• 55 results
  • 1
  • 2

This topic is locked from further discussion.

Posted by The Poet (8288 posts) - - Show Bio

Ladies and Gentlemen! Hopefully two anchored activities won't be too much.

What is this?

This is a poll to decide what is the best issues and comics of a certain month (in this case: August).

Each vote placing is worth different points (1st place = 3pts, 2nd place = 2pts, 3rd place = 1 pt) and the highest 5 of each category will be declared The Best of The Month!

Voting Resources

In case you don't remember what comics you read this month:

Example Ballot

for comics...

Best Cover Artwork

1st Green Lantern Guinea Pig #1

2nd The Poet’s Perra #1

3rd Batman’s Butler #5

for characters...

Favorite Male Hero

1st Alfred Pennyworth - Batman's Butler #6

2nd The Poet - Handsome Hosts #1

3rd

Reminder: Voting is ONLY for comics in THIS month (meaning August 2012)

Voting Ends: September 5th 2012 (exact time will be specified closer to date)

At any time until Sep 5th, you may edit your vote. If you have any questions, feel free to ask! :)

Voting Ballot

Best Writing

1st

2nd

3rd

Best Interior Artwork

1st

2nd

3rd

Best Cover Artwork

1st

2nd

3rd

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st

2nd

3rd

Favorite DC Comic

1st

2nd

3rd

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st

2nd

3rd

Most Underrated Comic

1st

2nd

3rd

Favorite Male Hero

1st

2nd

3rd

Favorite Female Hero

1st

2nd

3rd

Favorite Male Villain

1st

2nd

3rd

Favorite Female Villain

1st

2nd

3rd

Wild Card: Best Fight Scene (this category changes every month and will be decided by the nominators of last month’s Wild Card winner. This month's category brought to you by SupahForeigner and TheAcidSkull)

1st

2nd

3rd

Moderator
#1 Edited by johnkmccubbin91 (3486 posts) - - Show Bio

Voting Ballot

Best Writing

1st Winter Soldier #9

2nd Spider-Men #4

3rd Punisher #14

Best Interior Artwork

1st Batwoman #12

2nd Aquaman #12

3rd Flash #12

Best Cover Artwork

1st Flash #12

2nd Justice League #12

3rd Punisher #14

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Amazing Spider-Man #692

2nd Punisher #14

3rd Amazing Spider-Man #691

Favorite DC Comic

1st Before Watchmen: Rorschach

2nd Flash #12

3rd Batman Incorporated #3

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Walking Dead #101

2nd Thief of Thieves #7

3rd America's Got Power #3

Most Underrated Comic

1st Gambit #1

2nd Supercrooks #4

3rd Deadpool Kills The Marvel Universe #4

Favorite Male Hero

1st Batman (Batman Incorporated #3)

2nd Spider-Man (Amazing Spider-Man #692)

3rd Punisher (Punisher #14)

Favorite Female Hero

1st Catwoman (Catwoman #12)

2nd Batwoman (Batwoman #12)

3rd Spider-Woman (Avengers #29)

Favorite Male Villain

1st Captain Cold (Flash #12)

2nd Black Hand (Green Lantern #12)

3rd Black Manta (Aquaman #12)

If this and the next one are questions for characters that don't have to have been in a comic then my answers are different otherwise this

Favorite Female Villain

1st Dollhouse (Catwoman #12)

2nd Bloddy Mary (Batwoman #12)

3rd Can't think of a third

Wild Card: Best Fight Scene (this category changes every month and will be decided by the nominators of last month’s Wild Card winner. This month's category brought to you by SupahForeigner and TheAcidSkull)

1st Gladiator vs Praetorian (Supercrooks #4)

2nd Terminus vs Batman & Robin w/ Nightwing, Red Robin and Red Hood (Batman & Robin #12)

3rd Wolverine vs Sabertooth (Wolverine #312)

#2 Posted by The Poet (8288 posts) - - Show Bio

@johnkmccubbin91: thanks for voting.

Well, the best characters (heroes and villains both male and female) are for the month and thus have to have appearences (I can't just vote for the riddler because I like him...he has to have a villainous appearance in comics in the month of August).

Also something that you and other voters voters from the past do is include the names of the writers and the artists. To be perfectly frank, that bit of info I don't include when I copy voters ballots onto my excel document to tabulate the vote. A lot of people don't include those names and thus its more work for me to look up the winners who don't have those writers and artists. So I just focus on the titles (for example: I only focus on Winter Soldier #8). Now, if the title wins the first slot I add it, but other wise I don't include it. You can keep posting the names of everyone because they are all really talented people. I just thought I'd explain that I really only sort the votes by their titles).

Of course you don't change anything to that. Just wanted to say what I do.

Oh, something you do need to add is appearances for characters. I need "Character -- place they appeared in". It's a preference of mine, so I don't have to do so much look to look up 25 characters' appearances. Also, for characters like Spider-man and Batman who appear in a number of titles, it is really important to list the appearances because they do appear in a number of series in one month (spidy has 2 Amazing issues plus Avenging plus whatever else) and Batman appears in a number of series so what I need is which version (Batman Inc Batman? Batman Batman? other Batman?). So yeah...

Again, thanks for voting!

Moderator
#3 Posted by DoomDoomDoom (4212 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st - Animal Man #12

2nd - Dial H #4

3rd - Debris #2

Best Interior Artwork

1st - Debris #2

2nd - Batwoman #12

3rd - Dial H #4

Best Cover Artwork

1st - Before Watchmen: Ozymandias #2

2nd - Resurrection Man # 12

3rd - Mondo #3

Favorite DC Comic

1st - Dial H #4

2nd - Animal Man #12

3rd - Earth 2 #4

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st - Debris #2

2nd - Fables #120

Most Underrated Comic

1st - Debris #2

2nd - Dial H #4

3rd - Stormwatch #12

Wild Card: Best Fight Scene (this category changes every month and will be decided by the nominators of last month’s Wild Card winner. This month's category brought to you by SupahForeigner and TheAcidSkull)

1st - Maya Vs. Junk Monsters (Debris #2)

#4 Edited by MadeinBangladesh (5874 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st. BATMAN #1

2nd.HAWKEYE#1

3rd. PUNISHER #14

Best Interior Artwork

1st.HARVEST #12

2nd. BATWOMAN #12

3rd. BW DR. MANHATTAN #1

Best Cover Artwork

1st. BATWOMAN #12

2nd. BW RORSCHACH #1

3rd. HAWKEYE #1

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st. HAWKEYE #12

2nd. SPIDER-MEN #4

3rd. PUNISHER #14

Favorite DC Comic

1st. Batman #12

2nd. BW Rorschach #1

3rd. ALL-Star Western #12

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st. HARVEST #12

2nd.CREEP #0

3rd. WALKING DEAD #101

Most Underrated Comic

1st. HARVEST #1

2nd. CREEP #0

3rd. ALLSTAR WESTERN #12

Favorite Male Hero

1st. CLINT (HAWKEYE#1)

2nd. WALTER KOVACS (BW RORSCHACH#1)

3rd. GAMBIT (GAMBIT #1 and #2)

Favorite Female Hero

1st. BARBRA GORDON (BATGIRL #12)

2nd. TALLULAH BLACK (ALLSTAR WESTERN #12)

3rd. HARPER ROW (BATMAN#12)

Favorite Male Villain

1. SHADOW KING (UNCANNY X-FORCE#30)

2.DAVID GRAVES (JL#12)

3. Negan (WALKING DEAD)

Favorite Female Villain

1st. KNIGHFALL (BATGIRL)

2nd.POISION IVY ( BIRDS OF PREY #12)

3rd.

Wild Card: Best Fight Scene (this category changes every month and will be decided by the nominators of last month’s Wild Card winner. This month's category brought to you by SupahForeigner and TheAcidSkull)

1st. ANIMAL MAN AND SWAMP THING vs UN-MEN, ARCANE, THE ROT

2nd. GRAVES vs JUSTICE LEAGUE (JUSTICE LEAGUE #12)

3rd. BATGIRL vs BATWOMAN and KNIGH FALL's LACKEYS (BATGIRL #12)

#5 Edited by TheAcidSkull (17166 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st Amazing spider-man #692

2nd Ed Brubaker (Winter Soldier #8)

3rd Hulk 57#

Best Interior Artwork

1st J. H. Williams III (Batwoman #12)

2nd Ivan Reis (Aquaman #12)

3rd Francis Manapul (Flash #12)

Best Cover Artwork

1st The Incredible Hulk #12

2nd AvX 5#

3rd amazing spider-man #692

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Amazing Spider-Man #692

2ndAmazing Spider-Man #691

3rd hulk 57 #

Favorite DC Comic

1st Before Watchmen: Rorschach

2nd Flash #12

3rd Batman Incorporated #3

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Walking Dead #101

2nd America's Got Power #3

3rd Thief of Thieves #7

Most Underrated Comic

1st Gambit #1

2nd Supercrooks #4

3rd Deadpool Kills The Marvel Universe #4

Favorite Male Hero

1st Spider-Man

2nd Batman

3rd --

Favorite Female Hero

1st captain Marvel

2nd Catwoman

3rd Spider-Woman

If this and the next one are questions for characters that don't have to have been in a comic then my answers are different otherwise this

Wild Card: Best Fight Scene (this category changes every month and will be decided by the nominators of last month’s Wild Card winner. This month's category brought to you by SupahForeigner and TheAcidSkull)

1st Lizard Vs Spider-man

2nd Hulk Vs Thing and Wolverine ( The Incredibele Hulk #12)

3rd Wolverine vs Sabertooth (Wolverine #312)

#6 Posted by Outside_85 (8017 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st Brian Azzarello (Wonder Woman)

2nd Jeff Lemire (JLD/Animal Man)

3rd James D. Robinson (Earth-2)

Best Interior Artwork

1st Mikel Janin (JLD)

2nd Cliff Chiang (Wonder Woman)

3rd Nicola Scott (Earth-2)

Best Cover Artwork

1st J. H. Williams III (Batwoman)

2nd Cliff Chiang (Wonder Woman)

Favorite DC Comic

1st Wonder Woman

2nd Justice League Dark

3rd Swamp Thing

Favorite Male Hero

1st John Constantine (JLD)

2nd Nelson Jent (Dial H)

3rd Buddy Baker (Animal Man)

Favorite Female Hero

1st Wonder Woman

2nd Looker

3rd Catwoman

Favorite Male Villain

1st Mr. Sinister (Uncanny X-Men)

2nd Anton Arcane

Favorite Female Villain

1st Hera

2nd Susan Hatchi (Astonishing X-Men #53)

Wild Card: Best Fight Scene

1st Wonder Woman vs. Artemis (round 2)

2nd JLD vs. Felix Faust/Dr. Mist

#7 Posted by The Poet (8288 posts) - - Show Bio

@DoomDoomDoom: @Outside_85: @TheAcidSkull: @MadeinBangladesh: thanks for voting!

Moderator
#8 Posted by TheAcidSkull (17166 posts) - - Show Bio

@The Poet said:

@DoomDoomDoom: @Outside_85: @TheAcidSkull: @MadeinBangladesh: thanks for voting!

THANK YOU for inviting me to vote :)

#9 Posted by The Poet (8288 posts) - - Show Bio

@TheAcidSkull: np

Moderator
#10 Posted by Deranged Midget (17599 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st Grant Morrison- Action Comics #12

2nd Dan Slott- The Amazing Spider-Man #692

3rd Brian Bendis- Spider-Men #4

Best Interior Artwork

1st Ivan Reis- Aquaman #12

2nd Jim Lee- Justice League #12

3rd Dexter Soy- Captain Marvel #3

Best Cover Artwork

1st Marcos Martin- The Amazing Spider-Man #692

2nd Ryan Stegman- Scarlet Spider #8

3rd David Finch- The Dark Knight #12

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st The Amazing Spider-Man #692

2nd Hawkeye #1

3rd Spider-Men #4

Favorite DC Comic

1st Action Comics #12

2nd Green Lantern Annual #1

3rd Aquaman #12

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Star Wars Darth Maul: Death Sentence #2

2nd Star Wars Darth Vader: Ghost Prison #4

3rd The Walking Dead #101

Most Underrated Comic

1st Batman: The Dark Knight #12

2nd Hawkeye #1

3rd Saga #4

Favorite Male Hero

1st Peter Parker/ Spider-Man- The Amazing Spider-Man #692

2nd Clark Kent/Superman- Action Comics #12

3rd Arthur Curry- Aquaman #12

Favorite Female Hero

1st Carol Danvers- Captain Marvel #3

2nd Mera- Aquaman #12

Moderator
#11 Posted by kingjoeg (693 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st Hawkeye 1

2nd Before Watchmen: Minutemen 3

3rd Amazing Spider-man 692

Best Interior Artwork

1st Flash 12

2nd Hawkeye 1

3rd Amazing Spider-man 692

Best Cover Artwork

1st Fantastic Four 609

2nd Flash Annual 1

3rd Justice League 12

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Hawkeye 1

2nd Amazing Spider-man 692

3rd Venom 22

Favorite DC Comic

1st Before Watchmen: Minutemen 3

2nd Flash 12

3rd Justice League 12

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Saga 6

#12 Edited by Adnan (1037 posts) - - Show Bio

You'll probably be able to tell how small my pull list is from this lol

Best Writing

1st J.T. Krul (Captain Atom #12)

2nd Brian Azzarello (Wonder Woman #12)

3rd Kurtis J. Wiebe (Debris #2)

Best Interior Artwork

1st J.H. Williams III (Batwoman #12)

2nd Andrea Sorrentino (I,Vampire #12)

3rd Colin Lorimer (Harvest #1)

Best Cover Artwork

1st Riley Rossmo (Debris #2)

2nd Freddie E. Williams II (Captain Atom #12)

3rd Laura Tavishati (Harvest #1)

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Space Punisher #2

2nd

3rd

Favorite DC Comic

1st Captain Atom #12

2nd Wonder Woman #12

3rd I,Vampire #12

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Debris #2

2nd Saucer Country #6

3rd Think Tank #1

Most Underrated Comic

1st Captain Atom #12

2nd Saucer Country #6

3rd Harvest #1

Favorite Male Hero

1st Jay Garrick (Earth-2 #4)

2nd Frank Castle (Space Punisher #2)

3rd

Favorite Female Hero

1st Wonder Woman (Wonder Woman #12)

2nd Maya (Debris #2)

3rd

Favorite Male Villain

1st Phoebus Apollo (Wonder Woman #12)

2nd Hulk (Space Punisher #2)

3rd Grundy (Earth-2 #4)

Favorite Female Villain

1st Morgaine Le Fay (Demon Knights #12)

2nd

3rd

Wild Card: Best Fight Scene

1st Wonder Woman vs Artemis (Wonder Woman #12)

2nd Maya vs a Hund Umbral (Debris #2)

3rd Hulk vs Deadpool & Sabretooth (Space Punisher #2)

#13 Posted by MadeinBangladesh (5874 posts) - - Show Bio
@Adnan: LOL at Space Punisher. I'm not hating but it's just so funny you only read space punisher from marvel.
#14 Posted by Adnan (1037 posts) - - Show Bio

@MadeinBangladesh:I read one or two others this month but I wasn't fond of them, didn't feel I should put them on my list (felt the same way about some DC stuff) Yeah, Space Punisher is pretty stupid, but in a self-aware sorta way lol. It's as hilarious as it is ridiculous imo

#15 Posted by htb106 (1641 posts) - - Show Bio

@MadeinBangladesh: Do you mean Harper Row for best female villain for Batman 12, rather than Roy Harper?

#16 Posted by MadeinBangladesh (5874 posts) - - Show Bio

@htb106: Oh, WOW...LOL... I messed up. gonna fix it though..thanks for noticing :D

#17 Posted by htb106 (1641 posts) - - Show Bio

Best writing

1. Fabian Nicieza- DC Universe Presents: Kid Flash #12

2. Dan slott- The Amazing Spider Man #692

3. Scott Snyder- Batman #12

Best interior artwork

1. Becky Cloonan- Batman #12

2. Brett Booth- Teen Titans #12

3. Jorge Jimenez ( Sorry, couldn't find an accent. )- DC Universe Presents: Kid Flash #12

Best Cover Artwork

1. Humberto Ramos- Amazing Spider Man #692

2. Eddy Barrows- Nightwing #12

3. Jimmy Cheung- Spider Men #4

Best Marvel comic

1. Spider Men #4

2.The Amazing Spiderman #692

That's all I read from Marvel this month.

Best DC Comic.

1. Batman #12

2. Teen Titans #12

3. DC Universe Presents: Kid Flash #12

Favourite male hero

1. Kid Flash- DC Universe Presents: Kid Flash #12

2. Alpha- The Amazing Spiderman #692

3. Tim Drake- Teen Titans #12

Favourite female hero

1. Harper Row- Batman #12

2. Dac- DC Universe Presents: Kid Flash #12

3. Wonder Woman- Wonder Woman #12

Best male villain.

1. Steg- DC Universe Presents: Kid Flash #12

2. Terminus- Batman and Robin #12

3. Paragon- Nightwing #12

Best female villain.

1. Possesed Cassie Sandsmark- Teen Titans #12

2. Kiva- Superboy #12

Sorry, I couldn't find many good female villains this month.

Wild Card vote: Best fight scene.

1. Drunk Superboy Vs. Normal thugs / Mind powered demons ( Just a tad odd...)- Superboy #12

2. Batman Vs. teenage muggers- Batman #12

3. Tim Drake and Superboy Vs. Possesed Cassie Sandsmark- Teen Titans #12

#18 Posted by The Poet (8288 posts) - - Show Bio

@Deranged Midget: @kingjoeg: @Adnan: @htb106: thanks for voting! :D

9 voters in two days! yay!

Moderator
#19 Posted by knighthood (1693 posts) - - Show Bio

@The Poet said:

@Deranged Midget: @kingjoeg: @Adnan: @htb106: thanks for voting! :D

9 voters in two days! yay!

Impressive.

Just switched to an online comic shop. I may not have all my august books yet, but I definitely have to put my two cents in.

#20 Posted by Deranged Midget (17599 posts) - - Show Bio

@The Poet: Anytime! ;)

And it has to be that moderator tab. It's intimidating and all.

Moderator
#21 Posted by Katie24 (488 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st- Wonder Woman #12 (Brian Azzarello)

2nd- Saga #6 (Brian K. Vaughan)

3rd- Batwoman #12 (J.H. Williams III and W. Hayden Blackman

Best Interior Artwork

1st- Batwoman #12 (J.H. Williams III)

2nd- Saga #6 (Fiona Staples)

3rd- Wonder Woman #12 (Cliff Chuang)

Best Cover Artwork

1st- Batwoman #12 (J.H. Williams III)

2nd- Wonder Woman #12 (Cliff Chuang)

3rd- Pathfinder #1 (Lucio Parrillo)

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st- The Punisher #14

2nd- Captain Marvel #2

3rd- Captain America #16

Favorite DC Comic

1st- Wonder Woman #12

2nd- Batwoman #12

3rd- Earth 2 #4

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st- Saga #6

2nd- The Spider #4

3rd- Thun'da #1

Most Underrated Comic

1st- Thun'da #1

2nd- The Spider #4

3rd- Dial H #4

Favorite Male Hero

1st- Jay Garrick (Earth-2 #4)

2nd- Nelson Jent (Dial H #4)

3rd- The Spider (The Spider #4)

Favorite Female Hero

1st- Wonder Woman (Wonder Woman #12)

2nd-Batwoman (Batwoman #12)

3rd- Hawkgirl (Earth 2 #4)

Favorite Male Villain

1st- Apollo (Wonder Woman #12)

2nd- Grundy (Earth-2 #4)

3rd- Anton Arcane (Swamp Thing #12 , Animal Man #12 )

Favorite Female Villain

1st- Artemis (Wonder Woman #12)

2nd- Bloody Mary (Batwoman #12)

3rd- Hera (Wonder Woman #12)

Wild Card: Best Fight Scene (this category changes every month and will be decided by the nominators of last month’s Wild Card winner. This month's category brought to you by SupahForeigner and TheAcidSkull)

1st- Wonder Woman vs. Artemis (Wonder Woman #12)

2nd- Batgirl vs. Batwoman (Batgirl #12)

3rd- Justice League Dark vs. Felix Faust and Dr. Mist (JLA: Dark #12)

#22 Edited by coolguyr99 (3019 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st Dr Manhattan 1

2nd Invincible 94

3rd Morning Glories 21

Best Interior Artwork

1st Justice League 12

2nd Invincible 94

3rd Ozymandias 2

Best Cover Artwork

1st Red Hood and the Outlaws 12

2nd New Guardians 12

3rd The Flash 12

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Avengers vs X-Men 9

2nd Avengers vs X-Men 10

3rd Deadpool kills Marvel Universe 3

Favorite DC Comic

1st Dr Manhattan 1

2nd Justice League 12

3rd Captain Atom 12

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Invincible 94

2nd Morning Glories 21

3rd America's Got Powers 3

Most Underrated Comic

1st Captain Atom 12

2nd America's Got Powers 3

3rd Morning Glories 21

Favorite Male Hero

1st Superman (Superman Anuual #1 and Justice League #12)

2nd Captain Atom (Captain Atom #12)

3rd Dr Manhattan (Dr Manhattan #1)

Favorite Female Hero

1st Wonder Woman (Justice League #12)

2nd Casey (Morning Glories #21)

3rd Supergirl (Supergirl #12)

Favorite Male Villain

1st Helspont (Superman Annual #1)

2nd Black Hand (Green Lantern Annual #1)

3rd Graves (Justice League #12)

Wild Card: Best Fight Scene

1st Superman vs Helspont (Superman Annual #1)

2nd Rex and Monster Girl vs their Son (Invincible #94)

3rd Alan Scott vs Grundy (Earth 2 #4)

#23 Posted by The Poet (8288 posts) - - Show Bio

@Katie24: thanks for voting!

@coolguyr99: also thanks for voting! cg, can you add appearances to the characters and the wild card?

Moderator
#24 Posted by johnkmccubbin91 (3486 posts) - - Show Bio

@The Poet: Did you get my changes you asked for?

#25 Edited by knighthood (1693 posts) - - Show Bio

Voting Ballot

Best Writing

1st Batman the Dark Knight #12

2nd Wonder Woman #12

3rd Batman #12

Best Interior Artwork

1st Batwoman #12

2nd Before Watchmen Rorschach #1

3rd Animal Man #12

Best Cover Artwork

1st Batwoman #12

2nd Ozymandias #2

3rd American Vampire Lord of Nightmares #3

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Wolverine #312

2nd Wolverine #311

3rd

Favorite DC Comic

1st Batman the Dark Knight #12

2nd Batwoman #12

3rd Animal Man #12

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Hellblazer # 294

2nd Revival #2

3rd Infected #1

Most Underrated Comic

1st Captain Atom #12

2nd Infected #1

3rd Harvest #1

Favorite Male Hero

1st Batman - Batman the Dark Knight #12

2nd Constantine - Hellblazer #294

3rd Buddy Baker - Animal Man #12

Favorite Female Hero

1st Batwoman - Batwoman #12

2nd Wonder Woman - Wonder Woman #12

3rd Harper Row - Batman #12

Favorite Male Villain

1st Scarecrow - Batman the Dark Knight #12

2nd Hermes - Wonder Woman #12

3rd Terminus - Batman and Robin #12

Favorite Female Villain

1st Bloody Mary - Batwoman #12

2nd Artemis - Wonder Woman #12

3rd Gwendoline - Catwoman #12

Wild Card: Best Fight Scene (this category changes every month and will be decided by the nominators of last month’s Wild Card winner. This month's category brought to you by SupahForeigner and TheAcidSkull)

1st Batman and Robins vs. Terminus and co. - Batman and Robin #12

2nd Shade and other mystery men vs. Egyptian Gods - Shade #11

3rd Maxine Baker, Ellen Baker, and Abby Holland vs. the Rot - Swamp Thing #12

Not that I'm expecting to be the wildcard winner, but a good category could be best cameo. I felt Wonder Woman's cameo was excellent in this month's Batwoman.

#26 Posted by knighthood (1693 posts) - - Show Bio

Wow there is a lot of Captain Atom love this month! Too bad it is being canceled.

#27 Posted by Afro_Warrior (1120 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st: Brian Azzarello - Wonder Woman #12

2nd: China Mieville - Dial H #4

3rd James Robinson - Earth 2 #4

Best Interior Artwork

1st: Cliff Chiang - Wonder Woman #12

2nd: Mikel Janin - Justice League Dark #12

3rd: Andrea Sorrentino - I, Vampire #12

Best Cover Artwork

1st: Kenneth Rocafort - Red Hood and The Outlaws #12

2nd: Lee Bermejo - Before Watchmen: Rorschach #1

3rd: Tony Harris - Shade #11

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st: Spider-Men #4

2nd: Hawkeye #1

Favorite DC Comic

1st: I, Vampire #12

2nd: Wonder Woman #12

3rd: Shade #11

Most Underrated Comic

1st: Dial H #4

2nd: Demon Knights #12

3rd: I, Vampire #12

Favorite Male Hero

1st: Rorschach - Before Watchmen #1

2nd: Jay Garrick - Earth 2 #4

3rd: Nelson Jent - Dial H #4

Favorite Female Hero

1st: Wonder Woman - Wonder Woman #12

2nd: Harper Row - Batman #12

3rd: Hawkgirl - Earth 2 #4

Favorite Male Villain

1st: Apollo - Wonder Woman #12

2nd: Helspont - Superman Annual #1

3rd: Steg - DC Universe Presents #12

Favorite Female Villain

1st: Morgaine Le Fay - Demon Knights #12

Wild Card: Best Fight Scene

1st: Alan Scott vs Grundy - Earth 2 #4

Nothing else sticks in my mind.

#28 Posted by The Poet (8288 posts) - - Show Bio

@knighthood: @Afro_Warrior: thanks for voting guys! :D

11!

oh, Knighthood, that would be a nice candidate for a Wild Card. I've been compiling a list of possible ones, so that if the winning voters don't have a idea on what to pick I can shoot them a list of them they can peruse. I'll definitely add that one.

I'm taking any suggestions for other categories, but I won't be adding permanent ones because we have enough, but I can take any wild card suggestions.

Moderator
#29 Posted by stumpy49er (609 posts) - - Show Bio

I want to participate in this thread but my browser doesn't support the texteditor, therefore I can't paragraph or bold my words. I feel like it'd be a hassle to read.

#30 Edited by Mucklefluga (2504 posts) - - Show Bio

Voting Ballot

Best Writing

1st Before Watchmen Doctor Manhatten 1

2nd Batman Incorporated 3

3rd Green Lantern Annual 1

Best Interior Artwork

1st Batman Incorporated 3

2nd Saga 6

3rd Before Watchmen Rorschach 1

Best Cover Artwork

1st Flash Annual 1

2nd Creep 0

3rd Hawkeye 1

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Amazing Spider-man 692

2nd Spider-men 4 (I think was this month? Correct me if i'm wrong)

3rd Uncanny X-Force 30

Favorite DC Comic

1st Batman Incorporated 3

2nd Flash Annual 1

3rd Batman 12

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Creep 0

2nd Saga 6

3rd The Walking Dead 101

Most Underrated Comic

1st Creep 0

2nd Batman Incorporated 3

3rd Gambit 1

Favorite Male Hero

1st Redbird/Damian Wayne - Batman Incorporated 3

2nd Rorschach - Before Watchmen Rorschach 1

3rd Barry Allen - Flash 12

Favorite Female Hero

1st Harper Row - Batman 12

2nd Alana - Saga 6

3rd Michonne :P - The Walking Dead 101

Favorite Male Villain

1st Captain Cold - Flash Annual 1

2nd Darwin Elias - Flash Annual 1

3rd The Russian guy that kept saying bro - Hawkeye 1

Favorite Female Villain

1st Glider - Flash Annual 1

2nd Leviathan/Talia Al Ghul - Batman Incorporated 3

3rd Marko's mother haha - Saga 6

Wild Card: Best Fight Scene (this category changes every month and will be decided by the nominators of last month’s Wild Card winner. This month's category brought to you by SupahForeigner and TheAcidSkull)

1st The Flash Vs The Rogues - Flash Annual 1

2nd Rorschach Vs Thugs - Before Watchmen Rorschach 1

3rd Hawkeye Vs Russian Mobsters - Hawkeye 1

#31 Posted by The Poet (8288 posts) - - Show Bio

@Mucklefluga: thanks for voting! yay! 12!

Got my comics today, so I'll write a review or two for the series that aren't reviewed by anyone and then I'll actully post my votes (which I have not done in the past, but for the sake of transparency for this I will show my votes).

Moderator
#32 Posted by Mucklefluga (2504 posts) - - Show Bio

Just looked back at my votes and some of them are quite spoilery :P Oops.

#33 Posted by The Poet (8288 posts) - - Show Bio

@Mucklefluga: Well, I don't think it is too spoilerish. Seems alright to me, but you want to change anything feel free to edit it as you wish just until I call time and lock this.

Moderator
#34 Posted by Mucklefluga (2504 posts) - - Show Bio

@The Poet: Just in case :)

#35 Posted by The Poet (8288 posts) - - Show Bio

@Mucklefluga: ok. Mind you, I don't think Talia is a spoiler anymore. I mean, she's been winning the category of female villain for a number of months (she actully would have probably won last month if the issue of Batman Inc hadn't been delayed). I suppose Elias could be considered a spoiler, though not much of one.

My standard for being a spoiler is if the change happened this month or the very end of last month. Then, I will put a spoiler, but if it is something you can read on a wiki page or one of the many threads users use to complain then it's not as much a spoiler anymore. To my knowledge Cosmo didn't have any trouble with spoilers in the 4 polls she hosted and of the 7 I've hosted previously the only spoiler I protected was Lincoln Marsh's secret identity.

However, you can put spoiler block on anything you want here.

Moderator
#36 Posted by livlig (54 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st Punk Rock Jesus #2 (Sean Murphy)

2nd Spider-Men #4 (Brian Michael Bendis)

3rd Wonder Woman #12 (Brian Azzarello)

Best Interior Artwork

1st Batwoman #12 (J. H. Williams III)

2nd Hawkeye #1 (David Aja)

3rd Captain Marvel #2 (Dexter Soy)

Best Cover Artwork

1st Revival #2 (Jenny Frinson)

2nd Batwoman #12 (J. H. Williams III)

3rd Ultimate Comics: Spider-Man #13 (Jorge Molina)

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Amazing Spider-Man #692

2nd Ultimate Comics: X-Men

3rd Captain Marvel #2

Favorite DC Comic

1st Punk Rock Jesus #2

2nd Animal Man #12

3rd Batwoman #12

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Revival #2

2nd Adventure Time #7

3rd ... I've read too few creator-owned books this month. Saga would probably have been here if I had read this month's issue.

Most Underrated Comic

1st Ultimate Comics X-Men #15

2nd Captain Marvel #3

Favorite Male Hero

1st Thomas McKael (Punk Rock Jesus #2)

2nd Spider-Man (Amazing Spider-Man #692)

3rd Matches Malone (Batman Inc. #3)

Favorite Female Hero

1st Captain Marvel (Captain Marvel #2 + #3)

2nd Wonder Woman (Wonder Woman #12)

3rd Dana Cypress (Revival #2)

Favorite Male Villain

1st Antone Arcane (Animal Man #12, Swamp Thing #12)

2nd Andrew Bennett (I, Vampire #12)

3rd Apollo (Wonder Woman #12)

Favorite Female Villain

1st Possessed Cassie Sandsmark (Teen Titans #12)

2nd Kiva (Superboy #12)

3rd Bloody Mary (Batwoman #12)

#37 Posted by The Poet (8288 posts) - - Show Bio

@livlig: thanks for voting! you are lucky number 13 :D

Moderator
#38 Edited by The Poet (8288 posts) - - Show Bio

And number 14:

Voting Ballot

Best Writing

1st Steed and Mrs. Peel #0

2nd Snarked #11

3rd Green Lantern Annual #1

Best Interior Artwork

1st Flash #12

2nd Gambit #1

3rd Justice League #12

Best Cover Artwork

1st Flash Annual #1

2nd Batman Beyond Unlimited #7

3rd Flash #12

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Gambit #1

2nd Gambit #2 (wow I can actually vote for this category!)

3rd

Favorite DC Comic

1st Flash #12

2nd Justice League #12

3rd Green Lantern #12

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Steed and Mrs. Peel #0

2nd Snarked #11

3rd

Most Underrated Comic

1st Snarked #11

2nd Steed and Mrs. Peel #0

3rd Nightwing #12

Favorite Male Hero

1st John Steed - Steed and Mrs. Peel #0

2nd Dick Grayson - Nightwing #12

3rd Gambit - Gambit #1/2 (I can't decide which issue...)

Favorite Female Hero

1st Emma Peel - Steed and Mrs. Peel #0

2nd Wonder Woman - Justice League #12

3rd Queen/Princess Scarlet - Snarked #11

Favorite Male Villain

1st Black Hand - Green Lantern #12

2nd Graves - Justice League #12

3rd Paragon - Nightwing #12

Favorite Female Villain

1st Glider - Flash #12

2nd

3rd

Wild Card: Best Fight Scene (this category changes every month and will be decided by the nominators of last month’s Wild Card winner. This month's category brought to you by SupahForeigner and TheAcidSkull)

1st Sinistro/Hal vs. Black Hand - Green Lantern #12

2nd Graves vs. the Justice League - Justice League #12

3rd Gambit vs. unnamed lady - Gambit #2 (it's funny...)

Moderator
#39 Posted by Mucklefluga (2504 posts) - - Show Bio

@The Poet: I've changed one of my votes (Best Writing)

#40 Edited by RazzaTazz (9450 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st Aquaman #12

2nd Green Lantern #12

3rd Mind the Gap #3

Best Interior Artwork

1st Voodoo #12

2nd Danger Girl/G.I. Joe #2

3rd Mind the Gap #3

Best Cover Artwork

1st Voodoo #12

2nd Danger Girl/G.I. Joe #2

3rd Mind the Gap #3

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st

2nd

3rd

Favorite DC Comic

1st Aquaman #12

2nd Justice League International Annual #1

3rd Green Lantern #12

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Grimm Fairy Tales Presents Call of Wonderland #3

2nd Danger Girl/G.I. Joe #2

3rd Mind the Gap #3

Most Underrated Comic

1st Justice League International Annual #1

2nd Green Lantern New Guardians #12

3rd Voodoo #12

Favorite Male Hero

1st Booster Gold - Justice League International Annual #1

2nd Kyle Rayner - Green Lantern New Guardians #12

3rd Aquaman - Aquaman #12

Favorite Female Hero

1st Voodoo - Voodoo #12

2nd Julie Sands - Grimm Fairy Tales Presents Call of Wonderland #3

3rd Sydney Savage - Danger Girl/G.I. Joe #2

Favorite Male Villain

1st Invictus - Green Lantern New Guardians #12

2nd Black Hand - Green Lantern #12

3rd Black Manta - Aquaman #12

Favorite Female Villain

1st The Queen of Spades - Grimm Fairy Tales Presents Call of Wonderland #3

2nd Baroness - Danger Girl/G.I. Joe #2

3rd Hera - Wonder Woman #12

Wild Card: Best Fight Scene

1st Sydney Savage against Zarana (Danger Girl/G.I. Joe #2)

2nd Voodoo against her clone - Voodoo #12

3rd All of Olympus fighting against each other in Wonder Woman #12

Moderator
#41 Posted by The Poet (8288 posts) - - Show Bio

thanks for letting me know (haven't created the excel collection document yet, though I should...)

@RazzaTazz: thanks for voting.

Moderator
#42 Posted by batflash09 (25 posts) - - Show Bio

Voting Ballot

Best Writing

1st Scott Snyder - Batman #12

2nd Geoff Johns - Justice League #12

3rd James Robinson - Earth 2 #4

Best Interior Artwork

1st Jim Lee - Justice League #12

2nd Francis Manapul - The Flash #12

3rd Ivan Reis - Aquaman #12

Best Cover Artwork

1st Francis Manapul - Flash Annual #1

2nd Francis Manapul - Flash #12

3rd Jim Lee - Justice League #12

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Gambit #1

2nd Gambit #2

3rd

Favorite DC Comic

1st Flash Annual #1

2nd Green Lantern Annual #1

3rd Justice League #12

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Cobra #16

2nd Snake-Eyes & Storm Shadow #16

3rd G.I. Joe #16

Most Underrated Comic

1st The Flash #12

2nd Cobra #16

3rd Gambit #1

Favorite Male Hero

1st The Flash (Flash #12 & Annual #1)

2nd Snake-Eyes (Snake-Eyes & Storm Shadow #16)

3rd Gambit (Gambit #1 & 2)

Favorite Female Hero

1st Wonder Woman (Wonder Woman #12 & Justice League #12)

2nd Harper Row (Batman #12)

3rd Scarlett (G.I. Joe #16)

Favorite Male Villain

1st Black Hand (Green Lantern #12)

2nd The Guardians (Green Lantern Annual #1)

3rd Krake/Cobra Commander (Snake-Eyes & Storm Shadow #16)

Favorite Female Villain

1st

2nd

3rd

Wild Card: Best Fight Scene (this category changes every month and will be decided by the nominators of last month’s Wild Card winner. This month's category brought to you by SupahForeigner and TheAcidSkull)

1st Lady Jaye and Ronin vs. Blacklight - Cobra #16

2nd Barry Allen vs. the Rogues - Flash Annual #1

3rd O.M.A.C. vs. Booster Gold, Blue Beetle, August General in Iron, Godiva, and Olympian - Justice League International Annual #1

#43 Edited by The Poet (8288 posts) - - Show Bio

@batflash09: thanks for voting!

and before @RazzaTazz: edits this post I will say: RazzaTazz is awesome (and yes, this post was edited by RazzaTazz!)

Moderator
#44 Posted by RazzaTazz (9450 posts) - - Show Bio
@The Poet: Ah darling!
Moderator
#45 Posted by The Poet (8288 posts) - - Show Bio

@RazzaTazz: thanks for editing my post....

on an unrelated note: WW 's page is back! Huzzah!

Moderator
#46 Posted by Omega Ray Jay (7561 posts) - - Show Bio

This is when only getting two books a month really sucks, your ideal choices become somewhat repetitive. Awesome lists though.

#47 Edited by stumpy49er (609 posts) - - Show Bio

Voting Ballot

Best Writing

1st Brian K Vaughn- Saga 6

2nd Jeff Lemire- Animal Man 12

3rd Mike Mignola n John Arcudi- Lobster Johnson

Best Interior Artwork

1st Fiona Staples- Saga 6

2nd Animal Man

3rd

Best Cover Artwork

1st Fiona Staples- Saga 6

2nd Greg Capullo Batman 12

3rd

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Gambit

2nd Hawkeye

3rd Winter Soldier

Favorite DC Comic

1st Aquaman

2nd Rorschache

3rd Dial H

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Saga

2nd B.P.R.D.

3rd Lobster Johnson

Most Underrated Comic

1st Gambit

2nd Dial H

3rd Batman by Tony Daniel

Favorite Male Hero

1st Gambit

2nd Batman

3rd Hawkeye

Favorite Female Hero

1st Wonder Woman

2nd Catwoman

3rd Black Widow

Favorite Male Villain

1st Prince Robot- Saga

2nd Scarecrow

3rd Black Manta

Favorite Female Villain

1st X.N.- Dial H

2nd

3rd

Wild Card: Best Fight Scene (this category changes every month and will be decided by the nominators of last month’s Wild Card winner. This month's category brought to you by SupahForeigner and TheAcidSkull)

1st Lobster Johnson vs. Ptahmos- Lobster Johnson The Prayer of Neferu

2nd Winter Soldier vs. Novokov- Winter Soldier

3rd Aquaman vs Black Manta- Aquaman

#48 Posted by stumpy49er (609 posts) - - Show Bio

p.s. Thanks The Poet!

#49 Posted by The Poet (8288 posts) - - Show Bio

@stumpy49er: well, thank you for voting! I'm really glad you perservered and posted even with formatting troubles, because I can fix format. What I can't fix is a vote with your personalized voting preferences. So yeah! thank you for voting! yay! 17 voters!

Moderator
#50 Posted by cosmo111687 (1489 posts) - - Show Bio

Voting Ballot

Best Writing

1st Before Watchmen: Ozymandias #2

2nd Before Watchmen: Minutemen #3

3rd All-Star Western #12

Best Interior Artwork

1st Before Watchmen: Ozymandias #2

2nd Before Watchmen: Dr. Manhattan #1

3rd Batwoman #12

Best Cover Artwork

1st Before Watchmen: Dr. Manhattan #1

2nd Batwoman #12

3rd Hellblazer #294

Favorite Marvel Comic

1st Winter Soldier #9

2nd Daredevil #16

3rd Hawkeye #1

Favorite DC Comic

1st Before Watchmen: Minutemen #3

2nd Before Watchmen: Ozymandias #2

3rd All-Star Western #12

Favorite Non-Marvel or DC Comic (Dynamite, Image, Vertigo Boom! IDW, etc.)

1st Hellblazer #294

2nd The Walking Dead #101

3rd

Most Underrated Comic

1st Before Watchmen: Ozymandias #2

2nd All-Star Western #12

3rd Hellblazer #294

Favorite Male Hero

1st Constantine - Hellblazer #294

2nd

3rd

Favorite Female Hero

1st Silhouette - Before Watchmen: Minutemen #3 - MY FAVOURITE BY FAR! Probably one of my favourite characters ever.

2nd Tallulah Black - All-Star Western #12

3rd Batwoman - Batwoman #12

Favorite Male Villain

1st Ozymandias - Before Watchmen: Ozymandias #2

2nd

3rd

Favorite Female Villain

1st

2nd

3rd

Wild Card: Best Fight Scene (this category changes every month and will be decided by the nominators of last month’s Wild Card winner. This month's category brought to you by SupahForeigner and TheAcidSkull)

1st Ozymandias vs. Gangsters in Before Watchmen: Ozymandias #2

2nd

3rd