• 55 results
  • 1
  • 2
#1 Posted by SYMBIOTE9200 (440 posts) - - Show Bio

Who would win?(sorry to anyone who might have posted this before.im fairly new)

#2 Posted by The Mighty Thor (7469 posts) - - Show Bio

Eternal Chaos says:

"SYMBIOTE9200 says:
"Who would win?(sorry to anyone who might have posted this before.im fairly new)"
Its ok even though it's been posted about a million times. Anyway Welcome to the vine, and Superman wins easily."

i say hulk would esepically wwh

#3 Posted by Eternal Chaos (22990 posts) - - Show Bio

SYMBIOTE9200 says:

"Who would win?(sorry to anyone who might have posted this before.im fairly new)"

Its ok even though it's been posted about a million times. Anyway Welcome to the vine, and Superman wins easily.

#4 Posted by Sparda (15795 posts) - - Show Bio

My most hated enemy beats my favourite character......it's enough to drive me insane......

#5 Posted by Methos (40103 posts) - - Show Bio

head explodes

i've seen this thread too many times, WAY too many times...

Superman all the way

M

#6 Posted by Methos (40103 posts) - - Show Bio

Sparda says:

"My most hated enemy beats my favourite character......it's enough to drive me insane......"

Smeg happens lol

M

#7 Posted by SprtnFast (13 posts) - - Show Bio

hulk would win because superman's cape would piss him off

#8 Posted by Rotten gun (2509 posts) - - Show Bio

awesome! new minds to mould.... yes, the hulk would win. if we beleive we can make it so :)

#9 Posted by Superkitty (1086 posts) - - Show Bio

I vote every time this thread comes on, we give it some new variables, so here's mine:

It has to be a ping pong match (standard rules) on the Happy Rainbow Planet, which has a red sun. Who'd win?

#10 Posted by Eternal Chaos (22990 posts) - - Show Bio

Superkitty says:

"I vote every time this thread comes on, we give it some new variables, so here's mine: It has to be a ping pong match (standard rules) on the Happy Rainbow Planet, which has a red sun. Who'd win?"

I feel like I'm talking my ex's best friend with all this cute stuff. lol. Hulk wins.

#11 Posted by GL Bertron (3708 posts) - - Show Bio

SprtnFast says:

"hulk would win because superman's cape would piss him off "

GL Stands up and walks to closet door,which he proceeds to opens. Then he places his head inside and slams the door until the feeling leaves his legs.

#12 Posted by Eternal Chaos (22990 posts) - - Show Bio

GL Bertron says:

"SprtnFast says:
"hulk would win because superman's cape would piss him off "
*GL Stands up and walks to closet door,which he proceeds to opens. Then he places his head inside and slams the door until the feeling leaves his legs.*"

LMAO

#13 Posted by Terminal Velocity (583 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman wins because he's unimaginably stronger, even if Hulk is uber angry cause he just got forced to watch every season of sex in the city none stop.

#14 Posted by GambitO (980 posts) - - Show Bio

Hulk is very strong and he has incredible abilities but Superman he has an adult I number of powers that allow him to win he also has the enough agility to avoid any blow of Hulk and then against attacking it with great force and speed

#15 Posted by the creator (8577 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman wins this easily for the following reasons.

  1. He starts out hundreds of times stronger than the Hulk.

  2. His super speed reactions and speed enable him to avoid the all of Hulks blows.

  3. His invulnerability is so great that the Hulks attacks could not do any serious injury (at least for maybe the first few hours of the fight - until the Hulk got a lot stronger).

  4. His strength and heat vision are sufficiently potent to punch/cut straight through the Hulk.

  5. His endurance is many times greater than the Hulks, so after about 8 days of constant swinging the Hulk will eventually tire out and revert to human form.

#16 Posted by Sparda (15795 posts) - - Show Bio

The_Creator says:

"Superman wins this easily for the following reasons. 1. He starts out hundreds of times stronger than the Hulk. 2. His super speed reactions and speed enable him to avoid the all of Hulks blows. 3. His invulnerability is so great that the Hulks attacks could not do any serious injury (at least for maybe the first few hours of the fight - until the Hulk got a lot stronger). 4. His strength and heat vision are sufficiently potent to punch/cut straight through the Hulk. 5. His endurance is many times greater than the Hulks, so after about 8 days of constant swinging the Hulk will eventually tire out and revert to human form."

Um......most of that is correct. Hulk doesn't really tire....he swam across the Ocean for weeks non-stop and didn't show any signs of tiring. I don't think Superman could just punch straight throug him.....he'd just punch him once really, really hard and K.O. him. Everything else is right.......Superman wins.....

#17 Posted by the creator (8577 posts) - - Show Bio

Sparda says:

"The_Creator says:
"Superman wins this easily for the following reasons. 1. He starts out hundreds of times stronger than the Hulk. 2. His super speed reactions and speed enable him to avoid the all of Hulks blows. 3. His invulnerability is so great that the Hulks attacks could not do any serious injury (at least for maybe the first few hours of the fight - until the Hulk got a lot stronger). 4. His strength and heat vision are sufficiently potent to punch/cut straight through the Hulk. 5. His endurance is many times greater than the Hulks, so after about 8 days of constant swinging the Hulk will eventually tire out and revert to human form."
Um......most of that is correct. Hulk doesn't really tire....he swam across the Ocean for weeks non-stop and didn't show any signs of tiring. I don't think Superman could just punch straight throug him.....he'd just punch him once really, really hard and K.O. him. Everything else is right.......Superman wins....."

The hulk has been shown to tire out on many occasions - swimming does not tax him to the full but going all out will cause him to eventually run out of energy - big difference.

As for Superman putting his fist through him - that's easy. The hulk has been cut on many occasions, usually by a superhard material, in a sharp form, backed by considerable force.

Imagine that Superman takes his hand, flattens it and hit the hulk at his hardest, with a chopping motion.

This maximises his force to area ration and delivers a blow resemblying nothing less than a blade attack. This delivered at super speed and it becomes and instant spear attack.

#18 Posted by the creator (8577 posts) - - Show Bio

Sparda says:

"The_Creator says:
"Sparda says:
"The_Creator says:
"Superman wins this easily for the following reasons. 1. He starts out hundreds of times stronger than the Hulk. 2. His super speed reactions and speed enable him to avoid the all of Hulks blows. 3. His invulnerability is so great that the Hulks attacks could not do any serious injury (at least for maybe the first few hours of the fight - until the Hulk got a lot stronger). 4. His strength and heat vision are sufficiently potent to punch/cut straight through the Hulk. 5. His endurance is many times greater than the Hulks, so after about 8 days of constant swinging the Hulk will eventually tire out and revert to human form."
Um......most of that is correct. Hulk doesn't really tire....he swam across the Ocean for weeks non-stop and didn't show any signs of tiring. I don't think Superman could just punch straight throug him.....he'd just punch him once really, really hard and K.O. him. Everything else is right.......Superman wins....."
The hulk has been shown to tire out on many occasions - swimming does not tax him to the full but going all out will cause him to eventually run out of energy - big difference. As for Superman putting his fist through him - that's easy. The hulk has been cut on many occasions, usually by a superhard material, in a sharp form, backed by considerable force. Imagine that Superman takes his hand, flattens it and hit the hulk at his hardest, with a chopping motion. This maximises his force to area ration and delivers a blow resemblying nothing less than a blade attack. This delivered at super speed and it becomes and instant spear attack. "
Ok....it cuts him. Then Hulk heals. Then Superman punches him once and he wins. "

I don't think that he heals from the decapitation that this move permits.

#19 Posted by Sparda (15795 posts) - - Show Bio

The_Creator says:

"Sparda says:
"The_Creator says:
"Superman wins this easily for the following reasons. 1. He starts out hundreds of times stronger than the Hulk. 2. His super speed reactions and speed enable him to avoid the all of Hulks blows. 3. His invulnerability is so great that the Hulks attacks could not do any serious injury (at least for maybe the first few hours of the fight - until the Hulk got a lot stronger). 4. His strength and heat vision are sufficiently potent to punch/cut straight through the Hulk. 5. His endurance is many times greater than the Hulks, so after about 8 days of constant swinging the Hulk will eventually tire out and revert to human form."
Um......most of that is correct. Hulk doesn't really tire....he swam across the Ocean for weeks non-stop and didn't show any signs of tiring. I don't think Superman could just punch straight throug him.....he'd just punch him once really, really hard and K.O. him. Everything else is right.......Superman wins....."
The hulk has been shown to tire out on many occasions - swimming does not tax him to the full but going all out will cause him to eventually run out of energy - big difference. As for Superman putting his fist through him - that's easy. The hulk has been cut on many occasions, usually by a superhard material, in a sharp form, backed by considerable force. Imagine that Superman takes his hand, flattens it and hit the hulk at his hardest, with a chopping motion. This maximises his force to area ration and delivers a blow resemblying nothing less than a blade attack. This delivered at super speed and it becomes and instant spear attack. "

Ok....it cuts him. Then Hulk heals. Then Superman punches him once and he wins.

#20 Posted by Sparda (15795 posts) - - Show Bio

The_Creator says:

"Sparda says:
"The_Creator says:
"Sparda says:
"The_Creator says:
"Superman wins this easily for the following reasons. 1. He starts out hundreds of times stronger than the Hulk. 2. His super speed reactions and speed enable him to avoid the all of Hulks blows. 3. His invulnerability is so great that the Hulks attacks could not do any serious injury (at least for maybe the first few hours of the fight - until the Hulk got a lot stronger). 4. His strength and heat vision are sufficiently potent to punch/cut straight through the Hulk. 5. His endurance is many times greater than the Hulks, so after about 8 days of constant swinging the Hulk will eventually tire out and revert to human form."
Um......most of that is correct. Hulk doesn't really tire....he swam across the Ocean for weeks non-stop and didn't show any signs of tiring. I don't think Superman could just punch straight throug him.....he'd just punch him once really, really hard and K.O. him. Everything else is right.......Superman wins....."
The hulk has been shown to tire out on many occasions - swimming does not tax him to the full but going all out will cause him to eventually run out of energy - big difference. As for Superman putting his fist through him - that's easy. The hulk has been cut on many occasions, usually by a superhard material, in a sharp form, backed by considerable force. Imagine that Superman takes his hand, flattens it and hit the hulk at his hardest, with a chopping motion. This maximises his force to area ration and delivers a blow resemblying nothing less than a blade attack. This delivered at super speed and it becomes and instant spear attack. "
Ok....it cuts him. Then Hulk heals. Then Superman punches him once and he wins. "
I don't think that he heals from the decapitation that this move permits. "

If it cut off his head......probably wouldn't heal.

#21 Posted by Clark_EL (2654 posts) - - Show Bio

Bump!

Supes

#22 Posted by Malevolent1 (1072 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman. Too fast for Banner to deal with.

#23 Posted by chiq (1962 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman- too fast to versatile.

Online
#24 Edited by King Saturn (224189 posts) - - Show Bio

How about Captain Universe Hulk vs Superman ?

#25 Posted by CalebHara (2329 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman with relative ease.

#26 Posted by JimmyBlueEyes (5 posts) - - Show Bio

Not sure why this thread is still open after 5 years. In those 5 years Hulk has had an impressive list of feats. He can take Superman's heat, Gladiator's heat vision is much hotter, he can take the cold. Superman gets hits all the time so why would speed be a factor? It's a fight not a race. Superman doesn't heal and he doesn't stronger and more durable as the fight goes on, he gets weaker.

#27 Edited by Picallo3798 (226 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman even with pure strength > Hulk. Supes wins.

#28 Posted by JimmyBlueEyes (5 posts) - - Show Bio

@king_saturn: Superman has been beaten by Hulk rip-off Doosmday so he loses to the original.

#29 Edited by czarny_samael666 (17174 posts) - - Show Bio

How about Captain Universe Hulk vs Superman ?

Wouldn't change anything, Cap Hulk is featless. Only thing that would change is that Hulk would be able to fly. Nul, would be better tough.

@king_saturn: Superman has been beaten by Hulk rip-off Doosmday so he loses to the original.

This doesn't tell us about their feats. Majestic is Superman rip-off, but he would win with Superman.

Not sure why this thread is still open after 5 years. In those 5 years Hulk has had an impressive list of feats. He can take Superman's heat, Gladiator's heat vision is much hotter, he can take the cold. Superman gets hits all the time so why would speed be a factor? It's a fight not a race. Superman doesn't heal and he doesn't stronger and more durable as the fight goes on, he gets weaker.

It was Bannerless/Mindless Hulk (strongest version, but with lower stamina) and Gladiator was already almost KO'd.

And speed would be a factor. At the beginning, Hulk can even have an advantage, but if he will not end their fight fast, Superman at some point will use HV and reflex. And this combination will stomp Hulk.

Superman even with pure strength > Hulk. Supes wins.

WB Hulk has better feats. WWHulk doesn't have any feats above best Savage Hulk's ones. And I wouldn't be so sure about it, since even Savage Hulk proved that can break energy force field that can throw planet out of its orbit:

http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Hulk%20Durability/SavageHulkEnergy.jpg

#30 Edited by Picallo3798 (226 posts) - - Show Bio

@czarny_samael666 said:

WB Hulk has better feats. WWHulk doesn't have any feats above best Savage Hulk's ones. And I wouldn't be so sure about it, since even Savage Hulk proved that can break energy force field that can throw planet out of its orbit:

http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Hulk%20Durability/SavageHulkEnergy.jpg

Im honestly not an expert on Hulk, just not my character I like reading about so this may be true however everyone knows that Supermans strength at one point was lifting 200 quintillions. He also pulled planet(s) plural and what not. Also he held a black hole in his hand. What are some of WB hulk feats that rival these? Honest question

#31 Edited by czarny_samael666 (17174 posts) - - Show Bio

@czarny_samael666 said:

WB Hulk has better feats. WWHulk doesn't have any feats above best Savage Hulk's ones. And I wouldn't be so sure about it, since even Savage Hulk proved that can break energy force field that can throw planet out of its orbit:

http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Hulk%20Durability/SavageHulkEnergy.jpg

Im honestly not an expert on Hulk, just not my character I like reading about so this may be true however everyone knows that Supermans strength at one point was lifting 200 quintillions. He also pulled planet(s) plural and what not. Also he held a black hole in his hand. What are some of WB hulk feats that rival these? Honest question

1.Different version of Superman was lifting 200 quintillions.

2.He used travel speed to pull planet and it isn't a striking feat.

3.WB Hulk destroyed a planet as a side effect of his fight with Red She-Hulk. Google should help You with looking for scan of WB Hulk doing it.

#32 Edited by rolldestroyer (3508 posts) - - Show Bio

superman would win in a fight

#33 Edited by Shavo (2061 posts) - - Show Bio

lol why bring this thread back?

#34 Posted by Doomnaut (1993 posts) - - Show Bio

Hulk loses badly (depending on the incarnations used).

Flying brick>>>brick.

#35 Posted by AngryHulks (3001 posts) - - Show Bio

Not sure why this thread is still open after 5 years. In those 5 years Hulk has had an impressive list of feats. He can take Superman's heat, Gladiator's heat vision is much hotter, he can take the cold. Superman gets hits all the time so why would speed be a factor? It's a fight not a race. Superman doesn't heal and he doesn't stronger and more durable as the fight goes on, he gets weaker.

Superman's heat vision is more powerful, its intensity is enough to power up an ion engine capable of moving the entire planet.

Superman get hit all the time, yes, mostly from character with speed on par with him so this doesn't hold much water.

Superman have healing factor, his throat have been slit by Wonder Woman and he healed it in matter of few minutes.

As much as I like Hulk, he shouldn't be able to beat someone like Gladiator or Sentry at all. Also, being a walking powerhouse have a lot of disadvantage against flying powerhouse.

#36 Posted by Lvenger (19905 posts) - - Show Bio

Still Superman. It's difficult to see how Hulk can beat someone who's practically as strong, durable and possesses the same stamina as him who can also fly, move at hypersonic+ combat speeds, possess nanosecond reaction time as well as heat vision and freeze breath.

#37 Edited by silverJuggernaut (136 posts) - - Show Bio

superman wins

#38 Posted by Clark_EL (2654 posts) - - Show Bio
#39 Posted by Immortal777 (7584 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman.

Online
#40 Posted by New_World_Order (13189 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman.

#41 Edited by guttridgeb (4832 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman.

Thank goodness this isn't one of the threads in which noob-me said Hulk, I don't know how I ever believed that...

#42 Posted by Immortal777 (7584 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman

Mismatch

Online
#43 Posted by MirrorWave4 (1099 posts) - - Show Bio

If logic is needed for this battle thread = Superman

If this thread is based on Pure Fanboism = HULK SMASH LITTLE RED TIGHTS KRYPTONITE GOOD-FOR-SUCKING MAN!!!!!!

#44 Posted by Batman242 (4860 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman wins. The only people who I see that say Hulk wins are people that don't read comics.

#45 Edited by dum529001 (1624 posts) - - Show Bio

People like to act like Hulk doesn't move at supersonic speeds just because he jumps instead of running.

Hulk doesn't run because the ground isn't as strong as he is and upon reaching a certain speed, would break apart and give him no friction to run on.

With his power, Hulk can easily exceed the speed of sound with his punches (as it's made evident with the air shockwaves he produces) and super-leaps.

His Power=Speed

Speed of travel requires force.

Also, Freeze breath is ineffective and heat vision is no more effective than a super-powered punch from Superman. I suggest the heat vison be used at clsoe range lest it it's effectiveness be lessened.

Both character have to have shown to put out and planet-busting power and withstand it as well as core solar temperatures and environmental pressures.

It's an even enough match.

Hulk wins.

Why? Limitless strength in proportion to stress.

Fighting the Hulk is the same as fighting against the limitless forces of nature. Nature will win whether anyone loses or not.

#46 Edited by Clark_EL (2654 posts) - - Show Bio

Superman.

Thank goodness this isn't one of the threads in which noob-me said Hulk, I don't know how I ever believed that...

LOL

#47 Posted by Dredeuced (5543 posts) - - Show Bio

People like to act like Hulk doesn't move at supersonic speeds just because he jumps instead of running.

Hulk doesn't run because the ground isn't as strong as he is and upon reaching a certain speed, would break apart and give him no friction to run on.

With his power, Hulk can easily exceed the speed of sound with his punches (as it's made evident with the air shockwaves he produces) and super-leaps.

His Power=Speed

Speed of travel requires force.

Also, Freeze breath is ineffective and heat vision is no more effective than a super-powered punch from Superman. I suggest the heat vison be used at clsoe range lest it it's effectiveness be lessened.

Both character have to have shown to put out and planet-busting power and withstand it as well as core solar temperatures and environmental pressures.

It's an even enough match.

Hulk wins.

Why? Limitless strength in proportion to stress.

Fighting the Hulk is the same as fighting against the limitless forces of nature. Nature will win whether anyone loses or not.

This isn't really true. Hulk has frequently and many times over been KO'd before he could rage out to a level to beat someone. If it were as simple as "he's a force of nature who only gets stronger and can't be taken down" then he'd, well, lose less often.

#48 Posted by dum529001 (1624 posts) - - Show Bio


@dredeuce@dredeuced:

What i'm saying is that Superman can't kill the Hulk( because he's indestructible) and he certainly doesn't have an overwhelming advantage over him either.

#49 Edited by Dredeuced (5543 posts) - - Show Bio

Hulk is not indestructible. He just has great regen. People have cut him with something as weak as sharp human bones. Healing factors have been frequently and greatly circumvented by just knocking the dude out. Knocking someone out for a significant amount of time is an allowed victory condition.

#50 Posted by AngryHulks (3001 posts) - - Show Bio

People like to act like Hulk doesn't move at supersonic speeds just because he jumps instead of running.

Hulk doesn't run because the ground isn't as strong as he is and upon reaching a certain speed, would break apart and give him no friction to run on.

With his power, Hulk can easily exceed the speed of sound with his punches (as it's made evident with the air shockwaves he produces) and super-leaps.

His Power=Speed

Speed of travel requires force.

Also, Freeze breath is ineffective and heat vision is no more effective than a super-powered punch from Superman. I suggest the heat vison be used at clsoe range lest it it's effectiveness be lessened.

Both character have to have shown to put out and planet-busting power and withstand it as well as core solar temperatures and environmental pressures.

It's an even enough match.

Hulk wins.

Why? Limitless strength in proportion to stress.

Fighting the Hulk is the same as fighting against the limitless forces of nature. Nature will win whether anyone loses or not.

Hulk can move at relatively high speed, but his perception speed isn't similarly enhanced, most street levelers can outmaneuver Hulk. Superman's mental perception speed and operating speed compromised, not to mention he can move at least 1% the speed of light (as evident during the race with Flash) and has nanosecond reaction time.

Hulk did not tank solar temperature, he just survived it, if Gladiator sustain his beam a bit longer he could have kill (or incapacitate) Hulk, aside, he's already weakened by nearby nuclear reactor so his heat vision isn't at full power, but even weakened it's already enough to melt through him.

Superman's heat vision can warm up the entire Earth from distant, and most fight took places less than a mile, so its intensity will still be mostly conserved. His heat vision output is enough to powered up planet-moving machine, imagine that magnitude of energy.

Hulk's strength is potentially limitless, but it has limits to the output, he have been knocked out by low-100 tonners several times.