Animated Comic Book Movies Tournament

Welcome to yet another tournament! This time, as the title clearly states, we'll find out which is the most popular animated film based on comics of all time! A few points to be made:

• I post two movies and you guys vote for the one you like the best
• The first one to get 6 votes wins in the first round
• I'll only do this tourney by the beginning of the year, right before DC and Marvel release their new animated films
• If a match is going 5-0 to one of the movie's favor and someone doesnt vote for the other one (or the leading film) in 5 hours, I'm going to automatically declare the leading movie the winner. This rule will be altered as rounds go on.
• Oh, and all matches from round 1 are randomly generated of course

Movies that are not in this tournament:

• Hellboy Blood and Iron: Not well known enough, not enough space
• Marvel Superheroes 4D: Not well known enough and too short and simple
• Gen13: Not well known enough

PS: If someone wants to offer his help posting the matches while I'm not available, all help is accepted

Here we go then! First battle:

I vote for Batman Year One, 1-0

@JLDoom: Haven't seen either (even though I own both), but the Iron Man box looks cooler. So I vote Iron Man.

Batman

I own both, yet I've only seen Iron Man, which I loved. Iron Man.

Year One.

Batman

Batman

Batman iron man was just awful

Year One

@TheCannon: That's one the things I did during the time I was away, watch all these movies (or rather the ones I hadn't seen yet). I highly recommend Year One, especially if you havent read the original comic. Iron Man... not so much

Year One wins! Next match:

I vote for Public Enemies, 1-0

Public Enemies

Public Enemies

Public Enemies.

Public Enemies.

Public Enemies. I haven't seen Next Avengers, plus Public Enemies was just amazing.

Public Enemies

Public Enemies is the winner! Next match:

I vote for Under the Red Hood, one of my favorite animated movies ever, 1-0

Thor it had the Warriors Three.

Undet The Red Hood

Under the Red Hood.

Under the Red Hood!

Under the Red Hood

under the red hood

under the red hood

Under the Red Hood. And it will probably finish second overall to Mask of the Phantasm. Unless you include The Incredibles, which isn't technically a comic book movie.

I feel as if your intentionally putting certain movies, against other ones just to have the specific one being victorious. Anyway Under the Red Hood.

Never seen Thor (I'm so ashamed of myself), so Under the Red Hood. Tied for greatest animated movie of all time (along with Wonder Woman. Closely followed by Batman: Beyond Return of the Joker. Mask of the Phantasm doesn't make the To 10)

Under the Red Hood emerges victorious! Next match:

Superman vs the Elite, another one of my favorites, 1-0

Superman: Brainiac Attacks

Vs the Elite 1-1 Brainiac Attacks

@Wolfrazer said:

I feel as if your intentionally putting certain movies, against other ones just to have the specific one being victorious.

Umm I said in the OP that all the matches in round 1 are randomly generated. I had a list of movies, then I put them in this site and then used the results to make the tournament

Plus, Under the Red Hood is one of the most popular animated films ever, why would I need to pit it against a weak film like Thor for it to win?

Never seen Elite. But Brainiac Attacks is one of the worst films I've ever seen. So I vote Elite

Brainiac Attacks. That fun to say... Brainiac Attacks Brainiac Attacks.... sorry...

Superman vs the elite is the best animated superman movie, so i sure as hell am gonna pick it over the festival of weaksauce only known as brainiac attacks

Hmm... let me see: a bad film or a great film? Yeah, I think I'm going with the great film.

Superman vs. The Elite.

Bump.

Superman vs. The Elite

Elite 5-2 Brainiac Attacks

Superman vs The Elite, even though I was a tad dissapointed by it, it was still great.

Superman vs the Elite wins this match! Next battle:

I vote for All Star Superman, 1-0

All-Star Superman was a pretty damn good adaptation, even if they left out some parts of the original story. I do think the ending is much better than the original, though (and I thought the original ending was great). Also, the musical score is amazing.

All-Star

My vote is for All-Star Superman.

Superman, by far. I really disliked that particular Batman movie.

All Star 5-0 Mystery of the Batwoman

For some reason I thought this would be closer. I didnt like that Batman movie much, but DCAU products tend to be quite popular

Lol at Marvel movies even being included. We all know Phantasm will stomp.

All-Star Superman

@Nightwing4 said:

Lol at Marvel movies even being included. We all know Phantasm will stomp.

You couldn't be more wrong. Although it's quite obvious a DC film will win,

I think I'm the only one who liked Mystery of the Batwoman (even though it's nowhere near as good as others), so I vote that.

All Star Superman wins! Next match:

This isnt as easy for me as it would be for others so I'll refrain from voting, at least for a while

I haven't seen First Flight (I've been wanting to watch it for months though), but Mask of the Phantasm is an overrated piece of sh*t. So I vote Green Lantern: First Flight.

Batman