Bucky wins here
Winter Soldier vs Bane
D³
Bane stomps.
Huh?
Bane stomps.
Huh?
Eh, reconsidering that. From a H2H standpoint I feel Bane is superior since far less skilled people than him(Batroc and Punisher) have stalemated Bucky H2H, but I'm not really clear on the capabilities of Buckys arm or if he's accurate enough to hit Bane in a vital area.
@night4345: he just has a knife here.
@night4345: he just has a knife here.
Ah.
Bane gets stabbed.
Fixed.
Bane stomps.
Huh?
Eh, reconsidering that. From a H2H standpoint I feel Bane is superior since far less skilled people than him(Batroc and Punisher) have stalemated Bucky H2H, but I'm not really clear on the capabilities of Buckys arm or if he's accurate enough to hit Bane in a vital area.
My apologies. I re-read the OP and have to change my opinion.
I was under assumption that Bucky got full-gear and his arm was capable of electrical discharge, but those were removed in the OP.
Under the conditions in the OP I believe that Bucky is still the superior fighter, but Bane's physical attributes from the Venom are going to make it difficult for Bucky with nothing but a knife and his bare hands, even if Bucky has an arm that is superhumanly strong and durable. Bucky can win, but I am not sure that he wins a majority. Right now I am on the fence 50/50 and could see it going either way.
Bucky handily.
Why?
Because of the OP, realistically this fight can go either way.
But I'll root for Bucky, I like his character more.
Bucky handily.
Why?
I thought he had full gear and such when I initially posted. I think that Bucky has better skill based feats than Bane, can compete physically and possibly has an edge in strength with his arm, and then you add in the fact that his set of gear substantially outweighs that of Bane's, then I wasn't really seeing how Bane(Pre 52 at least) was supposed to come anything close to a majority.
But seeing how the OP has stripped Bucky of his gear and only left with him with a combat knife against a Venom amped Bane, this is much closer than I originally thought. I still stink Barnes gets the majority, but he'll have to work for it.
@wolverine08: I still stink Barnes gets the majority, but he'll have to work for it.
You're giving someone who's getting stalemated by Batroc and Punisher the majority against Bane?
Bucky handily.
Why?
I thought he had full gear and such when I initially posted. I think that Bucky has better skill based feats than Bane, can compete physically and possibly has an edge in strength with his arm, and then you add in the fact that his set of gear substantially outweighs that of Bane's, then I wasn't really seeing how Bane(Pre 52 at least) was supposed to come anything close to a majority.
But seeing how the OP has stripped Bucky of his gear and only left with him with a combat knife against a Venom amped Bane, this is much closer than I originally thought. I still stink Barnes gets the majority, but he'll have to work for it.
Good man.
@wolverine08: I still stink Barnes gets the majority, but he'll have to work for it.
You're giving someone who's getting stalemated by Batroc and Punisher the majority against Bane?
Punisher has already admitted that in a straight up confrontation with Barnes, he wouldn't come out on top.
Punisher's stalemate of Winter Soldier really just consisted of Frank sneaking up on Bucky and managing to get his pistol pointed at Bucky's head(While Barnes had his bionic arm around Frank's neck mind you) Had Bane had the same thing happen to him it's not like he wouldn't have been in a sticky situation as well. Even then, considering Frank's portfolio of giving Daredevil solid tussles using dirty fighting, hagging around with Daken, etc. having him managing to get his gun to Barnes' head in a very short tussle isn't really a negative.
Batroc has also had his ass kicked by Winter Soldier before. Batroc has had good fights with Bucky and Captain America, but completely stalemating either of them isn't a regular thing for him. Bucky's beaten 50's Captain America whom had Captain America's stats amped by a factor of six, he's beaten a 6 tonner Ursa Major right after not having slept for days and fighting numerous inmates in a prison. He did so without his mechanical arm giving him superhuman strength to boot. Crossbones has given Captain America good fights and even stalemated Steve if we play with high ends yet Bucky has beaten him soundly twice.
Bucky has a lot in his portfolio that suggests he can take Bane. It's going to be hard since he's stripped off the majority of his gear, but it's fully within his capabilities to walk away with a majority.
Bucky handily.
Why?
I thought he had full gear and such when I initially posted. I think that Bucky has better skill based feats than Bane, can compete physically and possibly has an edge in strength with his arm, and then you add in the fact that his set of gear substantially outweighs that of Bane's, then I wasn't really seeing how Bane(Pre 52 at least) was supposed to come anything close to a majority.
But seeing how the OP has stripped Bucky of his gear and only left with him with a combat knife against a Venom amped Bane, this is much closer than I originally thought. I still stink Barnes gets the majority, but he'll have to work for it.
He can compete in speed, agility, reflexes, and stamina, but Bane's durability is significantly higher. As far as strength Bucky has one arm that can maybe match Bane's strength level given the OP, but the rest of his body is not on par.
@wolverine08: I still stink Barnes gets the majority, but he'll have to work for it.
You're giving someone who's getting stalemated by Batroc and Punisher the majority against Bane?
Punisher has already admitted that in a straight up confrontation with Barnes, he wouldn't come out on top.
Punisher's stalemate of Winter Soldier really just consisted of Frank sneaking up on Bucky and managing to get his pistol pointed at Bucky's head(While Barnes had his bionic arm around Frank's neck mind you) Had Bane had the same thing happen to him it's not like he wouldn't have been in a sticky situation as well. Even then, considering Frank's portfolio of giving Daredevil solid tussles using dirty fighting, hagging around with Daken, etc. having him managing to get his gun to Barnes' head in a very short tussle isn't really a negative.
Batroc has also had his ass kicked by Winter Soldier before. Batroc has had good fights with Bucky and Captain America, but completely stalemating either of them isn't a regular thing for him. Bucky's beaten 50's Captain America whom had Captain America's stats amped by a factor of six, he's beaten a 6 tonner Ursa Major right after not having slept for days and fighting numerous inmates in a prison. He did so without his mechanical arm giving him superhuman strength to boot. Crossbones has given Captain America good fights and even stalemated Steve if we play with high ends yet Bucky has beaten him soundly twice.
Bucky has a lot in his portfolio that suggests he can take Bane. It's going to be hard since he's stripped off the majority of his gear, but it's fully within his capabilities to walk away with a majority.
I support this post though. Saying Bucky is lacking in skill because Frank and Batroc have stalemated him is grossly misleading. Thumbs up.
@wolverine08: Alright, thanks for clearing those instances up. I honestly don't know crap about Bucky beyond a respect thread I skimmed. Can't really comment on this fight, though I feel Bane can trump the feats you've given.
@highaccuser: No problem, and I like I said, this is very close due to the lack of gear. I can see an argument for Bane being crafted, but I think Bucky should get a slight majority.
@lunacyde: Thanks man.
Bane, but not easily. He's taken gunshots/stabs/etc without being on Venom and been fine. His skill is such that he's been able to stalemate Batman for a time, the Bat routinely needs gadgets to beat him. Barnes' arm has about 2 tons of power in it...but Bane has the same power on Venom. If Bucky had his standard arsenal I'd back him, but I'm going to say Bane 6-7/10.
Bane's taken knives before without showing much discomfort so the ka-bar isn't going to be that useful unless a Bucky gets a direct slice to the head which is not going to be easy. His durability against blunt-force is also pretty high along with his striking power which I think gives him a majority.
Winter Solider with medium to high difficulty.
Bucky is more skilled and has more items at his disposable.
Bane may be a lot bigger, stronger, and durable, but he isn’t skilled in martial arts. He just attacks with anger and swings his arms as hard as he can. Bucky could evade the blows and break that mask off his face with his bionic arm so he could actually hurt him.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment