X is a stone cold killer,Robin isn't but he's trained by the best fight their in Batman,so who wins.
"Hasn't Tim beat Lady Shiva before. He might do better then most expect."Sounds like a classic example of bad writing to me considering Shiva is widely considered to be a martial artist on par if not better than Batman.
We all know Tim ain't.
I wouldn't underestimate TIm in this,he my not be a killer but his fighting skill in on par with X 23 and if he has his utility belt and gagets he might have a change. keep in mind her claw are admantium not her entire skelton like Logan. Plus Robin has successfully battled super powered foes and won.
Tim is a good fighter but I think you are giving him way too much credit E Man 4. I wasn't even counting X-23's powers, rather simply relying on her fighting prowess. Every single one of her shot are probably going to be kill shots. I highly doubt he would block or evade them all. X-23 defeated Wolverine without much trouble. I really doubt Tim could do what she did. Tim is a good fighter, but X-23 is the perfect killer.
"Nighthunter said:oh right, probably bad writing seeing how Robin gets his ass kicked by opponents that are inferior than Shiva"Kurrent said:Didn't she give him his bo staff when he beat her""Hasn't Tim beat Lady Shiva before.umm...no"
Nightwing, Jason Todd, Azrael, Batgirl, Spoiler, etc