Posted by G-Man (37662 posts) - - Show Bio

The Good

Cyclops is a great character. He’s a great leader and is dedicated to his team and mutants around the world. Sometimes he can be a little stiff or two-dimensional. When Brian Michael Bendis brought the original X-Men from the past into the present, we found ourselves with two different versions of most of the characters. For a character like young Cyclops to see his future and what he’s become, even if you’re on the “Cyclops was right” side, it can be a lot to take in. Now young Cyclops has discovered his father, Corsair, thought to be dead, is alive and is a space pirate, how could he resist wanting to spend time with him.

By taking young Cyclops out of the familiar X-Men setting, as we've seen the first time around, and putting him in space, there's no telling what we'll see. This experience, and getting to know his father during these younger years, could shape him into a different person. It's both scary and fascinating to think about how all of these experiences could blow up the entire time stream. At the least, it could change who Cyclops grows up into.

Greg Rucka does a great job in filling newer readers on what's going on. It's a pretty convoluted bit of backstory but Rucka lays it all out with ease and also gives readers a taste of who the rest of the Starjammers are.

Russell Dauterman's art is phenomenal. As a relative newcomer to comics, he's someone to keep an eye on. His recent (but brief) stint on NIGHTWING immediately caught our attention. It's going to be a blast to see what Dauterman will have to draw in this series.

The Bad

This was a great starting point for a new series but it almost feels like a prologue with the rest of the series going in a slightly different direction. Will the series focus on Cyclops with the Starjammers or more on just Cyclops and his father? Rucka touches on it a little here but it still seems a little out of character for Cyclops to run away from the rest of his team. But you can't blame him for everything he's seen and experienced lately.

I know we shouldn't think about it but you have to wonder how long the young X-Men can stay in the present. It's a small distraction despite how much fun it is seeing them here.

The Verdict

Cyclops finally has his own ongoing series. Only this isn't quite the Cyclops we know. When the young original X-Men were brought to the present, we've had chance to see these characters slowly start to evolve differently. The idea of a sixteen-year-old Cyclops having adventures out in space with his father is pretty far out and is bound to have an affect on him. Russell Dauterman's art is perfect for the series and I can't wait to see what Greg Rucka throws at him in future issues. Whether you love Cyclops or not, this is a series to check out to find out who this Cyclops will become. Marvel is on fire with their recent new solo titles focusing on individual characters. It's a great time to be a comic fan. It's just a little hard on the wallet.

#1 Posted by greenlucario (250 posts) - - Show Bio

So how is Corsair alive? I thought Vulcan killed him during War of Kings.

#2 Posted by Maddpanda531 (1114 posts) - - Show Bio

@greenlucario: Through the magical power of the ancient god, R'Etcon

#3 Posted by TheCheeseStabber (8160 posts) - - Show Bio

@greenlucario: Through the magical power of the ancient god, R'Etcon

"...and he said'th onto them "" Let there be life!"" and those who were dead didth not die, but returnth a century later...."

- Bendiz 9:14 (The Holy Graphic Docturine.)

#5 Posted by LiveForever (312 posts) - - Show Bio

I bought this and am praying it's good... Cyclops is my favorite character. Would've preferred either present-day Cyclops to get a series, or for this to not take place in space... =/

#6 Posted by tximinoman (262 posts) - - Show Bio

This issue is awesome. A really great start, I hope it stays good.

Also, I don't care how Corsair resurrected, it's the Marvel Universe, everyone resurrects here. And he's like the coolest dad ever so I'm glad he's alive.

#7 Posted by Stephen_Mitchell (2 posts) - - Show Bio

Bought it. Read it. LOVED IT!!

Although I'm not going to lie, I'm slightly concerned that Corsair is planning on using his son as a means to an end. He IS a PIRATE, after all. Is he truly looking to bond with his son? Or does he see his son's ability as a tactical advantage to his craft.

#8 Posted by SummersBlood (32 posts) - - Show Bio

@liveforever: I gotta say, as a fellow fan of Cyclops, this issue spends a lot of energy having the younger version talk smack about the older one. He says he wishes he grew up to be like his deadbeat pirate dad instead the hero we know, who has saved the world multiple times.....cuz that makes sense.

#9 Posted by darkbeam (2496 posts) - - Show Bio

I hope people buy this.Support Cyclops people.

#10 Posted by LiveForever (312 posts) - - Show Bio

@summersblood: Yeah... I'm getting whiplash with all the younger X-Men's opinion changes. I get that they're teenagers, and teenagers have mood swings, but remember how upset young Jean Grey was getting at young Cyclops because of what present Cyclops turns out to be? Now, over in ANXM, Jean talks glowingly about present Cyclops. Meanwhile, after hanging out and siding with present Cyclops, young Cyclops hates on present Cyclops? It makes no sense.

#11 Posted by Djainess (185 posts) - - Show Bio

@maddpanda531 said:

@greenlucario: Through the magical power of the ancient god, R'Etcon

"...and he said'th onto them "" Let there be life!"" and those who were dead didth not die, but returnth a century later...."

- Bendiz 9:14 (The Holy Graphic Docturine.)

Okay, this made me laugh, hard :p

#12 Edited by Jonny_Anonymous (34297 posts) - - Show Bio

I'm going to be real sad if this book turns out to be only Tyke and Corsair, I want a Starjammers ongoing.

#13 Edited by tximinoman (262 posts) - - Show Bio

@summersblood: Yeah... I'm getting whiplash with all the younger X-Men's opinion changes. I get that they're teenagers, and teenagers have mood swings, but remember how upset young Jean Grey was getting at young Cyclops because of what present Cyclops turns out to be? Now, over in ANXM, Jean talks glowingly about present Cyclops. Meanwhile, after hanging out and siding with present Cyclops, young Cyclops hates on present Cyclops? It makes no sense.

When she got mad at young Cyclops she only had listened to the Jean Grey School's part of the story. Later, in battle of the atom, she actually met old Cyclops and unlike everyone at JGS (except for Kitty and Rachel), he was the only adult who support her so she realized that maybe he wasn't as bad as they said he was.

#14 Posted by tximinoman (262 posts) - - Show Bio

Bought it. Read it. LOVED IT!!

Although I'm not going to lie, I'm slightly concerned that Corsair is planning on using his son as a means to an end. He IS a PIRATE, after all. Is he truly looking to bond with his son? Or does he see his son's ability as a tactical advantage to his craft.

Nah, he's not. Back in the day, when he and old Scott met up for the first time, he also offered the chance to travel with him for a while but Scott declined after he met Madelyne Pryor.

#16 Posted by Eivion (95 posts) - - Show Bio

@summersblood said:

@liveforever: I gotta say, as a fellow fan of Cyclops, this issue spends a lot of energy having the younger version talk smack about the older one. He says he wishes he grew up to be like his deadbeat pirate dad instead the hero we know, who has saved the world multiple times.....cuz that makes sense.

Because what young Cyclops saw of his present self is a militant leader of mutants who is also a criminal on the run from the law. Whats more he ended up suffering guilt by association since it is his future self. And its bit much to call Corsair a deadbeat pirate. He was unaware his children were even alive until he met them as adults. And despite being a pirate Corsair for the most part has been a rebel against the Shiar.

#17 Posted by ArturoCalaKayVee (12233 posts) - - Show Bio

ONLY FOUR STARS?!?! ARE YOU SERIOUS?!?! G-MAN YOU ARE CRAZY!! HATER!!!

Totally kidding, of course!

I really loved this issue. I thought the art was great and felt this opened doors for a lot of future stories, so yeah, in a sense it did feel like a prologue. My only issue with this story is that it felt a tad long. Seemed never ending.

#18 Posted by Owie (3873 posts) - - Show Bio

I am also a bit annoyed at the continuing changes/backlash of the young X-men against Cyke, because honestly he has not really done anything all that bad around them. Before they showed up, maybe. But since? He's pretty much been a standard hero.

But anyway I am glad to have this opportunity for a young Cyclops book. I just hope they don't make him too happy go lucky, like they seem to be. Young or old, Slim was never happy go lucky.

#19 Edited by iceslick (805 posts) - - Show Bio

@g_man: I am assuming Cyclops leaves with his father because he wants to be just like him. But little does he know that his father isn't such a great father. I guess that's why older Cyclops doesn't like his Dad too much because he already knows that. This Cyclops in other hand is too blind to notice that maybe he isn't a great Dad and maybe he will later down the road. Also him being younger causes him to be blind. By the way, good review I agree with with every point you made.

#20 Edited by Avenger85 (1988 posts) - - Show Bio

ONLY FOUR STARS?!?! ARE YOU SERIOUS?!?! G-MAN YOU ARE CRAZY!! HATER!!!

Totally kidding, of course!

I really loved this issue. I thought the art was great and felt this opened doors for a lot of future stories, so yeah, in a sense it did feel like a prologue. My only issue with this story is that it felt a tad long. Seemed never ending.

Such an amazing book.

#21 Posted by derf_jenkins (418 posts) - - Show Bio

There is a lot to love about this issue. It's setting up to be a great potential story.

#22 Posted by ShadowJax (9 posts) - - Show Bio

Now this is the kind of space-faring adventure I want in Guardians of the Galaxy

#23 Edited by Superbat420 (253 posts) - - Show Bio

Why didn't they just send him back in time to find his father and spend time with him then?

#24 Posted by Dernman (15440 posts) - - Show Bio

Still hate the concept of the O5 being in the present but this book really was good. I like the pirate scenes. I hope after this is done they make a Starjammers series.

There is a question how the father is still alive but I would also like to know how he seems almost around the age as Adult Scott. Also what are those pills he's taking. Maybe they have to do with him being back.

#25 Edited by Ms-Lola (3727 posts) - - Show Bio

It would be great if time was spent on explaining Corsair being alive because it was a pretty big deal when Vulcan killed him and Havok ended up staying in space with Rachel and Polaris afterwards. Also, how did his gorgeous side-kick (I do like how they depict her, she's clearly independent and badass) get back together with him when last I saw her, she was hanging around the X-Mansion?

I know all the above won't be explained, but it would be nice. Also, @dernman, I think you are on to something about the pills.

As for the book, I think it's adorable and endearing and while I do think Scott is a bit over dramatic with the dad love, he is still just a kid. If he wants to idolize his long lost dad (he's dashing and everything), then let 'im. We all know it won't last long, anyway.

#26 Posted by danhimself (22683 posts) - - Show Bio

just got around to reading this and I've got to say I think I loved it!

#27 Posted by J_HickmanIsGod (297 posts) - - Show Bio

Greg Rucka is writing this.

this has to be fucking amazing. no excuses.

#28 Posted by Avenger85 (1988 posts) - - Show Bio

Greg Rucka is writing this.

this has to be fucking amazing. no excuses.

It is. Unless you have a bias towards the writer or character, there is absolutely no flaw to be found within this first issue.

#29 Posted by sora_thekey (8184 posts) - - Show Bio

@maddpanda531 said:

@greenlucario: Through the magical power of the ancient god, R'Etcon

"...and he said'th onto them "" Let there be life!"" and those who were dead didth not die, but returnth a century later...."

- Bendiz 9:14 (The Holy Graphic Docturine.)

Best comment EVER! (May I use this in the future?)

#30 Posted by TheCheeseStabber (8160 posts) - - Show Bio

@sora_thekey: Yu may indeed. Sorry for late reply I've been camping