) : 1 Cosign(s): Icon

Superman for All Seasons : 2 Cosign(s): Squalleon etragedy

Superman Inc. : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

Superman The Coming Of Atlas (SUPERMAN #677-680 and DC 1st Issue Special #1) : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_

Superman vs. Aliens : 1 Cosign(s): Z3RO180

Superman Vs. Muhammad Ali (1978) : 1 Cosign(s): Z3RO180

Superman: A Nation Divided : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

Superman: Birthright : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_

Superman: Camelot Falls (2007) : 2 Cosign(s): jonEsherfey xxxddd

Superman: Earth One : 2 Cosign(s): Icon ckuakini

Superman: Earth One : 1 Cosign(s): sethysquare

Superman: Ending Battle : 1 Cosign(s): Dracade102

Superman: Exile : 1 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus

Superman: For Tomorrow : 4 Cosign(s): Icon xxxddd RazzaTazz Moonchilde

Superman: Godfall : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_

SUPERMAN: KRYPTONITE NEVERMORE : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Superman: Last Son (2009) : 1 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries

Superman: Last Son of Earth (2000) : 1 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe

Superman: Peace on Earth : 1 Cosign(s): Gambit1,024

Superman: President Lex (2010) : 1 Cosign(s): sethysquare

Superman: Red Son : 3 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries Squalleon Moonchilde

Superman: Secret Identity : 1 Cosign(s): The_ Tree

Superman: Secret Origin (2009) : 1 Cosign(s): GunGunW

Superman: Speeding Bullets (1993) : 1 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe

Superman: Tales of the Bizarro World (Adventure Comics #285-299) : 1 Cosign(s): Dracade102

Superman: The Black Ring ( Action Comics #890-900, Action Comics Annual #13 and Secret Six #29) : 1 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries

Superman: The Dark Side (1998) : 1 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe

Superman: The Journey (Superman #117, 121-125, Action Comics #83) : 1 Cosign(s): xxxddd

Superman: The Last Family of Krypton (2010) : 1 Cosign(s): Delphic

Superman: The Wedding Album : 1 Cosign(s): Delphic

Superman: Up Up and Away! (2006) : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

Superman: World Without a Superman : 1 Cosign(s): Icon

Superman's Girl Friend, Lois Lane #106 ('I Am Curious (Black)!') : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Superman's Metropolis (1996) : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

Superman's Pal Jimmy Olsen #24 "The Gorilla Reporter" : 1 Cosign(s): Z3RO180

Superman/Batman: Absolute Power (Superman/Batman #14-18) : 1 Cosign(s): xxxddd

Superman/Batman: Finest Worlds (SUPERMAN/BATMAN #50-56) : 1 Cosign(s): GunGunW

Superman/Batman: Public Enemies ( Superman/Batman #1-6) : 1 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1

Superman/Fantastic four (1999) : 1 Cosign(s): Z3RO180

Superman/Shazam: First Thunder (2006) : 1 Cosign(s): The_ Tree

The Dark Knight Returns : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

The Greatest Hero of Them All : 1 Cosign(s): ckuakini

The Man of Steel (1986) : 3 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus etragedy ckuakini

The Supergirl from Krypton (Superman/Batman #8-13) : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

The Trial of Superman : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

Time and Time Again : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

Wednesday Comics : 1 Cosign(s): Chalkshark

Wednesday Comics : 1 Cosign(s): Dracade102

Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow? : 3 Cosign(s): Sandman_ Squalleon etragedy

World's Finest #75 ('The New Team of Superman and Robin' ) : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

11 years ago

ENGLENTINE

1959

Forum Posts

13056

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 1004

User Lists: 3

#22 Edited By ENGLENTINE

Elseworlds Speeding Bullets

Unauthorized Biography of Lex Luthor

The Death Of Superman

World Without A Superman

Rein Of The Supermen

Kingdom Come

All Star Superman

11 years ago

GC8

2900

Forum Posts

78610

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 1422

User Lists: 8

#23 Edited By GC8

Skeeter (Action Comics Annual #1) - It's great fun seeing Superman and Batman team-up, and this comic features a threat worthy of such a team: vampires! Batman is on the trail of a mass murderer who he's tracked to a swamp somewhere in the deep south. When he discovers that he's actually up against a vampire infestation, he knows he's in over his head, so he contacts Clark Kent and asks him to send Superman. The comic shows a Batman and a Superman who are aware of each others existence, and are starting to form a limited form of trust. They are becoming aware of each others strengths and weaknesses. The issue also features very good artwork.

Superman Takes a Wife (Action Comics #484) - The wedding of Clark and Lois! In this 40th Anniversary issue, Colonel Future and his C-F Gang recruit The Wizard to perform the greatest disappearing act he's ever done - making Superman disappear. While that has the intended effect for them - a world they can loot (nearly) unopposed, it has another unintended effect for Clark Kent. Free of his obligations as Superman, he can and does marry the woman he's always loved, Lois Lane. Artist Curt Swan imitates his own early art style in this Golden Age homage. (Not a duplicate of the Wedding Album)

'I Can't Go Home Again' (Superman #270) - The Kent home in Smallville is scheduled to be demolished for an interstate highway. This is a touching story about how good intentions can lead to terrible ideas.

Superman Breaks Loose (Superman #233) - The first time Superman was rebooted. Makes kryptonite rare again; Superman's powers are scaled back; Clark transitions from a newspaper reporter to a TV reporter, etc. At the start of the Bronze Age of Comics, this comic 'resets' Superman as if the Silver Age never happened. EDIT: see cosigns

'The Menace from the Stars' (World's Finest #68) - A giant asteroid is on a collision course with Earth. Superman stops it from hitting the Earth, but knocks it into Earth orbit, wreaking havoc with the weather. Worse, the asteroid was partially composed of Kryptonite which causes Superman to plummet to Earth with amnesia. This was the basis for the great 'Panic in the Sky' episode of the Superman TV show.

The Girl in Superman's Past (Superman #129) - Everyone has exes, even Superman. This story tells of the star-crossed love affair between Clark Kent and Lori Lemaris.

'The Battle of the Atoms' (supposed to be published in Superman #38 but EXPURGATED) - This was the infamous Superman story that the U.S. government didn't want you to see! Clark and Lois drive into the countryside looking for the source of a 'terrific upheaval'. They discover massive trees bent over, boulders melted and steel structures twisted. Upon further investigation they come across some of Luthor's thugs. Learning that Superman is close to discovering his plot, Luthor launches an immediate attack on the Daily Planet with a powerful Atomic weapon!

Europe at War (Action Comics #22-23) - In his first appearance, evil genius Luthor starts WWII in order to pave the way for his own world domination!

The Origin of Superman (Superman #53) - The first, and still most definitive version of Superman's origin.

'Detective Sergeant Blake' (Superman #1) - A text only story about a police sergeant who vows to take Superman in. Begins the complex relationship between Superman and the police.

* Aside from that last one which actually appears in a comic book, I have left off text based stories, and stories from other media like TV and movies, as I assume these are disallowed(?).

New cosigns:

'Superman' from Action Comics #1
'The Challenge of Luthor' (Superman #4)
Kryptonite Nevermore

11 years ago

xxxddd

3861

Forum Posts

29703

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 14

#24 Edited By xxxddd

@The Poet said:

@xxxddd: oh you are right on time!
added you as a cosigner for: Superman: For Tomorrow, Superman: Camelot Falls
Since Superman/Batman Absolute Power and Superman: The Journey haven't been nominated yet, can you write 3 or more sentences for each of them on why they should be nominated? (sort of like above ones)

Superman/Batman Absolute Power

Although non-canon, the story was a vivid reminder of why we all love the Man of Steel-his courage, honor, and dedication to doing the right thing. And in this story, you'll see those core values be challenged, and how he deals with it, will forever change how we all view the world's most iconic superhero!

11 years ago

DonFelipe

2373

Forum Posts

129833

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 8

#25 Edited By DonFelipe

Nobody mentioned anything about a limit of co-signs, so...

Action Comics #1 (1938)
Lex Luthor: Man of Steel
Superman Annual #11 (For the Man who has everything)
Superman: Birthright
Superman: Red Son
Superman: The Black Ring
The Man of Steel (1986)
Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow?

11 years ago

Squalleon

9994

Forum Posts

3193

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 7

#26 Edited By Squalleon

@etragedy said:

Superman Breaks Loose (Superman #233) - The first time Superman was rebooted. Makes kryptonite rare again; Superman's powers are scaled back; Clark transitions from a newspaper reporter to a TV reporter, etc. At the start of the Bronze Age of Comics, this comic 'resets' Superman as if the Silver Age never happened.

I have Kryptonite nevermore in the list! So this would be considered a duplicate!

Another story i would put in the list is Action Comics #761 "For A Thousand Tears"

Superman and Wonder Woman are summoned to fight a war in valhalla.As the time pass Superman starts to forget his life on earth and more importantly his wife! As Superman and Wonder Woman start coming very close,will superman betray his beloved wife(SPOILER ALERT: HE WON'T).One of my favorite single issues of AC!

11 years ago

GC8

2900

Forum Posts

78610

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 1422

User Lists: 8

#27 Edited By GC8

Also, I nominate that 'Action Comics #1' on the list be changed to 'Superman' (Action Comics #1), as that is the common name for that untitled story. Action Comics #1 is an anthology the bulk of which is non-Superman material.

11 years ago

sinestro_GL

3651

Forum Posts

6530

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 14

User Lists: 8

#28 Edited By sinestro_GL

Superman vs. the Amazing Spiuder-Man

1976 will go down in history as the year when it finally happened - DC Comics and Marvel Comics had joined forces to give us the most mouth-watering features of all time: Superman vs. Spider-Man. In one single issue, readers were treated to the sight of two of the comic world's most popular characters standing side-by-side, battling not only each other, but the joint forces of Doctor Octopus and Lex Luthor. Though this story may comic book (a generously oversized issue) not necessarily be remembered for it's story, it is more significantly remembered for the teaming up of the flagship characters of DC and Marvel.

11 years ago

DonFelipe

2373

Forum Posts

129833

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 8

#29 Edited By DonFelipe

@etragedy said:

Also, I nominate that 'Action Comics #1' on the list be changed to 'Superman' (Action Comics #1), as that is the common name for that untitled story. Action Comics #1 is an anthology the bulk of which is non-Superman material.

Good point! Superman should be mentioned there.

11 years ago

Squalleon

9994

Forum Posts

3193

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 7

#30 Edited By Squalleon

And Finally

DC ONE MILLION

One of the best events of all time, and a good Superman story since it is all about the return of the original Superman (Superman Prime) to the universe after centuries of ceclusion to the sun!The JLA of the past meets the JLA of the future for an epic battle against the living sun Solaris!

11 years ago

tomlikesfries

5341

Forum Posts

3102

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 106

User Lists: 3

#31 Edited By tomlikesfries

Co-signing:

Superman/Batman: Public Enemies
Final Crisis
Kingdom Come

Ah, it's nice to see people co-signing stories I nominated... Mwahaha!

11 years ago

chalkshark

1271

Forum Posts

407273

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 6

#32 Edited By chalkshark

I hereby co-sign the following nominations....

All Star Superman
Superman For All Seasons
Superman Peace On Earth
Kingdom Come
Superman #712

11 years ago

wmwadeii

3327

Forum Posts

266306

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 2261

User Lists: 3

#33 Edited By wmwadeii

@sinestro_GL said:

Superman vs. the Amazing Spiuder-Man
1976 will go down in history as the year when it finally happened - DC Comics and Marvel Comics had joined forces to give us the most mouth-watering features of all time: Superman vs. Spider-Man. In one single issue, readers were treated to the sight of two of the comic world's most popular characters standing side-by-side, battling not only each other, but the joint forces of Doctor Octopus and Lex Luthor. Though this story may comic book (a generously oversized issue) not necessarily be remembered for it's story, it is more significantly remembered for the teaming up of the flagship characters of DC and Marvel.

I second this, was just looking thru the issue the other day.

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#34 Edited By The Poet Moderator

@kfhrfdu_89_76k: added/changed

@etragedy: added. I need a page, so it has to be issues, arcs or such (can't do movies/tv shows as you suspected. I need a page and I won't do movies...).

@DonFelipe: added. There is a limit, but it seems pointless to try to hit it since you would be adding a point to every single story nominated...

@Squalleon: added. Sidenote: spoilers won't work on the actual list (remember all formating, links, etc. won't work in the comment sections of CV lists...Just thought I should let you know it won't work when we publish...

@etragedy said:

Also, I nominate that 'Action Comics #1' on the list be changed to 'Superman' (Action Comics #1), as that is the common name for that untitled story. Action Comics #1 is an anthology the bulk of which is non-Superman material.

I can compromise and say Action Comics (1938) #1 ("Superman"), but you have to know that is just a visual thing which would only go for this round and for Final Order Voting. all the titles you see are for voter's benifit. The only thing I really need is the Action Comics #1 so I can link plus the year of publication of the volume it is contained in so I know which issue to add. That's why I put the volume, then the year, then the issue number (and the title). Just explaining what I do. The reasons really speak for them selves. so in the finished product you'll see:


	#Ranking. The Terrible Toyman (Title of the story whatever is listed on the issue's wiki page) Action Comics #865: Well, we all know Toyman is this Joke character that nobody took seriously. The first time he was ever menacing was in STAS and I thought that it was a perfect portrayal. Shortly after that Geoff Johns took some cues from the animated series and made Toyman this A-list character and since I love toyman I thought this was a great time to add it to Superman's greatest stories

so I can add for your benifit the "Superman", but it's not essential to how I add issues or how I present them. Just saying.

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#35 Edited By The Poet Moderator

@Squalleon: @tomlikesfries: @chalkshark: @wmwadeii: added!

Status of the Cosigns:

SPOILER WARNING: Click here to reveal hidden content.

Action Comics (1938) #1 : 4 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus kfhrfdu_89_76k etragedy DonFelipe

Action Comics (1938) #22-23 "Europe at War" : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Action Comics (1938) #484 ("Superman Takes a Wife") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Action Comics (1938) #554 ("'If Superman Didn't Exist...'") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Action Comics (1938) #761 ("For A Thousand Tears") : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Action Comics (1938) #775 ("What's so Funny about Truth, Justice and the American Way?") : 2 Cosign(s): Squalleon kfhrfdu_89_76k

Action Comics (1938) #865 ("Terrible Toyman") : 2 Cosign(s): sethysquare kfhrfdu_89_76k

Action Comics (2011) #13 : 2 Cosign(s): Gambit1,024 kfhrfdu_89_76k

Action Comics Annual #1 ("Skeeter") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Adventures of Superman Annual #7 ("Truth and Justice") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

All-Star Superman : 5 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries Squalleon Moonchilde ENGLENTINE chalkshark

Batman/Superman/Wonder Woman: Trinity : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

Brainiac : 3 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries guttridgeb kfhrfdu_89_76k

Christmas With The Super-Heroes #2 ("Ex-Machina") : 1 Cosign(s): Chalkshark

DC Comics Presents #29 ('Where No Superman Has Gone Before'") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

DC Comics Presents #81 ("All This and Kobra Too!") : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_

DC Comics Presents #85 ("The Jungle Line") : 1 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1

DC Comics Presents #87 ("Year of the Comet") : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_

DC One Million : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Death of Superman : 3 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus ckuakini ENGLENTINE

Emperor Joker : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Escape from Bizarro World : 1 Cosign(s): Dracade102

Final Crisis : 3 Cosign(s): The_ Tree ckuakini tomlikesfries

Final Crisis: Superman Beyond 3D : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Flashpoint: Project Superman : 1 Cosign(s): Delphic

Grounded : 1 Cosign(s): ckuakini

H'el on Earth : 2 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1 ckuakini

Hitman #34 ("Of Thee I sing") : 2 Cosign(s): Squalleon kfhrfdu_89_76k

Infinite Crisis : 1 Cosign(s): Delphic

JLA: Liberty and Justice : 1 Cosign(s): Gambit1,024

JLA: The Nail : 1 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe

Justice League of America: The Lightning Saga : 3 Cosign(s): GunGunW Strafe Prower ckuakini

Justice Society of America: Thy Kingdom Come : 1 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1

K (Superman/Batman #44-9) : 1 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus

Kingdom Come : 7 Cosign(s): Squalleon etragedy ckuakini Moonchilde ENGLENTINE tomlikesfries chalkshark

Last Stand of New Krypton : 1 Cosign(s): Eternal19

Lex Luthor: Man of Steel : 3 Cosign(s): The_ Tree kfhrfdu_89_76k DonFelipe

Lex Luthor: The Unauthorized Biography : 3 Cosign(s): DonFelipe kfhrfdu_89_76k ENGLENTINE

New Krypton : 1 Cosign(s): Eternal19

Reign of Doomday : 2 Cosign(s): Z3RO180 Strafe Prower

Sinestro Corps War : 1 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1

Starman #75 ("Sons And Fathers") : 1 Cosign(s): Chalkshark

Superboy (1994) #59 ("Mission to Krypton") : 1 Cosign(s):

Superboy (1994) #60-65 Hyper-Tension! : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_

Superboy: Incubation (2011 Superboy #1-8) : 1 Cosign(s): sethysquare

Superboy: The Boy of Steel (2010 ADVENTURE COMICS #0-3 and 5-6) : 1 Cosign(s): The_ Tree

Supergirl Last Daughter of Krypton (Supergirl 2011 #1-7) : 1 Cosign(s): sethysquare

Supergirl Many Happy Returns (Supergirl #75-80) : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_

Supergirl Saga : 1 Cosign(s): Dracade102

Supergirl: Power (Supergirl 2005 #0-5) : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Superman (1939) #156 ("The Last Days of Superman") : 1 Cosign(s): GunGunW

Superman (1939) #165 ("The Sweetheart Superman Forgot") : 2 Cosign(s): etragedy kfhrfdu_89_76k

Superman (1939) #662 ("Secrets in the Night") : 1 Cosign(s): Delphic

Superman (1939) #676 ("Memorial Day") : 1 Cosign(s): Gambit1024

Superman (1939) #1 ("Detective Sergant Blake") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Superman (1939) #129 ("The Girl in Superman's Past") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Superman (1939) #141 ("Superman Returns Too Krypton!") : 2 Cosign(s): Sandman_ kfhrfdu_89_76k

Superman (1939) #166 ("The Sons of Superman!") : 1 Cosign(s): ckuakini

SUPERMAN (1939) #174 ("Super-Mxyzptlk....Hero!") : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Superman (1939) #2 ("Superman Champions Universal Peace!") : 2 Cosign(s): etragedy kfhrfdu_89_76k

Superman (1939) #247 ("Must there be a Superman?") : 2 Cosign(s): etragedy Squalleon

Superman (1939) #270 ('I Can't Go Home Again') : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Superman (1939) #38 ('The Battle of the Atoms') : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Superman (1939) #4 ("Challenge of Luthor") : 3 Cosign(s): jonEsherfey kfhrfdu_89_76k etragedy

Superman (1939) #408 ('The Day the Earth Died') : 2 Cosign(s): etragedy chalkshark

Superman (1939) #505 ("Reign of the Superman") : 3 Cosign(s): GunGunW ckuakini ENGLENTINE

Superman (1939) #53 ("The Origin of Superman") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Superman (1939) #64- "Metropolis Mailbag" : 1 Cosign(s): Chalkshark

Superman (1939) #712 ("Lost Boy, A Tale of Krypto the Superdog") : 2 Cosign(s): Gambit1,024 chalkshark

Superman (1987) #2 ("the Secret Revealed") : 1 Cosign(s): ckuakini

Superman 80-Page Giant 2011 #1 'Quarter-life Crisis of Infinite Jimmy Olsens' : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Superman Adventures #41 : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Superman and The legion Of Superheroes : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_

Superman and the Men of steel. ( 2011 Action Comics #1-8) : 2 Cosign(s): Sandman_ guttridgeb

Superman Annual #11 (For the Man who has everything) : 6 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus Squalleon etragedy RazzaTazz kfhrfdu_89_76k DonFelipe

Superman Annual #2 ('Loves Labors... "Private Lives"') : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Superman Annual #6 ("The Feral Man of Steel") : 1 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe

Superman Beyond : 1 Cosign(s): Icon

Superman Confidential #'s1-5 & 11 ("Kryptonite") : 1 Cosign(s): Chalkshark

Superman Family (2012) : 1 Cosign(s): Icon

Superman for All Seasons : 4 Cosign(s): Squalleon etragedy kfhrfdu_89_76k chalkshark

Superman Inc. : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

Superman The Coming Of Atlas (SUPERMAN #677-680 and DC 1st Issue Special #1) : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_

Superman vs. Aliens : 1 Cosign(s): Z3RO180

Superman Vs. Muhammad Ali (1978) : 1 Cosign(s): Z3RO180

Superman vs. the Amazing Spider-Man : 2 Cosign(s): sinestro_GL wmwadeii

Superman: A Nation Divided : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

Superman: Birthright : 2 Cosign(s): Sandman_ DonFelipe

Superman: Camelot Falls (2007) : 3 Cosign(s): jonEsherfey xxxddd kfhrfdu_89_76k

Superman: Earth One (Volume 1) : 2 Cosign(s): Icon ckuakini

Superman: Earth One (Volume 2) : 1 Cosign(s): sethysquare

Superman: Ending Battle : 2 Cosign(s): Dracade102 kfhrfdu_89_76k

Superman: Exile : 1 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus

Superman: For Tomorrow : 5 Cosign(s): Icon xxxddd RazzaTazz Moonchilde kfhrfdu_89_76k

Superman: Godfall : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_

SUPERMAN: KRYPTONITE NEVERMORE : 2 Cosign(s): Squalleon etragedy

Superman: Last Son (2009) : 1 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries

Superman: Last Son of Earth (2000) : 1 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe

Superman: Peace on Earth : 2 Cosign(s): Gambit1,024 chalkshark

Superman: President Lex (2010) : 1 Cosign(s): sethysquare

Superman: Red Son : 4 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries Squalleon Moonchilde DonFelipe

Superman: Secret Identity : 2 Cosign(s): The_ Tree kfhrfdu_89_76k

Superman: Secret Origin (2009) : 1 Cosign(s): GunGunW

Superman: Speeding Bullets (1993) : 2 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe ENGLENTINE

Superman: Tales of the Bizarro World (Adventure Comics #285-299) : 1 Cosign(s): Dracade102

Superman: The Black Ring ( Action Comics #890-900, Action Comics Annual #13 and Secret Six #29) : 3 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries kfhrfdu_89_76k DonFelipe

Superman: The Dark Side (1998) : 1 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe

Superman: The Journey (Superman #117, 121-125, Action Comics #83) : 1 Cosign(s): xxxddd

Superman: The Last Family of Krypton (2010) : 1 Cosign(s): Delphic

Superman: The Wedding Album : 1 Cosign(s): Delphic

Superman: Up Up and Away! (2006) : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

Superman: World Without a Superman : 1 Cosign(s): Icon

Superman's Girl Friend, Lois Lane #106 ('I Am Curious (Black)!') : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Superman's Metropolis (1996) : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

Superman's Pal Jimmy Olsen #24 "The Gorilla Reporter" : 1 Cosign(s): Z3RO180

Superman/Batman: Absolute Power (Superman/Batman #14-18) : 1 Cosign(s): xxxddd

Superman/Batman: Finest Worlds (SUPERMAN/BATMAN #50-56) : 1 Cosign(s): GunGunW

Superman/Batman: Public Enemies ( Superman/Batman #1-6) : 2 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1 tomlikesfries

Superman/Fantastic four (1999) : 2 Cosign(s): Z3RO180 kfhrfdu_89_76k

Superman/Shazam: First Thunder (2006) : 1 Cosign(s): The_ Tree

The Dark Knight Returns : 2 Cosign(s): etragedy kfhrfdu_89_76k

The Greatest Hero of Them All : 1 Cosign(s): ckuakini

The Man of Steel (1986) : 4 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus etragedy ckuakini DonFelipe

The Supergirl from Krypton (Superman/Batman #8-13) : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

The Trial of Superman : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

Time and Time Again : 1 Cosign(s): DonFelipe

Wednesday Comics : 2 Cosign(s): Chalkshark kfhrfdu_89_76k

Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow? : 5 Cosign(s): Sandman_ Squalleon etragedy kfhrfdu_89_76k DonFelipe

World of New Krypton : 1 Cosign(s): Dracade102

World's Finest #68 ('The Menace from the Stars') : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

World's Finest #75 ('The New Team of Superman and Robin' ) : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

In case people were interersted, our current top 5 based on the cosigns:

Kingdom Come : 7 Cosign(s):
Superman Annual #11 (For the Man who has everything) : 6 Cosign(s):
All-Star Superman : 5 Cosign(s):
Superman: For Tomorrow : 5 Cosign(s):
Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow? : 5 Cosign(s):

of course the latter 3 were tied...

11 years ago

RedheadedAtrocitus

6958

Forum Posts

8982

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 4

User Lists: 3

#36 Edited By RedheadedAtrocitus

Actually, the official title for Action Comics (1938-2011): #1 is "Superman! Champion of the Oppressed, the physical marvel who had sworn to devote his existence to helping those in need!" so...I would imagine "Superman! Champion of the Oppressed..." should be the title we use for that here...

11 years ago

DonFelipe

2373

Forum Posts

129833

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 8

#37 Edited By DonFelipe

@The Poet said:

@DonFelipe: added. There is a limit, but it seems pointless to try to hit it since you would be adding a point to every single story nominated...

Haha. No, I wouldn't!

Wow! +130 nominations. Here's a few more just in case we're aiming for 150 now:

Superman/Batman #81-84:
Sorcerer Kings (about magic, time travel and mystical creatures)
Superman/Supergirl: Maelstrom
(it's just cool to see Supes and S'girl in Phil Noto style, love the art!)
War of the Supermen (well... waaaaar!!!)

Let me know and I'll pass you more detailed reasons.

11 years ago

GC8

2900

Forum Posts

78610

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 1422

User Lists: 8

#38 Edited By GC8

@RedheadedAtrocitus: Heh. Yeah. That's why I said 'common name' rather than 'official name'.

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#39 Edited By The Poet Moderator

@DonFelipe: added. We don't really have a maximum (though I would not want to have over 200 as a preference but whatever people want on the list I'll add)

do you want War of the Supermen or would you want 100 Minute War?

11 years ago

the_tree

8456

Forum Posts

28513

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 14

#40 Edited By the_tree

I cosign the following

Action Comics (1938) #775 ("What's so Funny about Truth, Justice and the American Way?")
Action Comics (2011) #13
All-Star Superman
Brainiac
DC One Million
Death of Superman
H'el on Earth
Infinite Crisis
Last Stand of New Krypton
New Krypton
Reign of Doomsday
Superman and The Legion of Superheroes
Superman and the Men of steel. ( 2011 Action Comics #1-8)
Superman Annual #11 (For the Man who has everything)
Superman Family (2012)
Superman for All Seasons
Superman The Coming of Atlas (SUPERMAN #677-680 and DC 1st Issue Special #1)
Superman Vs. Muhammad Ali (1978)
Superman: Birthright
Superman: Earth One (Volume 1)
Superman: For Tomorrow
Superman: Godfall
Superman: Last Son (2009)
Superman: Red Son
Superman: Secret Origin (2009)
Superman: The Black Ring ( Action Comics #890-900, Action Comics Annual #13 and Secret Six #29)
Superman: The Wedding Album
Superman: Up Up and Away! (2006)
Superman/Batman: Absolute Power (Superman/Batman #14-18)
Superman/Batman: Finest Worlds (SUPERMAN/BATMAN #50-56)
War of the Supermen
Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow?
World of New Krypton

11 years ago

DonFelipe

2373

Forum Posts

129833

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 8

#41 Edited By DonFelipe

@The Poet said:

@DonFelipe: added. We don't really have a maximum (though I would not want to have over 200 as a preference but whatever people want on the list I'll add)
do you want War of the Supermen or would you want 100 Minute War?

Lets stick to War of the Supermen. It's the official title and even DC called the 2 double features and the hardcover "War of the Supermen".

"The 100 Minute War" is just the subtitle on the cover of issue #1 and then re-appears as a memo, from Lois to Clark/Superman, at the end of issue #4. This memo says as much as "they call it the 100 Minute War", if I remember correctly. Imho, the story arc should be called War of the Supermen, too.

11 years ago

xxxddd

3861

Forum Posts

29703

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 14

#42 Edited By xxxddd

@DonFelipe said:

Nobody mentioned anything about a limit of co-signs, so...

There isn't.

11 years ago

Mucklefluga

2653

Forum Posts

3678

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 5

#43 Edited By Mucklefluga

@The Poet Cosign me to All Star Superman and Superman Vs Muhammad Ali please

11 years ago

GunGunW

1027

Forum Posts

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 5

#44 Edited By GunGunW

You can also cosign me to All Star Superman as well as Superman/Batman: The Search for Kryptonite... sorry for not being as active

11 years ago

GC8

2900

Forum Posts

78610

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 1422

User Lists: 8

#45 Edited By GC8

cosign 79. Superman Confidential #'s1-5 & 11 ("Kryptonite")

11 years ago

Lvenger

36475

Forum Posts

899

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 50

User Lists: 18

#47 Edited By Lvenger

Aw man can't believe I missed out to be a voter on this! I'll add my cosigns to this list now. I can at least do that:

Action Comics (1938) #1 ("Superman! Champion of the Oppressed...")
Action Comics (1938) #22-23 "Europe at War"
Action Comics (1938) #775 ("What's so Funny about Truth, Justice and the American Way?")
All-Star Superman
Batman/Superman/Wonder Woman: Trinity
Brainiac
Death of Superman
Emperor Joker
Hitman #34 ("Of Thee I sing")
Infinite Crisis
JLA: Liberty and Justice
JLA: The Nail
Kingdom Come
Lex Luthor: Man of Steel
New Krypton
Reign of Doomday
Superman (1939) #247 ("Must there be a Superman?")
Superman (1939) #4 ("Challenge of Luthor")
Superman (1939) #408 ('The Day the Earth Died')
Superman (1939) #505 ("Reign of the Superman")
Superman (1939) #53 ("The Origin of Superman")
Superman and the Men of steel. ( 2011 Action Comics #1-8)
Superman Annual #11 (For the Man who has everything)
Superman for All Seasons
Superman Vs. Muhammad Ali (1978)
Superman vs. the Amazing Spider-Man
Superman: Birthright
Superman: For Tomorrow
Superman: Peace on Earth
Superman: President Lex (2010)
Superman: Red Son
Superman: Secret Identity
Superman: Secret Origin (2009)
Superman: Speeding Bullets (1993)
Superman/Batman: Absolute Power (Superman/Batman #14-18)
Superman/Batman: Finest Worlds (SUPERMAN/BATMAN #50-56)
Superman/Batman: Public Enemies ( Superman/Batman #1-6)
Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow?

And that's all I can think of. A lot of effort has gone into this list and it really shows when you look at how many Superman stories there are here! Great job to all involved!

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#48 Edited By The Poet Moderator

@The_Tree: @Mucklefluga: added. thanks!

@GunGunW: added. no worries!

@etragedy: added

@kfhrfdu_89_76k: added

11 years ago

The Poet

8646

Forum Posts

116846

Wiki Points

Followers

Reviews: 84

User Lists: 99

#49 Edited By The Poet Moderator

@Lvenger: thanks! added!

Cosign Status:

SPOILER WARNING: Click here to reveal hidden content.

Action Comics (1938) #1 ("Superman! Champion of the Oppressed...") : 5 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus kfhrfdu_89_76k etragedy DonFelipe Lvenger

Action Comics (1938) #22-23 "Europe at War" : 2 Cosign(s): etragedy Lvenger

Action Comics (1938) #484 ("Superman Takes a Wife") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Action Comics (1938) #554 ("'If Superman Didn't Exist...'") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Action Comics (1938) #761 ("For A Thousand Tears") : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Action Comics (1938) #775 ("What's so Funny about Truth, Justice and the American Way?") : 4 Cosign(s): Squalleon kfhrfdu_89_76k The_Tree Lvenger

Action Comics (1938) #865 ("Terrible Toyman") : 2 Cosign(s): sethysquare kfhrfdu_89_76k

Action Comics (2011) #13 : 3 Cosign(s): Gambit1,024 kfhrfdu_89_76k The_Tree

Action Comics Annual #1 ("Skeeter") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

Adventures of Superman Annual #7 ("Truth and Justice") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

All-Star Superman : 9 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries Squalleon Moonchilde ENGLENTINE chalkshark The_Tree Mucklefluga GunGunW Lvenger

Batman/Superman/Wonder Woman: Trinity : 2 Cosign(s): DonFelipe Lvenger

Brainiac : 5 Cosign(s): tomlikesfries guttridgeb kfhrfdu_89_76k The_Tree Lvenger

Christmas With The Super-Heroes #2 ("Ex-Machina") : 1 Cosign(s): Chalkshark

DC Comics Presents #29 ('Where No Superman Has Gone Before'") : 1 Cosign(s): etragedy

DC Comics Presents #81 ("All This and Kobra Too!") : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_

DC Comics Presents #85 ("The Jungle Line") : 1 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1

DC Comics Presents #87 ("Year of the Comet") : 1 Cosign(s): Sandman_

DC One Million : 2 Cosign(s): Squalleon The_Tree

Death of Superman : 5 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus ckuakini ENGLENTINE The_Tree Lvenger

Emperor Joker : 2 Cosign(s): Squalleon Lvenger

Escape from Bizarro World : 1 Cosign(s): Dracade102

Final Crisis : 3 Cosign(s): The_ Tree ckuakini tomlikesfries

Final Crisis: Superman Beyond 3D : 1 Cosign(s): Squalleon

Flashpoint: Project Superman : 1 Cosign(s): Delphic

Grounded : 1 Cosign(s): ckuakini

H'el on Earth : 3 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1 ckuakini The_Tree

Hitman #34 ("Of Thee I sing") : 3 Cosign(s): Squalleon kfhrfdu_89_76k Lvenger

Infinite Crisis : 3 Cosign(s): Delphic The_Tree Lvenger

JLA: Liberty and Justice : 2 Cosign(s): Gambit1,024 Lvenger

JLA: The Nail : 2 Cosign(s): Joshmightbe Lvenger

Justice League of America: The Lightning Saga : 3 Cosign(s): GunGunW Strafe Prower ckuakini

Justice Society of America: Thy Kingdom Come : 1 Cosign(s): joeagentofhand1

K (Superman/Batman #44-9) : 1 Cosign(s): RedheadedAtrocitus

Kingdom Come : 8 Cosign(s): Squalleon etragedy ckuakini Moonchilde ENGLENTINE tomlikesfries chalkshark Lvenger

Last Stand of New Krypton : 2 Cosign(s): Eternal19 The_Tree

Lex Luthor: Man of Steel : 4 Cosign(s): The_ Tree kfhrfdu_89_76k DonFelipe Lvenger

Lex Luthor: The Unauthorized Biography : 3 Cosign(s): DonFelipe kfhrfdu_89_76k ENGLENTINE

New Krypton : 3 Cosign(s): Eternal19 The_Tree Lvenger

Reign of Doomday : 4 Cosign(s): Z3RO180 Strafe Prower The_Tree Lvenger