Who do you like more?Why?
Now everyonecan complain about Batfans lol.
Between the two Supes easily. Aqua's one of the less cool members of thr JL. He can't compete.
While I prefer Superman over Aquaman, I think Aquaman is one of the much "cooler" members of the League. He is just badass.
Historically, it has to be Superman. Up until maybe the "hook Hand" version of Aquaman, he was about the lamest Super-Hero out there. They've done a great job of re-imagining him, and from what I understand, his New 52 book is very good (I've not read). Be that as it may, that doesn't change what he was for a very long time.