X men/Mutants(movies) vs. Harry Potter Wizards

The wizards are suddenly transported to the Xavier institute. Both sides view each other as threat and fighting breaks out. Who wins

Mutants: Storm, Jean(X2), Bishop, Magneto, Kitty, Iceman, Wolverine, Blink & Colossus

Wizards: Dumbledore, Voldermort, Harry, Severus, Madeye Moody, Belletrix, MacGonagall

• Both sides have prep and knowledge
• Both sides are working as a team
• Professor X is included, but he can only use his psychic abilities to co-ordinate his team(psychic link)
• Unforgivable curses are not allowed
• Start 50 ft apart
• No Horcruxes
• No potions, mind control or possession.

Mutants stomp hard.

How dare you put Hermione in this!

Wizards, Voldemort and Dumbledor solo.

@ironshinobi88 Why do you think they solo?

Wizards with prep win handily, they can set up wards, tricks and traps to a very high degree. Does Voldy have his horcruxes? If so he probably solos. No unforgivables makes it harder, but fiendfyre and some other high level spells (e.g. Dumbledore and Voldemort in Order of the Phoenix) should do the trick. Also Moody's eye makes the wizards incredibly hard to sneak up on.

@leo-343 Unforgivable curses are not allowed

@korraspirit: @korraspirit: Can't MacGonagal/Moody just turn them all into rats and then every goes for a butterbeer? None of the movie x-men have any magic resistance I can recall so...?

Mutants win. Blink redirects every spell, while Magneto and Storm uses all of their powers to attack. Then Kitty goes intagible with Wolverine and they attack and go intagible again.

Wizards.

The wizards are going to OWN this.

Even without unforgivable curses, Wizards have too much versatility. Given prep they should take this provided that this is the book versions.

Jean uses telekinesis to take the wands out of Wizards hands. Then Wolverine rips them limb by limb.

X-Men should take this.

@leo-343: Jean could effortlessly lift multiple cars when she was untrained. Trained, her TK should be stronger than Dumbledore and Voldemort's wand-less magic. And even if it isn't, it isn't weaker by much and Wolverine, Colossus and Storm would KO them before they get their wands back.

In addition, they have no way to hit Kitty who can rip out their hearts one by one.

Blink uses portal to redirect it to the Wizards, or Iceman stops it with his ice, or Magneto creates a wall of metal to protect the mutants.

Mismatch ...

Come on seriously ...

Movie Magneto his reflexes are so fast he can stop a bullet at 1000 meters / second , and he can even put his mind in a bullet and coordinate it while it's going 1000 meters a second ( Days of the future past to kill Revan ) .

First of all he has prep so magneto should be wearing a full metal outfit , have metal balls with him together with metal wires , some sort of plates he can fire at them while being shields etc ...

He can perfectly create flat iron objects , and use them as shields against the magic spells .

He can shoot metal pieces at all wizards before they can even think about what spell they should use .

He can collapse the roof above them also .

he could solo for sure .

EDIT : Magneto would see the spells coming in slow motion , while he can move normal , that is how it should be like really .

Then there's iceman who could just create ice walls , he could create an extra ice armor around he's ice body so their stunning or other spells can't reach him while he freezes them 1 by 1 .

Iceman can easily solo as i don't think magic spells can go trough ice .

Jean could as been said before here grab their wands, throw the wizards against the walls , and she can also redirect cyclops laser , so i think she can redirect the magic spells as well but i'm not sure .

Jean can solo as well .

And don't get me even started about the rest lol

a couple of kids outran it the X men can teleport. Ice man and Magneto can slowed it down while they run.

Xmen win this so easily

@leo-343: feindfire's not unavoidable. Besides no one here has ever used feindfire in combat (assuming this is book versions, movie Voldemort's fire snake might have been feindfire)

She is faster than any of them and she can teleport groups.

@leo-343: and what's stopping Blink from just teleporting them away or Magneto and Storm from battering the wizards or electrocuting them or impaling them?

@leo-343:

In the books only Dumbledore and Voldemort have apparated in combat

Protego has only really been used to block magic, it doesn't have any feats to suggest it can block physical attacks like lightning or metal

Half of those spells can be blocked or dodged or redirected by Blink

Magneto and Storm can fly too

@leo-343: Then why do they never apparate in combat?

We don't know if Protego could block magic lightning

No, I don't expect Blink to redirect every spell, I was just including it as an option among dodging and blocking (which I did mention so I don't know why you're saying I only mentioned Blink

I never said the Mutants had an advantage with flight, simply that it didn't give the wizards as much of an advantage as you were suggesting

If they could and it's such a valuable tactic then why doesn't anyone else use it. Voldemort and Dumbledore are in their own tier abover everyone else here

Proof that protego blocks everything? When have these wizards used Protego to block attacks like lightning, or Magneto's metal attacks or Bishop's blasts?

I never said Blink needed to do it for everyone, why do you keep bringing that up like I said she would?

How fast can Voldemort and Snape fly? They'll have to work around Storm's tornadoes and thunder storms

If it's so clear in the books you should be able to give me a quote?

I don't remember that, they might have teleported sometimes but not as part of a fight iirc

Only Voldemort caught up to Harry on Hagrid's bike, we don't know about Snape

Sunning spells can be blocked or dodged easily. How many wizards here use transfiguration in combat? Fiendfire is not unavoidable

http://www.spike.com/video-clips/4hzefm/x-men-the-last-stand-i-like-this-one

That's when she just met magneto and professor x, before she had training of any kind, before X1. She didn't even look at the cars. Her telekinesis is stronger now.

And even if Dumbledore and Voldemort's combined WAND-LESS magic is on the same level as Jean's TK (it isn't), the rest are still useless, and while Dumbledore and Voldemort are trying to get their wands back, Wolverine slices them in half. Or Storm electrocutes them. Or Iceman freezes them. You get the idea.

Yeah that's fine

I know Voldemort caught up to the bike. Snape was on a broom. Just because Snape can fly doesn't mean he's as fast or as skilled as Voldemort

Stunning spells can be blocked by solid objects.

When have they transfigured people in combat?

The fiendfyre won't protect the wizards from getting skewered or electrocuted or caught up in F5 tornadoes

Why will Blink automatically get overwhelmed if she teleports?

Days of Future past. Wizard version.

@leo-343: The fact is that Jean Grey could effortlessly lift multiple cars before the events of X1. That is an undeniable fact.

As such, it is safe to assume that she can pull a few wands out of the wizards' hands without too much trouble. And that is how Wolverine will get in class. A wizard without his wand is nothing. And yes I would like to know the spell that could put Jean down, not that the wizards would get a chance to use it.

In addition, as @arcus said, the wizards have never apparated or transmuted anything while in combat.

Lastly, Erik can make the mansion fall on them, and while the Wizards are struggling to hold it up, Storm can electrocute them. Don't tell me that a wizard can effortlessly move a building because they have never been shown to do so.

@gxrevolution96: is this in character?

Mutants.

How do we know some will get in?

Moody transfigured Draco Malfoy as discipline, that's not the same. Actually, that was Bart Crouch pretending to be Moody

They still don't seem to use transfiguration of people much in combat

How do you know the fiendfire will kill most of the mutants? How do you know these wizards will use it in combat?

Blink is not completely responsible for the X-Men, she can help but it's not like everything relies on her

CAN EVERYONE JUST STOP ? THIS BATTLE IS OVER .

MAGNETO SEES EVERYTHING IN SLOW MOTION SO HE WOULD KILL EVERY WIZARD IN 1 / 10 OF A SECOND .

STOP USING FRIENDLY FIRE , JEAN GREY CAN BLOCK IT, .

ICEMAN CAN FREEZE THEM FASTER THAN THEY CAN CREATE SPELLS / FRIENDLY FIRES .

THEY ARE ONLY 15 METERS AWAY , JEAN GREY PULLS THEIR WANDS AWAY BEFORE THEY CAN DO ANYTHING .

THE FACT IS MAGNETO IS TOO FAST , THE END .