Is this Wildstorm Zealot and Midnighter? Assuming it is.
Midnighter>Spider-man (Although Midnighter would eventually win due to Spider-man's morals Spider-man is more than capable of holding out a while).
Going by this I would give Team 1 a Majority. Spider-man is capable of holding his own against Midnighter. While its not a fight he can win with Morals On. Wildstorm Zealot would gut Deathstroke in a fight and going by what I've seen of Creeper he should take a majority against X-23. Midnighter would not be able to fight off both Zealot (who on her own gave him a good fight) and Creeper after having fought Spider-man.