post pics and comments and in a few days i will tally up the votes and give you the results
This topic is locked from further discussion.
My vote goes to Greed. I've had a soft spot for tragic, misunderstood characters since kindergarten (maybe a bit earlier), when I first saw Frankenstein. True, Envy is a bit tragic too, as are just about all of the Homunculi, but I also love antiheroes (not just villains), and Greed shows that in spite of the way he came into being, he's by far the most redeemable (especially in brotherhood)
I appreciated Greed for his tragic, misunderstood persona. He was more appealing with his anti-hero goofish attitude. Envy's way of playing with others emotions gave a darker hue to the character, where most like the goofy anti hero more then the cynical, hate imbued character. I prefer Greed.