Batman Begins hands down, my favorite of the trilogy :)
Comic Book Question of the Week RESULTS: Favorite Comic Book Movie Reboot
I agree with the top 3, but I have a different order. Here's my rank!
1. Batman Begins
2. Man of Steel
3. Dredd
4. Incredible Hulk
I did not like the other ones.
Yes - I voted for Dredd! I absolutely love that movie! If I could've picked a second it would've been Man of Steel, then Batman Begins, followed by the Amazing Spider-Man.
- Amazing Spider-Man
- Batman
Just my personal opinion. Dredd was decent overall.
Godzilla will dominate all once he hits the theaters.
Nolan is the only filmmaker on this list I have any respect for. Well, Joe Johnston for making The Rocketeer, but Zack Snyder and Michael Bay are hacks and whatever committee assembled the Amazing Spider-Man did so by creating one of the most schizophrenic and lifeless cinematic adaptations I've ever had the misfortune to sit through.
Dredd is good. Works great as a one-off piece. I wish it could launch a franchise but I doubt audiences have any desire for that kind of film anymore. Everything has to be PG-13 and gritty and real, and Dredd is R and fantastical and satirical.
Wow, Batman won, what a surprise.
At least Superman was loved enough to get the bronze. That's still on the winners platform, right? There's always 3 spaces.
Man of Steel got my vote, but I understand why BB won. I also completely agree with kennybaese in that we can thank BB for getting people to see CBMs (like Avengers, Dredd, and Man of Steel) as truly good movies and not just a bunch of weird guys doing dumb stuff. I'm sure some would argue that Spider-Man 1 and 2 got people to see CBMs as quality films, though.
@masterbelmont: I'm one of the some who would say xmen, Spider-Man 1 and 2 kicked started the big budgeted CMB films from the late 90s to the present. Ever since xmen film, a CMB film has followed every year almost.
I do agree that Batman Begins expanded the CMB genre to a broader and some would say a more sophisticated audience(whatever).
The Avenger film while great and tremendously fun. That was just great marketing. To build up anticipation over a spand of five films. That all stood on their own as solid and entertainig films. Then finally putting all the high caliber actors into one film with that much action, story, and special effects. You got the cinema gold called Avengers. The best anticipation for a film I had since the phantom menace after the original star wars trilogy.
Still, some might say the films I mentioned wouldn't be possible without the Tim Burton Batman film which was really big in the late 80s and the original superman films with Christopher Reeves. Zod was awesome in those films. It's all subjective.
@myerlanski:Pretty much this. I'd say SM1 made CBMs a thing due to its big success and the fact that it was a true Spider-Man film (both of which are opposite for X-Men).
@myerlanski: Not trying to shoot down anything you said, though.
My favorites would be:
1. Batman & Robin (Schumacher is a geniuuuuus)
2. Catwoman (I mean come on, evil make-up, who doesn't love that)
3. Superman Returns (Best Lex Luther ever, am I right?)
4. Superman IV: The Quest For Peace (This thing is like the holy grail, so good it should be kept from any human eyes)
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment