Alternate Reality Teams

Would you add a character to a team if they were part of that team in an alternate reality?  I've found some characters have been added, while others aren't. 
 
For instance, The Brotherhood:  
 
In House of M, the Brotherhood was part of the NYPD so it wasn't the usual 'Evil' collection.  The members included Boom Boom, Feral & Thunderbird.  It hadn't occured to me to add Boom Boom as a member of the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants, because technically she hasn't been.  But that is the Earth-616 equivilant of the team.   Neither she, nor Feral or Thunderbird have been included as members.   
 
Likewise, members of the Age of Apoclypse version of the Brotherhood haven't been added either.  So characters like Box & Copycat aren't included as Brotherhood of Evil members.
 
However, the Wolfpack: 
 
A lot of the classic New Warriors were part of the House of M's version of the Wolfpack.  They had nothing to do with the Wolfpack in Earth-616, and aside from the name the House of M's Wolfpack essentially was the New Warriors.  However, Alex & Julie Power, Rage, Speedball and Turbo all appear listed as Wolfpack members. 
 
So, which is right?  Do we add alternate reality teams or not??

HoM didnt occur in an alternate reality/world persay, it was an overlap of 616, as indicated when the Exiles visited in world tour,
and of course many 616 characters coming to the realization that they were in a trap, then coming out of it all together.

generally I notice a lot of alternate reality people as team members. I think it should be counted but it should mention that is was in an alternate reality on the members page. In my opinion, the member page should also mention if someone is a reserve member or no longer with the team. 
 
I don't read a lot of books with teams, so I get pretty confused looking at the members.
 
That's just what I think though, we'll see what a staff member or mod thinks.

This is a slippery slope. There's probably 100 members you could add to the X-Men if What if? issues counted including Mr. Sinister, Sauron, Malice, Unus, Mastermind, Vanisher, Blob, etc.. It makes for a very ugly, impossible to digest roster page. I'm of the opinion members of alternate universes should be described in the body of the overview but not added as "official" members that display along the right hand side. I think that list should be comprised only of the main reality of whatever the team exists in.  
 
Exception being something like the Exiles where there isn't one main reality.

" HoM didnt occur in an alternate reality/world persay, it was an overlap of 616, as indicated when the Exiles visited in world tour, and of course many 616 characters coming to the realization that they were in a trap, then coming out of it all together. "

I'm thinking this issue might be something that could be addressed if the site were revised. Have 'alternate realities' as a tab on the left side like Key Story Arcs/Creators, Friends/Enemies are now. Then have the alternate reality tab break down each reality kind of similar to the friends/enemies section but more expansive for the ongoing ones like HoM, Ultimates etc. 
It looks awesome in my brain, if only I knew mootools and django...

"HoM didnt occur in an alternate reality/world persay, it was an overlap of 616, as indicated when the Exiles visited in world tour, and of course many 616 characters coming to the realization that they were in a trap, then coming out of it all together. "

"I'm thinking this issue might be something that could be addressed if the site were revised. Have 'alternate realities' as a tab on the left side like Key Story Arcs/Creators, Friends/Enemies are now. Then have the alternate reality tab break down each reality kind of similar to the friends/enemies section but more expansive for the ongoing ones like HoM, Ultimates etc.  It looks awesome in my brain, if only I knew mootools and django... "

" @CATMANEXE said:

" HoM didnt occur in an alternate reality/world persay, it was an overlap of 616, as indicated when the Exiles visited in world tour, and of course many 616 characters coming to the realization that they were in a trap, then coming out of it all together. "

It still has an alternate universe number so it's technically an alternate reality "

" @CATMANEXE said:

"HoM didnt occur in an alternate reality/world persay, it was an overlap of 616, as indicated when the Exiles visited in world tour, and of course many 616 characters coming to the realization that they were in a trap, then coming out of it all together. "

It appears in the Alternate Realities section of many character pages.  Just like the Age of Apocalypse did.  It featured many characters in roles that they have never done before... that makes it an alternative reality, regardless of how long it lasted or the reasons why it came to be. 

some people argue just because, even though theyre not being called out just informed, very well...
 
in the story the House Of M, the characters came to realise that they were in fact who they were, and not alternate reality counterparts (in effect theyd had the biggest ever brainwashing scheme pulled on them). this was the basis of the entire story. the ruse was undone, one by one. Emma Frost and Layla Miller took a huge part in this...