While we're at it, since I'm having trouble finding a thread fully dedicated to it when I search, but feel like it probably exists and as soon as I create one it'll probably just get deleted and redirect me; but what's with the lack of half-star scores overall? If you don't want to give half stars you don't have to, but don't take away our ability to give them. Personally, and I know I'm not alone in this, I think a 5-star system is far too broad for proper reviewing, especially for something as rapid and excessive as comics. Half stars really helps create a smoother curve of quality judgement; AND it doesn't force those who don't agree to actually USE half stars; but now by making one group happy, you've angered or alienated the other by eliminating their ability to give half stars, when a system that allows it makes both groups happy, and if someone's upset by other people's ability to use half stars without being forced to use them themselves, well, they need to take a serious look at their sanity.
If it's a server thing or something like that, that's different, but I still think there's far more positives to just letting us give half-star scores.
Log in to comment