I was just searching for Usagi Yojimbo: Yokai HC and I couldn't find it here. I was wondering, if we should add HC or TPBs or not. I don't think this HC is a compilation of issues, it's a one-shot standalone (I think).
Should HC and TPB be added to CV?
the hardcover that you posted the link to is a compilation and to answer your question....no trades and hardcovers should not be added to the wiki since the individual issues making them up are already added....it would be to confusing for new readers....now if a graphic novel is released that is not a compilation then yes that should be added
I'm pretty sure that HC is not a compilation. The description states that it's an original story. I have the HC, but I don't have all of the UY issues, so I can't be certain.
" the hardcover that you posted the link to is a compilation and to answer your question....no trades and hardcovers should not be added to the wiki since the individual issues making them up are already added....it would be to confusing for new readers....now if a graphic novel is released that is not a compilation then yes that should be added "Sorry, but trade paperback collections are added. If you type 'Essential' into the Search box, then you'll see a list of the old phonebook sized trades of early Marvel titles.
I used to think that too. But ComicVine is all for comicbooks. It can get confusing, but as long as the title is correct & something is mentioned in the overview page for the volume, then hopefully it will be clear enough.
We don't appear to have any of the Usagi Yojimbo collected editions. But Yokai is an original Graphic Novel. I say it should be included.
LOL! The same goes for Original Graphic Novels. Like Usagi Yojimbo: Yokai... which jamesewelche was asking about ;)
@afierce: "Indicia" is the tiny fine print usually in the front of most comics and the last page of DC books.
I think that would be a good idea. I picked up another TPB "Serentity: Those Left Behind" and the title in the TPB indicia is the exact same as the 3 issue's volume name. So I would like to add it, but I think it would look funny to have a TPB in the same CV volume as the 3 issues. The other option is to have another volume with the same name as the volume with the issues ( Serenity: Those Left Behind), but it would have the TPB there.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment