Which was the better story in your opinion?
Which was the better representation of the main character featured within?
which had better art in your opinion?
Seriously though, this is like choosing between pie and cake. They're both awesome.
Seriously though, this is like choosing between pie and cake. They're both awesome.
picking between tacos and pizza
All-Star
All-Star
Thor
God butcher arc was the better overall story and had better artwork in my opinion. All Star Superman did a good job at showing what supes was all about.
qfMFt
@thecheesestabber: All Star Superman kind of bored me =\
Though I loved loved loved the god butcher saga, I actually started over rereading it tonight, Allstar Superman is just perfect IMO. And Frank Quitely is one of my all time favorites...like I would rather have Quitely draw my book than Esad. But that said the god butcher saga is incredible and the best Marvel book I've ever read
If you liked the God Butcher ark then you might like the Marvel Now! Title Uncanny Avengers. It has Thor in it and strikes a similar mood. Possibly the best superhero team book at the moment.
@godtriggerhulk: I'll have to pick it up in trade. Thanks
Avengers vs. X-Men sets up the context of the book but honestly reading a summary of it is good enough.
@godtriggerhulk: I'll read them in trade. I really like the bit it seems as though he hasn't had very many good stories over the years
@jmg: Me too, never got the hype
All-Star Superman is perfect
That being said, The God Butcher arc is one of my favorite Marvel stories.
That being said, The God Butcher arc is one of my favorite Marvel stories.
Seconded for me too. Comparing the two is like comparing two different types of cuisine. Both are brilliant but for different reasons.
All-Star
All-Star
Thor
All-Star
All-Star
Thor
Seriously though, this is like choosing between pie and cake. They're both awesome.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment