@killemall: I didnt know about Manitou earlier appearences but in the same issue he does seem godlike. First resurrecting a character is already big enough when you add other stuffs he does to the JLA.
He doesn't have earlier appearances, I'm talking about his later appearances. He joins the JLA right after that whole ordeal. Resurrecting a character isn't really a big deal, superheroes come back from the dead all the time. It was also at the cost of his old self's life so I wouldn't treat it as an amazing show of power, but of sacrifice. Also, leading up to that final battle, it's pertinent to know that he and Kyle had literally been waiting hundreds of years for that fight -- just like how in the earlier fight with the JLA, his side won because they had significant prep and scouting advantage (and even then admitted they only won because the JLA took it easy).
Like I said, Manitou isn't godlike. He's crafty, pretty powerful, and good at distractions.
I am not sure why Kyle having shown or not showing the planetary power would matter since we actually see a giant Kyle right there lift the planet in his arms.
Kyle isn't lifting anything. He's shown cradling an Earth that was already in its correct orbit thanks to the JLA's efforts. The JLA remark on their relief (due to the strain) when the ordeal is over after Gamenmae's defeat. If you think Kyle + Manitou Raven = turning into a giant planet juggling being then I think you're taking the scene too literally. Kyle's right back to normal at the conclusion.
We dont actually see anything in regards to planet being moved in either of the instance though. We dont see anything in regards to the planet other than 1 panel of JLA trying to pull the planet and another of Kyle standing there.
We see the JLA pulling the planet. They're literally worried about the fact that them pulling it will cause irreparable damage to the surface, so they had to take precautions. Does the amount of panels matter? They clearly pulled the Earth back when Gamenmae sent it out of orbit, but were beginning to lose it when Kyle and Manitou reversed Gamenmae's spell after Aquaman cut her off from her magic.
You see it as symbolic i do not, the whole reason we see Kyle there holding the planet and that the JLA members struggling either seem to suggest they failed and that it was Kyle who did it. After all that was his last sacrifice.
Manitou Raven can not turn into a giant, planet sized celestial raven. That is not actually in the scope or level of his ability. Same with Kyle. If that was something they could do then why didn't they do it before Gamenmae's spell was broken? Why rely on the JLA to pull the Earth? Why cast the spell on the lasso that allowed them to pull the Earth if he was capable of doing it all himself? The idea doesn't hold up in the storyline.
You say you don't see the JLA directly moving the Earth, but do you see Kyle directly moving the Earth? Nope. It's one panel, just like the JLA, if I use your reasoning. He's not shown putting forth any motion (unlike the JLA who are directly shown pulling a taut rope) to move the Earth.
We might not know the size and density of the planet but there is a lot of stuffs we do know.
1. It is the biggest planet of its solar system.
2. Its star was similar to our own, having turned into a dead red giant now.
3. It used to have life.
4. We actually see the planet, vis-a-vis other planet in the star-system.
I don't see any of the things you said presented in the scans aside from it having life (which means nothing, life exists on all sorts of planets), but again, there's no direct scale(how far in the distance are those planets? How big are they?). You can't compare something in the foreground's size to something in the background and assume it's bigger. Your thumb isn't bigger than your house because you hold it closer to your eye.
Just like you can't really tell how far the Earth moves when the backdrop is space in the JLA story. You don't just act like they didn't pull the Earth when them pulling the Earth is a plot point. Do you think that was just added to the story for no reason? The JLA failed to hold the Earth in orbit? Because they didn't. They specifically talk about how they were about to lose it (again, despite being weakened due to literally coming back to life), not that they had lost it or didn't keep the Earth in place at all. Kyle and Manitou fix the water problem -- once the water problem is fixed there's no need to have to move the Earth anymore.
Log in to comment