Log in or sign up to comment
1354 Comments Refresh
Posted by PikminMania
@The Poet: Oh okay!
Posted by Liberty
@aztek_the_lost said:

@Silkcuts said:

@RazzaTazz said:

@Silkcuts: Yes lets do the baseball cards versions of each other. Silkcuts and I can't be turned against each other though for the following reasons: 1. We are both Canadian 2. That is actually all you need.

I agree we both can't be turned against each other. I can name a few reasons

^_^

1) Both Canadians

what about me...I'm Canadian...

I don't get it.  Are you saying Canadians don't have good taste in music?
Posted by Liberty
@The Poet said:
@PikminMania: Well when I get all the nominations, I'll do a group PM, but I would prefer to compile a list of nominations before that (so we don't get any duplicates and such, plus it would be easier for me).
I thought we were voting in order of publishers.  If we do that and have them posted one at a time there would be no duplicates.  So Marvel posts their 8 then DC would post after Marvel and so on.
Posted by Silkcuts

@Liberty said:

@aztek_the_lost said:

@Silkcuts said:

@RazzaTazz said:

@Silkcuts: Yes lets do the baseball cards versions of each other. Silkcuts and I can't be turned against each other though for the following reasons: 1. We are both Canadian 2. That is actually all you need.

I agree we both can't be turned against each other. I can name a few reasons

^_^

1) Both Canadians

what about me...I'm Canadian...

I don't get it. Are you saying Canadians don't have good taste in music?

I know I do, I can't say for Aztek...lol

Posted by Liberty
@Silkcuts: I couldn't resist.  The least you guys could do is post a Barenaked Ladies Song.  =)
Posted by Liberty

I made a list of 19 underdogs I hope make the list.  I wonder how many will make it.

Posted by The Poet
@Liberty: yeah, I really am curious what some of the nominations are...
 
Marvel is waiting on DC...this might take a bit...
Moderator
Posted by Jnr6Lil

@The Poet: The Publisher I would like is Marvel.

Posted by Jnr6Lil

Also we're sticking to strictly comic book characters.

Posted by Liberty
@Jnr6Lil: lol really?
Posted by Liberty
@aztek_the_lost said:

@Liberty: =/ they were loving up on each other because of the attribute of being Canadian and I am Canadian too, so I was asking where is the love for me? :(

although I unironically kinda like that song, I don't listen to it anymore but if it came up on the radio I'd sing along, not a fan of the Black Eyed Peas in general though

my taste in music is flawless though, I don't think anyone can have bad taste in music, music is too personal a thing for anyone to be "doing it wrong"

I got it.  I was just joking around.  Ask Silkcuts.  It is all in jest.
 
I do disagree with the doing music wrong in a way.  Is it art?  Yes.  So is drawing but I would not put an infants scribbles in the same league as Michelangelo's "Universal Judgement".  Some music is deep profound and beautiful, some is throwing a xylophone down a hall and some is really just done buy computers.
Posted by The Poet
@Jnr6Lil said:

@The Poet: The Publisher I would like is Marvel.

I'm really sorry, but all the spots have been filled. Marvel it self was the first to be filled.
 
That being said, you can partisipate in making the list when we get all the nominations by suggesting which characters should be on the list. You can also vote once we actully create the list to move a character up or down in position...
Moderator
Posted by Silkcuts

@Liberty said:

@Silkcuts: I couldn't resist. The least you guys could do is post a Barenaked Ladies Song. =)

What about Billy Talent?

@Liberty said:

@aztek_the_lost said:

@Liberty: =/ they were loving up on each other because of the attribute of being Canadian and I am Canadian too, so I was asking where is the love for me? :(

although I unironically kinda like that song, I don't listen to it anymore but if it came up on the radio I'd sing along, not a fan of the Black Eyed Peas in general though

my taste in music is flawless though, I don't think anyone can have bad taste in music, music is too personal a thing for anyone to be "doing it wrong"

I got it. I was just joking around. Ask Silkcuts. It is all in jest. I do disagree with the doing music wrong in a way. Is it art? Yes. So is drawing but I would not put an infants scribbles in the same league as Michelangelo's "Universal Judgement". Some music is deep profound and beautiful, some is throwing a xylophone down a hall and some is really just done buy computers.

In JLA's defense it was harmless and like me, when he jokes like that it means he likes the person. Since Humor is a sign of comfort.

^_^

Posted by PikminMania

@The Poet: So can you do Liberty's idea? I also want to see what we have so far.

@Liberty said:

@The Poet said:
@PikminMania: Well when I get all the nominations, I'll do a group PM, but I would prefer to compile a list of nominations before that (so we don't get any duplicates and such, plus it would be easier for me).
I thought we were voting in order of publishers. If we do that and have them posted one at a time there would be no duplicates. So Marvel posts their 8 then DC would post after Marvel and so on.
Edited by The Poet

@PikminMania: we will (I misunderstood him). The reason We're waiting is our "outstanding" DC crew...just need to orginize them...when they logon agian...

And Marvel is waiting for DC (because some of their nominations are part of marvel...

so, if anyone who is part of the 22 who does not have DC characters in their nominations, please post your nominations! if you do have DC characters...well lets wait to make sure we don't have dups

Moderator
Posted by PikminMania

@The Poet: Do you mean post them on here?

Posted by The Poet
@PikminMania: yep, keeping mind that DC and Marvel nominations take priority on characters from their publisher (because they are actually two people and would take a longer time for them to decide on alternate characters than it would be if it was just one person...this priority does not affect other publisher nominations...so for everyone else its first come first serve)
 
An ordered nomination process seems to not work in this sense as not everyone is prepared or on line at the aproprate time, so we might tweak that a bit...
Moderator
Posted by Liberty
@The Poet: @PikminMania: Wait wait.  It doesn't matter if they have just DC.  If they have Marvel above them they will have to wait and so on.  MIne for example have been printed in DC, Charlton, Dynamite, AC, Image and others.  We have to do it in order or we will have to keep changing them right?
Posted by PikminMania

@Liberty: I was thinking we just post them here like Poet said, and whoever is higher in the list gets their choices first.

For example:

I post Dick Tracy first

But later DC also posts Dick Tracy, now I must switch out my Dick Tracy nomination.

Posted by Liberty
@PikminMania: That is just going to confuse things.  If you think it is a pain now waiting for one person imagine if we keep switching up.  So we all vote and then Marvel votes so several people have to revote.  Based on those votes others will likely have to revote.  Just keep it simple.  Let DC vote 8, then Marvel vote 8. 
Posted by PikminMania

@Liberty: yeah i guess you are right.

Posted by The Poet

DC has their nominations (just need to order them)...This is what I call progress!

Moderator
Posted by Jnr6Lil

@Liberty

Yes really

Posted by Jnr6Lil

@The Poet:

Fine with helping putting together list since I can't get Marvel :)

Posted by The Poet
@Jnr6Lil: thanks for understanding :)
Moderator
Posted by Jnr6Lil

@The Poet said:

@Jnr6Lil: thanks for understanding :)

No prob, JediXMan should get in on this also.

Posted by Liberty

As grains pass through the hour glass so do the days of our lives.  Come on DC!  where are you?

Posted by Liberty

Who are we waiting for Dark Huntress or Primemaster?

Edited by The Poet
@Liberty said:

As grains pass through the hour glass so do the days of our lives.  Come on DC!  where are you?

Well, they actully made progress! Dark Huntress was curdious and said Primm could do the nominating as long as a few characters made the list. I just need them to order it, but I guess it can wait...so without further ado their nominations:
 
(in no piticular order:)
 
Supergirl
Batman
Superboy
Dick Grayson
Superman
Captain Marvel (fawcett/DC)
Invincible (image, ect)
Wonder Woman
Moderator
Posted by Liberty
@The Poet: Nice List!  One question is that Captain Marvel (Billy Batson)?
Posted by The Poet

@Liberty: yep. I'll make sure in the future we note the ones which didn't start at the publisher (or at least are of another publisher)

just for future referance (I know we're not to AC yet, but i just want to make sure I don't forget about Turok's nominations which he just sent me...I bet it won't change):

AC Comics:

1.Ms. Victory

2.Nightveil

3.Yankee Girl

4.Catman

5.Rocketman

6. Turok Son of Stone(Goldkey)...boy thats a suprise...

7. The Mighty Samson (Gold Key)

8. Abe Sapien (Dark Horse)

Moderator
Posted by Liberty

Mighty Samson is Awesome!

Anybody Hear Anything?
Posted by The Poet

@Liberty: biggest suprise was #6...I did not know he was a fan of Turok! :P

Moderator
Posted by Liberty
@The Poet: The cool thing is Samson started out with Fox so he has my number 2 or 3 pick.  Everybody moves up on my list!  I also had Turok as one of my not Fox picks but that was before I knew Turok was going to vote.
Posted by Liberty
@The Poet: I also had Mrs. Victory as a Holyoak Yeah.  she was also in my top 8 I just noticed she was his number one pick.
Posted by The Poet

@Liberty: I don't really know a lot of these guys (the ones Turok nominated of course), so this list thing should help me and others learn about characters we don't really hear about that much...

I might create an "honorable mention" list for the characters who didn't make the list when I create the actual list for this thing...

Moderator
Posted by Liberty
@The Poet: That is cool.  What would be the criteria?
Posted by The Poet

@Liberty: well I was thinking it would consist of the characters which we bumped off the list so we had an even 100.

and we could still use the user's reasons for nominating them for the list. It would be a nice tribute for the characters who might not get on the list otherwise...

Moderator
Posted by Liberty
@The Poet: If you do that make it a separate list. For eample...
 
Main List
Top 100 greatest superheroes all time as decided in 2011
 
Honorable Mention
The honorable mentions from 2011.
Posted by The Poet

@Liberty: yeah (and when I create a regular CV list I'd make them both in addition to posting them here before locking it...)

Moderator
Posted by The Poet

oh goody! 2091 views on this blog which has only been in existance for 5 days...not bad

Moderator
Edited by Liberty
@The Poet: Let me help you on some of these.  I might have missed something but this should be better that nothing.
 
  1. Mrs Victory (Holyoke, AC)
  2. Nightveil (AC)
  3. Yankee Girl (Harry A. Chesler/Dynamic, AC, Dynamite Entertainment)
  4. Catman (Holyoake, AC, Dynamite Entertainment)
  5. Rocketman (Harry A. Chesler/Dynamic, AC, Dynamite Entertainment) 
  6. Turok Son Of Stone (Dell, Gold Key, Valiant)
  7. Mighty Samson (Dell, Gold Key, Dynamite Entertainment)
  8. Abe Sapien (Dark Horse
Posted by The Poet

@Liberty: thanks

Moderator
Posted by Silkcuts

@The Poet said:

@Liberty said:

As grains pass through the hour glass so do the days of our lives. Come on DC! where are you?

Well, they actully made progress! Dark Huntress was curdious and said Primm could do the nominating as long as a few characters made the list. I just need them to order it, but I guess it can wait...so without further ado their nominations: (in no piticular order:) Supergirl Batman Superboy Dick Grayson Superman Captain Marvel (fawcett/DC)Invincible (image, ect)Wonder Woman

I can't believe Invincible is on this list...lol

Whoever came up with that is not a DC fan...lol

Etrigan, Xanadu, Darkeid, Lois Lane, Deathstroke (since Deadpool will make Marvel's list), Swamp Thing, Batwoman (for the LGBT people), Catwoman, Joker, Two-Face, etc... with 8 choices there is no reason a non-DC character should make that list. Shame on who voted Invincible.

Heck there is no Green Lantern at all... Hal, Kyle, Guy, John or even Mogo.

Posted by turoksonofstone
Posted by Liberty
@turoksonofstone: Spelling was never my strong suit.
Posted by The Poet

@Silkcuts: @Silkcuts said:

@The Poet said:

Supergirl Batman Superboy Dick Grayson Superman Captain Marvel (fawcett/DC)Invincible (image, ect)Wonder Woman

I can't believe Invincible is on this list...lol

Whoever came up with that is not a DC fan...lol

Etrigan, Xanadu, Darkeid, Lois Lane, Deathstroke (since Deadpool will make Marvel's list), Swamp Thing, Batwoman (for the LGBT people), Catwoman, Joker, Two-Face, etc... with 8 choices there is no reason a non-DC character should make that list. Shame on who voted Invincible.

Heck there is no Green Lantern at all... Hal, Kyle, Guy, John or even Mogo.

Well, trust me when I say Primmaster is a DC fan. Its his choice (plus the suggestions of Dark Huntress). They had the chance to nominate other characters and they did that.

btw, your suggestions don't totally fit. Darkseid, catwoman, joker and two face are all villains (which we're not doing at the moment). and Swampthing I think Aztek might steal....

but its ultimately up to them. they can nominate what they want....

Moderator
Posted by harleyquinn12

I don't see why they can't nominate Invincible. I mean, they are allowed to. And Batwoman shouldb't be picked simply because she's lesbian, she's an intresting character without looking at her sexuality.

Posted by Liberty
@harleyquinn12: You can.  It is just an opinion.  You can nominate G'Nort too but expect a little criticism.  I think (could be wrong) Silkcuts was saying that with all the DC characters it is hard to see a DC for an Image character.  DC, because it has been around so long and bought so many other characters form out of business companies it is hard to see Invincible.  
 
For there record it doesn't bother me in the least.  I know that there are 20 other people who will add to the DC list with their extra three votes.