This topic is locked from further discussion.

#1 Edited by cosmo111687 (1489 posts) - - Show Bio

RULES:

  1. Using the Voting Ballot below, cast your votes for 1st, 2nd, and 3rd in each category.
  2. Write your votes in this format next to each ranking: [Title] [Issue Number]. For example: Justice League #1.
  3. Post your votes in a comments below.
  4. Votes can only be cast on books that have come out this month (September 2011) and, with the exception of the "Non-DC or Marvel" category, can be from any company; DC, Marvel, Image, etc.
  5. Please cast votes on books you've read.
  6. If you don't have want to cast a particular vote, write-in "N/A" or just leave it blank.

How the poll will be graded:

1st place votes are given 3pts

2nd place votes are given 2pts

3rd place votes are given 1 pt

Voting will end By 12:00 AM Thursday October 6th PST, after which I will tally up all the votes and post the results for the Top 5 winners in each category.

Voting Ballot:

Best Writing/Story

1st

2nd

3rd

Best Interior Artwork

1st

2nd

3rd

Best Cover Artwork

1st

2nd

3rd

Best Non-DC or Marvel Issue

1st

2nd

3rd

Best Issues of the Month

1st

2nd

3rd

#2 Posted by cosmo111687 (1489 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing/Story

1st - DC Universe Presents #1

2nd - All-Star Western #1

3rd - Batman #1

Best Interior Artwork

1st - Batwoman #1

2nd - Animal Man #1

3rd - I, Vampire #1

Best Cover Artwork

1st - Batwoman #1

2nd - Daredevil #4

3rd - DC Universe Presents #1

Best Non-DC or Marvel Issue

1st - N/A

2nd - N/A

3rd - N/A

Best Issues of the Month

1st - Action Comics #1

2nd - DC Universe Presents #1

3rd - Justice League Dark #1

#3 Posted by RazzaTazz (9641 posts) - - Show Bio

Will have to go with part votes 
Best Writing/Story

1st  Aquaman  #1

2nd  Wonder Woman #1

3rd

Best Interior Artwork

1st  Red hood and the Outlaws (while I dont agree with what is being drawn the art is pretty good)

2nd

3rd

Best Cover Artwork

1st  

2nd

3rd

Best Non-DC or Marvel Issue

1st

2nd

3rd

Best Issues of the Month

1st  Aquaman #1

2nd

 

3rd

 
I may come back later and edit these
Moderator
#4 Edited by MrUnknown (1700 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Story: 1) Batman #1

Best Artwork: 1) Avengers: Children Crusade #7

Best Cover: Batgirl #1

Best Non-Marvel or DC:

Overall Best: Batman #1

#5 Posted by CATPANEXE (9368 posts) - - Show Bio

curious, though you don't state it, the presence of Best Non-DC or Marvel implicates your asking for the other categories be filled in with exclusively DC and/or Marvel choices, yes/no?

#6 Posted by cosmo111687 (1489 posts) - - Show Bio

@CATPANEXE said:

curious, though you don't state it, the presence of Best Non-DC or Marvel implicates your asking for the other categories be filled in with exclusively DC and/or Marvel choices, yes/no?

Oh, other categories can be filled in with whatever comic book from whatever company you'd like, in so long as it came out in September 2011. :) The "Non-DC or Marvel" category was put there to show-case books from other companies that might be over-looked. :)

#7 Posted by JediXMan (30630 posts) - - Show Bio

Let you know after I finish today's batch.

Moderator
#8 Posted by Bestostero (5618 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing/Story

1st - Aquaman #1

2nd - Avengers Children's Crusade #7

3rd - Batgirl #1

Best Interior Artwork

1st - Aquaman #1

2nd - Detective Comics #1

3rd - Red Hood and the Outlaws #1

Best Cover Artwork

1st - Captain Atom #1

2nd - Batwoman #1

3rd - Grifter #1

Best Non-DC or Marvel Issue

1st - Buffy Season 9 #1

2nd - N/A

3rd - N/A

Best Issues of the Month

1st - Avengers Children's Crusade #7

2nd - Aquaman #1

3rd - Batgirl #1

#9 Posted by ReVamp (22865 posts) - - Show Bio

Strictly DCnU month for me, with some exceptions, but they're not making it.

Best Writing/Story

1st Men of War #1

2nd Batman #1

3rd Red Hood and the Ou---

Joking. Haha. :P

3rd. Deathstroke

Best Interior Artwork

1st Red Hood and the Outlaws #1

2nd Batwing #1

3rd Batman #1

Best Cover Artwork

1st Men of War #1

2nd Justice League Dark #1

3rd Green Lantern: New Guardians #1

Best Non-DC or Marvel Issue

N/A. Behind on Invincible =(

Best Issues of the Month

1st Men of War #1

2nd Nightwing #1

3rd Red Hood and the Outlaws #1

This may be subject to change though... I might edit this later... :P

#10 Posted by tim2081 (519 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Non-DC or Marvel Issue

1st - Fly #4 (Zenescope)

2nd - The Boys: Buthcer, Baker, Candlestickmaker #3 (Dynamite)

3rd - Fathom #2 (Aspen MLT)

#11 Posted by SC (13119 posts) - - Show Bio

Cool thread *smile*
 
Best Writing/Story

1st - X-Factor #224.1

2nd - Swamp Thing #1

3rd - Journey Into Mystery #627

Best Interior Artwork

1st - New Avengers Annual #1

2nd - Avengers Children's Crusade #7 

3rd - Batwoman #1

Best Cover Artwork

1st - New Avengers Annual #1

2nd - Journey Into Mystery #627

3rd - Justice League Dark #1

Best Non-DC or Marvel Issue

1st - Habibi (if it counts, its a graphic novel, size wise, if not then Buffy Season 9 #1 please) 

2nd - Abe Sapien: The Devil Does Not Jest

3rd - The Lil Depressed Boy #6

Best Issues of the Month

1st - Wonder Woman #1 

2nd - X-Factor #224.1

3rd - Batwoman #1

Moderator
#12 Posted by cosmo111687 (1489 posts) - - Show Bio

bump.

#13 Posted by DoomDoomDoom (4248 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing/Story

1st. Animal Man #1

2nd. DCU Presents: Deadman #1

3rd. Daredevil #4

Best Interior Artwork

1st. The Savage Hawkman #1

2nd. Animal Man #1

3rd. The Red Wing #3

Best Cover Artwork

1st. Animal Man #1

2nd. All-Star Western #1

3rd. DCU Presents: Deadman #1

Best Non-DC or Marvel Issue

1st. The Red Wing #3

2nd. N/A

3rd. N/A

Best Issues of the Month

1st. Animal Man #1

2nd. Davedevil #4

3rd. The Red Wing #3

#14 Posted by damswedon (499 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing/Story

  1. Low Life - The Deal parts 1 to 4 (2000 AD Progs 1750 to 1753)
  2. Judge Dredd - Downtime (2000 AD Prog 1752)
  3. All-Star Western #1

Best Interior Artwork

  1. Low Life - The Deal parts 1 to 4 (2000 AD Progs1750 to 1753)
  2. Angel Zero Parts 1 to 3 (2000 AD Progs 1751 to 1753)
  3. Ampney Crucis In vestigates... The English Assassin Parts 1 to 4 (2000 AD Progs1750 to 1753)

Best Cover Artwork

  1. 2000 AD - Prog 1751
  2. 2000 AD - Prog 1752
  3. All-Star Western #1

Best Non-DC or Marvel Issue

  1. 2000 AD Prog 1752
  2. 2000 AD Prog 1753
  3. 2000 AD Prog 1750

Best Issues of the Month

  1. 2000 AD Prog 1752
  2. 2000 AD Prog 1753
  3. 2000 AD Prog 1750

I hope you're okay with me splitting out the single stories in 2000AD like that.

#15 Posted by B'Town (2336 posts) - - Show Bio

I wanted to say, I have every intention of playing but still have a stack here from this month I haven't finished reading and my pulls from this past Wednesday have not yet arrived, I am a little concerned they won't arrive in time, if that is the case I will go ahead and make my list with what books I have read come closing time. :D

#16 Posted by Afro_Warrior (1120 posts) - - Show Bio

Voting Ballot:

Best Writing/Story

1st : Batman #1

2nd : All Star Western #1

3rd : Demon Knights #1

Best Interior Artwork

1st :  Batwing #1
2nd : Green Lantern:New Guardians #1

3rd : Justice League #1
Best Cover Artwork

1st : Demon Knights #1

2nd : Justice League #1

3rd : Green Lantern:New Guardians #1

Best Non-DC or Marvel Issue

1st : N/A

2nd : N/A

3rd : N/A

Best Issues of the Month

1st : Batman #1

2nd : Demon Knights #1

3rd : Batwing #1

#17 Posted by inferiorego (24714 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing/Story

1st Aquaman

2nd All Star Western

3rd Animal Man

Best Interior Artwork

1st Batwing

2nd Demon Knights

3rd Flash

Best Cover Artwork

1st Men of War

2nd Swamp Thing

3rd Voodoo

Best Non-DC or Marvel Issue

1st Brilliant #1 (I know it's a Marvel imprint)

2nd Red Wing #3

3rd Godzilla Gangsters and Goliaths #4

Best Issues of the Month

1st Aquaman #1

2nd Swamp Thing #1

3rd Brilliant #1

Staff
#18 Posted by keith71_98 (387 posts) - - Show Bio
@cosmo111687

Best Writing/Story

1st  Batman#1

2nd  All-Star Western #1

3rd  Swamp Thing #1

Best Interior Artwork

1st  Aquaman #1

2nd  Nightwing #1

3rd  Action Comics #1

Best Cover Artwork

1st  Resurrection Man #1

2nd  Grifter #1

3rd  DC Universe Presents #1

Best Non-DC or Marvel Issue

1st  Red Skull #3

2nd

3rd

Best Issues of the Month

1st  Batman #1

2nd  All-Star Western #1

3rd  Aquaman #1

#19 Edited by Daveyo520 (2447 posts) - - Show Bio

My favorite was a tie between Batman #1 and All-Star Western #1. As for the best art, All-Star Western or Batwoman. I will format this and work out the rest when I have the time.

#20 Posted by cosmo111687 (1489 posts) - - Show Bio

bump.

#21 Posted by cosmo111687 (1489 posts) - - Show Bio

final bump.

#22 Posted by B'Town (2336 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing/Story

1st - American Vampire Survival of the Fittest #4

2nd - Batwoman #1

3rd - Batgirl #1

Best Interior Artwork

1st - Batwoman #1

2nd - American Vampire Survival of the Fittest #4

3rd - Demon Knights #1

Best Cover Artwork

1st - Batwoman #1

2nd - American Vampire Survival of the Fittest #4

3rd - Deathstroke #1

Best Non-DC or Marvel Issue

1st- American Vampire Survival of the Fittest #4

2nd - Buffy the Vampire Slayer Season Nine #1

3rd - Angel & Faith

Best Issues of the Month

1st - Batwoman #1

2nd - American Vampire Survival of the Fittest #4

3rd - Catwoman #1

#23 Edited by Hawkeye446 (3939 posts) - - Show Bio

@cosmo111687: FANTASTIC IDEA COSMO!!!! Lovin' it!

Best Writing/Story

1st Batman #1

2nd X-Factor #224.1

3rd Batgirl #1

Best Interior Artwork

1st. Uncanny X-Force #15

2nd Batwoman #1

3rd Animal Man #1

Best Cover Artwork

1st Animal Man #1

2nd Batgirl #1

3rd New Guardians #1

Best Non-DC or Marvel Issue

1st N/A

2nd N/A

3rd N/A

Best Issues of the Month

1st Uncanny X-Force #15

2nd Batwoman #1

3rd Batman #1

I am probably forgetting so many amazing books :(

#24 Posted by cosmo111687 (1489 posts) - - Show Bio

@Hawkeye446: Unfortunately voting ended 3 hours ago and I've already posted results. ...But you know what, I think I'll push back the time to 12:00 PM Pacific Standard Time. :) (It's only fair to West Coasters, really, who might need those extra hours to catch up on reading.)

#25 Posted by Hawkeye446 (3939 posts) - - Show Bio

@cosmo111687 said:

@Hawkeye446: Unfortunately voting ended 3 hours ago and I've already posted results. ...But you know what, I think I'll push back the time to 12:00 PM Pacific Standard Time. :) (It's only fair to West Coasters, really, who might need those extra hours to catch up on reading.)

I live in Australia... South Coast :D Haha, I assumed it hadn't ended, oh well :)

#26 Posted by cosmo111687 (1489 posts) - - Show Bio

@Hawkeye446: haha! well, maybe I'll rethink the way I do time next competition, for non-U. S./Western Hemisphere comic viners, but for now (since I'm just trying to figure out the best way of running this thing) your vote is in. :)

#27 Posted by Hawkeye446 (3939 posts) - - Show Bio

@cosmo111687 said:

@Hawkeye446: haha! well, maybe I'll rethink the way I do time next competition, for non-U. S./Western Hemisphere comic viners, but for now (since I'm just trying to figure out the best way of running this thing) your vote is in. :)

The time restraints were fine, I just didn't see the thread 'til I went on your profile :)

THANKS! :D Give Uncanny X-Force a Little Love :)