Batman or Captain America, who would be forced to kill first

Basically, Batman and Cap are both completly trapped in a room and forced to kill thier most fearsome villian (i.e. Joker and Red skull respectivly),in order to save innocent lives, they will not be let out of the room untill one of them snaps.

So how cracks first?

Cap. Cap doesn't have his issues holding him back like Bruce does.

@Joygirl said:

Cap. Cap doesn't have his issues holding him back like Bruce does.

Cap has no issues with killing, even more so if the lives of innocent were at risk.

Bruce's moral code is way stricter than Cap's is.

Batman has psychological issues, Captain America enlisted to go to war.

@ZombieBigfoot said:

Bruce's moral code is way stricter than Cap's is.

@ZombieBigfoot said:

Bruce's moral code is way stricter than Cap's is.

Then why the hell did he kill Chuck Norris in the Roman Colluseum? Oh wait.. Different Bruce. My bad.. :p

@ssejllenrad said:

@ZombieBigfoot said:

Bruce's moral code is way stricter than Cap's is.

Then why the hell did he kill Chuck Norris in the Roman Colluseum? Oh wait.. Different Bruce. My bad.. :p

Well, that Bruce did it to make people realize that Chuck Norris isn't actually a god.

@BlackArmor said:

@ZombieBigfoot said:

Bruce's moral code is way stricter than Cap's is.

@War Killer said:

Cap has no issues with killing, even more so if the lives of innocent were at risk.

@Andy Steven Summers said:

@Joygirl said:

Cap. Cap doesn't have his issues holding him back like Bruce does.

All of these.

@Army2442: Cap , he has killed in his early runs and he is a soldier

Both have killed before... Batman even killed Darkseid but won't kill Joker... Pffft pis.

Captain America actually has killed and would kill again.

It's not really a difficult question.

Captain America actually has killed and would kill again.

It's not really a difficult question.

Both have killed before... Batman even killed Darkseid but won't kill Joker... Pffft pis.

Ok still

@JediXMan said:

Captain America actually has killed and would kill again.

It's not really a difficult question.

We have a winner!

Captain America obviously. The man is an elite soldier so he has obviously killed in the past and he would do so again to protect the country he loves.

As above. I remember Steve 1-hit killing a terrorist by punching him and breaking his neck. He was pissed and seemed determined on the action, nor remorseful of it.

There's a scan floating around of that somewhere I'm sure.

Why do people think that Steve doesn't kill?
BB

Cap

Cap is a soldier. He will kill if he has to.

@Billy. It's very rare that he does and hr is against it but just not in the same way Batman is.

Batman would just to spite the people in this thread for pretending to know what he would do. In fact he kills Captain America first, climbs inside his body and kills the rest of the people innocents included then goes on to be the Cap Man. Blue, Red and White Knight. Caparang to the shins. Chickens go come home to roost. 

@BlackArmor said:

@ZombieBigfoot said:

Bruce's moral code is way stricter than Cap's is.

@War Killer said:

Cap has no issues with killing, even more so if the lives of innocent were at risk.

@Andy Steven Summers said:

@Joygirl said:

Cap. Cap doesn't have his issues holding him back like Bruce does.

All of these. 

I think Batman should kill first.

No I am not saying this for real, its just everyone agrees that Cap should kill first.

@Billy Batson said:

Why do people think that Steve doesn't kill?
BB

I was just wondering the same thing lol.

@ZombieBigfoot said:

Bruce's moral code is way stricter than Cap's is.

Cap spent a good chunk of WWII killing Nazis. It's not like those times he got out on the battlefield he and the Invaders just knocked them out and arrested them. No, Cap decapitated some with his shield, Bucky has probably racked up more headshots than Punisher and Bullseye combined, Namor ripped people apart, Human Torch and Toro just incinerated them where they stood... yeah, no. I firmly believe Cap would win in a hand-to-hand fight between the two just because Cap already has a body count.

@JediXMan: The differnce was he killed in WAR and didnt kill someone who had surendered.

@The Stegman said:

@BlackArmor said:

@ZombieBigfoot said:

Bruce's moral code is way stricter than Cap's is.

@War Killer said:

Cap has no issues with killing, even more so if the lives of innocent were at risk.

@Andy Steven Summers said:

@Joygirl said:

Cap. Cap doesn't have his issues holding him back like Bruce does.

All of these.

This all of this A better question would be who would kill first "Superman or Batman"

How about Spiderman or Batman?

If their is no other way cap would kill batman

IMO the real question is who would kill first Batman or Spiderman

@Army2442 said:

@JediXMan: The differnce was he killed in WAR and didnt kill someone who had surendered.

... and Batman has?

Fact is, Captain America has a lot of blood on his hands. Whereas Batman... well doesn't.

@JediXMan said:

Fact is, Captain America has a lot of blood on his hands. Whereas Batman... well doesn't.

Gallery

@Andy Steven Summers said:

@Joygirl said:

Cap. Cap doesn't have his issues holding him back like Bruce does.

@War Killer said:

Cap has no issues with killing, even more so if the lives of innocent were at risk.

@hectorsquall said:

@JediXMan said:

Fact is, Captain America has a lot of blood on his hands. Whereas Batman... well doesn't.

Gallery

A lot of that isn't in continuity.

The last two aren't even Batman.
BB

@ReVamp:

That post was meant to be a joke, but check this:

SPOILER WARNING: Click here to reveal hidden content.

"The Beast invites Batman to fight him to the death, but instead Batman locks the room, effectively burying the assassin alive.Batman later informed the police that the KGBeast was trapped (presumably waiting long enough for Knyazev to have suffocated)"

(http://batman.wikia.com/wiki/KGBeast)

Gallery

The events of Batman/Deadman: Death and Glory by James Robinson/John Estes (1996) take place here and now. I’m not numbering this story, however, because I believe that it has been heavily retconned (or should be). In this lackluster tale, Batman gets possessed by an evil spirit known as The Clown. While under possession of this vile apparition, Batman murders a room full of innocent people. Let me repeat this. Batman stabs to death dozens of people.

(http://www.therealbatmanchronologyproject.com/the-modern-age/the-year-one-era/year-six/)

Gallery

And he didn't really kill Darkseid but he still shot him.

The others pics were from the Golden Age Batman, a Batman impersonator and the awful Batman Odyssey.

@Billy Batson: Well it's not Bruce but it's still the Batman of the Flashpoint Universe (Thomas Wayne was really badass!)

@hectorsquall:

Yeah, it was Thomas Wayne. Going to read the mini later since it was done by favorite creators.
BB

@Joygirl said:

Cap. Cap doesn't have his issues holding him back like Bruce does.

this: spiderman and batman might be a harder pick.

@hectorsquall: nice

cap

Cap would kill first.

He's a soldier and as such would recognize and accept the fact that killing is sometimes necessary before Bats would.

@JediXMan said:

Captain America actually has killed and would kill again.

It's not really a difficult question.

Cap has already "killed" the villain Baron Blood when he beheaded him.

@soccersss said:

Captain America obviously. The man is an elite soldier so he has obviously killed in the past and he would do so again to protect the country he loves.

Captain America has killed before. He tries not too but it's not exactly outside the realm of possibility.

Oh hell yeah, definitely Captain America.

@Strider92 said:

Cap