This topic is locked from further discussion.

Posted by The Poet (8299 posts) - - Show Bio

First off I want to apologise. This month was chaotic with school essays being due and family related stuff, so the results of October will be released soon (just haven't had the time to compile the votes). However, that does not mean we can't move forward to the Best of the Month of November!

What is this?

This is a poll to decide what is the best issues and comics of a certain month (in this case: ___).

Each vote placing is worth different points (1st place = 3pts, 2nd place = 2pts, 3rd place = 1 pt) and the highest 5 of each category will be declared The Best of The Month!

Voting Resources

In case you don't remember what comics you read this month:

Example Ballot

for comics...

Best Cover Artwork
1st Green Lantern Guinea Pig #1
2nd The Poet’s Perra #1
3rd Batman’s Butler #5

for characters...

Favorite Male Hero
1st Alfred Pennyworth - Batman's Butler #6
2nd The Poet - Handsome Hosts #1
3rd

Reminder: Voting is ONLY for comics in THIS month (meaning NOVEMBER 2012)

Voting Ends: Wednesday, December 5th (exact time will be specified closer to date)

At any time until December 5th, you may edit your vote. If you have any questions, feel free to ask! :)

Voting Ballot

Best Writing

1st

2nd

3rd

Best Interior Artwork

1st

2nd

3rd

Best Cover Artwork

1st

2nd

3rd

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st

2nd

3rd

Favorite DC Comic

1st

2nd

3rd

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st

2nd

3rd

Most Underrated Comic

1st

2nd

3rd

Favorite Male Hero

1st

2nd

3rd

Favorite Female Hero

1st

2nd

3rd

Favorite Male Villain

1st

2nd

3rd

Favorite Female Villain

1st

2nd

3rd

Wild Card Nominations Normally, I let the voters of the winning comic of the Wild Card category choose what should be the next month's Wild Card category However, this being the second to last month we will be doing something different: you get to nominate 3 (or more) Wild Card categories which you think are missing from the above categories (for example, previously we have done the following Wild Cards: Best Team, Best Battle, Best Revised Origins, Best Ending). Think we should add a category? nominate it and you might see it!

1st

2nd

3rd

COMIC VINE VOTES - Best of the Year! 2012

The end of the year is drawing neigh and with that comes the End of the Year Awards. @RazzaTazz and I have not discussed this nor do I know which one of us will host this (side note: Razz, guess what! I have an idea! :P ), but I think I'm sure either of us could make this happen.

However, I thought it would be a nice idea to see what you think and if we should tweak something. The following are the categories from last year's Comic Vine End of the Year Awards hosted by @MrUnknown

Have a suggestion? Feel free to post even if you don't vote in the other items (though I hope you do vote if you can).

Moderator
#1 Posted by kfhrfdu_89_76k (3720 posts) - - Show Bio

Can I nominate a category, too? If so:

Best funny scene of the month.

#2 Posted by The Poet (8299 posts) - - Show Bio

@kfhrfdu_89_76k said:

Can I nominate a category, too? If so:

Best funny scene of the month.

yeah, you can nominate / suggest stuff for the later categories if you want.

Moderator
#3 Posted by htb106 (1641 posts) - - Show Bio

I think we could have something like "Best Shock" for an extra category, I think I know who'll win that though...

#4 Posted by The Poet (8299 posts) - - Show Bio

@htb106: yeah that would be interesting...

Moderator
#5 Edited by xybernick (25 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st Thor: God of Thunder #1

2nd All-New X-Men #2

3rd Fantastic Four #1

Best Interior Artwork

1st Thor: God of Thunder #1

2nd Captain America #1

3rd Deadpool #2

Best Cover Artwork

1st Thor: God of Thunder #1

2nd Uncanny Avengers #2

3rd Indestructible Hulk #1

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Thor: God of Thunder #1

2nd All-New X-Men #1

3rd Hawkeye #4

Favorite Male Hero

1st Thor (Thor: God of Thunder #1 and 2)

2nd Iceman (All-New X-Men #2)

3rd Beast (All-New X-Men #2)

Favorite Female Hero

1st Captain Marvel (Captain Marvel #7)

2nd Lady Sif (Journey into Mystery #646)

3rd Scarlet Witch (Uncanny Avengers #2)

I know I am a LOT biased, and skipped some categories, but Thor: God of Thunder is so refreshing to me considering how downplayed (and not quite poorly written, but boringly written) he has been in the past few years. Ignore my bias and carry on... and I sure hope I'm not the only one submitting these votes, I don't want to throw it off...that much.

#6 Edited by tomlikesfries (4626 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st Batman #14

2nd Thor: God of Thunder #2

3rd Indestructible Hulk

Best Interior Artwork

1st Batman #14 (I really don't like to keep nominating Batman all the time, but both art and plot are brilliant)

2nd Indestructible Hulk #1

3rd Deadpool #1

Best Cover Artwork

1st Indestructible Hulk #1

2nd Deadpool #2

3rd Flash #14

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Hawkeye #4

2nd Thor: God of Thunder #2

3rd All-New X-men #2

Favorite DC Comic

1st Batman #14

2nd Swamp Thing #14

3rd The Flash #14

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Shadowman #1

2nd Judge Dredd #1

3rd I really didn't read any other comics. I am still catching up to TWD, Invincible and American Vampire.

Most Underrated Comic

1st Shadowman #1

2nd Uncanny Avengers #2

3rd All-New X-men #1

Favorite Male Hero

1st Batman (Batman)

2nd Thor (Thor: God of Thunder)

3rd Hawkeye (Hawkeye by Fraction)

Favorite Female Hero

1st Batgirl

2nd Wonder Woman

3rd Supergirl

Favorite Male Villain

1st Joker (Batman)

2nd The God Butcher (Thor: God of Thunder)

3rd Andrew Bennett (I mean, although he's the protagonist of I, Vampire, he is a villain right?)

Favorite Female Villain

1st Poison Ivy (Detective Comics)

2nd Cheetah (Justice League)

3rd Lady Shiva (Nightwing)

Funniest Comic

1st FF #1

2nd Deadpool #1

3rd Deadpool #2

#7 Posted by The Poet (8299 posts) - - Show Bio

@xybernick: thanks for voting! do you have any catagory suggestions for our wild card section which revolves every month? or any comments on the end of the year awards thing? Just curious...

@tomlikesfries: thank you also for voting. i'm assuming you are nominating funnist comic to be a wild card at a future date. that would be an interesting catagory to do...would be fasinating to see what people vote for that...

ALSO for both of you: I need you guys to list where the characters appeared for the hero/villain catagories. Some of them are straight forward (Hawkeye instance), but others are not so like (like batman/Joker for instance. they are appearing in a number of issues...I can ASSUME which appearence you want, but i don't want to assume....you get what I'm saying?). Also, since I don't read Marvel (aside from Gambit) I'm not sure where Thor appeared this month...

Moderator
#8 Posted by tomlikesfries (4626 posts) - - Show Bio

@The Poet: Done.

And yeah, Funniest Comic is my wild card. I was thinking about Worst Comic, but most people only buy the comics they like.

#9 Posted by RazzaTazz (9490 posts) - - Show Bio

Voting Ballot

Best Writing

1st  Mind the Gap

2nd Danger Girl GI Joe

3rd Sleepy Hollow

Best Interior Artwork

1st  Mind the Gap

2nd Danger Girl GI Joe

3rd  Justice League

Best Cover Artwork

1st  Mind the Gap

2nd Wonder Woman

3rd Sleepy Hollow

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Uncanny Avengers (its the only one I read and I still didn't want to put it first)

2nd

3rd

Favorite DC Comic

1st Wonder Woman

2nd Green Lantern New Guardians

3rd Aquaman

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic 

1st  Mind the Gap

2nd Danger Girl GI Joe

3rd Sleepy Hollow

Most Underrated Comic

1st  Mind the Gap

2nd Danger Girl GI Joe

3rd Sleepy Hollow

Favorite Male Hero

1st Kyle Rayner

2nd  Chas Worthington (Great Pacific)

3rd Aquaman

Favorite Female Hero

1st Wonder Woman

2nd Sydney Savage (my votes for Sydney are always in vain)

3rd Samantha Darren (also in vain)

Favorite Male Villain

1st Storm Shadow

2nd Ocean Master

3rd Red Skull

Favorite Female Villain

1st  Baroness

2nd Queen of Spades (Wonderland)

3rd Baba Yaga (various GFT - but mostly Bad Girls and Myths and Legends)

Wild Card Nominations 

1st Best moment that reminds you why you read comics

2nd Best forgotten genre (identify genre and title - for instance Post Apocalyptic in  Beowulf backup story for Sword of Sorcery)

3rd Best cliffhanger

Moderator
#10 Posted by The Poet (8299 posts) - - Show Bio

@RazzaTazz: cool. thanks for voting.

You could, if you really wanted to, move Uncanny Avengers down a position if you wanted to...I mean the places do represent point values (1st = 3 pts) I will be honest and say there are some times when I don't give a character their full points (some times i'll give them a 2 or a 1), so you could move the title down to 2nd or 3rd even if you didn't read other Marvel titles. Just a thought of course...

Moderator
#11 Posted by VictorVonDoom_1 (142 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st All New X-Men #1

2nd Indestructible Hulk #1

3rd Batman The Dark Knight #14

Best Interior Artwork

1st Thor: God of Thunder #1

2nd Hawkeye #4

3rd All New X-Men #2

Best Cover Artwork

1st Deadpool #2

2nd Wolverine MAX #2

3rd Batman #14

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Deadpool #2

2nd All New X-Men #1

3rd Thor God of Thunder #1

Favorite DC Comic

1st Batman The Dark Knight #q4

2nd Aquaman #14

3rd The Savage Hawkman #14

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Bedlam #1

2nd Great Pacific #1

3rd -

Most Underrated Comic

1st Bedlam #1

2nd Hawkeye #4

3rd -

Favorite Male Hero

1st Thor God of Thunder #2

2nd Hawkeye #4

3rd -

Favorite Female Hero

1st Captain Marvel #7

2nd Super Girl #14

3rd Lady Sif (Journey into the Mystery #646)

Favorite Male Villain

1st God Butcher (Thor God of Thunder)

2nd Madder Red (Bedlam #1)

3rd Doc Ock (Amazing Spider-Man #698)

Favorite Female Villain

1st Poison Ivy (Detective Comics)

2nd -

3rd -

Funniest Comic

1st Deadpool #2

2nd Deadpool #1

3rd -

#12 Posted by cyberchop979 (451 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st Batman #14

2nd FF#1

3rd Thor God of Thunder #1

Best Interior Artwork

1st FF #1

2nd All New X-Men #1

3rd Saga #7

Best Cover Artwork

1st All New X-men #1 Skottie Young Variant

2nd Saga #7

3rd Batwoman #14

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st FF

2nd Hawkeye

3rd All New X-Men

Favorite DC Comic

1st Batman

2nd Wonder Woman

3rd Flash

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Saga

2nd Harvest

3rd Creep

Most Underrated Comic

1st X-Factor

2nd I, Vampire

3rd Red Hood and the Outlaws

Favorite Male Hero

1st Batman

2nd Spider-Man

3rd Hawkeye

Favorite Female Hero

1st Wonder Woman

2nd Captain Marvel

3rd Batwoman

Favorite Male Villain

1st Joker

2nd Gorr the God Butcher

3rd Magneto

#13 Posted by The Poet (8299 posts) - - Show Bio

@VictorVonDoom_1: Thank you for voting. I do want to clarify one point which is Funniest Comic. Now, the Wild Card category is a category is one which revolves every month so we are not doing the same thing.

However, this month's Wild Card is different in the sense that I want people to suggest possible ones. Funniest Comic was nominated by @VictorVonDoom_1: and, while we all love my man Deadpool, deadpool won't be winning this month's wildcard (it's more a suggestion category this month). So if you have a suggestion on what category(ies) we should do for the wild card next month or next year this is the time to do it. Hopefully that is clear.

@cyberchop979: thanks also for voting! any suggestions for any future wild cards?

Moderator
#14 Posted by VictorVonDoom_1 (142 posts) - - Show Bio

@The Poet: Got it.

Here are my future wild card suggestions:

  • Favorite Team-Up (from a solo character comic)
  • Best Threat/Insult
#15 Posted by The Poet (8299 posts) - - Show Bio

@VictorVonDoom_1: cool! thanks :D

Moderator
#16 Posted by Jonny_Anonymous (32891 posts) - - Show Bio

someone remind me to do this later

#17 Posted by BlackRowan (51 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st Batman The Dark Knight #14

2nd Thor: God of Thunder #2

3rd Fantastic Four #1

Best Interior Artwork

1st Deadpool#1

2nd Indestructible Hulk #1

3rd Captain America #1

Best Cover Artwork

1st Flash #14

2nd Batman #14

3rd Batwoman #14

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Hawkeye #4

2nd Wolverine Max #2

3rd All New X-Men #1

Favorite DC Comic

1st Birds of Prey #14

2nd Batgirl #14

3rd Swamp Thing #14

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Shadowman #1

2nd-

3rd-

Most Underrated Comic

1st Birds of Prey #14

2nd Batman #14

3rd-

Favorite Male Hero

1st Batman

2nd Captain America

3rd Wolverine

Favorite Female Hero

1st Black Canary

2nd Starling

3rd Katana

Favorite Male Villain

1st Joker

2nd-

3rd-

Favorite Female Villain

1st Poison Ivy

2nd-

3rd-

#18 Posted by DarkBirdGera (14 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st Batman The Dark Knight #14

2nd Thor: God of Thunder #2

3rd Fantastic Four #1

Best Interior Artwork

1st Deadpool#1

2nd Batwoman #14

3rd Captain America #1

Best Cover Artwork

1st Flash #14

2nd -

3rd -

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st All New X-Men #1

2nd Wolverine Max #2

3rd -

Favorite DC Comic

1st Birds of Prey #14

2nd Batgirl #14

3rd -

Most Underrated Comic

1st Birds of Prey #14

2nd Green Arrow #14

3rd Batman #14

Favorite Male Hero

1st Hawkeye

2nd Captain America

3rd Green Arrow

Favorite Female Hero

1st Black Canary

2nd Mockingbird

3rd Emma Frost

Favorite Male Villain

1st Joker

2nd-

3rd-

Favorite Female Villain

1st Poison Ivy

2nd Lady Shiva

3rd-

#19 Posted by The Poet (8299 posts) - - Show Bio

@BlackRowan: @DarkBirdGera: thanks for voting, though I will say I am only counting one of your accounts (no matter how much you want to, you can't vote twice). I would love to see any suggestions you might have for catagories so you could add that if you feel like voting some more...

@Jonny_Anonymous: I'll try to if I remember...

Moderator
#20 Posted by kfhrfdu_89_76k (3720 posts) - - Show Bio

Faf mod: Icarusflies.

Bet you couldn`t see that coming.

#21 Posted by The Poet (8299 posts) - - Show Bio

@kfhrfdu_89_76k said:

Faf mod: Icarusflies.

Bet you couldn`t see that coming.

Voting has not started yet, so can't beat me just yet (wait a week so I'll be ready to take on last year's mod champ...You have a Green Lantern Guinea Pig? That's nothing! I have a Pirate Dog :P )

Moderator
#22 Posted by kfhrfdu_89_76k (3720 posts) - - Show Bio

But you wrote that nominations could be made...

Oh well.

About your pets, that would be a tough fight.

#23 Posted by The Poet (8299 posts) - - Show Bio

@kfhrfdu_89_76k: well, for that section I was more thinking suggestions if anyone had any ideas of what to tweak. you can nominate categories for the wild card section or categories for the Awards thing Razz and I are playing with, but the actual voting won't be until next week or so...

Moderator
#24 Posted by Yai_Inn (352 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1. Uncanny X-Force #33 + #34 (can I nominate two titles in the same spot if there double shipped ones?)

2. Justice League Dark #14

3. X-O Manowar #7

Best Interior Artwork

1. Thor: God of Thunder #1 + #2

2. The Flash #14

3. New Avengers #34

Best Cover Artwork

1. X-Men Legacy #1

2. Minimum Carnage Omega #1

3. Before Watchman: Oxymandias #4

Favorite Marvel Comic

1. X-Men #38

2. Gambit #6

3. Hawkeye #4

Favorite DC Comic

1. Flash #14

2. Batgirl #14

3. Animal Man #14

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1. X-O Manowar

2. Archer + Armstrong #4

3. Shadowman #1

Most Underrated Comic

1. X-Men #38

2. X-Factor #246 + #247

3. Suicide Squad #14

Favorite Male Hero

1. Nightcrawler - Uncanny X-Force #33

2. Peter Stanchek - Harbinger #6

3. Cyclops - AvX Consequences #5

Favorite Female Hero

1. Batgirl - Batgirl #14

2. Domino - X-Men #38

3. Amethyst - Sword of Sorcery #2

Favorite Male Villain

1. Coyote - Dare Devil #20

2. Daken - Uncanny X-Force #34

3. Joker - Batman #14, Batgirl #14, Suicide Squad #14

Favorite Female Villain

1. Merlin - Iron Man #2

2. Madame Mask - Hawkeye #4

3. Mystique - Uncanny X-Force #33

Funniest Comic

1. Fantastic Four #1

2. Deadpool #1 + #2

3. X-Factor #246 + #247

Biggest Let Downs / Most Disappointing / Worst of the Month (My Nomination Category)

1. Catwoman #14

2. X-Men Legacy #2

3. Venom #27

#25 Edited by SavageDragon (2248 posts) - - Show Bio

Voting Ballot

Best Writing

1st BKV Saga

2nd Scott Snyder Batman

3rd Brian Michael Bendis All New X- Men

Best Interior Artwork

1st I, Vampire

2nd Saga

3rd Earth 2

Best Cover Artwork

1st Flash

2nd Cyber Force

3rd

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st All New X-Men

2nd Thor

3rd

Favorite DC Comic

1st Batman

2nd Demon Knights

3rd I, Vampire/Earth 2

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Savage Dragon

2nd Fatale

3rd Bloodshot/Walking Dead

Most Underrated Comic

1st Bloodshot

2nd Demon Knights

3rd I, Vampire

Favorite Male Hero

1st Batman

2nd Dragon (From Savage Dragon)

3rd Calvin Rose (From Talon)

Favorite Female Hero

1st Alana (from Saga)

2nd

3rd

Favorite Male Villain

1st Joker

2nd Andre Bennet (from I, Vampire)

3rd Hansel (From Fatale)

Favorite Female Villain

1st

2nd

3rd

#26 Posted by SavageDragon (2248 posts) - - Show Bio

I would Like to vote every month in your poll. If you could shoot me a message to next months a poll when it goes up I would appreciate it

#27 Posted by The Poet (8299 posts) - - Show Bio

@SavageDragon: I normally pm the voters from the previous month to let them know the new poll is up, so as long as you vote I'll try to pm you (though sometimes it gets a little crazy...)

also I thank you and you, @Yai_Inn: for voting!

Moderator
#28 Posted by JairamGanpat (952 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st Mind the Gap #6

2nd Hawkeye #4

3rd Bedlam #2

Best Interior Artwork

1st Flash #14

2nd Bedlam #2

3rd Indestructible Hulk #1

Best Cover Artwork

1st Indestructible Hulk #1

2nd Clone #1

3rd Nowhere Men #1

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Hawkeye #4

2nd FF #1

3rd Indestructible Hulk #1

Favorite DC Comic

1st Swamp Thing #14

2nd Animal Man #14

3rd The Flash #14

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Mind the Gap #6

2nd Bedlam #2

3rd Saga #7

Most Underrated Comic

1st Mind The Gap #6

2nd Clone #1

3rd Nowhere Men #1

Favorite Male Hero

1st Hawkeye from Hawkeye #4

2nd Flash from The Flash #14

3rd Hulk from The Indestructible Hulk #1

Favorite Female Hero

1st Elle Peterssen from Mind The Gap #6

2nd Kate Bishop from Hawkeye #4

3rd Alana from Saga #7

Favorite Male Villain

1st Madder Red from Bedlam #2

2nd Gorilla Grodd from The Flash #14

3rd Joker from Batman #14

Favorite Female Villain

1st Lady Shiva from Nightwing #14

2nd Madame Masque from Hawkeye #4

3rd Don't have a 3rd. Women are underrepresented RABBLE RABBLE RABBLE

#29 Posted by broo1232 (1520 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st Batman #14

2nd Swamp-thing #14

3rd Indestructible Hulk #1

Best Interior Artwork

1st All new X-men #1

2nd Swamp-thing #14

3rd Indestructible Hulk #1

Best Cover Artwork

1st Batman #14

2nd Daredevil #20

3rd Uncanny Avengers #2

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Indestructible Hulk #1

2nd All new X-men #2

3rd Deadpool #1

Favorite DC Comic

1st Batman #14

2nd Swamp-thing #14

3rd Batwoman #14

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Masks #1

2nd Shadowman #1

3rd Judge Dredd #1

Most Underrated Comic

1st Uncanny X-force #34

2nd Deadpool #2

3rd Uncanny Avengers #2

Favorite Male Hero

1st Swamp-thing

2nd Batman

3rd Hulk

Favorite Female Hero

1st Wonder Woman

2nd Rogue

3rd Psylocke

Favorite Male Villain

1st Joker

2nd Anton Arcane

3rd Red skull

Favorite Female Villain

1st Mystique

2nd Poison Ivy

3rd-

Wild Card Nominations

1st Best Cliffhanger

2nd Best splash page

3rd Funniest moment.

#30 Posted by The Poet (8299 posts) - - Show Bio

@broo1232: thanks for voting :D

Moderator
#31 Posted by The Poet (8299 posts) - - Show Bio

@JairamGanpat said:

3rd Don't have a 3rd. Women are underrepresented RABBLE RABBLE RABBLE

yeah it is sort of pitiful. When I actully compile the results, I see how many people vote for each catagory and how fewer people vote for female heros/villains than their male counterparts. Not to be sexist, but the males are always stonger in these polls. We do have wonder woman, Talia, Batwoman, Captain Marvel, heck even Batgirl. But, we don't have a Talon, Joker or even a batman. In other words: we don't have a result whose total is so much higher than the others that we have a clear victor. When Captain Marvel had the #1 issue, then she won the female catagory very strongly similar to how Talon won when Night of Owls was prevalent in readership. However, she couldn't sustain being a strong victor like she did that month unlike Batman or Talon. If you look at the previous polls in this contest's more than year long history (side note check out my bio for the result blogs. I'm keeping a little library there), then you will see how Batman had a winning streak in a number of the catagories. Talia also had a winning streak, but comparing the numbers she was no Talon and of course no batman. What would be fasinating would be if we could see everyone's pull lists and see how many of those pulls have a female lead...

oh, right...thanks for voting :P

Moderator
#32 Posted by DonFelipe (1096 posts) - - Show Bio

Well, I do read DC - Marvel not so much - but my favorites are definitely not from the big 2.

Voting Ballot

Best Writing

1st - Saga

2nd - Bedlam

3rd - Snyder's Batman (well... exception for greatness)

Best Interior Artwork

1st - Saga

2nd - Point of Impact

3rd - Comeback

Best Cover Artwork

1st - Creator-Owned Heroes #6: Black Sparrow

2nd - Colder

3rd - Saga

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st -

2nd -

3rd - Indestructible Hulk

Favorite DC Comic

1st - Wonder Woman

2nd - Frankenstein, Agent of Shade

3rd - Animal Man

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st - Saga

2nd - The Massive

3rd - Shadowman

Most Underrated Comic

1st - The Massive

2nd - Creator-Owned Heroes

3rd - Thief of Thieves

Favorite Male Hero

1st - Madder Red (he's my hero for now!)

2nd - Marko (Saga)

3rd - Shadowman

Favorite Female Hero

1st - Michonne

2nd - Alana (Saga)

3rd - Wonder Woman

Favorite Male Villain

1st - definitely that giant, naked triclops from Saga

2nd - Madder Red (he is/was also a really good villain)

3rd - Buddy, the Bear (Non-Humans) LOL

Favorite Female Villain

1st - like favorite male villain, this one's wicked: Siracca (from Wonder Woman, and even though Siracca eventually ends up being WW's ally)

2nd - Mary, Queen of Blood

3rd - Voodoo

Wild Cards

1st - Quote of the month (Marko in Saga: "Mother please!")

2nd - Best #1 (Comeback)

3rd - Best story arc (Rotworld)

#33 Posted by The Poet (8299 posts) - - Show Bio

@DonFelipe: thanks for voting!

Moderator
#34 Edited by MadeinBangladesh (6165 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st. Hawkeye #4

2nd. All-New Xmen #2

3rd. Daredevil #20

Best Interior Artwork

1st.Batwoman #13

2nd.Masks #1

3rd.Swamp Thing #14

Best Cover Artwork

1st. Colder #1

2nd. Silk Spectre #4

3rd. Batwoman #14

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st. Hawkeye #4

2nd. All New XMEN #2

3rd. Uncanny X-force #34

Favorite DC Comic

1st.Batman #14

2nd. Silk Spectre #4

3rd. Animal Man#14

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st. Walking Dead #104

2nd.Number 13 #1

3rd.Clone #1

Most Underrated Comic

1st. Number 13 #1

2nd.Colder #1

3rd. Clone #1

Favorite Male Hero

1st. Carl (Walking Dead)

2nd. Marko (Saga)

3rd. Clint Barton (Hawkeye)

Favorite Female Hero

1st. Barbra Gordon (Batgirl)

2nd. Silk Spectre (Silk Spectre)

3rd. Kate Kane (Batwoman)

Favorite Male Villain

1st.Joker (Batman)

2nd. Red Skull (Uncanny Avengers)

3rd Negan (Walking Dead)

Favorite Female Villain

1st.

2nd

3rd

Wild Card Nominations Normally, I let the voters of the winning comic of the Wild Card category choose what should be the next month's Wild Card category However, this being the second to last month we will be doing something different: you get to nominate 3 (or more) Wild Card categories which you think are missing from the above categories (for example, previously we have done the following Wild Cards: Best Team, Best Battle, Best Revised Origins, Best Ending). Think we should add a category? nominate it and you might see it!

1st. Best Ending

2nd.Best Quote

3rd.Best Team

#35 Posted by The Poet (8299 posts) - - Show Bio

@MadeinBangladesh: cool! thanks for voting!

Moderator
#36 Posted by batflash09 (25 posts) - - Show Bio

Voting Ballot

Best Writing

1st - Scott Snyder - Batman #14

2nd - Geoff Johns - Aquaman #14

3rd - Francis Manapul/Brian Buccelatto - Flash #14

Best Interior Artwork

1st - Francis Manapul - Flash #14

2nd - Greg Capullo - Batman #14

3rd - Doug Mahnke - Green Lantern #14

Best Cover Artwork

1st - Art Adams - FF #1

2nd - Alex Ross - Peter Cannon Thunderbolt #3

3rd - J.H. Williams - Batwoman #14

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st I need to start reading more Marvel

2nd

3rd

Favorite DC Comic

1st - Batman #14

2nd - Flash #14

3rd - Justice League #14

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st - Cobra #19

2nd - G.I. Joe #19

3rd - Snake Eyes & Storm Shadow #19

Most Underrated Comic

1st - Cobra

2nd - Flash

3rd - Team Seven

Favorite Male Hero

1st - Batman

2nd - Flash

3rd - Aquaman

Favorite Female Hero

1st - Wonder Woman

2nd - Scarlett (G.I. Joe #19)

3rd - Batgirl

Favorite Male Villain

1st - The Joker

2nd - Black Manta

3rd -

Favorite Female Villain

1st - Cheetah (Justice League #14)

2nd -

3rd

Wild Card Nominations Normally, I let the voters of the winning comic of the Wild Card category choose what should be the next month's Wild Card category However, this being the second to last month we will be doing something different: you get to nominate 3 (or more) Wild Card categories which you think are missing from the above categories (for example, previously we have done the following Wild Cards: Best Team, Best Battle, Best Revised Origins, Best Ending). Think we should add a category? nominate it and you might see it!

1st Best Action Sequence

2nd Most Anticipated Series

3rd Best One-Liner

#37 Posted by The Poet (8299 posts) - - Show Bio

@batflash09: thanks for voting!

Moderator
#38 Edited by G_Money_Christmas (881 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st Batman #14

2nd Hawkeye #4

3rd All New X-Men #2

Best Interior Artwork

1st Superman #14 (Love Rocafort... Hawkeye #4 would be here if Aja drew it.)

2nd Batman #14

3rd All new X-Men #2

Best Cover Artwork

1st Batman #14

2nd Uncanny Avengers #2

3rd Superman # 14

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Hawkeye #4

2nd All New X-Men #2

3rd Uncanny Avengers #2

Favorite DC Comic

1st Batman #14

2nd Superman #14

3rd Supergirl #14

Favorite Male Hero

1st Hawkeye

2nd Superman

3rd Gambit

Favorite Female Hero

1st Supergirl

2nd Black Widow

3rd Rogue

Favorite Male Villain

1st Joker

2nd H'El

3rd Red Skull

Favorite Female Villain

1st Cheetah

2nd

3rd

I've read a lot of comics this month. It's hard to remember everything about all of them.

#39 Posted by inferiorego (21254 posts) - - Show Bio

Voting Ballot

Best Writing

1st Saga

2nd All New X-Men

3rd Aquaman

Best Interior Artwork

1st Masks

2nd Saga

3rd Avenging Spider-Man

Best Cover Artwork

1st

2nd

3rd

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Amazing Spider-Man

2nd All New X-Men

3rd Ultimates

Favorite DC Comic

1st Aquaman

2nd Animal Man

3rd Justice League Dark

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Walking Dead

2nd Saga

3rd Judge Dredd

Most Underrated Comic

1st Saga

2nd GI Combat

3rd Demon Knights

Favorite Male Hero

1st Marko (Saga)

2nd Spider-Man

3rd Rick Grimes

Favorite Female Hero

1st Michonne!

2nd Michonne!

3rd Michonne!

Favorite Male Villain

1st Negan (Walking Dead)

2nd

3rd

Favorite Female Villain

1st

2nd

3rd

Wild Card Nominations

1st Best Story Arc

2nd

3rd

Staff
#40 Posted by The Poet (8299 posts) - - Show Bio

@G_Money_Christmas: @inferiorego: thanks so much for voting guys!

15 voters. Pretty good. I'm expecting a few more so it'll be a nice selection...

Moderator
#41 Posted by The Poet (8299 posts) - - Show Bio

@Jonny_Anonymous said:

someone remind me to do this later

is this later?

Moderator
#42 Posted by Jonny_Anonymous (32891 posts) - - Show Bio

it sure is

Voting Ballot

Best Writing

1st Saga

2nd Harbringer

3rd Fatale

Best Interior Artwork

1st Masks

2nd Saga

3rd Invincible

Best Cover Artwork

1st Masks

2nd Saga

3rd Bedlam

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Fantastic Four

2nd Indestructible Hulk

3rd Thor God of Thunder

Favorite DC Comic

1st Hellblazer (does that count?)

2nd

3rd

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Saga

2nd Masks

3rd 2000AD

Most Underrated Comic

1st 2000AD

2nd Hypernaturals

3rd The Spider

Favorite Male Hero

1st Marko

2nd The Spider

3rd Peter Stanchek

Favorite Female Hero

1st Faith Herbert

2nd Alana (Saga)

3rd Josephine

Favorite Male Villain

1st Harada

2nd Bishop (Fatale)

3rd Madder Red

Favorite Female Villain

1st

2nd

3rd

Wild Card Nominations

1st Best Story Arc

2nd Best TPB

3rd

#43 Posted by The Poet (8299 posts) - - Show Bio

@Jonny_Anonymous: thanks so much for voting!

16 voters! Huzzah!

Voting will end tommorow (wednesday). I can't give an exact time like I normally do because some lazy person decided to have a busy (yet fun) weekend and forgot to pick up his comics from the last week of November so we'll keep the polls open so he can vote :P

hopefully that means others will vote as well

Moderator
#44 Posted by The Poet (8299 posts) - - Show Bio

Just to documentation I will post mine (forgot to, but remember as I was compiling the results...)

Voting Ballot

Best Writing

1st Batman 14

2nd Justice League 14

3rd Steed and Mrs. Peel 3

Best Interior Artwork

1st Flash 14

2nd Justice League 14

3rd Nightwing 14

Best Cover Artwork

1st Smallville Season Eleven 8

2nd Batman Beyond Unlimited 10

3rd Batman 14

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Gambit 6

2nd

3rd

Favorite DC Comic

1st Batman 14

2nd Justice League 14

3rd Nightwing 14

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Steed and Mrs. Peel 3

2nd

3rd

Most Underrated Comic

1st Batman Beyond Unlimited 10

2nd Steed and Mrs. Peel 3

3rd Nightwing 14

Favorite Male Hero

1st Batman - Batman 14

2nd Gambit - Gambit 6

3rd Nightwing - Nightwing 14

Favorite Female Hero

1st Emma Peel - Steed and Mrs. Peel 3

2nd Babs/Nightwing - Smallville Season Eleven 8

3rd big barda - Batman Beyond Unlimited 10

Favorite Male Villain

1st Joker - Batman 14

2nd Grodd - Flash 14

3rd Prankster - - Smallville Season Eleven 8

Favorite Female Villain

1st Shiva - Nightwing 14

2nd Cheetah - Justice League 14

3rd Kobra queen lady - - Batman Beyond Unlimited 10

Wild Card Nominations Normally, I let the voters of the winning comic of the Wild Card category choose what should be the next month's Wild Card category However, this being the second to last month we will be doing something different: you get to nominate 3 (or more) Wild Card categories which you think are missing from the above categories (for example, previously we have done the following Wild Cards: Best Team, Best Battle, Best Revised Origins, Best Ending). Think we should add a category? nominate it and you might see it!

I decline since I already have my suggestions...

Moderator