are rorschach and the punisher the same?

or similar

Been done

Similar but not quite the same.

What's up with all these Punisher and Rorschach threads?

Rorschach >Punisher imo

Not really. Their motives and methodology are different, although their general philosophies are pretty similar.

There are some slight similarities but they are not the same.

A better question is "Are punisher and the question the same or similar?".